Thursday, April 28, 2011

Transformative research and evaluation

Mertens, Donna M. (2009). New York, NY: Guilford.

Introduction (1-7)
Mertens earlier noted four dominant paradigms in educational and psychological research: positivism, constructivism, pragmatism and emancipatory. In this text, he renamed emancipatory to transformative to emphasize working together with people for personal and social transformation. In this context, he discussed the transformative paradigm as "an overarching metaphysical framework" (3) to cover various approaches labeled critical theory, feminist theory, participatory, inclusive, culturally responsive, etc. that aim to furthering social justice through research and evaluation. [Here Mertens mentions research and evaluation together. I wonder what is difference. Perhaps it is the use of terms. Research is often referred to activities of seeking knowledge for the sake of knowledge while evaluation as more practical, but knowledge-for the sake of knowledge is not practical in particular in the domain of the transformative paradigm. In a sense, research is part of evaluation.]

1. Resilience, resistance, and complexities that challenge (9-42)

Mertens wrote for the foci of the transformative paradigm:

"Rather, the paradigm focuses on culturally appropriate strategies to facilitate understandings that will create sustainable social change. Understanding the dynamics of power and privilege and how they can be challenged in the status quo is also a priory" (10)

In this light, she emphasized participatory approaches to research and evaluation and stressed the potential role of the researcher or evaluator as an "instrument of social change" (11).

Mertens wrote, "Participatory action research is one example of an approach that is compatible with the transformative paradigm when it is applied to the goal of social justice" (21).

Mertens discussed ethical impetus. Looking at the Belmont report from the U.S. national commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research (1979), she wrote that the landscape of ethics is useful, and yet, issues outside of the norms and principles also arise in the conduct of research: "some ethical issues will surface differently or not at all, depending on the researchers' or evaluators' paradigmatic stance" (35)

Chilisa (2005, Educational research within postcolonial Africa. International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education, 18, 659-684) suggests that ethics narrowly defined as protection fails to protect the researched as it fails to recognize ethics in light of respect for the integrity of the researched community.

Mertens also looked into AEA's Guiding Principles over a period of time and other codes, and suggested that revisions of professional association code recently made indicate a "greater awareness of the need to consciously incorporate principles of cultural competence as a salient dimension of their ethical codes" (36): APA, AERA, America Evaluation Association, American Sociological Association, American Anthropological Association, and the United Nations.

[Find out the examples, and look for some examples in Canadian contexts]

Mertens read through Kirkhart (1995, 2005) and Lincoln (1995) for the discussion of research validity. In particular, Kirkhart (2005) proposed "multicultural validity" to indicate "correctness or authenticity of understanding across multiple, intersecting cultural contexts" (p.22) and suggested five justifications for multicultural validity: theoretical, experiential, consequential, interpersonal, methodological.

Lincoln (1995, Standards for qualitative research. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the AERA, San Francisco) suggested the followings for the criteria for quality in research and evaluation: positionality or standpoint epitemology (researchers should acknowledge all texts are incomplete and limited by the position of the researchers), community (know well enough of the community), attention to voice (researchers should seek out those who are silent), critical reflexivity (high level of awareness to acknowledge the psychologocal state of others and themselves), reciprocity (should demonstrate that a method was used to develop a sense of trust and mutuality with the participants), sharing the perquisites of privilege. (as cited 39-40)

[Checking the quality of the embedded research (PV), it demonstrates sustained quality]

2. Basic beliefs and commensurate theories (43-69)

Some philosophical statements of the transformative paradigm:

Axiology (assumptions about ethics): "Ethical considerations include respect for cultural norms of interaction; beneficence is defined in terms of the promotion of human rights and increase in social justice)

Ontology (assumptions about what exists; what is reality): "Rejects cultural relativism and recognizes the influence of privilege in determining what is real ad the consequence of accepting one version of reality over another; multiple realities are shaped by social, political, cultural, economic, ethnic, gender, disability, and other values" (p. 49)

Epistemology (assumptions about the nature of knowledge and the relationship between the researcher/evaluator and the stakeholders needed to achieve accurate knowledge): Recongnizes an interactive link between researcher/evaluator and participants/co-researchers/evaluator; knowledge is seen as socially and historically situated; issues of power and privilege are explicitly addressed; development of a trusting relationship is seen as critical

Methodology (assumptions about appropriate methods of systematic inquiry): "Inclusion of qualitative methods (dialogical) is seen as critical; quantitative and mixed methods can be used; interactive link recognized between the researcher/evaluator and participants in the definition of the focus and questions; methods are adjusted to accommodate cultural complexity; and contextual and historical factors are acknowledged. especially as they relate to discrimination and oppression. (p. 49)

About Validity
Gaventa and Cornwall (2006, Power and knoweldge. In Reason and Bradbury (Eds.) Handbook of action research (71-82)) argued for the need to evolve new concepts of validity in participatory research and the quality of knowledge. [So, WHAT IS THEIR CONCEPT?]

Mertens stressed that researchers should be sensitive to cultural diversity because "The embedded biases of researchers and evaluators toward culturally diverse people threaten validity. In contrast, validity is enhanced by cultural responsiveness" (62). [Mertens stressed cultural responsiveness as criteria of validity]

In this regard, Mertens disregarded triangulation and called for crystallization: she wrote that triangulation was used to validate findings in traditional qualitative research through different methods. But she implied that triangulation does not convey the multifaceted nature of knowledge, subject to cultural refraction (oh, nice word that I coined), and supported crystallization indicating multidimentionalities, angles of approaches, transmutations, borrowing from Richardson and St. Pierre (2005, Writing: A method of inquiry, in Denzin & Lincoln (eds.) The sage handbook of qualitative research (3rd, 959-978)).


6. Quantitative, qualitative, and mixed methods (164-198)

Mertens suggests that specific quantitative and qualitative approaches have the potential to be used as a mixed-methods approach as long as they are used in culturally appropriate context.

In particular in the context of participatory action research, Mertens quotes Greenwood and Levine (2007, Introduction to action research, Sage), who argued that AP is not limited to group meetings and qualitative methods. They regarded action research as a research strategy that "generates knowledge claims for the express purpose of taking action to promote social analysis and democratic social change" (p. 5, cited in 183). They summarized, "Surveys, statistical analyses, interviews, focus groups, ethnographies, and life histories are all acceptable, if the reason for deploying them has been agreed upon by the AP collaborators and if they are used in a way that does not oppress the participants" (p. 6).

[GREENWOOD and LEVINE is good to quote to support the mixed method used in my study.]

Tuesday, April 26, 2011

Qualitative research & evaluation methods

(3rd ed.). Patton, Michael Quinn. (2002). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

1. The nature of qualitative inquiry (3-29)
*Three kinds of qualitative data: interview, observation, and document

The purposes of research and evaluation are different, but research can be evaluative: "When one examines and judges accomplishments and effectiveness, one is engaged in evaluation. When this examination of effectiveness is conducted systematically and empirically through careful data collection and thoughtful analysis, one is engaged in evaluation research" (p. 10)

*Criteria to judge the quality of the findings:
evaluation standards: utility, feasibility, propriety, accuracy
nontraditional criteria: trustworthiness, diversity of perspectives, clarity of voice, credibility of the inquirer to primary users of the findings.

Patton noted, "In qualitative inquiry, the researcher is the instrument. The credibility of qualitative methods, therefore, hinges to a great extent on the skills, competence, and rigor of the person doing fieldwork--as well as things going on in a person's life that might prove a distraction" (p. 14)

Patton discussed the purposes of open-ended responses and participant observation for evaluative research: "the open-ended responses permit one to understand the world as seen by the respondents. The purpose of gathering responses to open-ended questions is to enable the researcher to understand and capture the points of view of other people without predetermining those points of view through prior selection of questionnaire categories. . . . The task for the qualitative researcher is to provide a framework within which people can respond in a way that represents accurately and thoroughly their points of view about the world..." (p. 21)

In order to overcome the limitations pertaining to what people say, Patton called for participant observation for evaluation research. "The purpose of observational analysis is to take the reader into the setting that was observed" (p. 23).

[In my evaluation research, I utilized participant observation, written out in depth in chapter 3, and made available direct quotes from the observed to provide readers with their points of view.]

2. Strategic themes in qualitative inquiry (37-73)
* Patton presented some analysis strategies: unique case orientation (capturing the details of the individual case being studied), inductive analysis and creative synthesis, holistic perspective (focusing on complex interdependence and providing it as a complex system), context sensitivity (attentive to a social, historical, and temporal context), voice/reflexivity (reflective on my own voice)

With regard to reflexivity, Patton wrote: "Reflexivity has entered the qualitative lexicon as a way of emphasizing the importance of self-awareness, political/cultural consciousness, and ownership of one's perspective" (p. 64) He suggested using the first-person, active voice in this light.

Patton seems to be skeptical about paradigmatic division. He argued that a paradigmatic strategy indeed can be a hindrance for evaluation research. He argued:

"Such prejudices and paradigmatic blinders limit methodological choices, flexibility, and creativity. Adherence to a methodological paradigm can lock researchers into unconscious patterns of perception and behavior that disguise the biased, predetermined nature of their methods "decision." " (p. 71)

Further, he argued that "the qualitative-quantitative debate oversimplified and often confused methodological and philosophical issues" (p. 71), as in reality, there are the cases that notably consistent methods and philosophy in a certain paradigm have proven problematic.

3. Variety in qualitative inquiry: Theoretical orientations (75-142)
Patton introduces 16 qualitative inquiries, including phenomenology and grounded theory, which I think are the most relevant to my dissertation research. So I will take a close look at them.

Phenomenology
Foundational question: what is the meaning, structure, and essence of the lived experience of this phenomenon for this person or group of people?

Phenomenon can be emotion, a relationship, a program, or a culture. The focus is on describing the essence of people's experience in a certain phenomenon and developing a worldview. It usually involves participant observation and in-depth interviews. For example, the essence of being a participant in a particular program can be a kind of phenomenological study. [My chapter 4 is a definitely phenomenological study in that sense.]

Grounded theory
Foundational question: What theory emerges from systematic comparative analysis and is grounded in fieldwork so as to explain what has been and is observed?

Popular in social sciences and methodology with emphasis on generating, instead of testing, theory. Patton asserts that all the approaches are grounded in the empirical world, but the conceptualizations of what to ask vary from one inquiry to another. "While the phrase "ground theory" is often used as a general reference to inductive, qualitative analysis, as an identifiable approach to qualitative inquiry, it consists of quite specific methods and systematic procedure" (p. 126). Thus, he argued:

"As a matter of philosophical distinctness, then, grounded theory is best understood as fundamentally realist and objectivist in orientation, emphasizing disciplined and procedural ways of getting the researcher's biases out of the way but adding healthy doses of creativity to the analytic process." (p. 128-129).

[To the extent that I compared the experience of the research participants with that of others in other programs in Chapter 4, it has a systematic comparison emphasized in grounded theory, and yet, this analysis is not so much grounded theory as phenomenology. On the other hand, Chapter 5 is more linked to grounded theory as I intend to provide some methodological tools to researchers. But I also doubt that it can be called grounded theory as I do not develop theory out of the fieldwork. ]

4. Particularly appropriate qualitative applications (143-205)
Patton holds pragmatism in his approach to methodology: "Pragmatic and utilitarian frameworks can guide qualitative inquiry on their practical and applied underpinnings without having to be attached to or derived from a theoretical tradition." (p. 145)

Patton suggests various evaluation models:

Goal-free evaluation
"doing fieldwork and gathering data on a broad array of actual effects or outcomes, then comparing the observed outcomes with the actual needs of program participants" (p. 169). In general, it purposefully suspends the researcher's judgment.

[Then, I can take up goal-free evaluation for the embedded study. The participants want to find out ways to help increase retention rate, in the end, they suggested a way. There is no way to check the actual effects, but from the participants' perspective, the research brought about some solutions they looked for. ]

Transaction models: responsive and illuminative evaluation

The transaction model of evaluation that Ernie House (1978) called concentrates on case studies and "places prime emphasis on perception and knowing as a transactional process between researcher and research participant" (p. 172). Its variations include illuminative evaluation, developed in educational evaluation, and Stake's (1975) responsive approach to evaluation, which requires to have "face-to-face contact with people in the program and learn about diverse stakeholder's perspectives, experiences and concerns. This responsive evaluation has been integrated into Guba and Lincoln's (1989) "responsive constructivist evaluation" known as the fourth generation evaluation, which is based on naturalistic inquiry.
Connoisseurship studies
It places the evaluator's perceptions and expertise at the center of the evaluation process, "drawing heavily on his or her own judgments about what constitutes excellence" (172).

Interactive and participatory applications:

Placing a greater emphasis on human interaction in designing evaluation strategies, Patton wrote:

Qualitative methods may also be perceived as more personal because of their inductive nature. This means that, again, rather than imposing on people or a program some predetermined model or hypotheses, the results unfold in a way that takes into account idiosyncrasies, uniqueness, and complex dynamics. Finally, qualitative methods may be perceived as more humanistic and personal simply by avoiding numbers. (p. 176)

Action research, action learning, reflective practice
i.e. adult educators interviewing students as case studies, then through cross-case analysis they deepened their sensitivity to new immigrant students and developed their professional skills.
Participatory research and evaluation
Film: Awakening (1990)--a real story of participatory research in a mental hospital

Patton provided an overview of a growing popularity of participatory research:
"Interest in participatory research has exploded in recent years, especially as an element of larger community change efforts (Stoecker 1999). The principal researcher trains the coresearchers to observe, interview, reflect, and/or keep careful records or diaries. Those involved come together periodically to share in the data analysis process. The purpose of such shared inquiry is typically to elucidate and improve the nature of practice in some arena of action" (183).

In particular, participatory evaluation emphasizes "working with people" (183), thus, Patton wrote: "The process is facilitated by the researcher, but is controlled by the people in the program or community. They undertake a formal, reflective process for their own development and empowerment" (183).

Patton noted that participatory evaluation has been used with great success by a number of NGOs and private voluntary organization in the Third World.

Patton also drew attention to various connotations of participatory inquiry, saying that there is no definitive definition for participatory evaluation. Patton, in particular, emphasized teaching inquiry logic and skills as the purpose of participatory evaluation, as "the process of participatory self-evaluation, in and of itself, provided useful learning experience for participants" (184).

[Here Patton suggests participatory evaluation/inquiry as a pedagogical form.]

Finally, he noted, "these participatory approaches often employ qualitative methods because those methods are understandable, teachable, and usable by people without extensive research training." (185)

[Patton regards participatory paradigm from the perspective of pragmatism and links qualitative methods as strong candidates for that paradigmatic inquiry.]

8. Qualitative analysis and interpretation (431-534)

Patton discussed about summative vs. formative evaluation: Summative evaluations are usually accompanied by a full report with data, analysis, and recommendations, whereas formative evaluation is conducted for program improvement and may not generate a written report. Findings are often presented orally to the staff or funders. Patton wrote:
"The methods are qualitative, the purpose is practical, and the analysis is done throughout fieldwork; no written report is expected beyond a final outline of observations and implications. Academic theory takes second place to understanding the program's theory of action as actually practices and implemented" (435)

[The VT research can be viewed as formative evaluation to give insights into the OP program, which is not academic theory oriented and rather concentrates on providing critical insights from the insiders' perspective.]

Theory-based analysis approaches: Patton discusses phenomenological analysis and ground theory analysis in great detail, along with qualitative comparative analysis and analytic induction.

Analytic induction seems to be the most relevant to my approach. It originally emphasized discovering universal causal generalizations, but gradually moved away to qualitative inquiry and comparative case analysis including examination of preconceived hypotheses. In this approach, "researchers actively seek to disconfirm emerging hypotheses through negative case analysis, that is, analysis of cases that hold promise for disconfirming emerging hypotheses and that add variability to the sample. In this way, the originators of the method sought to examine enough cases to assure the development of universal hypothesis." (Jane Gilgun 1995:268-269, We shared something special: the moral discourse of incest perpetrators, Journal of marriage and the family, 57, 265-81). Analytic induction consists of re-examinations.

9. Enhancing the quality and credibility of qualitative analysis (541-597)

In traditional scientific research, among the criteria for judging the credibility are objectivity, validity, systematic rigor of fieldwork procedures, triangulation, etc. The common aim is "to use qualitative methods to describe and explain phenomena as accurately and completely as possible so that their descriptions and explanations correspond as closely as possible to the way the world is and actually operates" (p. 546)

Social construction and constructivist criteria: Lincoln and Guba (1986) proposed credibility (for internal validity), transferability, dependability and confirmability. In combination, they viewed these criteria as addressing trustworthiness (in lieu of rigor). Fundamentally, they are "suspicious of causal explanations and empirical generalizations applied to complex human interactions and cultural system" (546)

Critical change criteria: another stream of qualitative inquiry aims at social and political change. Thus consequential validity matters in addressing the credibility of the inquiry.

[For the analysis of my dissertation study, what criteria should be applied? The set of criteria should stem from the hypotheses of participatory (video) research. What does participatory research claim to be able to do? Does my study prove or disprove it? How do I make judgment? --My judgment should be grounded in constructivist perspective, the fourth generation evaluation. Then, what I need to verify is the claims of participatory research. ]

Saturday, April 16, 2011

Ciné-Ethnography

Jean Rouch (2003). (ed. & trans. by Steven Feld). Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.

The politics of visual anthropology (Jean Rouch with Dan Georgakas, Udayan Gupta, and Judy Janda). (pp. 210-225)

[Today I watched Chronicle of a Summer again. One thing that I noticed is that Rouch and Morin were building relationship with in particular four subjects, Marceline, Marilou (depressed Italian immigrant), Landry (African student), and Angélo (a Renaut worker) throughout. In the last conversation with Marilou, Morin said "for a month..."]

Interviewers asked about how Rouch helped some Africans begin careers in film: It appeared that Rouch interacted with some of his subjects. Some of them "created a narration for the film that works at three levels. The first is a description of what you see, the second is a kind of dialogue, and the third is a statement about his own condition." (p. 219)

[This indicates that the line between filmmakers and subjects were not clearly distinguished in his approach to ethnographic filmmaking. ]

About distortion of reality: Rouch said that the camera magnifies the distortion that the presence of an inquisitor brings to the scene. But it does not matter. For him, researchers can change research practices with a camera by showing the film to its subjects and helping subjects become filmmakers, etc. instead of keeping all the information for the sake of researchers' own.

"When the survey is completed, the anthropologist goes back to the university, writes the dissertation, and possibly wins distinction in the field. What is the result for those who were surveyed? Nothing. There is no feedback from the disruption the anthropologist has created. The subjects will not read the survey. With a camera, there can be a far more fruitful result. The film can be shown to the subjects. Then they are able to discuss and have access to what has happened to them. The can have reflection even if the film is bad, for however incompetent the film may be, there will be the stimulation of the image you give of them and the chance for them to view themselves from a distance, up there on the screen. Such a distortion changes everything." (p. 220)

Chronicle of a film (Edgar Morin, 229-265)

Pointing out various reactions to the film Chronicle of a summer, Morin said it marks the failure and the success of the film: Failure, because the film did not gain the sympathy of the majoirty; success, because Rouch and himself "gave the characters the chance to speak and because, to a certain degree, we gave the public a liberty of appreciation that is unusual in cinema" (p. 259). In particular, he emphasized, the film modified the relationship between actor and spectator: "We have emerged from mystery, we have shown ourselves, present, fallible, men among others, and we have provoked the viewer to judge as a human being" (p. 259).

Morin wrote about cinema-verite:

"Cinéma-vérité: this means that we wanted to eliminate fiction and get closer to life. This means that we wanted to situate ourselves in a lineage dominated by Flaherty and Dziga Vertov. Of course this term "cinéma-vérité" is daring, pretentious; of course there is a profound truth in works of fiction as well as in myths. At the end of the film, the difficulties of truth, which had not been a problem in the beginning, became apparent to me. In other words, I thought that we would start from a basis of truth and that an even greater truth would develop. Now I realize that if we achieved anything, it was to present the problem of the truth." (p. 263)

Kino-Eye: The writing of Dziga Vertov

(1984). (Annette Michelson ed. & Kevin O'Brien trans.). Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

1923. Kinoks: A revolution

Vertov called the camera a kino-eye [cine-eye] and was so obsessed to the amount that he identified himself with the eye:

"I am kino-eye. I am a builder. I have placed you, whom I've created today, in an extraordinary room which did not exist until just now when I also created it." (17)

"I am kino-eye, I am a mechanical eye. I, a machine, show you the world as only I can see it.
Now and forever, I free myself from human immobility, I am in constant motion, I draw near, then away from objects, I crawl under, I climb onto them. I move apace with the muzzle of a galloping horse, I plunge full speed into a crowd, I outstrip running soldiers, I fall on my back, I ascend with an airplane, I plunge and soar together with plunging and soaring bodies. Now I, a camera, fling myself along their resultant, maneuvering in the chaos of movement, recording movement, starting with movements composed of the most complex combination" (17)

1924. The birth of kino-eye

Vertov further defined the kino-eye:

"Not kino-eye for its won sake, but truth through the means and possibilities of film-eye, i.e., kinopravda["film-truth"].
Not "filming life unawares" for the sake of the "unaware," but in order to show people without masks, without makeup, to catch them through the eye of the camera in a moment when they are not acting, to read their thoughts, laid bare by the camera.
Kino-eye as the possibility of making the invisible visible, the unclear clear, the hidden manifest, the disguised overt, the acted nonacted; making falsehood into truth.
Kino-eye as the union of science with newsreel to further the (p. 41) battle for the communist decoding of the world, as an attempt to show the truth on the screen--Film-truth." (p. 42)

Vertov called him and his colleagues kinoks as opposed to cinematographers. Editor and translator explained this term as "cine-eye men".

1924. On Kinopravda

One of Vertov's newsreels, Kinopravda, was distinct from the traditional newsreels in that Vertov experimented in assembling film footage representing a certain epoch into "harmonious" montage (p. 42). It was not a simple recording of an event. The 14th Kinopravda was totally rejected by the authority because of its obscurity and made Vertov perplexed. Nonetheless, Vertov pointed out young people and workers received it well. He simply noted:

"Kinopravda made heroic attempts to shield the proletariat from the corrupting influence of artistic film-drama. To many, these attempts seemed ridiculous. The paltry number of prints of Kinopravda could serve, at most, some thougsands of people, not millions. But though Kinopravda's role in the creation of an extensive workers' repertoire was small, its propagandistic action in the battle with the commercial movie theater repertoire proved signiticant." (p. 44)

[Here, Vertov hinted at the formulation of the kino-eye movement.]

"In attacking Kinopravda our detractors gloatingly point out that it's made from previously shot, and therefore "random" footage. To us this means that the newsreel is organized from bits of life into a theme, and not the reverse. This also means that Kinopravda doesn't order life to proceed according to a writer's scenario, but observes and records life as it is, and only then draw conclusion from these observations." (p. 45)

1924. Artistic drama and kino-eye

In this note, Vertov more clearly demonstrates the essence of the kino-eye movement, rooted in the grassroots participation from worker correspondents and agricultural correspondents:

"Comrades, I am speaking on behalf of the kinoks group. As most of you know, our group doesn't connect either its existence or its work with what is called "art."
We engage directly in the study of the phenomena of life that surround us. We hold the ability to show and elucidate life as it is, considerably higher than the occasionally diverting doll games that people call theater, cinema, etc. " (p. 47)

1925. The Essence of Kino-Eye

Vertov defined the kino-eye movement: "led by newsreel workers, the kinoks, [it] is an international movement, and its development is keeping strides with the worldwide proletarian revolution" (p. 49).

Organized by film editors, cinema-worker correspondents cooperated in making decisions on distribution and other tasks. Vertov used the term "decoding" in defining the objective:

"The method of radio-broadcasting images, just recently invented, can bring us still closer to our cherished basic goal--to unite all the workers scattered over the earth through a single consciousness, a single bond, a single collective will in the battle for communism.
This objective of ours we call kino-eye. The decoding of life as it is. Using facts to influence the workers' consciousness." (p. 49)

The purpose of cinema became clearer to Vertov:

"We will not prepare for the broadcast of operas and drama. We will prepare wholeheartedly to give the workers of every land the opportunity to see and hear the whole world in an organized form; to see, hear, and understand one another." (p. 56, in 1925)

1958. Love for the living person.

Vertov later in his life had this conversation:

"As a matter of fact, everything I have done in cinema was connected, directly and indirectly, with my persistent effort to reveal the thinking of the 'living person.' Sometimes that person was the film's author-director, not shown on the screen. Sometimes this image of the 'living person' included traits not of a single concrete person, but of several and even many people who had been chosen accordingly." (p. 156)

Here he implied that authors can be multiple in cinema.

Wednesday, April 13, 2011

Dziga Vertov: Defining Documentary Film

Hicks, Jeremy. (2007). New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.

Introduction (1-4)
In this book, Hicks focuses on the question as to "how Soviet journalism inspired his creative transformation of newsreel into the new form of documentary film" (p. 1). Contrary to the general assumption that Vertov obviated performance, Hicks argued that Vertov balanced between "recording and reworking and his greatest works combined with unstaged footage to unleash an influential rhetoric force.
The birth of documentary from the spirit of journalism: Cine-Pravda, Cine-Eye (5-21)

In 1922, Vertov began to work on news series Cine-Pravda with his future wife and his brother Mikhail Kaufman. Hicks commented:

"It is with Cine-Pravda that Vertov truly begins to realise cinema's power to exhort in images. Cine-Pravda no. 1 (June 1922) sets the tone for Vertov's newsreels in its sharply rhetorical style, downplaying the registering of events and instead editing together shots taken at different times and places so as to construct an argument. (p. 6-7)

Hicks argued, "The camera does not record an already existing causal relation, it creates it" (p. 7). He found the root cause of this transition from recording to discursive force, persuasion and exhortation in cinema in Soviet journalism.

"Vertov's transformation of what to become known as documentary cinema is inconceivable outside the context of the Bolshevik approach to journalism. Stylistically and in its approach to information, persuasion and communication, Vertov's film-making of the 1920s extends the model of the Bolshevik newspaper." (p. 8)

Hicks stressed that in stark contrast to the liberal conception of journalism in the West, the Bolshviks never considered objectivity as a primary consideration. Lenin stated "A newspaper is not only a collective propagandist and a collective agitator, it is also a collective organiser" (as cited in page 8).

Hicks finds the similarity between Soviet Journalism and Vertov's renewal of newsreel as:

"[T]hey start from the fact, but elaborate on it so as to present it as powerfully and as engagingly as possible. Vertov too maintained a similar dual commitment, on the one hand to the capacity of cinema to record as a starting point, and on the other hand to exploring and unleashing its creative, persuasive, analytical potential." (p. 10)

In this context Hicks saw Cine-Pravda as "a revolutionary newsreel entailing a root and branch reassessment of the possibilities of film as a medium" (p. 11)

Hicks saw that Vertov achieved a higher stage with Cine-Eye (1924), which was an "attempt to create a manifesto for a grassroots movement of cine-journalists whose purpose was to transform society, along with relations to creativity and technology" (p. 15)

Hicks finds the background of Vertov's Cine-Eye movement in Soviet journalism which emphasized the worker correspondent movement. This movement in fact began with the situation that the population found the press difficult to understand, thus the Bolsheviks created new dailies aimed at peasants and semi-illiterate strata of the working class by urging them to write letters to the press. Hicks wrote, "This served to encourage reader participation, and at the same time enabled the setting up of an amateur correspondents' network" (p. 17). The Cine-Eye movement is a precisely embodiment of this movement in Soviet cinema. However, Hicks further pointed out that Vertov went a step further and emphasized the participatory model of news-gathering to make this grassroots movement far more effective. Vertov stated that he tried to

"create an army of cine-observers and cine-correspondents with the aim of moving away from the authorship from a single person to mass authorship, with the aim of organising a montage vision--not an accidental but a necessary and sufficient overview of the world every few hours" (as cite in pages 17-18)

Hicks paid particular attention to the use of the Pioneers (Soviet scouts). They are observed and at the same time observers who undertake amateur journalistic research to show every day life. Hicks wrote "Cine-Eye reveals that everyday life, the normal appearance of bread, masks the labour invested in it" (p. 19). The choice of the Pioneers was significant to Vertov, argued Hicks. It represents Vertov's emphasis on teaching the next generation the methods of making cinema. The Pionners, while being filmed, were also learning about filming.

Nonetheless, by 1925 the Cine-Eye movement was close to end because of state control over media to disseminate the views of the Party.

Review of Chronicle of a Summer

Dumont, Jean-Paul. (1978). American Anthropologist, 80(4), 1020-1022.

Dumont pointed out two aspects in Rouch and Morin's approach to anthropology in this film: (1) (2) "Rouch the ethnographer and Morin the sociologist eschew the pitfalls of typologies, samplings, and generalizations" (p. 1021). In this sense, Dumont argued that their project did not study Paris but in Paris; (2) precedence of methodology over the content. He put it, "From the outset, Morin and Rouch know what their method will be but not what it will lead them to" (p. 1021).

Dumont sharply stated the reason why this film was an anthropological success:
Morin and Rouch have been able to capture a slice of life, even though in reality the film has been edited and constructed. It is not of course a neutral slice of life, but the way they have (p. 1021)perceived it. Here it is offered to the viewer with little effort on their part to be didactic about it. It is not a thesis; it has little to prove; but it is a documentation of the way in which Parisians of 1960 lived. And yet, of course, Rouch's and Morin's biases, their personalities, their sensibilities are there also. After all, they too have something to say about antisemitism, racism
and class-consciousness. (p. 1022)

For Dumont, this film does not represent Parisian live but the ideology of their existence in the summer of 1960 and it prompts an audience to meaning-making out of it, instead of providing the full meaning of the topic of the film:

"[T]he topic of the film is strongly pulled toward an intersubjectivity in gestation, whereby the construction of meaning is a process which takes place right in front of my eyes. In this sense, the film is not representative of anything, but it represents less what it was to live in Paris in the summer of 1960 than the ideology of what this experience was." (p. 1022)

Russian Cinema

Gillespie, David. (2003). Essex, UK: Longman.

Film and Ideology (103-123)

Gillespie asserted that films in the 1920s follows Bolshevik policies and its view of history and progress. Directors, including Pudovkin, Eisenstein, Vertov, etc. undertook different styles to commit to the Bolshevik cause and used their art to promote it. As Gillespie addressed, in particular, Vertov combined this political perspective with his artistic sense and cinematic authorship in order to "create a utopian vision of the new city through the medium of the camera" (p. 107). This artistic and political ambition, however, came to nothing under the propaganda of social realism determining all forms of cultural production in 1934, Gillespie argued.

Christie and Taylor (1994). The film factory: Russian and Soviet cinema in documents, 1986-1939.

Tuesday, April 12, 2011

Cinematic authorship

Gaut, Berys. (2010). In A philosophy of cinematic art (pp. 98-151). Cambridge University Press.

In this chapter, Gaut developed his multiple-authorship thesis in cinematic authorship. First of all, he wrote, "Yet the notion of film authorship--so appealing to lay intuition and scholarly understanding alike--oddly mysterious and deeply elusive" (p. 98). Single authorship, predominating the film study, fails to explain the tendency of mainstream films, which is characterized with collaboration, Gaut said. Here, he argued that "we must acknowledge that collaborative films have multiple authors" (p. 99).

(He defined a mainstream film: "one that has at least two people in the key production roles" (p. 106).)

Responding to Livingston's influential argument in the defense of single authorship of mainstream films, Gaut argued that Livingston's dual requirements of expressive/artistic intentions and sufficient control of the work as whole is important; but as Livingston notes that in large-scale commercial films single authorship is not the most common, Gaut finds the irony in L's argument for single-authorship. In particular, in the context of actors' roles in collaboration, Gaut put it:

[A]ctors and many other contributors should count as co-authors of the film, since they typically have expressive sub-plans that mesh, to varying degrees, with the other contributors to the film, just as the director typically has expressive sub-plans that mesh with theirs; and, in the case of those authors who are artists, they typically also have plans to give the film artistically relevant qualities, such as making it beautiful or original, and so on. (p. 122)

Gaut agrees that the director is likely to be the most important contributor of expressive and artistic properties to a film. By saying so, he stressed that multiple-authorship does not require that all the contributions must be of equal importance. Further, as to "sufficient control", Gaut argued, "If the relationship of a film are construed broadly, as in the pattern making example, then other artistic contributors besides the writer-director must count as co-authors." By emphasizing non-hierarchical relationship in lieu of control, Gaut argues a possibility of multiple contribution, and thus, multiple-authorship.

Gaut defended multiple-authorship from the ontological aspect of film. He argued that "films are moving pictures with sound, which incorporate mechanical recordings of performances" (p. 126). Nonetheless, tarnished by the literary paradigm, which uses a quite different medium, cinematic authorship has been wrongly understood, Gaut argued. Further, Gaut continued to stress, "The film actor, then, co-determines (with the screen writer, director, or whomever) the character she plays in a film.

Gaut further refined multiple authorship. Gaut discussed: (1) different degrees of creative powers in collaborative artistic activities; (2) different degrees to which different collaborators are in agreement with others. Gaut points out, "The collaborators may also either be aware of , or be completely unconscious of the fact that they are in agreement or in conflict" (p. 128)
[Which is true in VTW projects. Collaboration sometimes breaks.]

Therefore, Gaut argued that films should be multiply classified, not only by directors but also actors, cameramen, editors, etc. In particular, Gaut argued, multiple-authorship successfully explains the "contradictory text" of a film, in which authors do not have the same views and interpretation, which results in different results from the director's intention. Defending multiple-authorship, Gaut put it:

"Sub-plans can refuse to mesh with each other, sometimes spectacularly, but a multiply authored film can result, and it may be an artistically successful one, sometimes precisely because of this lack of significant mesh." (p. 132)

Finally, interesting to see his comparison between film-making and jazz music performance, which show "a set of strong musical personalities who converse with each other through their playing and create music richer than any could make on his own." (p. 132). For him, both are one of the "dramatic individualism" (p. 132) and a synergistic outcome.

Types of authorship in cinema

Livingston, Paiseley. (2009). In Cinema, philosophy, and Bergman: On film as philosophy (pp. 63-83). Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Livingston three key issues of mainstream large-scale film-making. (1) individual and joint/collective authorship: he emphasizes these two forms of authorship in lieu of the predominant notion of individual authorship. (2)authorship and value: one of the reasons for discussing authorship is the link between certain kinds of values and intentional activity. (3) authorship and unity: Livingston argues, "only the maker of a large, strongly unified life work or oeuvre complet truly qualifies as an author" (p. 68). [This view makes him distinct from Gaut, who argued for multiple authors within a single work of art.]

Livingston argues for two conditions of cinematic authorship: sufficient control over the production of a work plus an intentional act to express the author's own attitude. In this regard, he presented various types of cinematic authorship: individual authorship, individual authorship in the context of a collective film-making process, and joint authorship amongst equals. In particular with joint authorship, Livingston borrowed the term "mashing sub-plans" used by Michael E. Bratman (Faces of intention: Selected essays on intention and agency, 98-103, Cambridge University Press, 1999):

"In many cases where two or more persons jointly author an utterance or work, they intentionally generate or select the text, artefact [sic], performance, or structure that is the work's publicly observable component; in so doing, they act on meshing sub-plans and exercise shared control and decision-making authority over the results; furthermore, in making the work or utterance, they together take credit for it as a whole." (p. 74)

Livingston contended that individual authorship is indeed rare in large-scale commercial film-making, for film-making is a collective process in which people depend on each other's skills. And yet, he stressed that there should be one who control over the overall process. In this respect, Livingston distinguishes himself from Gaut (1997, 2010), who argued for multiple authorship in mainstream authorship, in part, because actors also contribute to creating artistic properties that deserves recognition as one of the work's multiple authors.

Despite his agreement with Gaut that most films are not individually authored and various artistic contributions merit appreciation, Livingston limited the word author to " a person who has played the role of the dominant coordinating collaborator in the creation of the work, provided, that is, that the work has been made by this person with the aim of expressing his or her attitude (or, in the absence of any expressive content, with the aim of endowing the work with artistic quality)" (p. 77). One of the reasons why Livingston disqualify actors' performances as authorship is that they do not play controlling and expressive roles in the making of the work, although their performances are successfully "mashed" with the director's intention and expression.

In short, Livingston emphasized, in the notion of cinematic authorship, overall control and expressive or artistic intentional design in the making of a work. Nonetheless, he does not exclude other types of cinematic authorship, namely, in non-hierarchical forms of artistic collaboration. He leaves the door open to this field. [I think that PV can fall into this category.]

Thursday, April 7, 2011

Vertov's World

Power, Nina. (2010). Film Quarterly, Vol. 63, No. 4 (Summer 2010), pp. 65-69

In this article, Power reviews Dziga Vertov's film world, in particular, by taking a critical gaze on his films, A Sixth Part of the World (1926) and The Eleventh Year (1928), both of which were followed by Man with a Movie Camera (1929). Contrary to the suggestion that the title, A Six Part of the World, made, Power argued that the film is not. She focused on the use of the word "you" in this film, implying various ethnic groups of the USSR, audiences, and members of the USSR as a political totality. Throughout the film, Power noted Vertov's genuine egalitarian humanity. She put it as:

"Vertov’s presentation of the cultural diversity of the USSR in A Sixth Part of the World strives to unite the audience, who are both its subject and its intended recipient: cinema as social inclusion. This land is your land: your oil, your cotton, your flax, your machines." (p. 68)

On the five obstructions

Hjort, Mette. (Ed.). (2008). London, UK: Wallflower Press.

Preface (M. Hjort, xiii-xxviii)
It overviews The Five Obstructions (2003), Lars von Trier and Jørgen Leth's collaborative experimental film. In 2000, von Trier invited Leth, his former teacher and filmmaker, to his game-like project. In his statement, von Trier wrote:

Fiction is limited by our imagination and facts by our insights, and the part of the world that we are seeking cannot be encompassed by a 'story' or embraced from an 'angle'. The subject matter we seek is found in the same reality that inspires fiction-makers; the reality that journalists believe they are describing. But they cannot find this unusual subject matter because their techniques blind them. Nor do they want to find it, because the techniques have become the goal itself. (xvi). . . In a world life where the media kneel before the altar of sharpness, draining life out of life in the process, the DEFOCUSISTS will be the communicators of our era--nothing more, nothing less! (xvii--original. Danish Film Institute 2002)

[For von Trier, the most pressing task in filmmaking is to break the techniques that try to sharpen the representation of reality: Counter-intuitively, these techniques blind us to see the facts and block our imagination. Within this context, he embarked on an experiment with Leth. The Five Obstructions is the result of this experiment to challenge the existing techniques and bring about a new definition of cinematic reality.]

Responding to von Trier's statement, Leth wrote in his statement:

We follow the flow, we see where it wants to to and what it want to do with us. We watch it take form and come together but we must ground it while it is still flowing and not too defined. We are in love. A feeling has bit us, we try to perceive it during its superficial passage yet are afraid of losing it again by understanding it too well. (cited on page xvii)

Leth also tried to break the conventions to "follow the flow", however, he did not think that von Trier's intention of defocus influenced the actual filmmaking of The Five Obstructions (p. xvi).

Style and creativity in The Five Obstructions (Mette Hjort, 15-37)
Hjort discusses styles by looking at the Five Obstructions. Effectively summarizing the film:

"The Five Obstructions, a philosophically-minded experiment involving Danish filmmakers Lars von Trier and Jørge Leth, contributes a number of key insights to the discussion of film and style. Analysis of this work shows, more specifically, that (i) salient regularities can be the mark of creativity at one moment in time and an obstacle to creativity at a later moment in time; (ii) style, narrowly understood as discernible regularities, can be the cause of a loss of style in a broader sense; and (iii) a loss of style that arises n this manner is a problem that can be resolves through strategies involving the obstruction of preferred practices and the imposition of new rules for creative production" (p. 16)

Within this context, she expands the notion of individual style in the context of cinematic authorship. In particular, Berys Gaut (1997, Film authorship and collaboration) is on the focus of her debate. Gaut pointed out some problems that a defense of cinematic authorship as a single author entailed, stressing the collaborative nature of filmmaking, thus suggesting that films should be "multiply categorized: by actors, cameramen, editors, composers, and so on" (p. 165), breaking the rigid categorization by directors. With this respect, Hjort spectulated the validity of the multiple authorship thesis, arguing that, as Gaut conceded, creativity tends to be centralized in filmmaking.

Artistic nesting in the Five Obstructions (Laisley Livingston, 57-75)

Livingston asserted that authorship requires "uncoerced expressive action" that "serves to indicate someone's attitude" (p. 71). He wrote: "Someone who neither makes nore displys anything indicative of any attitudes cannot be an author; anyone who does engage in such expressive actions is in a broad sense an author." (p. 71)

In the case of The Five Obstruction, although its credits include "von Trier as a performer plyaing the role of 'Obstructor' and Leth that of 'Director'" (p. 73), he credit von Trier as joint authors because "the nesting of works by Leth and his collaborators has the function of constituting a favourable context for both the making and reception of Leth's cinematic art" (p. 74), which is done by von Trier. Livinston concluded:

"Obviously, the challenges themselves provide Leth with help in the form of motivation and orientation, but my point here has also been that the film's skillfully crafted story of the Leth/von Trier interaction constitutes a favourable context for the reception and appreciation of the nested works, which acquire certain positively valenced stylistic and thematic qualities only in this context. And this is partly what makes Lars von Trier's help Jørgen Leth' project a success." (p. 74)

[Then, can I think of me as von Trier and PV participants as Leth, who are challenged by missions that I impose to them? This idea at least gives me something to think about. Interesting allegory.]

Work and play: The 5-0 game
(Trevor Ponech, 76-94)

Ponech describes The Five Obstructions's production as a game with a particular strain of cinéma-vérité and formost a commitment to participation. Then, Ponech looks into Chronicle of a summer and singled out a commitment to "provocation" in the way the film was produced. For the filmmakers, discovering or recording psychological dramas is not as important as provoking events, "especially otherwise unattainable self-revelations". In short, Ponech states the role of the camera for Rouch and Morin in their approach to cinéma-vérité:

"Participation in the vérité film extends to viewing the cinematic representations of one's self, with an eye to critiquing both mirror and window insofar as its use facilitates self-awareness and communication among participants." (p. 87)

Ponech argued that the film The Five Obstructions moves a step further, as such:

"Von Trier not only pins his subject beneath the camera's lens so that he might reveal something hidden for all, including the subject, to see; he also makes an expert practitioner struggle with practical and creative problems of filmmaking under barbed constraints customised to chafe, like a bespoke hair shirt. (p. 87).