Showing posts with label postmodern. Show all posts
Showing posts with label postmodern. Show all posts

Saturday, February 12, 2011

The Symbolism of video

: Exploring migrant mothers' experiences. Yolanda Hernandez-Albujar. (2007). in Gregory Stanczak (2007), Visual research methods: Image, society, and representation (pp, 281-306). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

The author discussed some ethical issues involved in visual ethnographic video approach in her study of the migratory experience among Latin American mothers in Italy. She argued that the conventional ethnographic videotaping was not feasible because it could disclose identities of the participants. Thus she reconfigured the video (the title is "Voices") by incorporating related images in an experimental way to convey emotions and situations that the participants described through in-depth interviews. She wrote the final video was a practical solution to the participants' refusal to be video-recorded, and writing, "I substituted the participants' faces and their gestures and actions in front of the camera by symbols that engages metaphors of the verbal and visual narratives" (p. 291)

Finally, she discussed some limitations of her work: Although the video should represent the finding, but screening the video itself potentially limit a generation of sociological knowledge. She admitted that the video should be presented alongside with the conventional text analysis of the project for the best understanding of the project. However, she pointed out, access to visual data in publication limits video methodology in the social sciences. Video is not streamlined in the publication unlike still images, she argued.

She quoted Ken Plummer (2001, Documents of life 2, An invitation to a critical humanism) in the delayed use of video for sociology:

"[I]ndeed a whole new generation of "video" experts seems to have emerged outside of sociology to do sociology's work! There are now several generations of "video workers" who have used video as radical means of transforming the orthodox visual image and of providing a whole library of "alternative video forms." (p. 71, cited p. 303)

Tuesday, January 26, 2010

Modernity versus Postmodernity

Habermas, Jürgen. (1981). New German Critique, 22 (Special Issue on Modernism, 3-14.

Habermas's primary focus lies in a disturbed communicative infrastructure of everyday life, which is caused in the process of social modernization for economic growth and accomplishments of the state by subordinating human life-world to systems' imperatives.

In this ground, he sheds light on cultural modernity, which he notes stems from a doubt of the project of modernity and criticism of modernity. Habermas draws the conceptual framework of cultural modernity from Max Weber, who characterized cultural modernity as the separation of the substantive reason of religion and metaphysics into three autonomous spheres: science, morality and art. From this foundation, Habermas finds the root of the modernity in the project of Enlightenment in the 18th century. According to Habermas, the Enlightenment, which aimed at the rationalization of every day life by developing objective science, universal morality and law, and autonomous art under the control of specialists, came to impoverish real life and diminish everyday communication.

Observing surrealists' approach to art, negation of art, Habermas asserts, "nothing remains form a desublimated meaning or a destructured form; an emancipatory does not follow". Looking for alternatives, Habermas contests that the project of modernity has not yet fulfilled, suggesting that the project should relink modern culture with everyday life and a new kind of societal modernization is a prior condition of the cultural reconnection.

Habermas distinguishes three conceptions surrounding modenity: the antimodernism of young conservatives, the remodernism of old conservatives and the postmodernism of neoconservatives.[my emphasis... This analysis is somewhat ambiguous.]

Sunday, January 24, 2010

The Postmodern Explained

Lyotard, Jean-François. (1993). Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.

Chapter 1. Answers to the Question, What is the Postmodern? (p. 1-16)

Lyotard describes the key concept of the postmodern as "war on totality" (p. 16). In the conceptualization, he opposes in particular to Habermas on his quest of modernity through unifying experiences. Lyotard writes succinctly:

In short, Habermas demands of the arts and the experience they provide that they form a bridge over the gap separating the discourses of knowledge, ethics, and politics, thus opening the way for a unity of experience. (p. 3)

Opposing the concept of unity, Lyotard asserts that the postmodernity reexamines the thought of the Enlightenment, the idea of a uniform end of history, and the idea of the subject.

[Lyotard's idea of the postmodernity revolves primarily around aesthetic judgment.] He holds, "aesthetic judgment would only have to reach a verdict on whether a particular work conforms to the established rules of the beautiful...political academicism understands and imposes a priori criteria of the 'beautiful,' criteria that can, in one move and once and for all, select works and their public." (p. 7).

According to Lyotard, art and literary work is threatened by cultural politics coupled with a capital market order. Thus reality in such work is now to be confirmed by both science and capitalism, and we discover the lack of reality in reality. It is a condition of modernity, he argues.

Lyotard distinguishes modern/avant-guard art and postmodern/transavantguard art in terms of the representation of the "unpresentable". He states:

"[T]he avant-guardes continually expose the artifices of presentation that allow thought to be enslaved by the gaze and diverted from the unpresentable...The postmodern would be that which in the modern invokes the unpresentable in presentation itself, that which refused the consolation of correct forms, refuses the consensus of taste permitting a common experience of nostalgia for the impossible, and inquiries into new presentation--not to take pleasure in them, but to better produce the feeling that there is something unpresentable." (pp. 12-15).

For Lyotard, postmodern artists are a philosopher who constantly investigates the preestablished rules to establish new ones.

Chapter 2. Apostil on Narratives (pp. 17-21)
Defining the project of modernity as the realization of universality, Lyotard argues that the project is "liquidated". He contests that, while contemporary capitalist technoscience was instrumental to fulfilling the project, it became part of the subject that humans tried to master. As a result, contemporary technoscience profoundly "destablized" the project, as seen the populicide at Auschwitz, for instance. Within this context, Lyotard discredits the grand narratives of legitimation and calls for postmodernity, not as the end of modernity but as its anti-thesis.

Chapter 4. Memorandum on Legitimation (pp. 39-59)
In this chapter, Lyotard approaches totalitarianism from the perspective of legitimation. In the quest, he shows his political perspective. He states:

[R]ight cannot be de facto; real society draws legitimacy not from itself but from a community that is not properly nameable, merely required. One cannot deduce what a people ought to be from what it is today, nor can one deduce the concept of the universal citizen from its French or American name--only the reverse is possible. This is why, as I remarked earlier, the ferment and decomposition of the real community are inscribed in the principle of republicanism and in the history it develops. Sovereignty belongs not to the people but to the Idea of the free community. History simply marks the tension of this lack. The republic invokes freedom against security. (p. 51)

This statement implies that republicanism is based on the power of universality. Lyotard argues that totalitarianism borrows its universalizaing power from republicanism and decompose people into "masses" as its identity through authorized parties.

Chapter 7. Note on the Meaning of Post
A simple distinction Lyotard makes between modern and postmodern is that post means "a new direction from the previous one" (p. 76). On the other hand, he states as to modernity:

"The very idea of modernity is closely correlated with the principle that it is both possible and necessary to break with tradition and institute absolutely new ways of living and thinking." (p. 76).

[Lyotard, however, argues that the ideal of modernity has been destroyed for the reasons described earlier.]

Saturday, February 7, 2009

The Cinematic Society and The Reflexive Interview

(Norman Denzin. (2003). In J.F. Cubrium & J.A. Holstein (eds.), Postmodernism Interviewing (pp. 141-155). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage)

In writing "we inhabit a secondhand world" (p. 141)where we experience only representations of the world, Denzin names the contemporary society postmodern cinematic society--"the society that knows itself through the reflective gaze of the cinematic apparatus". The birth of cinematic surveillance in the early 20th century, he explains, made the society exceptionally prone to listening and looking, and this tendency brought about interview society as a consequence of the advent of cinematic realism such as color and sound as well as the emergence of journalistic reporting in mid 1920s. He observes expansions of the use of interview in all sectors of social life and studies such that "the interview society has turned the confessional mode of discourse into a public form of entertainment" and "a public commodity".

He categorizes into four formats the machinery of interview that the interview society takes: objectively neutral format, entertainment and investigative format, collaborative or active format and reflective interview format. By reflexive interview format he means careful interpretation of hidden meanings by paying attention to details and deconstructing the interview itself.

In reviewing "technological apparatus that produce truthful statement" from M. Trinh (1991, When the Moon Waxes Red: Representation, Gender and Cultural Politics. NY: Routledge; p.39), he agrees with Trinh on the influences of documentary interview style on the culture of cinematic society: that is, a filmmaker-as-interivewer sculpts the illusion that viewers watch unmediated reality by using the apparatus and this became predominant cinematic practice in American culture, in particular TV commercials and news. Echoing Trinh's emphasis on reflexive reading, Denzin reminds us that reality is socially constructed and writes, "Filmmaking and documentary interviewing thus become methods of "framing" reality".