Showing posts with label author. Show all posts
Showing posts with label author. Show all posts

Thursday, April 7, 2011

On the five obstructions

Hjort, Mette. (Ed.). (2008). London, UK: Wallflower Press.

Preface (M. Hjort, xiii-xxviii)
It overviews The Five Obstructions (2003), Lars von Trier and Jørgen Leth's collaborative experimental film. In 2000, von Trier invited Leth, his former teacher and filmmaker, to his game-like project. In his statement, von Trier wrote:

Fiction is limited by our imagination and facts by our insights, and the part of the world that we are seeking cannot be encompassed by a 'story' or embraced from an 'angle'. The subject matter we seek is found in the same reality that inspires fiction-makers; the reality that journalists believe they are describing. But they cannot find this unusual subject matter because their techniques blind them. Nor do they want to find it, because the techniques have become the goal itself. (xvi). . . In a world life where the media kneel before the altar of sharpness, draining life out of life in the process, the DEFOCUSISTS will be the communicators of our era--nothing more, nothing less! (xvii--original. Danish Film Institute 2002)

[For von Trier, the most pressing task in filmmaking is to break the techniques that try to sharpen the representation of reality: Counter-intuitively, these techniques blind us to see the facts and block our imagination. Within this context, he embarked on an experiment with Leth. The Five Obstructions is the result of this experiment to challenge the existing techniques and bring about a new definition of cinematic reality.]

Responding to von Trier's statement, Leth wrote in his statement:

We follow the flow, we see where it wants to to and what it want to do with us. We watch it take form and come together but we must ground it while it is still flowing and not too defined. We are in love. A feeling has bit us, we try to perceive it during its superficial passage yet are afraid of losing it again by understanding it too well. (cited on page xvii)

Leth also tried to break the conventions to "follow the flow", however, he did not think that von Trier's intention of defocus influenced the actual filmmaking of The Five Obstructions (p. xvi).

Style and creativity in The Five Obstructions (Mette Hjort, 15-37)
Hjort discusses styles by looking at the Five Obstructions. Effectively summarizing the film:

"The Five Obstructions, a philosophically-minded experiment involving Danish filmmakers Lars von Trier and Jørge Leth, contributes a number of key insights to the discussion of film and style. Analysis of this work shows, more specifically, that (i) salient regularities can be the mark of creativity at one moment in time and an obstacle to creativity at a later moment in time; (ii) style, narrowly understood as discernible regularities, can be the cause of a loss of style in a broader sense; and (iii) a loss of style that arises n this manner is a problem that can be resolves through strategies involving the obstruction of preferred practices and the imposition of new rules for creative production" (p. 16)

Within this context, she expands the notion of individual style in the context of cinematic authorship. In particular, Berys Gaut (1997, Film authorship and collaboration) is on the focus of her debate. Gaut pointed out some problems that a defense of cinematic authorship as a single author entailed, stressing the collaborative nature of filmmaking, thus suggesting that films should be "multiply categorized: by actors, cameramen, editors, composers, and so on" (p. 165), breaking the rigid categorization by directors. With this respect, Hjort spectulated the validity of the multiple authorship thesis, arguing that, as Gaut conceded, creativity tends to be centralized in filmmaking.

Artistic nesting in the Five Obstructions (Laisley Livingston, 57-75)

Livingston asserted that authorship requires "uncoerced expressive action" that "serves to indicate someone's attitude" (p. 71). He wrote: "Someone who neither makes nore displys anything indicative of any attitudes cannot be an author; anyone who does engage in such expressive actions is in a broad sense an author." (p. 71)

In the case of The Five Obstruction, although its credits include "von Trier as a performer plyaing the role of 'Obstructor' and Leth that of 'Director'" (p. 73), he credit von Trier as joint authors because "the nesting of works by Leth and his collaborators has the function of constituting a favourable context for both the making and reception of Leth's cinematic art" (p. 74), which is done by von Trier. Livinston concluded:

"Obviously, the challenges themselves provide Leth with help in the form of motivation and orientation, but my point here has also been that the film's skillfully crafted story of the Leth/von Trier interaction constitutes a favourable context for the reception and appreciation of the nested works, which acquire certain positively valenced stylistic and thematic qualities only in this context. And this is partly what makes Lars von Trier's help Jørgen Leth' project a success." (p. 74)

[Then, can I think of me as von Trier and PV participants as Leth, who are challenged by missions that I impose to them? This idea at least gives me something to think about. Interesting allegory.]

Work and play: The 5-0 game
(Trevor Ponech, 76-94)

Ponech describes The Five Obstructions's production as a game with a particular strain of cinéma-vérité and formost a commitment to participation. Then, Ponech looks into Chronicle of a summer and singled out a commitment to "provocation" in the way the film was produced. For the filmmakers, discovering or recording psychological dramas is not as important as provoking events, "especially otherwise unattainable self-revelations". In short, Ponech states the role of the camera for Rouch and Morin in their approach to cinéma-vérité:

"Participation in the vérité film extends to viewing the cinematic representations of one's self, with an eye to critiquing both mirror and window insofar as its use facilitates self-awareness and communication among participants." (p. 87)

Ponech argued that the film The Five Obstructions moves a step further, as such:

"Von Trier not only pins his subject beneath the camera's lens so that he might reveal something hidden for all, including the subject, to see; he also makes an expert practitioner struggle with practical and creative problems of filmmaking under barbed constraints customised to chafe, like a bespoke hair shirt. (p. 87).