Thursday, May 7, 2009

Performance Ethnography

Denzin, Norman. (2003). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.

The Call to Performance (pp. 3-24)
In crafting an emancipatory discourse, Denzin turns to a performance or art-based approach to culture, politics and pedagogy and explores performance autoethonography and performance art as vehicles for enacting a cultural politics.

Denzin defines cultural performances as contingent events in the flow of everyday life while performance as an interpretive event, an act of intervention and a form of agency that brings culture and the person into play. He argues that if the world is a performance, we need a model of social science that is performative. To him, performance questions an conventional ethnographic textualism, which turns culture to words or books, and instead put culture into action or motion. He also notes that unlike the conventional ethnography, it values intimacy and involvement as forms of understanding and makes sites of oppression visible.

Denzin pays particular attention to performance autoethnographers, who insert their own experience into the cultural perfomances they study and turn the personal into political. Performance autoethnography, he observes, becomes a civic, participatory and collaborative project. With members of community, the performer creates community-based interpretations and community actions for social change, much as Du Bois's all-black theater did (p. 17).

The Cinematic Society and the Reflexive Interview (pp. 57-76)

In his critique about Trinh's film Surname Viet Given Name Nam (1989), Denzin discusses a reflexive documentary interview style. To him, reflexivity centers on representation. His summary about Trinh's reflexive and dialogic interivew text includes:

--It makes the audience responsible for interpretation.
--It resists all dichotomies (male/female and so on).
--It foregrounds difference not conflict.
--It uses multiple voices.
--It presents silence as a form of resistance.

Denzin states that Trinh creates the space for viewers to appraise critically the politics of representation by challenging the traditional rules of a unbiased gaze and letting the audience actively participate in the interpretation process.


Critical Performance Pedagogy (pp. 222-241)

Denzin writes, "[Performance ethonography] is a way of being moral and political in the world. Performance ethonography is moral discourse. In the discursive spaces of performativity there is no distance between the performance and the politics that hte performance enacts. The two are interwined, each nourishing the other, opposite sides of the same coin, one and the same thing" (p. 224)

"A genuine democracy requries hope, dissent, and criticism" (p. 224).

"Performance (auto)ethnography is the future of ethnography...The reflexive ethnographer becomes the guiding presence in the ethonographic text" (p. 224).
Performance Ethics (pp. 242-262).

"As praxis, performance ethnography is a way of acting on the world in order to change it" (p. 228).

"Performance texts provide the grounds for liberation practice by opening up concrete situations that are being transformed through acts of resistance" (p. 229).

"Through performance and participation, the scholar develops a 'participatory mode of consciousness' (Bishop, 1998:208) and understanding. This helps shape the participant-driven nature of this form of inquiry and folds the researcher as performenr into the narrative and moral accountability structures of the group" (p. 239).

(Bishop, Russell. "Freeing Ourselves from Neo-colonial Domination in Research: A Maori Approach to Creating Knowledge" International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education 11: 199-219.)