Monday, November 22, 2010

Voice of change

: Participatory research in the United States and Canada. Park, Peter, Brydon-Miller, Mary, Hall, Budd, & Jackson, Ted. (Eds.). (1993). Toronto: OISE.

Forward (Paulo Freire, ix-x)
Freire saw PR as a "politico-pedagogic instrument for moving women and men to such transformative action" (ix). This approach changes the relationship between research subjects, the silenced, and researchers as well as the subjects' relationship with their own world. Freire stated:
[T]he silenced are not just incidental to the curiosity of the researcher but are the masters of inquiry into the underlying causes of the events in their world. In this context research becomes a means of moving them beyond silence into a quest to proclaim the world. (p. x)

Introduction (Hall, xiii - xxii)

He defines the first uses of the term, PR, in the research in Tanzania in the early 1970s, and tracks its tradition in emancipatory approach to research, including Fals-Borda and Anisur Rahman (1991). Here action is not as explicit as in action research, which is often described as a short cycle, yet action is implicit, more specifically, "mobilizing for action" (Gaventa, 1988, p. 19) or "a guide in their own action" (Rahman, 1991, "The theoretical standpoint of PAR", p. 15).

Hall stated as participatory research "a process which combines three activities: research, education, and action" (p. xiv). He acknowledged feminist influence, in particular Maguire, on the advance of PR, in that she revealed the distinct silence of gender and women in the PR discourse.
Defining characteristics of PR
1) as QUEST OF VOICE (ontological assumption)
Hall stated, "Participatory research fundamentally is about the right to speak" (p. xvii) and "Participatory research argues for the articulation of points of view by the dominated or subordinated, whether form gender, race, ethnicity, or other structures of subordination" (p. xvii).
2) as COUNTER HEGEMONIC PRACTICE (epistemological assumption)
This view presents PR's epistemological perspective. Hall sees the knowledge produced in PR as part of the counter-hegemonic process.

For Hall, thus, PR is an instrument to having the voices from the margins be heard assertively whereas the creation of knowledge becomes a site of resistance.

What is participatory research? A theoretical and methodological perspective (Peter Park, 1-19)

Park defined PR as "a means of putting research capabilities in the hands of the deprived and disenfranchised people so that they can transform their lives for themselves" (p. 1).

Goals: PR aims at bringing about a more just society by helping the oppressed--or poor--change their social structure.

In this milieu, PR plays a role of providing a framework in which people understand the oppressive social forces and produce knowledge in collective action through a partnership with the researcher. Thus, Park stated that PR is profoundly educational in that people searching and researching, which corresponds to experiential learning (Dewey 1963) and transformative pedagogy (Freire 1970). In particular, Park pointed out, the path from knowledge generation to knowledge utilization is direct because the same actors are involved in both activities: There is no middle-person.

Kinds of knowledge: Park names three kinds of knowledge: instrumental, interactive, and critical knowledge. Instrumental knowledge originates from natural sciences in the attempt to control external events. It influenced traditional social sciences, yet it doesn't recognize human factors in social science. Interactive knowledge, on the other hand, makes human community possible by sharing a world together. The third comes through reflection and action, focusing on justice and public good. Park argued that such knowledge should be formed through a public forum with the full participation of the citizenry, of which the perspective resonates in Habermas's (1972) critical theory. With respect to critical knowledge, Park stated that people learn not only the root causes of the problems but also come to "realize that things do not have to remain the way they are and that they can engage in actions to transform the reality" (pp. 8-9) [This reflects what Katrina said in her reflection essay] Park associated this critical knowledge with Freire's conscientization, which refers to the cycle of reflection-action-reflection. [Here action is not something readily applicable and measurable as indicated in most action research literature. It is more internal process in each individual or within a group.]

The Research Process

Park emphasizes the roles of the researcher:

"The researcher participates in the struggle of the people. This is the other side of participation in this kind of work. He or she becomes a member of the research team with a specific role to play. The researcher works with the community to help turn its felt but unarticulated problem into an identifiable topic of collective investigation." (p.9)

Related to this perspective, Park refers to the researcher as the focal point of research:

"They [participants] usually require an organizing force that will act as the focal point around which they can rally and deal with their problem. This is the role that the researcher plays in participatory research" (p. 9)

Thus, "The researcher essentially acts as a discussion organizer and facilitator and as a technical resource person" (p. 10) [But this shouldn't be narrowly understood.]

Park suggests in the evaluation of PR that "Its success will depend on how acutely the problem is felt by the community and how motivated its members are to do something about it"(p. 10) [Here, Park rejects the criteria of validity or trustworthiness and defines different types of criteria for PR.]

Park argued that the researcher should present to the group methodological options. Park agreed that PR is not bound to any particular methodologies and theoretically draws upon all possible research methods. Yet, he warned that certain methods, which separate researched from researcher, such as psychological experimentation researcher, should be eschewed. In addition, any methods should be designed to allow greater interaction between the questioner and the questioned in order to enhance dialogue. Park argued that dialogue is the most critical methodological feature of participatory research.

Unlike traditional (more QUAN) research, in which all responses are converted to measures of variables, Park argued that the validity of PR depends on "the subjects fully emphasizing with the purpose of the study, thoroughly understanding the intent of the questions, and wanting to give the needed information the best way they know how" (p. 13)

Additionally, Park suggested as a long term criterion of PR:

"Because participatory research is a continuous educational process, it does not end with the completion of one project. When successful, it lives on in the radicalized critical consciousness and the renewed emancipatory practices of each participant" (p. 15)

The Question of Validity
Park is more explicit about the criticism on PR's objectivity and validity: knowledge is not objective is not valid. Park argued that this presumption comes from the epistemological prejudice of positivism, which stems from natural science and the emphasis on instrumental knowledge. He argued that the validity of interactive and critical knowledge should be claimed differently: Does the research produce communal understanding through a broad sense of empathy and connectedness? Does this research produce knowledge that leads to transformation and emancipation both internally and with respect to the external world?

Finally Park argued that even that process of establishing the validity of PR should also be participatory, taking the form of participatory evaluation.

Recovering Popular Knowledge
The PR enterprise is to recover popular knowledge to recreate the participants' authentic life. From this viewpoint, Park argued that PR is more effective in the less developed areas of the world, in which indigenous community/knowledge/communal life still remains.


//
Gaventa, John. (1991). Participatory research in North America. Convergence. 24 (2-3), 19-28.
Fals-Borda & Rahman. (Eds.). (1991). Action and knowledge: Breaking monopoly with participatory action research. New York: Apex.

Moments, Mixed Methods, and Paradigm Dialogs

Denzin, Norman K. (2010). Qualitative Inquiry. 16 (6), 419-427. doi: 10.1177/1077800410364608

Denzin examined mixed methods community, who calls for triangulation in qualitative inquiry. The paradigm wards of the 1970s and 80s, he noted, were played out against a post-Vietnam wars and civil right movements, resulting in flourishing qualitative program evaluation. Now, he sees the current paradigm war plays out against federal interventions, regulating sets of auditing criteria. He calls this current moment the “politics of evidence” (p. 425) Against this positivistic backlash, Denzin called for moral research:

Inquiry has always been and will always be a moral, political, value-laden enterprise. We seek only a politics of hopes, models of social justice to lead us forward.

As members of a larger moral community, we all need to draw together so we can share our problems and experiences with these new discourses. We need a moral and methodological community that honors and celebrates paradigm and methodological diversity. As fellow travelers we need research agendas that advance human rights and social justice through multiple forms of qualitative research. (425-426)

Sunday, November 21, 2010

The action research dissertation

: A guide for students and faculty. Herr, Kathryn & Anderson, Gary L. (2005). Thousand Oaks, London and Delhi: Sage.

1. Introduction (1-7)

The authors note that action research, despite its similarities with QUAL (even with QUAN), is different in that "research participants themselves are either in control of the research or are participants in the design and methodology of the research" (p. 1) and action is central to research. They stated as the most important feature the shifting locus of control from professional researchers to research subjects. They noted several terms indicating research in collaboration with practitioners or community members: PAR, community-based PAR, participatory rural appraisal, feminist action research, emancipatory praxis... The authors choose action research as an umbrella term of these.

The authors defined action research as (1) inquiry done "by or with insiders to an organization or community" (p. 3) (2) action-oriented, (3) a reflective process, meaning "deliberately and systematically undertaken and generally requires that some form of evidence be presented to support assertions."(p. 3). Interestingly, the authors argued that "what constitutes evidence or, in more traditional terms, data is still being debated" (p. 3). (4) It is value laden. The authors rightly pointed out that although action research hopes for solving pressing problems or improving situations, what constitutes improvement or a solution is not self-evident. That reflects conflicting values and an unequal distribution of power and resources. Here they stress the importance of reflexivity: "[T]he notion of reflexivity is crucial because action researchers must interrogate received notions of improvement or solutions in terms of who ultimately benefits from the actions undertaken"(p. 4)

The authors observe a researcher's double burden: action (improvement of practice or social change) and research (valid knowledge production), which sets up a conflict between the rigor and the relevance of the research. Similarly, action research demands a form of intervention which is not honored by traditional researchers. The authors pointed out such interventions constitutes a spiral of action cycles--plan-act-observe-reflect (kemmis 1982, p.7)

The authors also observe that "there is more writing about action research than documentation of actual research studies" (p. 6) They suggest that "a dissertation may represent the documentation of a successful collaboration and be used as a case study of not only the process but also the product of the collaboration" (p. 6).
2. Action research traditions and knowledge interests (8-28)

The authors noted two bands of action research: business-oriented administration and emancipatory practice linked to anticapitalist, grassroots movement. They asserted that "action research is working with an oppressed community ti identify what Freire(1970) called generative themes, or issues that the community agreed had highest priority" (p. 9) Participatoy action research (PAR) emphasizes the aspect of this internal/participatory process from insiders. The authors noted, "Participatory action research (PAR) tempers this expert knowledge with the expertise of locals about their own problems and solutions" (p. 10).

The authors defined participatory research by and large in the legacy of Freire (1970 Pedagogy of the Oppressed). He viewed research as a form of social action in which generative themes are identified and used as a basis of literacy instruction through collaboration. Focusing on Freirean-inspired participatory research, Brown and Tandon(1983) argued that traditional action research concentrated on an individual or group level of analysis, whereas emancipatory participatory research tends to focus on a broader societal analysis. Such PR often creates a resistance to the research.

On the other hand, coining the term co-operative inquiry, Heron (1996) undertook experiential approaches to action research, emphasizing intersubjectivity among researchers and participants: "[T]here is the possibility of reciprocal participative knowing" (p. 11)

The authors remarked that both the trends (liberation or humanistic psychology) are concerned with using PR for humanization.

The authors pointed out the danger of co-optation in doing action research. They argued that the nature of social institutions is keeping its status quo, thus, if action research lacks a critical spirit, it runs the risk of legimitizing the current status quo.

They noted emerging critical approaches to action research from feminist and critical race theorists to a lesser extent.

Epistemologically, the authors trace back to Jurgen Habermas (1971, Knowledge and Human Interests), who argued knowledge production is never neutral and always pursued with some interest. He argued three types of interest: technical interest (controlling over the natural and social realm), practical interest (gaining understanding through interpretation), and emancipatory interest (the release of human potential and the investigation of ideology and power relation). Depending on types of interest, the authors argue that research aims vary. They see action research in tune with emancipatory knowledge interest, which aims at critical reflection on power constraint imposed on our understanding. However, they stated:

"[W]hile certain methodologies tend to be associated with certain knowledge interest, we don't see a conflict in using statistical methods toward emancipatory ends, as long as it forms part of a cycle of ongoing critical reflection" (p. 28).

[Here, again, the authors place action (participatory) research as a paradigm distinguished from qualitative or qualitative methodology, while slightly emphasizing their position in the emancipatory stream. HOWEVER, when participants utilize or emulate certain methods, which are considered dehumanizing, would it be considered emancipatory? The positionality of participants as insiders would make a difference, while outside researchers conduct surveys, for instance...But I am not quite sure right now.]

3. The continuum of positionality in action research (29-48)

The authors explore different implications of positionality between insiders and outsiders. Here PAR is defined as either reciprocal collaboration or outsider(s) collaborating with insider(s). They assert that although reciprocal collaboration is ideal, many different positinalities are possible and valuable as long as researchers are aware of them and honest about them. The issue of positionalities is also important to the authors because it affects the criteria for quality or trustworthiness of the study they conduct.

4. Quality criteria for action research (49-68)
The authors reject validity (QUAN) and trustworthiness (QUAL/naturalistic researchers) as criteria for action research because the terms do not acknowledge action-oriented outcomes. Instead, they propose five validity criteria which are associated with the goals of action research.

Goal1: the generation of new knowledge-->dialogic and process validity
Goal2: the achievement of action-oriented outcomes-->outcome validity
Goal3: the education of both researcher and participants-->catalytic validity
Goal4: Results that are relevant tot eh local setting-->Democratic validity
Goal5: A sound and appropriate research methodology-->process validity

Process validity: the manner in which research is conducted, including triangulation
Outcome validity: whether action occurs [What is action? In many emancipatory participatory research, action may be intrinsic and they may lack agency to implement the research results but their research has implications of policy change. Thus, actions that may be qualified in more conventional action research may not be appropriate here.]
Catalytic validity: does research lead its participants and researchers to know the reality and transform it? This validity has to do with transformative potential.
Democratic validity: is the research done in collaboration with all parties? In particular, it draws on locality (Cunningham, 1983): does problems emerge from a local context and the solutions are appropriate to that context?
Dialogic validity: peer review.

[I WONDER whether it is appropriate to apply these criteria to both business-oriented and emancipatory action research.]

Reason and Bradbury (2001, Handbook of action research) defined action research as "an emerging, evolutionary and educational process of engaging with self, persons and communities that needs to be sustained for a significant period of time" (p. 12, as cited p. 58).

In short, the authors depart from current QUAN and QUAL validity criteria for action research.

About GENERALIZATION.
The authors take on Robert Stake's (1986) position on naturalistic generalization to illustrate their own. He explained naturalistic generalizations as a way of leading audiences to vicarious experience and helping them think of their own problems in a new way:

A person would be described as an individual, with uniqueness not just in deviance scores, but as a key to understanding the interactions. A reader senses the experience of teamwork in this particular situation. It is a unique situation in some respects, but ordinary in other respects. Readers recognize similarities with situations of their own. Perhaps they are stimulated to think of old problems in a new way (p.99)

In writing dissertation, the authors emphasize that students clarify the evolution, documenting the decisions made. They acknowledge that in naturalistic inquiry, methodologies evolve, yet it should be documented. Secondly, they stress that the students think through their multiple roles in this research as researcher, as outsider, as facilitator, etc.


////
Brown & Tandon
doi: 10.1177/002188638301900306 Journal of Applied Behavioral Science September 1983 vol. 19 no. 3 277-294

Heron, J. (1996). Co-operative inquiry: Research into the human condition. London: Sage.

Cunningham, J. B. (1983). Gathering data in a changing organization. Human relations, 36 (5), 403-420

Stake, R. (1986). An evolutionary view of educational improvement. In E.R. House (Ed.), New directions in educational evaluation (pp. 89-102). London: Falmer.

Saturday, November 20, 2010

A Critique of Experimentalism

Howe, Kenneth R. (2004). Qualitative Inquiry, 10 (1), 42-61. doi: 10.1177/1077800403259491

Howe criticized neoclassical experimentalism—appropriating medical research as a model for all science research--saying “it gets the shoe on the wrong foot” (p. 49); On the other hand, mixed-methods experimentalism—predominantly in education field--is an advance over neoclassical experimentalism. Yet, it also places quantitative methods and centering technocratic perspective, what works for the research, and randomized experiments, thus Howe wrote this, too, is retrograde. He argued that it focuses on the question “whether interventions are effective in achieving given outcomes” (p.54).

Howe argued that there is no preset of criteria to determine what constitutes “scientific” research. Instead, researchers should decide what is counted as science or scientific, he said, adding such decisions are value laden.

Pointing out the pervasive influence of interpretivism on social science, Howe drew attention on Cronbach’ (1975) generalizations decay and Giddens’s (1976) double hermeneutic. What Cronbach meant by generalization decay is generalizations are fallible and subject to change over time. Double hermeneutic means that there are two types of interpretations in social science—one by researchers and the other by their audience. Howe pointed out, “For ‘critical’ researchers, making generalizations decay—generalizations documenting oppressive relationships, in particular—is an explicit goal of social research” (51-52).

Criticizing the mainstream mixed methods experimentalism, Howe looked into mixed methods interpretivism. He stressed that the outcome of this type of research are open to end and determined by stakeholders, thus, for him, inclusion and dialogue are central to this research approach. He put qualitative methods at the front versus QUAN. More importantly, the role of participants divides this approach from mixed methods experimentalism.

In conclusion, Howe noted that the contrast between the technocratic experimentalism and democratic interpretivism gets at the political dimensions of educational research. [Here Howe’s democratic interpretivism can be framed as “participatory” research, although he does not mention.]

Qualitative Inquiry Under Fire

: Toward a new paradigm dialogue. Denzin, N. K. (2009). Walnut Creek, CA: Left coast press.

1. Introduction (13-24)
Denzin defined the current regime of qualitative research as conservative evidence based or scientifically based research (SBR). He finds this trend in a nostalgia toward positivism and sees it as a continuation of the paradigm wars of the 1980s, being implemented as part of a conservative political backlash. "American postpositivists in the 1990s and the in the first decade of the new century were aligned with SBR movements that were gaining force under conservative political regimes..."(p. 21)
Denzin stated that "Mixed methods are direct descendants of classical experimentalism and the triangulation movement of the 1970s" (p. 17, Denzin 1989 "The research act: a theoretical introduction to sociological methods") The advent of the mixed-methods movement called for the paradigm wars of the 1980s, asking whether methods and perspectives could be combined and compatible. Morse(2003) warns that ad-hoc mixing of methods would threat validity; others deconstruct validity; Hesse-Biber and Leavy (2008) emphasized emerging methods that blur the boundaries between QUAL and QUAN methods and seeks to reveal subjugated knowledge underpinning everyday life. Amid the blurring boundariesDenzin noted an emerging confluence that focuses on the value of multivocal texts, as Guba and Lincoln (2005) suggested, which emphasizes a shared commitment to social justice and human rights. Within this context, Denzin write: "It is time to take stack, time, time to be reflexively self-critical" (p. 21)

2. Interpretive research after 9/11/01 (25-38)
Denzin argued that the conservative backlash after 9/11 attempted to regulate interpretive inquiry by enforcing bio-medical and evidence-based methods. Thus, he called for a radical change in critical interpretive inquiry.

4. The Elephant in the living room or extending the conversation about the politics of evidence (57-82)
Denzin describes the evidence-based model of research in qualitative inquiry as an elephant sitting in a living room. The evidence-based research movement and emerging standards and guidelines for conducting qualitative inquiry is at the brink of an global tendency.
Denzin pointed out three basic positions on the issue of evaluative criteria: foundational, quasifoundational, and nonfoundational. Foundational argues for a shared set of criteria, QUAL or QUAN, such as validity, credibility, transferability, confirmability, warrantibility, tranparency); Quasifoundational concerns about criteria for qualitative research, such as reflexivity, theoretical grounding, iconic; nonfoundationalists "stress the importance of understanding versus prediction. They conceptualize inquiry within a moral frame, implementing an ethic rooted in the concepts of care, love, and kindness" (p. 61).

For Denzin, "Inquiry is always political and moral" (p. 82). Likewise, "Objectivity and evidence are political and ethical terms" (p. 82). He stresses that ways of knowing are always partial, moral, and political.

5. The art of interpretation: The stories we tell one another (85-114)

Monday, November 8, 2010

The theory & practice of learning

By Peter Jarvis, John Holford, Colin Griffin

e-book : www.myilibrary.com?id=7668
[get e-reader: 2 week loan period]

Sunday, November 7, 2010

Constructing grounded theory : a practical guide through qualitative analysis

Charmaz, Kathy. (2006). Sage.

S/S library. H61.24 C45 2006