Orlando Fals-Borda. (2002). In P. Valero & O. Skovsmose (Eds.), Proceedings of the 3rd International conference on mathematics education and society (pp. 1-10).
Copenhagen: Centre for Research in Learning Mathematics.
For him, PAR attempts to challenge power through a radical change in knowledge production. He stated:
We appeared to be involved in a risky mixture of power/ knowledge, for we dared to challenge established ways and rules with heterodox research-and-study techniques in the field, in the classroom and even in the comfort of our armchairs in order to promote changes that are felt necessary both for academia and for society at large. (p. 2)
PAR is a remedy for ineffective analytical procedure in academia and at the same time a tool to pursue social justice for ordinary people in society. From this perspective, he drew attention to three types of tensions that arose in building PAR : (1) theory/practice in determining appropriate safeguards for the application of praxis, (2) in the meaning of the subject/ object and knowledge triad; and 3) in the search for a more satisfactory vision of science, within the context of mathematics education.
Concerning validity, Fals-Borda argued that it has to do with the notions of QUAL and QUAN research. He continued that quantitative measures may be combined with qualitative descriptions. More importantly, he stated:
Validity criteria could be derived from sources other than numerical regressions and correlations. Such alternative guidelines could be drawn by common sense, from inductive/deductive analysis of results obtained in practice through personal involvement in processes, and approved by the considered judgement of local reference groups. (p. 7)
Validity can be sought through self-reflexivity, participants, and other reference groups, as suggested in constructivist approaches as shown in fourth generation evaluation.
Fals-Borda asserted that PAR can bring together diverse knowledge systems--suggesting both QUAL and QUAN--and wrote that is a challenge for intellectual and moral reconstruction. He stated:
Convergence of this type should only be limited by how useful it is in the sociocultural and environmental context that inspired it, and in producing the positive practical results expected of it in the real world. (p. 8)
He noted, "PAR approach is open, plural, practical and interdisciplinary" (p. 9). He continued to stress that:
This open, holistic paradigm of PAR brings together praxis and ethics, academic knowledge and popular wisdom, the professor and the student, the rational and the existential, the regular and the fractal, the qualitative and the quantitative. It breaks down the subject/object dichotomy. It is founded on the democratic pluralist concepts of otherness, service and justice, upholding toleration of diversity and introducing neglected perspectives of culture, gender, popular classes and pluriethnicity into research and teaching activities. (p. 9)
Showing posts with label action research. Show all posts
Showing posts with label action research. Show all posts
Friday, December 3, 2010
Ideology and Political Economy in Inquiry
: Action research and participatory research. (1983). L. David Brown & Rajesh Tandon. Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 19 (3), 277-294. DOI: 10.1177/002188638301900306
The authors examine two traditions of applied behavioral science inquiry--action research and participatory research. They argued that both espouse similar values and employ common methods in different settings.
They pointed out that action research, formulated by Lewin, which consists of cycles of analysis, fact finding, conceptualization, planning, implementation, and evaluation to simultaneously solve problems and generate new knowledge. They observed that action research took place in the Global North in business firms and educational organizations. Yet, academia social scientists had not accepted it as fully as applied researchers in organizations.
On the other hand, participatory research emerged from the work with the oppressed in the Third World, where problems of adult education and social oppression are particularly acute, in various forms, such as Freire's conscientization and other work in Africa and Asia. The international network of participatory researchers was formed in 1978 sponsored by the International Council for Adult Education. Here the characteristics of participatory research were summarized:
Hall (1981, Convergence, p.7) defined participatory research as "an integrated activity that combines social investigation, educational work and action."
The authors examine two traditions of applied behavioral science inquiry--action research and participatory research. They argued that both espouse similar values and employ common methods in different settings.
They pointed out that action research, formulated by Lewin, which consists of cycles of analysis, fact finding, conceptualization, planning, implementation, and evaluation to simultaneously solve problems and generate new knowledge. They observed that action research took place in the Global North in business firms and educational organizations. Yet, academia social scientists had not accepted it as fully as applied researchers in organizations.
On the other hand, participatory research emerged from the work with the oppressed in the Third World, where problems of adult education and social oppression are particularly acute, in various forms, such as Freire's conscientization and other work in Africa and Asia. The international network of participatory researchers was formed in 1978 sponsored by the International Council for Adult Education. Here the characteristics of participatory research were summarized:
Hall (1981, Convergence, p.7) defined participatory research as "an integrated activity that combines social investigation, educational work and action."
Thursday, December 2, 2010
An alternative paradigm dialog
Egon C. Guba (1990). In E.G. Guba (Ed.), The paradigm dialog (pp. 17-30). Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
In this chapter, Guba proposed as the generic definition of paradigm "a basic set of belief that guides action" (p. 17), in particular, disciplined inquiry as the action in our concern. Such paradigms respond to three questions: ontological, epistemological, and methodological questions.
1) Ontological: What is the nature of reality?
2) Epistemological: What is the nature of the relationship between the knower (researcher) and the known (researched)?
3) Methodological: what is the process of finding out knowledge or research?
Positivism
The positivist paradigm is rooted in a realist ontology, the belief that "there exists a reality out there driven by immutable natural laws" (p. 19). The purpose of science is to discover the true nature of reality and how it truly works.
From this ground, positivists practice an objectivist epistemology, in which they put questions directly to nature and wait for its answer without altering it. Since the inquirer can be positioned far away from nature, research outcomes are value free. Within this paradigm, experimental/manipulative methodology is the most appropriate in such a way that questions and hypotheses are stated in advance and subjected to empirical tests under carefully controlled conditions.
Postpositivism
It is a modified/less naïve version of positivism. It is based on critical realism: postpositivists believe that reality exists out there, yet because of human sensory/intellectual limitations, it is impossible for humans truly to perceive it. Thus, they emphasize the need for being critical about what researchers find.
Epistemologically, postpositivists recognize the absurdity of the separation of inquirers from the inquired; thus they take on a modified objectivist epistemology in the sense that objectivity is a regulatory ideal to adhere, yet in reality, can be achieved reasonably closely (approximated) only by cleaning up one's preposition, relying on the tradition of the field to report the inquiry, and seeking judgment from peers in the disciplinary community. Guba criticized that the latter two requirements virtually make is impossible for new paradigm to assert themselves.
Methodologically, it put forth critical multiplism (modified experimentalism/manipulatism), which was also articulated as triangulation by Denzin (1978). Because of limited human sensory, it seeks as many sources as possible to draw findings. They often calls for more qualitative methods, depending more on grounded theory, and reintroducing discovery into the inquiry process.
Critical Theory
Guba proposed the label of "ideologically oriented inquiry" instead of critical theory, which encompasses feminism, neo-Marxism, Frerieism, participatory inquiry, and critical theory. The shared quality in this family is rejecting the claim of "value freedom" made by positivism (and postpositivism to an extent). They believe that values do enter into every inquiry; inquiry thereby becomes a political act.
Guba criticizes an ontological juncture that critical theorists (ideologists) adhere to:
But, for whatever reason, critical theorists (ideologists) have elected to believe in an objective reality--as the phrase commonly used by them, "false consciousness," readily demonstrates (because it implies that there is a "true consciousness" somewhere "out there," or, more likely, possessed by the inquirer or some better informed elite). The task of inquiry is, by definition, to raise people (the oppressed) to a level of "true consciousness." Once they appreciate how oppressed they are, they can act to transform the world. The close parallel between transforming the world and predicting and controlling it should not be lost. (p. 24)
Critical theorists undertake subjectivist epistemology, regarding inquiry acts as a process intimately related to the inquirer's values. Yet, Guba points out a logical disjunction a "realist ontology coupled with a subjectivist epistemology" (p. 24).
Guba asserted that critical theorists' methodology is more consistent and framed it as transformative and dialogic one. It seeks to eliminate false consciousness and to facilitate transformation.
Constructivism
Constructivist calls for a completely different paradigm. It acknowledge value-laden facts and furthermore, the interaction of inquirer and inquired into that shapes outcomes of an inquiry. Therefore, constructivists state that:
It [constructivism] renders the distinction between ontology and epistemology obsolete; what can be known and the individual who comes to know it are fused into a coherent whole. Further, it makes the findings of an inquiry not a report of what is "out there" but the residue of a process that literally creates them. Finally, it depicts knowledge as the outcome or consequence of human activity; knowledge is a human construction, never certifiable as ultimately true but problematic and ever changing. (p. 26)
From this perspective, ontologically, it takes a position of relativism in that "realities are multiple, and they exist in people's minds" (p. 26). Guba argued that relativism is "the key to openness and the continuing search for ever more informed and sophisticated constructions" (p. 26).
Epistemologically, the constructivist takes a subjectivist position, not because of the limited human conditions but because of its ontological assumptions: if realities exist only in people's minds, subjectivist interaction is the only way to accessing them.
Methodologically, the constructivist takes hermeneutics and dialectics: it attempts to depict individual constructions as accurately as possible, and simultaneously, contrast and compare dialectically to generate informed constructions on which there is substantial consensus.
In this chapter, Guba proposed as the generic definition of paradigm "a basic set of belief that guides action" (p. 17), in particular, disciplined inquiry as the action in our concern. Such paradigms respond to three questions: ontological, epistemological, and methodological questions.
1) Ontological: What is the nature of reality?
2) Epistemological: What is the nature of the relationship between the knower (researcher) and the known (researched)?
3) Methodological: what is the process of finding out knowledge or research?
Positivism
The positivist paradigm is rooted in a realist ontology, the belief that "there exists a reality out there driven by immutable natural laws" (p. 19). The purpose of science is to discover the true nature of reality and how it truly works.
From this ground, positivists practice an objectivist epistemology, in which they put questions directly to nature and wait for its answer without altering it. Since the inquirer can be positioned far away from nature, research outcomes are value free. Within this paradigm, experimental/manipulative methodology is the most appropriate in such a way that questions and hypotheses are stated in advance and subjected to empirical tests under carefully controlled conditions.
Postpositivism
It is a modified/less naïve version of positivism. It is based on critical realism: postpositivists believe that reality exists out there, yet because of human sensory/intellectual limitations, it is impossible for humans truly to perceive it. Thus, they emphasize the need for being critical about what researchers find.
Epistemologically, postpositivists recognize the absurdity of the separation of inquirers from the inquired; thus they take on a modified objectivist epistemology in the sense that objectivity is a regulatory ideal to adhere, yet in reality, can be achieved reasonably closely (approximated) only by cleaning up one's preposition, relying on the tradition of the field to report the inquiry, and seeking judgment from peers in the disciplinary community. Guba criticized that the latter two requirements virtually make is impossible for new paradigm to assert themselves.
Methodologically, it put forth critical multiplism (modified experimentalism/manipulatism), which was also articulated as triangulation by Denzin (1978). Because of limited human sensory, it seeks as many sources as possible to draw findings. They often calls for more qualitative methods, depending more on grounded theory, and reintroducing discovery into the inquiry process.
Critical Theory
Guba proposed the label of "ideologically oriented inquiry" instead of critical theory, which encompasses feminism, neo-Marxism, Frerieism, participatory inquiry, and critical theory. The shared quality in this family is rejecting the claim of "value freedom" made by positivism (and postpositivism to an extent). They believe that values do enter into every inquiry; inquiry thereby becomes a political act.
Guba criticizes an ontological juncture that critical theorists (ideologists) adhere to:
But, for whatever reason, critical theorists (ideologists) have elected to believe in an objective reality--as the phrase commonly used by them, "false consciousness," readily demonstrates (because it implies that there is a "true consciousness" somewhere "out there," or, more likely, possessed by the inquirer or some better informed elite). The task of inquiry is, by definition, to raise people (the oppressed) to a level of "true consciousness." Once they appreciate how oppressed they are, they can act to transform the world. The close parallel between transforming the world and predicting and controlling it should not be lost. (p. 24)
Critical theorists undertake subjectivist epistemology, regarding inquiry acts as a process intimately related to the inquirer's values. Yet, Guba points out a logical disjunction a "realist ontology coupled with a subjectivist epistemology" (p. 24).
Guba asserted that critical theorists' methodology is more consistent and framed it as transformative and dialogic one. It seeks to eliminate false consciousness and to facilitate transformation.
Constructivism
Constructivist calls for a completely different paradigm. It acknowledge value-laden facts and furthermore, the interaction of inquirer and inquired into that shapes outcomes of an inquiry. Therefore, constructivists state that:
It [constructivism] renders the distinction between ontology and epistemology obsolete; what can be known and the individual who comes to know it are fused into a coherent whole. Further, it makes the findings of an inquiry not a report of what is "out there" but the residue of a process that literally creates them. Finally, it depicts knowledge as the outcome or consequence of human activity; knowledge is a human construction, never certifiable as ultimately true but problematic and ever changing. (p. 26)
From this perspective, ontologically, it takes a position of relativism in that "realities are multiple, and they exist in people's minds" (p. 26). Guba argued that relativism is "the key to openness and the continuing search for ever more informed and sophisticated constructions" (p. 26).
Epistemologically, the constructivist takes a subjectivist position, not because of the limited human conditions but because of its ontological assumptions: if realities exist only in people's minds, subjectivist interaction is the only way to accessing them.
Methodologically, the constructivist takes hermeneutics and dialectics: it attempts to depict individual constructions as accurately as possible, and simultaneously, contrast and compare dialectically to generate informed constructions on which there is substantial consensus.
Tuesday, November 30, 2010
The Sage handbook of action research
: Participative inquiry and practice. Reason, Peter & Bradbury, Hilary (Eds.). (2008). London, Thousand Oaks, New Delhi, and Singapore: Sage.
Introduction (P. Reason & H. Bradbury, 1-13)
Reason and Bradbury traced back to the origin of action research to Lewin, liberationist perspective, exemplified by Freire, scholar-practitioners' work in education, health, and community development, and philosophical roots in critical theory, constructivism, phenomenology, etc. Epistemologically, they argue that action research has been shied away from the mainstream social sciences, which focus on objectivity and emphasize representation rather than action. Within this context, they define action research as:
a family of practices of living inquiry that aims, in a great variety of ways, to link practice and ideas in the service of human flourishing. It is not so much a methodology as an orientation to inquiry that seeks to create participative communities of inquiry in which qualities of engagement, curiosity and question posing are brought o bear on significant practical issues. (p. 1)
In their definition, action research is characterized with a participatory process. They wrote: "[A]ction research is participatory research, and all participatory research must be action research" (p. 4). Here "action" means that research responds to "people's desire to act creatively in the face of practical and often pressing issues in their lives in organization and communities" (p. 3) and it is action because the research looks into the participants' own action in their daily lives. They distinguish action research from traditional research in that action research aims at producing practical knowledge to act upon practical issues and bring about transformative experience of our daily lives. Thereby, it is contentious to some of the academic community, which aims at producing academic theories unencumbered by practical questions. In so doing, action research challenges a monopoly of knowledge production inveterate in academic practices. The authors emphasize the emancipatory dimension of action research: Without it, action research would be co-opted by the status quo instead of flourishing individual or community lives.
The authors' terms first, second, and third-person research practices as an organizing framework are useful to analyze the process of action research. First-person action research practices involve with the individual ability to inquire into his or her own life. Second-person action research practices addresses the ability to inquire into mutual issues and problem through face-to-face interpersonal dialogue and develop organizations. Third-person action research practices aims to create a wider impact. They assert that research reports can be an important form of third-person inquiry.
The authors do not bind action research with a specific set of methodologies. Instead, they draw attention to action research as a form of bringing scholarship and praxis together and a new way of knowing, and the development of new thinking about validity and quality in research. It is a paradigm. In their definition, participation is the backbone of action research. They also note that participation is political in that it allows people to have a say in decision making and producing knowledge about them. It empowers them because it allows them to see that they can construct and use their own knowledge to address pressing issue.
Living inquiry: Personal, political and philosophical groundings for action research practice (15-30, Wicks, P. G., Reason, P., & Bradbury, H. ).
The authors analyze the survey responses from action research practitioners. One of the patterns noted by the respondents is Thomas Kuhn's influence on paradigmatic shift for their epistemological understanding and research practices. Some also attributed their practices to pragmatist position that "knowledge is acquired through responding to a real need in life" (p. 19). Most respondents also seek critical social theories as their philosophical backdrop: the political dimension of theories and knowledge led them to the perspective that knowledge is value-laden and can be emancipatory. Also many come from the objection to traditional education research and embraces critical perspectives on pedagogy influenced by Freire and Hall. McTaggart and Kemmis in particular look for the transformative potential of action research. The authors conclude as the status of action researchers:
[A]ction researchers themselves could be understood to have been action as 'bricoleurs' over time, and in a very real sense, 'making the road while walking'. Indeed, the active process of integrating and making sense of various influences and perspectives and of developing one's own understanding seems to be central to many action researchers' accounts. (p. 26)
Participatory action research as practice (31-48, Swantz, Marja Liisa)
Swantz argued that the conventional scientific criteria could not validate PAR; practical success verifies the usefulness, asserted the author. Specifically, she noted Heinz Moser's (1975, as cited on page 43) three criteria: (1) transparency: are all the participants aware of the whole process of research, such as functions, aims, and methods, (2) compatibility of the aims and methods. For instance, outside researchers cannot be an independent observer, and (3) participant researcher's claim: does she claim that she knows better than does any outside observer and can she set forth all the aspects that she knows? [Criteria to evaluate PR]
Analyzing her own work, Swantz argued for the potential of participatory action research: She argued that by breaking the monopoly of privileged knowledge, people can break the monopoly of bureaucratic and technocratic power. She also asserts that knowledge should be grained in people's lives and PAR should promote such knowledge production.
Some trends in the praxis of participatory action research (Rahman, Anisur. 49-62)
Rahman finds the philosophical background of PAR in Marxist's call for the working class to create their own history, yet pointed out that Marxists have shown little interest in PAR movement. Instead, Freirians or others who focused micro-level grassroots movement and "conscientization" have promoted active PAR. Looking through regional trends throughout the world, Rahman defined PAR as a 'micro ideology' (p. 60), through which the downtrodden people can create their own history by building their own science.
[As Swantz, knowledge is tied to power in the discourse of PAR. Yet, on what basis?]
Continuing the journey: articulating dimensions of feminist participatory action research (FPAR) (Collen Reid and Wendy Frisby, 93-105)
Based on their experience, the authors articulate six dimensions of FPAR:
(1) Centering gender and women's diverse experiences in addressing power;
(2) Accounting for intersectionality across the differences in gender, class, race, culture, etc.
(3) Honoring voice and difference: by articulating personal experiences based on real life, FPAR aims at revealing hidden structural and social institutions. Cooke and Kothari (2001) warned that participatory approaches could contribute to perpetuating entrenched power relations if the heterogeneity of communities is neglected or there is lack of institutional change.
The authors noted as the current limitation of FPAR: "Yet, the feminist ideals of using participatory research techniques to give voice to people's experience and create change by focusing on action aimed at social transformation have not been fully realized" (p. 99).
(4) Exploring new forms of representation by continuing to pushing boundaries of prescribed ways of conducting research;
(5) Reflexivity: The authors define reflexivity in research as making explicit the power relations and the exercise of power in the research process. They note that feminist action researchers are attentive to self criticism and consciously write about themselves into the text. Yet, they argue that writing themselves into the text is not enough; researchers should write themselves into action and activism, meaning provoking self-discovery by using researchers' own self reflection.
(6) Honoring many forms of action: FPAR sees that actions are dependent on one's social, economic and political situation and can occur at both individual and collective levels. Yet, they argue that in some FPAR, it is not always clear what actions were taken and by whom, its effect, etc. More critically, they stated:
"Another critical consideration is whether individual and local actions eventually link up to a larger social change agenda. What this should look like and what steps could be taken to accomplish this are seldom clear." (p. 102)
* Cooke, B., & Kothari, U. (2001). The case of participation as tyranny. In B. Cooke & U. Kothari (Eds.), Participation: The new tyranny? (pp. 1-15). London: Zed.
Towards transformational liberation: Participatory and action research and praxis (M. Brington Lykes & Amelia Mallona, 106-120)
The authors discussed the liberatory and transformational potential of participatory "and" action research. They argued for a preferential option for the poor and a politically contextualized psychology to realize its radical potential. In particular, looking at PAR conceived in the majority society in the 70s and 80s, they asserted:
Participatory and action research and the broad-based social movements of the time were 'walking a long road together' and, in the best of circumstances, contributed to self- and social consciousness among social actors who constructed participatory and transformative grassroots movements towards social transformation. Participatory and action research were thus situated as a resource at the interface of radical humanism and structural transformation. (p. 109)
The authors also found the same idea in participatory and action research in the late 1960s and 70s in India and Latin America, in which personal transformation was emphasized (i.e Rahman, 1990). The authors described it as radical humanism. Reflecting on their own work around participatory and action research, they wrote:
[W]e are still 'making the road as we go', ever aware of the contradictions described above and that transformational liberation is a process to be engaged in, not an endpoint or outcome that we have achieved. (p. 117)
[Action doesn't have to me immediate, as social change is less likely to occur immediately. It is a progress. Thus I would call participatory research, instead of action research or participatory action research.]
Critical theory and participatory action research (Stephen Kemmis, 121-138)
Drawing upon critical theory--in particular the work of Habermas, Kemmis theorizes a new definition of critical participatory action research (CPAR) [WHY so many words?]
He attended to the increasing emphasis on the "social" in PAR. In particular, he drew attention to Habermas's analysis of social life in late modernity and stressed "communicative spaces" that transforms subjectivity to intersubjectivity, through which people "thematize and explore issues and crises, not from the perspective of whole system (either people or states or other social totalities as 'systems') but in terms of public discussions aimed at greater understanding and transformations of social life at the moments and places where specific crises occur" (p. 122).
But in fact, Kemmis's definition of critical PAR is not new. Rather, it insinuates a change within his perspective. His emphasis on PAR was closer to Lewin's action research. In this chapter, he came to see macro-dynamics and adjoin critical theory to his own definition of PAR.
Social construction ad research as action (159-171. Kenneth J. Gergen and Mary M. Gergen)
Gergen and Gergen explores the nexus between action research and constructionist theory. (To begin with, they clarify constructionism and constructivism: Social construction refers to a tradition of scholarship that traces the origin of knowledge, meaning or understanding to human relationships, whereas constructivist scholars views processes inherent in the individual mind and their interpretation of the world.)
As the convergence between "action oriented research" and constructionist theory, the authors explore four aspects:
(1) research as political action: As opposed to posivitists who are committed to a view of scientific neutrality and value-free facts, constructionists believe that "all research is essentially a contribution to domains of meaning" regardless of the researcher's intention. Likewise, action researchers also bring forth values in their research and do not advocate universality, treating action research as like storytelling than sermonizing.
(2) collaboration beyond individualism: As another characteristic of action research that cut away from traditional positive research practices, the authors refer to collaborative methods as opposed to individualist orientation of research. (Heron and Reason (2001) emphasizeds action research as a 'practice of co-operative inquiry,' a domain of practice that researches 'with people rather than on people'). This shift from an individualist to a collectivist orientation to research methods is in tune with constructionism. The authors noted, " constructionist theory lends itself to an ontology in which relationship precedes the individual" (p. 166) and it accounts constructionists' approach to knowledge formation.
(3) From mapping to world making: as opposed to positivist program, in which researchers attempt to bring about accurate accounts of the world, constructionists believe that language cannot map the world of human behaviors and social sciences can only bring about the meaning of the world. Likewise, action researchers reject the concept of describing "the world as it is". Rather, their focus is laid on social change and to realize versions of "what the world can become" (p. 167).
(4) From theoretical and practical priority: In the positivist tradition, the ultimate goal of research is the development of general theory and research itself is important as a case to vindicate or challenge theoretical assumptions. On the other hand, constructionists believe that experimental methods are typically remote from everyday life, thus being stripped of cultural significance; abstract theory has not of use. Within this context, the authors state that action research provides a refreshing and productive alternative by attempting to change existing conditions of life, for its ultimate goal is to generate change.
*Heron, J. & Reason, P. (2001). The practice of co-operative inquiry: research "with" rather than "on" people. In P. Reason and H. Bradbury (Eds.), Handbook of action research: participative inquiry and practice (pp. 179-99). London: Sage.
Power and knowledge (172-189, John Gaventa and Andrea Cornwall)
The authors observed that participatory action researchers have focused on their critique on structural relationships between power and monopolies of knowledge. In particular, Fals-Borda and Rahman (1991) asserted that the control of knowledge and its production was as important as material and other social relations. In this light, they saw the role of PAR is to empower themselves by participating in knowledge production through action and reflection.
The authors asserted that despite slightly different understandings of the location of power (i.e. power within, power between, power embedded in social relations, etc.), PAR practitioners share an epistemological critique about ways in which knowledge is embedded and reinforced in the dominant (or positivist) knowledge production system.
(1) positivist methods distort reality by distancing those who study reality from those who experience it;
(2) traditional research methods (surveys, i.e.) further alienate powerless groups by making them the objects of another's inquiry. And, empirical, quantitative form of knowledge may reduce the complexity of human experience;
(3) it perpetuates the legitimacy of knowledge produced by a small number of privileged experts by obscuring other forms of knowledge and the voices of other knowers.
From this perspective, PAR (1) attempts to bring forth a different forms of knowledge, the authors argued, thereby letting those who directed affected by the research participate in the research process ; PAR also recognizes the social constructedness of knowledge, thus delving into collective analysis of life experiences of power and knowledge; Lastly PAR recognizes different ways of knowing and viewing reality: research often starts with popular knowledge, yet it is deepened through a dialectical process of acting and understanding. It also stresses the importance of listening to diverse voices within the group.
The authors draw a diagram of dimensions of participatory research: participation is constituted by knowledge (as a source to affect decision-making), action (involvement in such knowledge production), and consciousness (production of knowledge as consciousness builder). They observe that one or more aspects are emphasized among PAR practitioners.
[It is interesting to note that "action" is far from the concept of Lewin's action research. Action-reflection is an important cycle of the authors' PAR, yet here action is the process of participation in knowledge production itself, not the part of verification of Lewin's concept of action research.]
Ethics and action research: Deepening our commitment to principles of social justice and redefining systems of democratic practice (199-209, Mary Brydon-Miller)
Brydon-Miller analyzes key ethical principles of research within the notion of power in research setting. For her, the shared values of action research, such as "participation in democratic processes, the improvement of human life, and engagement in morally committed action" (p. 209), are the very ethical challenge among action researchers. Yet, there is a discrepancy between the morality and institutional structural for ethics review. In this light, she rejects the tradition of ethical review centered on university-based experts. She wrote:
[S]hifts in power within the research setting away from the oversight and control of university-based experts and paternalistic oversight committees and toward ownership by members of communities themselves would better reflect the ethical principles of respect for person, beneficence, and justice. This is a critical move if the full promise of these principles is to be realized in our practice as action researchers, but at the same time such redistributions of power and control carry unique challenges and genuine risks if we do not remain vigilant to the ethical implications of our practice. (p. 208)
Introduction (P. Reason & H. Bradbury, 1-13)
Reason and Bradbury traced back to the origin of action research to Lewin, liberationist perspective, exemplified by Freire, scholar-practitioners' work in education, health, and community development, and philosophical roots in critical theory, constructivism, phenomenology, etc. Epistemologically, they argue that action research has been shied away from the mainstream social sciences, which focus on objectivity and emphasize representation rather than action. Within this context, they define action research as:
a family of practices of living inquiry that aims, in a great variety of ways, to link practice and ideas in the service of human flourishing. It is not so much a methodology as an orientation to inquiry that seeks to create participative communities of inquiry in which qualities of engagement, curiosity and question posing are brought o bear on significant practical issues. (p. 1)
In their definition, action research is characterized with a participatory process. They wrote: "[A]ction research is participatory research, and all participatory research must be action research" (p. 4). Here "action" means that research responds to "people's desire to act creatively in the face of practical and often pressing issues in their lives in organization and communities" (p. 3) and it is action because the research looks into the participants' own action in their daily lives. They distinguish action research from traditional research in that action research aims at producing practical knowledge to act upon practical issues and bring about transformative experience of our daily lives. Thereby, it is contentious to some of the academic community, which aims at producing academic theories unencumbered by practical questions. In so doing, action research challenges a monopoly of knowledge production inveterate in academic practices. The authors emphasize the emancipatory dimension of action research: Without it, action research would be co-opted by the status quo instead of flourishing individual or community lives.
The authors' terms first, second, and third-person research practices as an organizing framework are useful to analyze the process of action research. First-person action research practices involve with the individual ability to inquire into his or her own life. Second-person action research practices addresses the ability to inquire into mutual issues and problem through face-to-face interpersonal dialogue and develop organizations. Third-person action research practices aims to create a wider impact. They assert that research reports can be an important form of third-person inquiry.
The authors do not bind action research with a specific set of methodologies. Instead, they draw attention to action research as a form of bringing scholarship and praxis together and a new way of knowing, and the development of new thinking about validity and quality in research. It is a paradigm. In their definition, participation is the backbone of action research. They also note that participation is political in that it allows people to have a say in decision making and producing knowledge about them. It empowers them because it allows them to see that they can construct and use their own knowledge to address pressing issue.
Living inquiry: Personal, political and philosophical groundings for action research practice (15-30, Wicks, P. G., Reason, P., & Bradbury, H. ).
The authors analyze the survey responses from action research practitioners. One of the patterns noted by the respondents is Thomas Kuhn's influence on paradigmatic shift for their epistemological understanding and research practices. Some also attributed their practices to pragmatist position that "knowledge is acquired through responding to a real need in life" (p. 19). Most respondents also seek critical social theories as their philosophical backdrop: the political dimension of theories and knowledge led them to the perspective that knowledge is value-laden and can be emancipatory. Also many come from the objection to traditional education research and embraces critical perspectives on pedagogy influenced by Freire and Hall. McTaggart and Kemmis in particular look for the transformative potential of action research. The authors conclude as the status of action researchers:
[A]ction researchers themselves could be understood to have been action as 'bricoleurs' over time, and in a very real sense, 'making the road while walking'. Indeed, the active process of integrating and making sense of various influences and perspectives and of developing one's own understanding seems to be central to many action researchers' accounts. (p. 26)
Participatory action research as practice (31-48, Swantz, Marja Liisa)
Swantz argued that the conventional scientific criteria could not validate PAR; practical success verifies the usefulness, asserted the author. Specifically, she noted Heinz Moser's (1975, as cited on page 43) three criteria: (1) transparency: are all the participants aware of the whole process of research, such as functions, aims, and methods, (2) compatibility of the aims and methods. For instance, outside researchers cannot be an independent observer, and (3) participant researcher's claim: does she claim that she knows better than does any outside observer and can she set forth all the aspects that she knows? [Criteria to evaluate PR]
Analyzing her own work, Swantz argued for the potential of participatory action research: She argued that by breaking the monopoly of privileged knowledge, people can break the monopoly of bureaucratic and technocratic power. She also asserts that knowledge should be grained in people's lives and PAR should promote such knowledge production.
Some trends in the praxis of participatory action research (Rahman, Anisur. 49-62)
Rahman finds the philosophical background of PAR in Marxist's call for the working class to create their own history, yet pointed out that Marxists have shown little interest in PAR movement. Instead, Freirians or others who focused micro-level grassroots movement and "conscientization" have promoted active PAR. Looking through regional trends throughout the world, Rahman defined PAR as a 'micro ideology' (p. 60), through which the downtrodden people can create their own history by building their own science.
[As Swantz, knowledge is tied to power in the discourse of PAR. Yet, on what basis?]
Continuing the journey: articulating dimensions of feminist participatory action research (FPAR) (Collen Reid and Wendy Frisby, 93-105)
Based on their experience, the authors articulate six dimensions of FPAR:
(1) Centering gender and women's diverse experiences in addressing power;
(2) Accounting for intersectionality across the differences in gender, class, race, culture, etc.
(3) Honoring voice and difference: by articulating personal experiences based on real life, FPAR aims at revealing hidden structural and social institutions. Cooke and Kothari (2001) warned that participatory approaches could contribute to perpetuating entrenched power relations if the heterogeneity of communities is neglected or there is lack of institutional change.
The authors noted as the current limitation of FPAR: "Yet, the feminist ideals of using participatory research techniques to give voice to people's experience and create change by focusing on action aimed at social transformation have not been fully realized" (p. 99).
(4) Exploring new forms of representation by continuing to pushing boundaries of prescribed ways of conducting research;
(5) Reflexivity: The authors define reflexivity in research as making explicit the power relations and the exercise of power in the research process. They note that feminist action researchers are attentive to self criticism and consciously write about themselves into the text. Yet, they argue that writing themselves into the text is not enough; researchers should write themselves into action and activism, meaning provoking self-discovery by using researchers' own self reflection.
(6) Honoring many forms of action: FPAR sees that actions are dependent on one's social, economic and political situation and can occur at both individual and collective levels. Yet, they argue that in some FPAR, it is not always clear what actions were taken and by whom, its effect, etc. More critically, they stated:
"Another critical consideration is whether individual and local actions eventually link up to a larger social change agenda. What this should look like and what steps could be taken to accomplish this are seldom clear." (p. 102)
* Cooke, B., & Kothari, U. (2001). The case of participation as tyranny. In B. Cooke & U. Kothari (Eds.), Participation: The new tyranny? (pp. 1-15). London: Zed.
Towards transformational liberation: Participatory and action research and praxis (M. Brington Lykes & Amelia Mallona, 106-120)
The authors discussed the liberatory and transformational potential of participatory "and" action research. They argued for a preferential option for the poor and a politically contextualized psychology to realize its radical potential. In particular, looking at PAR conceived in the majority society in the 70s and 80s, they asserted:
Participatory and action research and the broad-based social movements of the time were 'walking a long road together' and, in the best of circumstances, contributed to self- and social consciousness among social actors who constructed participatory and transformative grassroots movements towards social transformation. Participatory and action research were thus situated as a resource at the interface of radical humanism and structural transformation. (p. 109)
The authors also found the same idea in participatory and action research in the late 1960s and 70s in India and Latin America, in which personal transformation was emphasized (i.e Rahman, 1990). The authors described it as radical humanism. Reflecting on their own work around participatory and action research, they wrote:
[W]e are still 'making the road as we go', ever aware of the contradictions described above and that transformational liberation is a process to be engaged in, not an endpoint or outcome that we have achieved. (p. 117)
[Action doesn't have to me immediate, as social change is less likely to occur immediately. It is a progress. Thus I would call participatory research, instead of action research or participatory action research.]
Critical theory and participatory action research (Stephen Kemmis, 121-138)
Drawing upon critical theory--in particular the work of Habermas, Kemmis theorizes a new definition of critical participatory action research (CPAR) [WHY so many words?]
He attended to the increasing emphasis on the "social" in PAR. In particular, he drew attention to Habermas's analysis of social life in late modernity and stressed "communicative spaces" that transforms subjectivity to intersubjectivity, through which people "thematize and explore issues and crises, not from the perspective of whole system (either people or states or other social totalities as 'systems') but in terms of public discussions aimed at greater understanding and transformations of social life at the moments and places where specific crises occur" (p. 122).
But in fact, Kemmis's definition of critical PAR is not new. Rather, it insinuates a change within his perspective. His emphasis on PAR was closer to Lewin's action research. In this chapter, he came to see macro-dynamics and adjoin critical theory to his own definition of PAR.
Social construction ad research as action (159-171. Kenneth J. Gergen and Mary M. Gergen)
Gergen and Gergen explores the nexus between action research and constructionist theory. (To begin with, they clarify constructionism and constructivism: Social construction refers to a tradition of scholarship that traces the origin of knowledge, meaning or understanding to human relationships, whereas constructivist scholars views processes inherent in the individual mind and their interpretation of the world.)
As the convergence between "action oriented research" and constructionist theory, the authors explore four aspects:
(1) research as political action: As opposed to posivitists who are committed to a view of scientific neutrality and value-free facts, constructionists believe that "all research is essentially a contribution to domains of meaning" regardless of the researcher's intention. Likewise, action researchers also bring forth values in their research and do not advocate universality, treating action research as like storytelling than sermonizing.
(2) collaboration beyond individualism: As another characteristic of action research that cut away from traditional positive research practices, the authors refer to collaborative methods as opposed to individualist orientation of research. (Heron and Reason (2001) emphasizeds action research as a 'practice of co-operative inquiry,' a domain of practice that researches 'with people rather than on people'). This shift from an individualist to a collectivist orientation to research methods is in tune with constructionism. The authors noted, " constructionist theory lends itself to an ontology in which relationship precedes the individual" (p. 166) and it accounts constructionists' approach to knowledge formation.
(3) From mapping to world making: as opposed to positivist program, in which researchers attempt to bring about accurate accounts of the world, constructionists believe that language cannot map the world of human behaviors and social sciences can only bring about the meaning of the world. Likewise, action researchers reject the concept of describing "the world as it is". Rather, their focus is laid on social change and to realize versions of "what the world can become" (p. 167).
(4) From theoretical and practical priority: In the positivist tradition, the ultimate goal of research is the development of general theory and research itself is important as a case to vindicate or challenge theoretical assumptions. On the other hand, constructionists believe that experimental methods are typically remote from everyday life, thus being stripped of cultural significance; abstract theory has not of use. Within this context, the authors state that action research provides a refreshing and productive alternative by attempting to change existing conditions of life, for its ultimate goal is to generate change.
*Heron, J. & Reason, P. (2001). The practice of co-operative inquiry: research "with" rather than "on" people. In P. Reason and H. Bradbury (Eds.), Handbook of action research: participative inquiry and practice (pp. 179-99). London: Sage.
Power and knowledge (172-189, John Gaventa and Andrea Cornwall)
The authors observed that participatory action researchers have focused on their critique on structural relationships between power and monopolies of knowledge. In particular, Fals-Borda and Rahman (1991) asserted that the control of knowledge and its production was as important as material and other social relations. In this light, they saw the role of PAR is to empower themselves by participating in knowledge production through action and reflection.
The authors asserted that despite slightly different understandings of the location of power (i.e. power within, power between, power embedded in social relations, etc.), PAR practitioners share an epistemological critique about ways in which knowledge is embedded and reinforced in the dominant (or positivist) knowledge production system.
(1) positivist methods distort reality by distancing those who study reality from those who experience it;
(2) traditional research methods (surveys, i.e.) further alienate powerless groups by making them the objects of another's inquiry. And, empirical, quantitative form of knowledge may reduce the complexity of human experience;
(3) it perpetuates the legitimacy of knowledge produced by a small number of privileged experts by obscuring other forms of knowledge and the voices of other knowers.
From this perspective, PAR (1) attempts to bring forth a different forms of knowledge, the authors argued, thereby letting those who directed affected by the research participate in the research process ; PAR also recognizes the social constructedness of knowledge, thus delving into collective analysis of life experiences of power and knowledge; Lastly PAR recognizes different ways of knowing and viewing reality: research often starts with popular knowledge, yet it is deepened through a dialectical process of acting and understanding. It also stresses the importance of listening to diverse voices within the group.
The authors draw a diagram of dimensions of participatory research: participation is constituted by knowledge (as a source to affect decision-making), action (involvement in such knowledge production), and consciousness (production of knowledge as consciousness builder). They observe that one or more aspects are emphasized among PAR practitioners.
[It is interesting to note that "action" is far from the concept of Lewin's action research. Action-reflection is an important cycle of the authors' PAR, yet here action is the process of participation in knowledge production itself, not the part of verification of Lewin's concept of action research.]
Ethics and action research: Deepening our commitment to principles of social justice and redefining systems of democratic practice (199-209, Mary Brydon-Miller)
Brydon-Miller analyzes key ethical principles of research within the notion of power in research setting. For her, the shared values of action research, such as "participation in democratic processes, the improvement of human life, and engagement in morally committed action" (p. 209), are the very ethical challenge among action researchers. Yet, there is a discrepancy between the morality and institutional structural for ethics review. In this light, she rejects the tradition of ethical review centered on university-based experts. She wrote:
[S]hifts in power within the research setting away from the oversight and control of university-based experts and paternalistic oversight committees and toward ownership by members of communities themselves would better reflect the ethical principles of respect for person, beneficence, and justice. This is a critical move if the full promise of these principles is to be realized in our practice as action researchers, but at the same time such redistributions of power and control carry unique challenges and genuine risks if we do not remain vigilant to the ethical implications of our practice. (p. 208)
Sunday, November 21, 2010
The action research dissertation
: A guide for students and faculty. Herr, Kathryn & Anderson, Gary L. (2005). Thousand Oaks, London and Delhi: Sage.
1. Introduction (1-7)
The authors note that action research, despite its similarities with QUAL (even with QUAN), is different in that "research participants themselves are either in control of the research or are participants in the design and methodology of the research" (p. 1) and action is central to research. They stated as the most important feature the shifting locus of control from professional researchers to research subjects. They noted several terms indicating research in collaboration with practitioners or community members: PAR, community-based PAR, participatory rural appraisal, feminist action research, emancipatory praxis... The authors choose action research as an umbrella term of these.
The authors defined action research as (1) inquiry done "by or with insiders to an organization or community" (p. 3) (2) action-oriented, (3) a reflective process, meaning "deliberately and systematically undertaken and generally requires that some form of evidence be presented to support assertions."(p. 3). Interestingly, the authors argued that "what constitutes evidence or, in more traditional terms, data is still being debated" (p. 3). (4) It is value laden. The authors rightly pointed out that although action research hopes for solving pressing problems or improving situations, what constitutes improvement or a solution is not self-evident. That reflects conflicting values and an unequal distribution of power and resources. Here they stress the importance of reflexivity: "[T]he notion of reflexivity is crucial because action researchers must interrogate received notions of improvement or solutions in terms of who ultimately benefits from the actions undertaken"(p. 4)
The authors observe a researcher's double burden: action (improvement of practice or social change) and research (valid knowledge production), which sets up a conflict between the rigor and the relevance of the research. Similarly, action research demands a form of intervention which is not honored by traditional researchers. The authors pointed out such interventions constitutes a spiral of action cycles--plan-act-observe-reflect (kemmis 1982, p.7)
The authors also observe that "there is more writing about action research than documentation of actual research studies" (p. 6) They suggest that "a dissertation may represent the documentation of a successful collaboration and be used as a case study of not only the process but also the product of the collaboration" (p. 6).
2. Action research traditions and knowledge interests (8-28)
The authors noted two bands of action research: business-oriented administration and emancipatory practice linked to anticapitalist, grassroots movement. They asserted that "action research is working with an oppressed community ti identify what Freire(1970) called generative themes, or issues that the community agreed had highest priority" (p. 9) Participatoy action research (PAR) emphasizes the aspect of this internal/participatory process from insiders. The authors noted, "Participatory action research (PAR) tempers this expert knowledge with the expertise of locals about their own problems and solutions" (p. 10).
The authors defined participatory research by and large in the legacy of Freire (1970 Pedagogy of the Oppressed). He viewed research as a form of social action in which generative themes are identified and used as a basis of literacy instruction through collaboration. Focusing on Freirean-inspired participatory research, Brown and Tandon(1983) argued that traditional action research concentrated on an individual or group level of analysis, whereas emancipatory participatory research tends to focus on a broader societal analysis. Such PR often creates a resistance to the research.
On the other hand, coining the term co-operative inquiry, Heron (1996) undertook experiential approaches to action research, emphasizing intersubjectivity among researchers and participants: "[T]here is the possibility of reciprocal participative knowing" (p. 11)
The authors remarked that both the trends (liberation or humanistic psychology) are concerned with using PR for humanization.
The authors pointed out the danger of co-optation in doing action research. They argued that the nature of social institutions is keeping its status quo, thus, if action research lacks a critical spirit, it runs the risk of legimitizing the current status quo.
They noted emerging critical approaches to action research from feminist and critical race theorists to a lesser extent.
Epistemologically, the authors trace back to Jurgen Habermas (1971, Knowledge and Human Interests), who argued knowledge production is never neutral and always pursued with some interest. He argued three types of interest: technical interest (controlling over the natural and social realm), practical interest (gaining understanding through interpretation), and emancipatory interest (the release of human potential and the investigation of ideology and power relation). Depending on types of interest, the authors argue that research aims vary. They see action research in tune with emancipatory knowledge interest, which aims at critical reflection on power constraint imposed on our understanding. However, they stated:
"[W]hile certain methodologies tend to be associated with certain knowledge interest, we don't see a conflict in using statistical methods toward emancipatory ends, as long as it forms part of a cycle of ongoing critical reflection" (p. 28).
[Here, again, the authors place action (participatory) research as a paradigm distinguished from qualitative or qualitative methodology, while slightly emphasizing their position in the emancipatory stream. HOWEVER, when participants utilize or emulate certain methods, which are considered dehumanizing, would it be considered emancipatory? The positionality of participants as insiders would make a difference, while outside researchers conduct surveys, for instance...But I am not quite sure right now.]
3. The continuum of positionality in action research (29-48)
The authors explore different implications of positionality between insiders and outsiders. Here PAR is defined as either reciprocal collaboration or outsider(s) collaborating with insider(s). They assert that although reciprocal collaboration is ideal, many different positinalities are possible and valuable as long as researchers are aware of them and honest about them. The issue of positionalities is also important to the authors because it affects the criteria for quality or trustworthiness of the study they conduct.
4. Quality criteria for action research (49-68)
The authors reject validity (QUAN) and trustworthiness (QUAL/naturalistic researchers) as criteria for action research because the terms do not acknowledge action-oriented outcomes. Instead, they propose five validity criteria which are associated with the goals of action research.
Goal1: the generation of new knowledge-->dialogic and process validity
Goal2: the achievement of action-oriented outcomes-->outcome validity
Goal3: the education of both researcher and participants-->catalytic validity
Goal4: Results that are relevant tot eh local setting-->Democratic validity
Goal5: A sound and appropriate research methodology-->process validity
Process validity: the manner in which research is conducted, including triangulation
Outcome validity: whether action occurs [What is action? In many emancipatory participatory research, action may be intrinsic and they may lack agency to implement the research results but their research has implications of policy change. Thus, actions that may be qualified in more conventional action research may not be appropriate here.]
Catalytic validity: does research lead its participants and researchers to know the reality and transform it? This validity has to do with transformative potential.
Democratic validity: is the research done in collaboration with all parties? In particular, it draws on locality (Cunningham, 1983): does problems emerge from a local context and the solutions are appropriate to that context?
Dialogic validity: peer review.
[I WONDER whether it is appropriate to apply these criteria to both business-oriented and emancipatory action research.]
Reason and Bradbury (2001, Handbook of action research) defined action research as "an emerging, evolutionary and educational process of engaging with self, persons and communities that needs to be sustained for a significant period of time" (p. 12, as cited p. 58).
In short, the authors depart from current QUAN and QUAL validity criteria for action research.
About GENERALIZATION.
The authors take on Robert Stake's (1986) position on naturalistic generalization to illustrate their own. He explained naturalistic generalizations as a way of leading audiences to vicarious experience and helping them think of their own problems in a new way:
A person would be described as an individual, with uniqueness not just in deviance scores, but as a key to understanding the interactions. A reader senses the experience of teamwork in this particular situation. It is a unique situation in some respects, but ordinary in other respects. Readers recognize similarities with situations of their own. Perhaps they are stimulated to think of old problems in a new way (p.99)
In writing dissertation, the authors emphasize that students clarify the evolution, documenting the decisions made. They acknowledge that in naturalistic inquiry, methodologies evolve, yet it should be documented. Secondly, they stress that the students think through their multiple roles in this research as researcher, as outsider, as facilitator, etc.
////
Brown & Tandon
doi: 10.1177/002188638301900306 Journal of Applied Behavioral Science September 1983 vol. 19 no. 3 277-294
Heron, J. (1996). Co-operative inquiry: Research into the human condition. London: Sage.
Cunningham, J. B. (1983). Gathering data in a changing organization. Human relations, 36 (5), 403-420
Stake, R. (1986). An evolutionary view of educational improvement. In E.R. House (Ed.), New directions in educational evaluation (pp. 89-102). London: Falmer.
1. Introduction (1-7)
The authors note that action research, despite its similarities with QUAL (even with QUAN), is different in that "research participants themselves are either in control of the research or are participants in the design and methodology of the research" (p. 1) and action is central to research. They stated as the most important feature the shifting locus of control from professional researchers to research subjects. They noted several terms indicating research in collaboration with practitioners or community members: PAR, community-based PAR, participatory rural appraisal, feminist action research, emancipatory praxis... The authors choose action research as an umbrella term of these.
The authors defined action research as (1) inquiry done "by or with insiders to an organization or community" (p. 3) (2) action-oriented, (3) a reflective process, meaning "deliberately and systematically undertaken and generally requires that some form of evidence be presented to support assertions."(p. 3). Interestingly, the authors argued that "what constitutes evidence or, in more traditional terms, data is still being debated" (p. 3). (4) It is value laden. The authors rightly pointed out that although action research hopes for solving pressing problems or improving situations, what constitutes improvement or a solution is not self-evident. That reflects conflicting values and an unequal distribution of power and resources. Here they stress the importance of reflexivity: "[T]he notion of reflexivity is crucial because action researchers must interrogate received notions of improvement or solutions in terms of who ultimately benefits from the actions undertaken"(p. 4)
The authors observe a researcher's double burden: action (improvement of practice or social change) and research (valid knowledge production), which sets up a conflict between the rigor and the relevance of the research. Similarly, action research demands a form of intervention which is not honored by traditional researchers. The authors pointed out such interventions constitutes a spiral of action cycles--plan-act-observe-reflect (kemmis 1982, p.7)
The authors also observe that "there is more writing about action research than documentation of actual research studies" (p. 6) They suggest that "a dissertation may represent the documentation of a successful collaboration and be used as a case study of not only the process but also the product of the collaboration" (p. 6).
2. Action research traditions and knowledge interests (8-28)
The authors noted two bands of action research: business-oriented administration and emancipatory practice linked to anticapitalist, grassroots movement. They asserted that "action research is working with an oppressed community ti identify what Freire(1970) called generative themes, or issues that the community agreed had highest priority" (p. 9) Participatoy action research (PAR) emphasizes the aspect of this internal/participatory process from insiders. The authors noted, "Participatory action research (PAR) tempers this expert knowledge with the expertise of locals about their own problems and solutions" (p. 10).
The authors defined participatory research by and large in the legacy of Freire (1970 Pedagogy of the Oppressed). He viewed research as a form of social action in which generative themes are identified and used as a basis of literacy instruction through collaboration. Focusing on Freirean-inspired participatory research, Brown and Tandon(1983) argued that traditional action research concentrated on an individual or group level of analysis, whereas emancipatory participatory research tends to focus on a broader societal analysis. Such PR often creates a resistance to the research.
On the other hand, coining the term co-operative inquiry, Heron (1996) undertook experiential approaches to action research, emphasizing intersubjectivity among researchers and participants: "[T]here is the possibility of reciprocal participative knowing" (p. 11)
The authors remarked that both the trends (liberation or humanistic psychology) are concerned with using PR for humanization.
The authors pointed out the danger of co-optation in doing action research. They argued that the nature of social institutions is keeping its status quo, thus, if action research lacks a critical spirit, it runs the risk of legimitizing the current status quo.
They noted emerging critical approaches to action research from feminist and critical race theorists to a lesser extent.
Epistemologically, the authors trace back to Jurgen Habermas (1971, Knowledge and Human Interests), who argued knowledge production is never neutral and always pursued with some interest. He argued three types of interest: technical interest (controlling over the natural and social realm), practical interest (gaining understanding through interpretation), and emancipatory interest (the release of human potential and the investigation of ideology and power relation). Depending on types of interest, the authors argue that research aims vary. They see action research in tune with emancipatory knowledge interest, which aims at critical reflection on power constraint imposed on our understanding. However, they stated:
"[W]hile certain methodologies tend to be associated with certain knowledge interest, we don't see a conflict in using statistical methods toward emancipatory ends, as long as it forms part of a cycle of ongoing critical reflection" (p. 28).
[Here, again, the authors place action (participatory) research as a paradigm distinguished from qualitative or qualitative methodology, while slightly emphasizing their position in the emancipatory stream. HOWEVER, when participants utilize or emulate certain methods, which are considered dehumanizing, would it be considered emancipatory? The positionality of participants as insiders would make a difference, while outside researchers conduct surveys, for instance...But I am not quite sure right now.]
3. The continuum of positionality in action research (29-48)
The authors explore different implications of positionality between insiders and outsiders. Here PAR is defined as either reciprocal collaboration or outsider(s) collaborating with insider(s). They assert that although reciprocal collaboration is ideal, many different positinalities are possible and valuable as long as researchers are aware of them and honest about them. The issue of positionalities is also important to the authors because it affects the criteria for quality or trustworthiness of the study they conduct.
4. Quality criteria for action research (49-68)
The authors reject validity (QUAN) and trustworthiness (QUAL/naturalistic researchers) as criteria for action research because the terms do not acknowledge action-oriented outcomes. Instead, they propose five validity criteria which are associated with the goals of action research.
Goal1: the generation of new knowledge-->dialogic and process validity
Goal2: the achievement of action-oriented outcomes-->outcome validity
Goal3: the education of both researcher and participants-->catalytic validity
Goal4: Results that are relevant tot eh local setting-->Democratic validity
Goal5: A sound and appropriate research methodology-->process validity
Process validity: the manner in which research is conducted, including triangulation
Outcome validity: whether action occurs [What is action? In many emancipatory participatory research, action may be intrinsic and they may lack agency to implement the research results but their research has implications of policy change. Thus, actions that may be qualified in more conventional action research may not be appropriate here.]
Catalytic validity: does research lead its participants and researchers to know the reality and transform it? This validity has to do with transformative potential.
Democratic validity: is the research done in collaboration with all parties? In particular, it draws on locality (Cunningham, 1983): does problems emerge from a local context and the solutions are appropriate to that context?
Dialogic validity: peer review.
[I WONDER whether it is appropriate to apply these criteria to both business-oriented and emancipatory action research.]
Reason and Bradbury (2001, Handbook of action research) defined action research as "an emerging, evolutionary and educational process of engaging with self, persons and communities that needs to be sustained for a significant period of time" (p. 12, as cited p. 58).
In short, the authors depart from current QUAN and QUAL validity criteria for action research.
About GENERALIZATION.
The authors take on Robert Stake's (1986) position on naturalistic generalization to illustrate their own. He explained naturalistic generalizations as a way of leading audiences to vicarious experience and helping them think of their own problems in a new way:
A person would be described as an individual, with uniqueness not just in deviance scores, but as a key to understanding the interactions. A reader senses the experience of teamwork in this particular situation. It is a unique situation in some respects, but ordinary in other respects. Readers recognize similarities with situations of their own. Perhaps they are stimulated to think of old problems in a new way (p.99)
In writing dissertation, the authors emphasize that students clarify the evolution, documenting the decisions made. They acknowledge that in naturalistic inquiry, methodologies evolve, yet it should be documented. Secondly, they stress that the students think through their multiple roles in this research as researcher, as outsider, as facilitator, etc.
////
Brown & Tandon
doi: 10.1177/002188638301900306 Journal of Applied Behavioral Science September 1983 vol. 19 no. 3 277-294
Heron, J. (1996). Co-operative inquiry: Research into the human condition. London: Sage.
Cunningham, J. B. (1983). Gathering data in a changing organization. Human relations, 36 (5), 403-420
Stake, R. (1986). An evolutionary view of educational improvement. In E.R. House (Ed.), New directions in educational evaluation (pp. 89-102). London: Falmer.
Friday, November 5, 2010
How Critical Reflection Triggers Transformative Learning
Mezirow, Jack. (1990). In J. Mezirow & associates (Eds.), Fostering critical reflection in adulthood: A guide to transformative and emancipatory learning (pp. 1-20). San Francisco & Oxford: Jossey-Basse.
Mezirow argued that central to adult education is reflecting upon prior learning to determine its validity against present circumstances. He called this critical assessment of assumptions critical reflection, which bases reflective action. He stated, "the most significant learning experiences in adulthood involve critical self-reflection--reassessing the way we have posed problems and reassessing our own orientation to perceiving, knowing, believing, feeling, and acting" (p. 13).
In this light, he classified two distinctive learning paths: instrumental learning and communicative learning. Instrumental learning occurs while involved in task-oriented problem solving. In the process, Mezirow asserted, "reflection is significantly involved when we look back on content or procedural [sic] assumptions guiding the problem-solving process to reassess the efficacy of the strategies and tactics used." (p. 7) It also involves "the process of learning to control and manipulate the environment or other people," thus the results can be empirically demonstrated. (p. 8). On the other hand, communicative learning involves understanding the meaning of others' values, feelings, decisions, and such abstract concepts of justice, love, democracy and commitment. Mezirow emphasized that this learning has even greater significance in adult learning. It focuses on achieving coherence rather than exercising more effective control. It is like a "building block of understanding" (p. 9) by integrating further insights, which involves "hermeneutic circle," which move back and forth between parts and a whole of what we seek to understand. Thus, reflection in this learning ensures identifying similarities and unfamiliarities in order to give them coherence.
Precisely, Mezirow defined as critical reflection "challenging the validity of presuppositions in prior learning" (p. 12). He argued that although critical reflection may be an integral part of making decision, it cannot be an integral element in the immediate action process. He contended that this transition requires transforming their own perspectives. He argued that perspective transformation occurs in response to "disorienting dilemma"(p. 13): a divorce, death of a loved one, job change, an eye-opening discussion, book, culture shock, etc. He put it:
"Anomalies and dilemmas of which old ways of knowing cannot make sense become catalysts or "trigger events" that precipitate critical reflection and transformation." (p. 14)
Mezirow pointed out psychic distortions as something that hinders adults from learning: unwarranted anxiety that impedes taking actions, which resulted from traumatic events in childhood (Roger Gould, 1978, transformation: Growth and change in adult life). Mezirow wrote, "Adulthood is a time of regaining such lost functions. The learner must be helped to identify both the particular action that he or she feels blocked about taking and the source and nature of stress in making a decision to act" (p. 17). In this light, educators "can provide skillful emotional support and collaborate as co-learners in an educational context" (p. 17).
Mezirow defined as transformative learning the process of learning through critical reflection via either instrumental or communicative learning, and acting on the learned insights derived from transformation of their perspectives. Emancipatory education is "an organized effort to help the learner challenge presuppositions, explore alternative perspectives, transform old ways of understanding, and act on new perspective" (p. 18).
Looking at educational approaches, Mezirow asserted that they are adaptable as research methods for study the nature, significance, and changes in perspectives. He wrote:
"In transformative learning, the line between learning, education, and research often becomes mercifully blurred. The educator becomes a co-learner, helping the learner explore alternative ways of interpreting his or her experience." (p. xix-x, Preface)
Mezirow argued that central to adult education is reflecting upon prior learning to determine its validity against present circumstances. He called this critical assessment of assumptions critical reflection, which bases reflective action. He stated, "the most significant learning experiences in adulthood involve critical self-reflection--reassessing the way we have posed problems and reassessing our own orientation to perceiving, knowing, believing, feeling, and acting" (p. 13).
In this light, he classified two distinctive learning paths: instrumental learning and communicative learning. Instrumental learning occurs while involved in task-oriented problem solving. In the process, Mezirow asserted, "reflection is significantly involved when we look back on content or procedural [sic] assumptions guiding the problem-solving process to reassess the efficacy of the strategies and tactics used." (p. 7) It also involves "the process of learning to control and manipulate the environment or other people," thus the results can be empirically demonstrated. (p. 8). On the other hand, communicative learning involves understanding the meaning of others' values, feelings, decisions, and such abstract concepts of justice, love, democracy and commitment. Mezirow emphasized that this learning has even greater significance in adult learning. It focuses on achieving coherence rather than exercising more effective control. It is like a "building block of understanding" (p. 9) by integrating further insights, which involves "hermeneutic circle," which move back and forth between parts and a whole of what we seek to understand. Thus, reflection in this learning ensures identifying similarities and unfamiliarities in order to give them coherence.
Precisely, Mezirow defined as critical reflection "challenging the validity of presuppositions in prior learning" (p. 12). He argued that although critical reflection may be an integral part of making decision, it cannot be an integral element in the immediate action process. He contended that this transition requires transforming their own perspectives. He argued that perspective transformation occurs in response to "disorienting dilemma"(p. 13): a divorce, death of a loved one, job change, an eye-opening discussion, book, culture shock, etc. He put it:
"Anomalies and dilemmas of which old ways of knowing cannot make sense become catalysts or "trigger events" that precipitate critical reflection and transformation." (p. 14)
Mezirow pointed out psychic distortions as something that hinders adults from learning: unwarranted anxiety that impedes taking actions, which resulted from traumatic events in childhood (Roger Gould, 1978, transformation: Growth and change in adult life). Mezirow wrote, "Adulthood is a time of regaining such lost functions. The learner must be helped to identify both the particular action that he or she feels blocked about taking and the source and nature of stress in making a decision to act" (p. 17). In this light, educators "can provide skillful emotional support and collaborate as co-learners in an educational context" (p. 17).
Mezirow defined as transformative learning the process of learning through critical reflection via either instrumental or communicative learning, and acting on the learned insights derived from transformation of their perspectives. Emancipatory education is "an organized effort to help the learner challenge presuppositions, explore alternative perspectives, transform old ways of understanding, and act on new perspective" (p. 18).
Looking at educational approaches, Mezirow asserted that they are adaptable as research methods for study the nature, significance, and changes in perspectives. He wrote:
"In transformative learning, the line between learning, education, and research often becomes mercifully blurred. The educator becomes a co-learner, helping the learner explore alternative ways of interpreting his or her experience." (p. xix-x, Preface)
Monday, April 26, 2010
The Methodological Dilemma
Gallagher, Kathleen. (Ed.). (2008). London and New York: Routledge.
Introduction (pp. 1-8)
Gallagher takes a constructionist perspective, writing, "Through our research and the choices we make, we imagine the world in ever more complex and interesting ways and re-commit ourselves to our intellectual and political projects. But we also risk our comfortable norms and truth claims each time we seek understanding" (pp. 1-2).
In the same vein, she argues that "researchers can mobilize theory [sic], in creative ways, to think through the 'pragmatics' of method" (p. 2). Thus she calls for unfettering our imagination for creative methods.
The Art of Methodology: A Collaborative Science (pp 67-81)
Gallagher proposes participatory research methods as a dialectical exchange between science and art. She argues that such exchange is indispensable in social sciences and humanities research, insinuating a potential for research that is politically engaged as well as pedagogically useful.
Introduction (pp. 1-8)
Gallagher takes a constructionist perspective, writing, "Through our research and the choices we make, we imagine the world in ever more complex and interesting ways and re-commit ourselves to our intellectual and political projects. But we also risk our comfortable norms and truth claims each time we seek understanding" (pp. 1-2).
In the same vein, she argues that "researchers can mobilize theory [sic], in creative ways, to think through the 'pragmatics' of method" (p. 2). Thus she calls for unfettering our imagination for creative methods.
The Art of Methodology: A Collaborative Science (pp 67-81)
Gallagher proposes participatory research methods as a dialectical exchange between science and art. She argues that such exchange is indispensable in social sciences and humanities research, insinuating a potential for research that is politically engaged as well as pedagogically useful.
Monday, April 19, 2010
Theorizing Audience, Products and Provocation
Michelle Fine & María Elena Torre. (2008). In Peter Reason & Hilary Bradbury (Eds.), The Sage Handbook of Action Research Participative Inquiry and Practice (pp. 407-419). LA, London, New Delhi, and Singapore: Sage Publications.
Describe PAR products as "counter-hegemonic 'weapons of mass instruction'" (p. 407), Fine and Torre write, "PAR is explicitly political" (p. 417), thus call for critical deliberation about the ethics of provocation in relation to vulnerability of participants and social justice.
Describe PAR products as "counter-hegemonic 'weapons of mass instruction'" (p. 407), Fine and Torre write, "PAR is explicitly political" (p. 417), thus call for critical deliberation about the ethics of provocation in relation to vulnerability of participants and social justice.
Action Research
Ernest T. Stringer. (1999). (2nd Ed.). Thousand Oaks, London, and New Delhi: Sage.
Chapter 1. Research in Professional and Public Life.
Similar to Kurt Lewin's model of action research, Ernest Stringer calls attention to action research as a decentralized small-scale format of research that would benefit practitioners' daily work in working with community groups. His model consists of a look-think-act routine. There are three basic assumptions in his model: a researcher's involvement, research subjects' participation in the research processes, and direct benefit to all participants. Thus, community-based research takes on action research. Built on Denzin and Lincoln's (1994) argument, Stringer defines as community-based research "enacting local, action-oriented approaches to inquiry, applying small-scale theorizing to specific problems in specific situations" (p. 10). Characterizing such research as stakeholders' participation, he specifies stages for the participation: data collection, analysis, theorizing, action, and evaluation. Here Stringer describes researchers as research facilitators with less directive power.
Chapter 5. Think: Interpreting and Analyzing.
Built on Denzin's (1997, Interpretive Ethnography) call for performance--"texts waiting to be staged" (as cited on the page 109)--Stringer contends that predominant formalist texts for presentation of research findings may not only silence the voices of people but also limit evocative responses from audiences. He calls particular attention to the movement to performance, such as drama, role play, dance, song, poem, etc., in action research so that people can express their feelings without intrusion of the formality.
Chapter 8. Formal Reports, Theses, and Dissertations (pp. 165-186)
This chapter has useful information about how to write up research findings in formal/informal ways. [GOOD]
In particular, the section of methodology is excellent. Stringer divides it into four subsections.
(1) Methodological Assumptions or a Philosophical Rationale: he suggests a more extended treatment than usual as PAR is not widely accepted yet. Identify research paradigm, detailed purposes, processes, outcomes of research. Cite sources. In principle, answer these questions, "why have we used this approach to research? Is it a valid and rigorous research process? Clarify the nature of the research process by comparing it with survey research, or more conventional styles.
(2) Research Processes: details, who was involved, what information collected, how analyzed. Include position of the researcher and participants. Data collection technique may include INTERVIEWS, OBSERVATIONS, DOCUMENTS (MEDIA, ARTIFACTS), RECORDING INFORMATION (VIDEOTAPES, PHOTOS...). The part of analysis should provide how research participants analyzed information. Stringer introduces the term BRAKETING to refer to the process of analyzing information in interpretive research to reduce it to its most significant or key, elements.
(3) Rigor: Unlike traditional criteria for evaluating rigor, such as objectivity, reliability, validity and generalizability, Stringer proposes CREDIBILITY, TRANSFERABILITY, AND DEPENDABILITY AND CONFIRMABILITY in order to establish the trustworthiness of PAR.
He asserts that credibility is established by prolonged engagement with participants, triangulation of information from multiple sources, member checking to verify the accuracy, and peer debriefing for reflection on the process.
By Transferability Stringer means applying research findings to other contexts. He argues that research methods should provide thick description so that audiences can identify similarities of the research setting with other contexts.
Dependability and confirmability are obtained through detailed description of collecting and analyzing processes and references to the raw data.
[I think that my research project can have certain credibility to begin with. I should work in transferability and the other. Should I keep the raw data? Final video should be sufficient as raw data if we publish a report in a formal way?]
Stringer also suggests having a section of limitations, not for an apology, but for an explanation about why traditional criteria such as objectivity, reliability, etc. are not appropriate.
(4) Ethical issues
guard against unwarranted intrusion into private life, maintaining privacy, establishing ownership, describe how research processed were enacted in ways sensitive to the cultural values and protocols of research participants.
Chapter 9. Understanding Action Research: The Theory Behind the Practice (187-215)
Chapter 1. Research in Professional and Public Life.
Similar to Kurt Lewin's model of action research, Ernest Stringer calls attention to action research as a decentralized small-scale format of research that would benefit practitioners' daily work in working with community groups. His model consists of a look-think-act routine. There are three basic assumptions in his model: a researcher's involvement, research subjects' participation in the research processes, and direct benefit to all participants. Thus, community-based research takes on action research. Built on Denzin and Lincoln's (1994) argument, Stringer defines as community-based research "enacting local, action-oriented approaches to inquiry, applying small-scale theorizing to specific problems in specific situations" (p. 10). Characterizing such research as stakeholders' participation, he specifies stages for the participation: data collection, analysis, theorizing, action, and evaluation. Here Stringer describes researchers as research facilitators with less directive power.
Chapter 5. Think: Interpreting and Analyzing.
Built on Denzin's (1997, Interpretive Ethnography) call for performance--"texts waiting to be staged" (as cited on the page 109)--Stringer contends that predominant formalist texts for presentation of research findings may not only silence the voices of people but also limit evocative responses from audiences. He calls particular attention to the movement to performance, such as drama, role play, dance, song, poem, etc., in action research so that people can express their feelings without intrusion of the formality.
Chapter 8. Formal Reports, Theses, and Dissertations (pp. 165-186)
This chapter has useful information about how to write up research findings in formal/informal ways. [GOOD]
In particular, the section of methodology is excellent. Stringer divides it into four subsections.
(1) Methodological Assumptions or a Philosophical Rationale: he suggests a more extended treatment than usual as PAR is not widely accepted yet. Identify research paradigm, detailed purposes, processes, outcomes of research. Cite sources. In principle, answer these questions, "why have we used this approach to research? Is it a valid and rigorous research process? Clarify the nature of the research process by comparing it with survey research, or more conventional styles.
(2) Research Processes: details, who was involved, what information collected, how analyzed. Include position of the researcher and participants. Data collection technique may include INTERVIEWS, OBSERVATIONS, DOCUMENTS (MEDIA, ARTIFACTS), RECORDING INFORMATION (VIDEOTAPES, PHOTOS...). The part of analysis should provide how research participants analyzed information. Stringer introduces the term BRAKETING to refer to the process of analyzing information in interpretive research to reduce it to its most significant or key, elements.
(3) Rigor: Unlike traditional criteria for evaluating rigor, such as objectivity, reliability, validity and generalizability, Stringer proposes CREDIBILITY, TRANSFERABILITY, AND DEPENDABILITY AND CONFIRMABILITY in order to establish the trustworthiness of PAR.
He asserts that credibility is established by prolonged engagement with participants, triangulation of information from multiple sources, member checking to verify the accuracy, and peer debriefing for reflection on the process.
By Transferability Stringer means applying research findings to other contexts. He argues that research methods should provide thick description so that audiences can identify similarities of the research setting with other contexts.
Dependability and confirmability are obtained through detailed description of collecting and analyzing processes and references to the raw data.
[I think that my research project can have certain credibility to begin with. I should work in transferability and the other. Should I keep the raw data? Final video should be sufficient as raw data if we publish a report in a formal way?]
Stringer also suggests having a section of limitations, not for an apology, but for an explanation about why traditional criteria such as objectivity, reliability, etc. are not appropriate.
(4) Ethical issues
guard against unwarranted intrusion into private life, maintaining privacy, establishing ownership, describe how research processed were enacted in ways sensitive to the cultural values and protocols of research participants.
Chapter 9. Understanding Action Research: The Theory Behind the Practice (187-215)
Tuesday, November 17, 2009
Action Research and Minority Problems
Lewin, Kurt. (1946). Journal of Social Issues, 2(4), 34-46.
In carrying out research on inter-group relation, Kurt calls action-research, which will help practitioners. He criticizes that survey-based research is limited in that is it rather superficial of poll taking and such diagnosis should be complemented by experimental comparative studies for the effectiveness of various techniques of change. Thus he emphasizes that studies about social inter-group relations should proceed "in a spiral steps each of which is composed of a circle of planning, action, and fact-finding about the result of the action" (p.38). In an experiment on minority problems, he illustrates the potential of cooperation between practitioners and social scientists. Thus he writes, "it seems to be crucial for the progress of social science that the practitioner will understand that through social sciences and only through them he can hope to gain the power necessary to do a good job" (p.44).
Overall PAR may owe much to him about the concept of the methodology, however, it seems that action research in Lewin's context values the cooperation between practitioners and social scientists to bring about a desirable result, thus leaving out the grassroots participation.
In carrying out research on inter-group relation, Kurt calls action-research, which will help practitioners. He criticizes that survey-based research is limited in that is it rather superficial of poll taking and such diagnosis should be complemented by experimental comparative studies for the effectiveness of various techniques of change. Thus he emphasizes that studies about social inter-group relations should proceed "in a spiral steps each of which is composed of a circle of planning, action, and fact-finding about the result of the action" (p.38). In an experiment on minority problems, he illustrates the potential of cooperation between practitioners and social scientists. Thus he writes, "it seems to be crucial for the progress of social science that the practitioner will understand that through social sciences and only through them he can hope to gain the power necessary to do a good job" (p.44).
Overall PAR may owe much to him about the concept of the methodology, however, it seems that action research in Lewin's context values the cooperation between practitioners and social scientists to bring about a desirable result, thus leaving out the grassroots participation.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)