Images that transform and empower. Shirley A. White. (Ed.). (2003). New Delhi, India: Sage.
In the Forward, White astutely stated that despite participatory communication experiences over the last three decades, scholarly theories and definitions are yet to be developed and more so in information on practical and innovative programs at the grass root level.
Introduction: Video Power (17-30)
White approaches participatory video as a practical program of participatory communication. In the introduction to the book, she asserted that the major objective of participatory communication is to "empower people to shape their own destiny" (p. 20), arguing, "Participatory communication has the capacity to connect human beings as they experience social change" (p. 20).
White summarizes the current development of participatory video:
"Not only are there few definitive concepts but there is remarkable absence of any well-formulated theories to undergird the participatory video practices. While projects have been routinely evaluated, the lessons learned and understandings that have resulted have not led to significant theoretic work on the part of academics or other development professionals."(p.24)
Chapter 2. Involving people in a participatory process (33-62)
According to White, participation surfaced in the 1970s and dominated the development scene since then; in particular, communication technologies have played an important role in giving "voice" to the grass roots people. White emphasizes participatory communication as a process:
It [participatory communication] also must be conceived as process methodology that involves people in an interactive way, making communication resources accessible to them directly, in turn, helping the grass roots people acquire the knowledge and skill that enables a partnership in generating messages. (p. 37)
White describes the outcomes of the process of participatory communication:
"Through the process, a person experiences self-awareness and becomes conscious of social issues that affect their lives. The transformative dynamic of communication exchanges acts as a catalyst for identifying one's own problems, recognizes possible routes to empowerment and self-reliance, and builds a sense of independence through interdependence." (p. 37)
While describing the dimensions of involvement in participatory communication for development, White wrote:
"Initially, people may become involved out of curiosity, but when given the opportunity to be recognized and have a "voice", the enthusiasm builds. Video has proven to be a powerful tool for motivating participation, when used in the initial stages of involvement." (p. 47-48).
Besides, White also discussed confidence and self-development as a dimension of involvement. Here she implies the role of learning to build confidence and let them continue to be involved. She wrote:
"As individuals experience success in expressing views, learning new things, using indigenous knowledge and skills, they will develop the confidence to continue to be involved. They will recognize their own self-development and the fact that they are becoming different people. Feelings of satisfaction and usefulness result from being able to play a part in community effort and be recognized and valued for that part (CONNECT TO STAR'S REFLECTION)." (p. 49)
Discussing the role of the facilitator as a communication catalyst, Nair and White (1999) wrote that they "unlock the human potentials of individuals, increasing their capacity to think, to relate, to act, and to reflect from a foundation of communication competencies" (p. 40) (cited on p. 51).
*Nair, K. S., & White, S. A. (1999). The catalyst communicator: Facilitation without fear. In S. White, K. Nair & J. Ascroft (Eds.), Participatory communication: Working for change and development. New Delhi: Sage.
With regard to conflict, White writes "no change is possible without conflict--the greater the change, the greater the conflict" (p. 58). Thus, she writes as the role of facilitator:
"The development facilitator, as a catalyst communicator, can enter a conflicted community and readily recognize conflicts. Bringing the people together and giving them tools to address their differences is the first order of the day. Creating the opportunity for them to talk about and share their differences will quickly lead to the identification of common interests and aspirations. Participatory Video (PV) has played a vital role in this process throughout communities on all continents" (p. 58)
Finally, White discusses some challenges of participatory communication: One of them is a long time span to build human capacity. In this light, she proposes "mini" projects (p. 60):
In the future there needs to be recognition of the fact that projects need to be small and localized in order to allow participants a safer, more comfortable relationship with fellow community members. These "mini" projects can offer greater feelings of satisfaction and in reality, be more effectively managed and controlled. Small successes produce capacity, confidence, and courage to tackle larger, more complex development plans of action. Communication media--video, audio, and the Internet--will provide the mechanisms for linking and sharing the outcomes of these projects" (p. 60).
For White, PV is useful for conducting mini projects.
Chapter 3. Participatory video: A process that transforms the self and the other (63-101)
White succinctly defined PV as follows:
"Participatory video as a process is a tool for individual, group, and community development. It can serve as a powerful force for people to see themselves in relation to the community and become conscientized about personal and community needs. It brings about a critical awareness that forms the founcation for creativity and communication. Thus, it has the potential to bring about personal, social, political, and cultural change. That's what video power is all about." (p. 64)
White distinguished PV as a process and as a product: PV as a process is described as a tool to facilitate interaction and enable self-expression. PV as a product, on the other hand, emphasizes the video itself, which becomes a historical fact. Unlike non-participatory video, White argued, PV as a product is highly interactive to make a message come across via video.
Among others, White stressed PV as a tool for education and self-training that emerged in the use of PV in particular FAO projects. For video has "immediacy" (p. 67) that video can be replayed in the field. In particular, she mentioned video feedback as one of the most powerful yet simple uses of PV, such as videotaping a simple process of pesticides or other similar skills, conducting an interview for participatory research, conducting a training session, etc.
White highly regarded participatory message-making with video, which enables bottom-up grass roots involvement in the development of knowledge construction. Calling this process as PMD (Participatory Message Development), she emphasized the researcher as an important variable in the PMD process and listed the following as other critical variables.
1. Flexibility of the process (i.e., willingness to adapt and change directions)
2. Ability of the development communicator to play the facilitator role
3. The necessity of effective interpersonal communication
4. The joint analysis/teamwork or spirit among the researchers, development communicators and intended receivers
5. Recognizing that the participatory process is an educational process.
As outcomes of her research with Patel (1994), she write the following in relation to video:
"The characteristic and potential of small format video, as a development tool, is an ideal medium of communication when using a participatory research approach"
"Video as a development tool allows people to become involved in the process of decision-making and change in their community, which is an empowering experience."
"The presence of video in the community takes on a new meaning in that its evolution will move from a form of entertainment to a means of serious communication, dealing with and trying to find solutions to day-to-day issues." (p. 70)
In discussing Transformation, White argued that initially transformation must take place within individuals and it is intertwined with knowledge acquisition. She argued that knowledge acquisition is in itself empowering. She further stated:
"It [knowledge] builds the capacity for gaining control over one's own life and life space. It is at the heart of transforming situations and moving toward better quality life" (p. 76). More, she stressed that transformation accompanies conflict, saying, "There is no change without conflict whether it be interpersonal conflict or conflict within one's self" (p. 81). Further, "[C]onflicts can be negotiated in positive and constructive ways through mediation and management...Conflict is actually healthy because it helps move relationships out of a rut and can result in new visions and renewed confidence between conflicting individuals." (p. 81). In this light, she called for the process of reaching a consensus: "Consensus doesn't necessarily mean that everyone agrees on an issue, but it does mean they can be committed to a decision that is reached through dialog in which each person has been able to freely express an opinion on that issue" (p. 79).
Her personal reflection on those days in which small format video emerged is interesting. She recalled that even in the late 1960s when portable cameras became available, the concepts and norms that had governed television technologies dominated the guidelines for the use of small format video. She recalled that alternative video was born out of experiment, in her case, via an enthusiastic audiovisual librarian, who did not set boundaries for the use of the new technology. Then they teamed up to explore the power of video based on do-it-yourself spirit for students and faculty. Then, interestingly, they traveled to Canada to learn about the Challenge for Change programs for the purpose of learning an approach to participatory media.
Chapter 4. Participatory video that empowers (102-121, Renuka Bery)
Bery gives a succinct definition of empowerment: "Empowerment is closely linked with identity and context. Gaining control of one's life, making one's own decisions and being able to influence the context in which one lives are essential elements of empowerment." (p. 104)
Bery discussed the flexibility of participatory video throughout the world: "Participatory video producers can adapt the medium to meet their needs, whether it is used to expose current reality or to weave a narrative that brings the changing world closer to the viewers. Different styles of participatory video have emerged around the world that address the specific context and needs of the communities it served." Then she concluded, "[P]articipatory video is truly empowering. It opens up new aveunes for telling stories in ways that will build strong individuals and communities. These stories are strong enough to identify problems and to make necessary changes in order to improve lives and to transform societies in ways that value the individual and recognize the unique contribution and dynamic of every interaction" (p. 119).
Chapter 8. Trapped: Women Take Control of Video Storytelling (195-214, K. Sadanandan Nair and Shirley A. White)
The authors introduced participatory video research project that began in 1985 in rural areas of India. This research was experimentation with portable video cameras, responding to questions with respect to video as a communication tool for knowledge production, policy change, and empowerment, in particular, in the context of women's need. They stated that the problems described in this research were different from those identified in the World Bank's recent report on poverty, arguing that women are doubly rejected in a poverty-stricken family environment.
The authors noted that this experimental approach to video gave rise to the concept of participatory video. Based on the data gathered in 23 different villages, the research team produced the documentary called The Trapped. It was reviewed with several women and they confirmed the authenticity of the video and their comments were incorporated in further editing. Then, the research team moved toward the participatory model of message production. First, researchers visited some villages and selected two villages for "experimental" work (p. 204). Next, the researchers used a "Trigger Tape" (p. 205), which consisted of video images of rural women shot throughout earlier days of the research, to catalyze the involvement of village women in the investigation of community problems on their own. Here the authors emphasized the role of researchers as a catalyst as well as the Trigger Tape:
"The primary role of the researcher was that of a catalyst to get the women to discuss their own problems. The Trigger Tape led not only to discussions of problems, but also to the decision to produce a participatory tape jointly with the researchers. The researchers (p. 206) concurred that the reason the women agreed to do their own tapes was that they thought that the researchers depicted their way of life incorrectly. As such, they realized that the researchers made a lot of mistakes just like they do, and therefore were not superior to them. The women felt they could do it because our tape wasn't all that good. All of them were excited about doing video to have some fun. They wanted to show it to their friends and relatives in other village." (p. 206-207)
Finally, five women made a commitment to produce the video, Rural Women's Problems. They were individually or in groups. Then, a camera was left in the village, while the women were asked to document whatever they felt important about the issues they had been discussing. In the following, the village women and the researchers reviewed an hour long video footage. They continued to define problems faced by rural women through group discussions while providing video training simultaneously for a six week period. The authors concluded that "these meetings helped not only to raise issues, but also to find solutions to problems through collective action" (p. 208). The completed video (15 min) were presented in several villages.
The authors compared the two documentaries, The Trapped and Rural Women's Problems:
"Beneath the outward appearances of their 'hard life and abusive life space' they have a bond of dignity. They do not want to be perceived as downtrodden and they value the daily aspects of their lives, even though difficult at times. This pride shows through in the participatory tape they produced.
The Trapped was a 'poor me' story, while Rural Women's Problems was am 'I am Me' story. When women could tell their own story, they carefully portrayed the reality of their daily life, without pity or apology. They declared themselves as people who clearly recognized their problems and had ideas as to how to solve them." (p. 211)
Through the documentation of the participation process, the authors concluded that the process of participation contributed to the participants' transformation in that they formed alliances and gained confidence that their perspectives are valuable; further, the video they created empowered the women for a short duration.
Showing posts with label PAR. Show all posts
Showing posts with label PAR. Show all posts
Tuesday, March 22, 2011
Monday, January 10, 2011
Participatory Theatre and Video: Acting Against Violence in Northern Nigeria
Oga Steve Abah, Jenkeri Zakari Okwori and Ogoh Alubo. (2009). Institute of Development Studies [IDS] Bulletin, 40(3), 19-26.
The authors discussed the use of theatre for development [TFD] and participatory video [PV] in the research on violence in northern Nigeria. First, they carried out a survey throughout several communities, then developed a drama performed in each community and followed by a debate. PV was used throughout. The research finding is interesting: they argued that people do not see contemporary violence as a result of religion; rather, people perceive it as the organizing platform.
Interesting to note the reasons for choosing TFD and PV for this participatory action research (p. 21):
1. high level of illiteracy
2. "Wonderment about video makes people eager to speak to the camera" (p. 21)
3. can "afford participant ownership of the research tools and process.
4. "participatory process. . . is a spur to reflection and self-critical analysis".
5. alternative ways of looking at violence and manipulating the end of violence.-->seed for change.
The way they used PV techniques was to record the process from the community survey through drama-making to the discussions after the performances. It also recorded message from people on opposite sides of the religious and ethnic divides. It was done by trained community researchers.
The authors defined the roles of theatre and PV played:
"Theatre thus played multiple roles of information-gathering, feedback, analysis and triangulation or validation of facts, while PV played a role in building up a broadly accepted and pluralistically-constructed version of events, and in data-recording on both content and process" (p. 22).
Reflecting on the methods, the authors wrote:
"In broad terms, the TFD and PV, the quantitative research and qualitative interviews complemented each other very nicely throughout. The quantitative component provided useful information on the areas most affected by the violent incidents in Kaduna, Plateau and Kano States" (p. 23).
[Seamless use of quantitative, qualitative, arts-based methods for community-based research]
Arguing the suitability of TFD and PV for participatory research, the authors wrote about its connection with oral culture, reinforced reflection, and catharsis:
"The appeal and relevance of such reinterpretation and reflexivity are underscored by the fact that the work we do is mostly situated in oral cultures where the ability to read and write are limited or non-existent. Instead of being constrained by specific questions, people were enabled to connect with the incidents of violence in a reflective manner, through testimony or narration of their experiences during the drama and during the PV discussion. This outpouring appeared to allow them purgation and relief" (p. 24)
They also pointed out the importance of non-verbal expression that constitutes real life reflected in the methods of TFD and PV:
"In real life, most meanings are constructed not just by words, but by signs and body language. Eliciting these through TFD and then capturing them for posterity using PV generates a permanent and rich source of complex data including body language, facial expressions, postures, movements, bodily adornment and material culture" (p. 24)
As an advantage of PV over TFD, the authors argued for its transferability:
"While TFD can only be experienced at the place and the moment when it is happening, the videos enabled community members to see what happened in other communities, hear the views
of others and see the multiple ways these were articulated, including their emotions and bodily
expressions. No dramatic action can be repeated exactly twice, but PV can record the action and
repeat it several times over, which allows for deeper reflection" (pp. 24-25)
The authors asserted that this research contributed to consciousness raising achievement by telling some emblematic stories of individual participants. They attributed two factors --the participatory method and the experiential lives of the community --to the outcome. They argued that these two factors created ownership, participants' ownership not only of the research process but also of the discussions, arguments, etc. [Ownership is discussed in the context of the content]
The authors discussed the use of theatre for development [TFD] and participatory video [PV] in the research on violence in northern Nigeria. First, they carried out a survey throughout several communities, then developed a drama performed in each community and followed by a debate. PV was used throughout. The research finding is interesting: they argued that people do not see contemporary violence as a result of religion; rather, people perceive it as the organizing platform.
Interesting to note the reasons for choosing TFD and PV for this participatory action research (p. 21):
1. high level of illiteracy
2. "Wonderment about video makes people eager to speak to the camera" (p. 21)
3. can "afford participant ownership of the research tools and process.
4. "participatory process. . . is a spur to reflection and self-critical analysis".
5. alternative ways of looking at violence and manipulating the end of violence.-->seed for change.
The way they used PV techniques was to record the process from the community survey through drama-making to the discussions after the performances. It also recorded message from people on opposite sides of the religious and ethnic divides. It was done by trained community researchers.
The authors defined the roles of theatre and PV played:
"Theatre thus played multiple roles of information-gathering, feedback, analysis and triangulation or validation of facts, while PV played a role in building up a broadly accepted and pluralistically-constructed version of events, and in data-recording on both content and process" (p. 22).
Reflecting on the methods, the authors wrote:
"In broad terms, the TFD and PV, the quantitative research and qualitative interviews complemented each other very nicely throughout. The quantitative component provided useful information on the areas most affected by the violent incidents in Kaduna, Plateau and Kano States" (p. 23).
[Seamless use of quantitative, qualitative, arts-based methods for community-based research]
Arguing the suitability of TFD and PV for participatory research, the authors wrote about its connection with oral culture, reinforced reflection, and catharsis:
"The appeal and relevance of such reinterpretation and reflexivity are underscored by the fact that the work we do is mostly situated in oral cultures where the ability to read and write are limited or non-existent. Instead of being constrained by specific questions, people were enabled to connect with the incidents of violence in a reflective manner, through testimony or narration of their experiences during the drama and during the PV discussion. This outpouring appeared to allow them purgation and relief" (p. 24)
They also pointed out the importance of non-verbal expression that constitutes real life reflected in the methods of TFD and PV:
"In real life, most meanings are constructed not just by words, but by signs and body language. Eliciting these through TFD and then capturing them for posterity using PV generates a permanent and rich source of complex data including body language, facial expressions, postures, movements, bodily adornment and material culture" (p. 24)
As an advantage of PV over TFD, the authors argued for its transferability:
"While TFD can only be experienced at the place and the moment when it is happening, the videos enabled community members to see what happened in other communities, hear the views
of others and see the multiple ways these were articulated, including their emotions and bodily
expressions. No dramatic action can be repeated exactly twice, but PV can record the action and
repeat it several times over, which allows for deeper reflection" (pp. 24-25)
The authors asserted that this research contributed to consciousness raising achievement by telling some emblematic stories of individual participants. They attributed two factors --the participatory method and the experiential lives of the community --to the outcome. They argued that these two factors created ownership, participants' ownership not only of the research process but also of the discussions, arguments, etc. [Ownership is discussed in the context of the content]
Sunday, December 5, 2010
Gracias Companero: an appreciation of Orlando Fals Borda
Hall, Budd. (2008). Action research, 6 (4) , 442-444. doi: 10.1177/14767503080060040503
Here Hall credited Fals-Borda with the development of the term Participatory Action Research since 1977 Cartagena conference in Colombia.
"Some of those scholars had been working to these ends since the late 1960s outside of academic confines. Orlando traced his lineage in Participatory Action Research and related approaches from that meeting. At the time, I was a newly appointed research officer working with the International Council for Adult Education, fresh from five years working in Tanzania where a number of us began the work which we coined ‘participatory research’. (p. 442)
Here Hall credited Fals-Borda with the development of the term Participatory Action Research since 1977 Cartagena conference in Colombia.
"Some of those scholars had been working to these ends since the late 1960s outside of academic confines. Orlando traced his lineage in Participatory Action Research and related approaches from that meeting. At the time, I was a newly appointed research officer working with the International Council for Adult Education, fresh from five years working in Tanzania where a number of us began the work which we coined ‘participatory research’. (p. 442)
Intimate details : Participatory action research in prison
Michelle Fine and María Elena Torre. (2006). 4 (3), 253–269. doi: 10.1177/1476750306066801
For the authors, "participatory action researchers have an obligation to reveal, when possible, the intimate details of PAR undertaken in difficult social institutions" (p. 255)
"In communities, schools or prisons, PAR projects document the subterranean pools of collective dissent by aggregating and making public ‘private’ troubles among very different youth, women and men. Revealing the common, public roots of these ‘private’ troubles (Mills, 1959), PAR demonstrates the differentiated consequences of social oppression, distributed unevenly (but not only) by race, ethnicity and class. PAR shatters the false consensus of neo-liberal institutional life by challenging the everyday banality and seeming inevitability of injustice. More specifically, participatory action research lifts the multiple stories and counter stories dwelling within any complex institution or social arrangement, privileging in particular those perspectives that age on the bottom of social arrangements, where the lies, the ghosts, the buried memories, the disposables, the traitors and the silences gather." (p. 255)
Fine continues to use and stresses the word PAR.
[Fancy descriptions and cautious uses of words in this article]
For the authors, "participatory action researchers have an obligation to reveal, when possible, the intimate details of PAR undertaken in difficult social institutions" (p. 255)
"In communities, schools or prisons, PAR projects document the subterranean pools of collective dissent by aggregating and making public ‘private’ troubles among very different youth, women and men. Revealing the common, public roots of these ‘private’ troubles (Mills, 1959), PAR demonstrates the differentiated consequences of social oppression, distributed unevenly (but not only) by race, ethnicity and class. PAR shatters the false consensus of neo-liberal institutional life by challenging the everyday banality and seeming inevitability of injustice. More specifically, participatory action research lifts the multiple stories and counter stories dwelling within any complex institution or social arrangement, privileging in particular those perspectives that age on the bottom of social arrangements, where the lies, the ghosts, the buried memories, the disposables, the traitors and the silences gather." (p. 255)
Fine continues to use and stresses the word PAR.
[Fancy descriptions and cautious uses of words in this article]
Friday, December 3, 2010
The North-South convergence : A 30-year first-person assessment of PAR
Orlando Fals Borda. (2006). Action Research 4(3), 351–358. DOI: 10.1177/1476750306066806
Fals-Borda warns the attempts of asserting a set of rules or guides applicable to all. He argued that there are so many autonomous groups. So, he argued:
[I]t is preferable for us to seek our own explanations for building an alternative paradigm, by studying our indigenous or founding regional groups and emphasizing their values of human solidarity. Some of these groups extend from one country to another without respecting present frontiers . . . . The fundamental values of the founding groups provide a strong ethos identifiable with a deep-rooted non-violent socialism that is worth salvaging to repair our deteriorating social fabric.(p. 356-357)
Within this perspective, he called for an alternative methodological paradigm pertinent to regional context:
Our methodology is now faced with the creative challenge of constructing an alternative paradigm in regional contexts, for understanding and valuing the complexities of societies,
as regards their oral links, particular characteristics, present situation and spontaneous nature. (p. 357)
Fals-Borda warns the attempts of asserting a set of rules or guides applicable to all. He argued that there are so many autonomous groups. So, he argued:
[I]t is preferable for us to seek our own explanations for building an alternative paradigm, by studying our indigenous or founding regional groups and emphasizing their values of human solidarity. Some of these groups extend from one country to another without respecting present frontiers . . . . The fundamental values of the founding groups provide a strong ethos identifiable with a deep-rooted non-violent socialism that is worth salvaging to repair our deteriorating social fabric.(p. 356-357)
Within this perspective, he called for an alternative methodological paradigm pertinent to regional context:
Our methodology is now faced with the creative challenge of constructing an alternative paradigm in regional contexts, for understanding and valuing the complexities of societies,
as regards their oral links, particular characteristics, present situation and spontaneous nature. (p. 357)
Research tensions and paradigm shifts in action sciences
Orlando Fals-Borda. (2002). In P. Valero & O. Skovsmose (Eds.), Proceedings of the 3rd International conference on mathematics education and society (pp. 1-10).
Copenhagen: Centre for Research in Learning Mathematics.
For him, PAR attempts to challenge power through a radical change in knowledge production. He stated:
We appeared to be involved in a risky mixture of power/ knowledge, for we dared to challenge established ways and rules with heterodox research-and-study techniques in the field, in the classroom and even in the comfort of our armchairs in order to promote changes that are felt necessary both for academia and for society at large. (p. 2)
PAR is a remedy for ineffective analytical procedure in academia and at the same time a tool to pursue social justice for ordinary people in society. From this perspective, he drew attention to three types of tensions that arose in building PAR : (1) theory/practice in determining appropriate safeguards for the application of praxis, (2) in the meaning of the subject/ object and knowledge triad; and 3) in the search for a more satisfactory vision of science, within the context of mathematics education.
Concerning validity, Fals-Borda argued that it has to do with the notions of QUAL and QUAN research. He continued that quantitative measures may be combined with qualitative descriptions. More importantly, he stated:
Validity criteria could be derived from sources other than numerical regressions and correlations. Such alternative guidelines could be drawn by common sense, from inductive/deductive analysis of results obtained in practice through personal involvement in processes, and approved by the considered judgement of local reference groups. (p. 7)
Validity can be sought through self-reflexivity, participants, and other reference groups, as suggested in constructivist approaches as shown in fourth generation evaluation.
Fals-Borda asserted that PAR can bring together diverse knowledge systems--suggesting both QUAL and QUAN--and wrote that is a challenge for intellectual and moral reconstruction. He stated:
Convergence of this type should only be limited by how useful it is in the sociocultural and environmental context that inspired it, and in producing the positive practical results expected of it in the real world. (p. 8)
He noted, "PAR approach is open, plural, practical and interdisciplinary" (p. 9). He continued to stress that:
This open, holistic paradigm of PAR brings together praxis and ethics, academic knowledge and popular wisdom, the professor and the student, the rational and the existential, the regular and the fractal, the qualitative and the quantitative. It breaks down the subject/object dichotomy. It is founded on the democratic pluralist concepts of otherness, service and justice, upholding toleration of diversity and introducing neglected perspectives of culture, gender, popular classes and pluriethnicity into research and teaching activities. (p. 9)
Copenhagen: Centre for Research in Learning Mathematics.
For him, PAR attempts to challenge power through a radical change in knowledge production. He stated:
We appeared to be involved in a risky mixture of power/ knowledge, for we dared to challenge established ways and rules with heterodox research-and-study techniques in the field, in the classroom and even in the comfort of our armchairs in order to promote changes that are felt necessary both for academia and for society at large. (p. 2)
PAR is a remedy for ineffective analytical procedure in academia and at the same time a tool to pursue social justice for ordinary people in society. From this perspective, he drew attention to three types of tensions that arose in building PAR : (1) theory/practice in determining appropriate safeguards for the application of praxis, (2) in the meaning of the subject/ object and knowledge triad; and 3) in the search for a more satisfactory vision of science, within the context of mathematics education.
Concerning validity, Fals-Borda argued that it has to do with the notions of QUAL and QUAN research. He continued that quantitative measures may be combined with qualitative descriptions. More importantly, he stated:
Validity criteria could be derived from sources other than numerical regressions and correlations. Such alternative guidelines could be drawn by common sense, from inductive/deductive analysis of results obtained in practice through personal involvement in processes, and approved by the considered judgement of local reference groups. (p. 7)
Validity can be sought through self-reflexivity, participants, and other reference groups, as suggested in constructivist approaches as shown in fourth generation evaluation.
Fals-Borda asserted that PAR can bring together diverse knowledge systems--suggesting both QUAL and QUAN--and wrote that is a challenge for intellectual and moral reconstruction. He stated:
Convergence of this type should only be limited by how useful it is in the sociocultural and environmental context that inspired it, and in producing the positive practical results expected of it in the real world. (p. 8)
He noted, "PAR approach is open, plural, practical and interdisciplinary" (p. 9). He continued to stress that:
This open, holistic paradigm of PAR brings together praxis and ethics, academic knowledge and popular wisdom, the professor and the student, the rational and the existential, the regular and the fractal, the qualitative and the quantitative. It breaks down the subject/object dichotomy. It is founded on the democratic pluralist concepts of otherness, service and justice, upholding toleration of diversity and introducing neglected perspectives of culture, gender, popular classes and pluriethnicity into research and teaching activities. (p. 9)
Participatory Action Research
: Psychology and social change. (1997). Mary Brydon-Miller. Journal of social issues, 53 (4), 657-666.
PAR can be defined as a process of research, education, and action (Hall, 1981, Participatory research, popular knowledge and power: A personal reflection. Convergence, 14(3), 6-1 7).
Hall explained: The term participatory research was first used in the early 1970s in the research in Tanzania that drew on local knowledge and expertise in developing a project. Fals-Borda preferred the term PAR to emphasize the social change component of the work. In India, Tandon developed similar approaches to conducting community-based research.
Brydon-Miller finds its major philosophical influence in the work of Freire, who emphasized experience-based learning and developing critical consciousness from this knowledge through repeated cycles of action-and-reflection. The author stated that this cycle lies at the heart of PAR's knowledge generation.
One of the distinctions between PAR and more traditional research is in the acknowledgment of the political nature of research. PAR rejects value-free knowledge production. Brydon-Miller noted that this acknowledgment allows researcher to act in a more direct manner upon social issues.
Brydon-Miller described a basic set of tenets of PAR by following Hall (1981):
PAR originates in communities and populations that have traditionally been exploited; PAR addresses specific concerns of the community and the fundamental causes of oppression in order to bring about change; and PAR is a process of research, education, and action.
Brydon-Miller asserted the difficulty in typifying the methodology of PAR. In this light, she stated:
PAR can and does use what might seem to be fairly traditional methods of social scientific inquiry such as community questionnaires and interviews, the fundamental difference being that in PAR, members of the community determine which methods to use. (p. 661) [This indicates PAR is not a kind of methods, which is often divided into QUAL and QUAN. Both can be used in PAR but under a different set of rules, i.e., who determines what methods to use.]
She continued to state:
They then develop or adapt the research instruments and learn to carry out the research and to take part in analyzing the results. Finally, and most important, they own the results of the research and can determine how the information is to be used in addressing the concerns they have articulated. In addition to more standard methods, PAR also utilizes a variety of other approaches, including popular theater, political action, group discussions, community seminars, educational camps, intercultural exchange programs, video productions, and storytelling, to name just a few. (p. 661).
PAR can be defined as a process of research, education, and action (Hall, 1981, Participatory research, popular knowledge and power: A personal reflection. Convergence, 14(3), 6-1 7).
Hall explained: The term participatory research was first used in the early 1970s in the research in Tanzania that drew on local knowledge and expertise in developing a project. Fals-Borda preferred the term PAR to emphasize the social change component of the work. In India, Tandon developed similar approaches to conducting community-based research.
Brydon-Miller finds its major philosophical influence in the work of Freire, who emphasized experience-based learning and developing critical consciousness from this knowledge through repeated cycles of action-and-reflection. The author stated that this cycle lies at the heart of PAR's knowledge generation.
One of the distinctions between PAR and more traditional research is in the acknowledgment of the political nature of research. PAR rejects value-free knowledge production. Brydon-Miller noted that this acknowledgment allows researcher to act in a more direct manner upon social issues.
Brydon-Miller described a basic set of tenets of PAR by following Hall (1981):
PAR originates in communities and populations that have traditionally been exploited; PAR addresses specific concerns of the community and the fundamental causes of oppression in order to bring about change; and PAR is a process of research, education, and action.
Brydon-Miller asserted the difficulty in typifying the methodology of PAR. In this light, she stated:
PAR can and does use what might seem to be fairly traditional methods of social scientific inquiry such as community questionnaires and interviews, the fundamental difference being that in PAR, members of the community determine which methods to use. (p. 661) [This indicates PAR is not a kind of methods, which is often divided into QUAL and QUAN. Both can be used in PAR but under a different set of rules, i.e., who determines what methods to use.]
She continued to state:
They then develop or adapt the research instruments and learn to carry out the research and to take part in analyzing the results. Finally, and most important, they own the results of the research and can determine how the information is to be used in addressing the concerns they have articulated. In addition to more standard methods, PAR also utilizes a variety of other approaches, including popular theater, political action, group discussions, community seminars, educational camps, intercultural exchange programs, video productions, and storytelling, to name just a few. (p. 661).
Ideology and Political Economy in Inquiry
: Action research and participatory research. (1983). L. David Brown & Rajesh Tandon. Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 19 (3), 277-294. DOI: 10.1177/002188638301900306
The authors examine two traditions of applied behavioral science inquiry--action research and participatory research. They argued that both espouse similar values and employ common methods in different settings.
They pointed out that action research, formulated by Lewin, which consists of cycles of analysis, fact finding, conceptualization, planning, implementation, and evaluation to simultaneously solve problems and generate new knowledge. They observed that action research took place in the Global North in business firms and educational organizations. Yet, academia social scientists had not accepted it as fully as applied researchers in organizations.
On the other hand, participatory research emerged from the work with the oppressed in the Third World, where problems of adult education and social oppression are particularly acute, in various forms, such as Freire's conscientization and other work in Africa and Asia. The international network of participatory researchers was formed in 1978 sponsored by the International Council for Adult Education. Here the characteristics of participatory research were summarized:
Hall (1981, Convergence, p.7) defined participatory research as "an integrated activity that combines social investigation, educational work and action."
The authors examine two traditions of applied behavioral science inquiry--action research and participatory research. They argued that both espouse similar values and employ common methods in different settings.
They pointed out that action research, formulated by Lewin, which consists of cycles of analysis, fact finding, conceptualization, planning, implementation, and evaluation to simultaneously solve problems and generate new knowledge. They observed that action research took place in the Global North in business firms and educational organizations. Yet, academia social scientists had not accepted it as fully as applied researchers in organizations.
On the other hand, participatory research emerged from the work with the oppressed in the Third World, where problems of adult education and social oppression are particularly acute, in various forms, such as Freire's conscientization and other work in Africa and Asia. The international network of participatory researchers was formed in 1978 sponsored by the International Council for Adult Education. Here the characteristics of participatory research were summarized:
Hall (1981, Convergence, p.7) defined participatory research as "an integrated activity that combines social investigation, educational work and action."
Thursday, December 2, 2010
Paragidmatic controversies, contradictions, and emerging confluences
Egon G. Guba & Yvonna S. Lincoln. (2008). In Norman K. Denzin & Yvonna S. Lincoln (Eds.), The landscape of qualitative research (3rd ed.) (pp. 255-286). Thousand Oaks, London, New Delhi, and Singapore: Sage.
The authors developed their definition of the nature of paradigms proposed in 1994 by incorporating John Heron and Peter Reason's (1997) participatory/cooperative paradigm. In this chapter, they focused on issues of axiology, commensurability, action, control, foundations of truth and knowledge, validity, voice, reflexivity, and postmodern textual representation.
It is interesting to note that they changed their perspective on commensurability: in the past, they had argued commensurability between paradigms is not possible, although within each paradigm, mixed methodologies may make good sense. Yet, in this chapter is argued that it would not be impossible to blend some elements from each paradigm. For instance, positivism and postpositivism are clearly commensurable.
Concerning the call to action, the authors noted:
"The mandate for social action, especially action designed and created by and for rearch participants with the aid and cooperation of researchers, can be most sharply delineated between positivist/postpositivist and new paradigm inquirers. (p. 267)
Another controversy around paradigms is centered on control of the study: who initiates? who determines research processes? who determines what to be represented? The authors noted that the issue of control is deeply embedded in the questions of voice, reflexivity, and postmodern textual representation, which are relevant only to new paradigm inquirers. Interestingly, however, the term control is used to foster empowerment, noted the authors:
"[F]or new-paradigm researchers control is a means of fostering emancipation, democracy, and community empowerment, and of redressing power imbalances such that those who were previously marginalized now achieve voice (Mertens, 1998) or "human flourishing" (Heron & Reason, 1997). (p. 268)
Validity is the most controversial term among paradigms. Questions relevant to validity include: are the findings sufficient enough to act upon them?
Voice: In the past, the only appropriate voice was "voice from nowhere" (p. 277). While the voice of informants becomes important, the authors observed that it is critical to participatory research, having a researcher's voice in the text and simultaneously letting participants speak for themselves through various media, such as plays, forums, performance-oriented media... The authors remarked: "Performance texts, in particular, give an emotional immediacy to the voices of researchers and research participants far beyond their own sites and locale" (p. 278). For Rosanna Herz (1997, Introduction: Reflexivity and voice. In (Ed.), Reflexivity and voice), voice is a struggle for representation of the author's self as well as the respondents' selves. She wrote:
Voice has multiple dimensions: First there is the voice of the author. Second, there is the presentation of the voices of ones' respondents within the text. A third dimension appears when the self is the subject of the inquiry. (p. 278).
[Participatory video, these dimensions come into play. How do participants represent their voice when they present their respondents' interviewed voice? Is this argument really relevant ti PV in any case? I explored a bit of this issue in writing reflexivity.]
Reflexivity: The authors defined as reflexivity here reflecting critically on the self as researcher, instrumental to research.
Postmodern textual representations: postmodern and poststructural perspectives brought forth criticism around conventional texts: their reductionist representation of human reality and contribution to historical oppression. As a counter-text, new forms of texts flourish to break boundaries and moving the center to the margin. One of the examples is "messy texts" (Marcus & Fischer, 1986), which breaks the binary between science and literature. The authors noted that "Representation may be arguably the most open-ended for the controversies surrounding phenomenological research today" (p. 280).
In concluding, the authors remain as constructivists. They think it is highly unlikely and even less than useful that positivist and new paradigm forms of inquiry resolve their differences because of the assumption that there is no single truth. Thus, they wrote:
"We stand at the threshold of a history marked by multivocality, contested meanings, paradigmatic controversies, and new texual forms" (p. 281).
The authors developed their definition of the nature of paradigms proposed in 1994 by incorporating John Heron and Peter Reason's (1997) participatory/cooperative paradigm. In this chapter, they focused on issues of axiology, commensurability, action, control, foundations of truth and knowledge, validity, voice, reflexivity, and postmodern textual representation.
It is interesting to note that they changed their perspective on commensurability: in the past, they had argued commensurability between paradigms is not possible, although within each paradigm, mixed methodologies may make good sense. Yet, in this chapter is argued that it would not be impossible to blend some elements from each paradigm. For instance, positivism and postpositivism are clearly commensurable.
Concerning the call to action, the authors noted:
"The mandate for social action, especially action designed and created by and for rearch participants with the aid and cooperation of researchers, can be most sharply delineated between positivist/postpositivist and new paradigm inquirers. (p. 267)
Another controversy around paradigms is centered on control of the study: who initiates? who determines research processes? who determines what to be represented? The authors noted that the issue of control is deeply embedded in the questions of voice, reflexivity, and postmodern textual representation, which are relevant only to new paradigm inquirers. Interestingly, however, the term control is used to foster empowerment, noted the authors:
"[F]or new-paradigm researchers control is a means of fostering emancipation, democracy, and community empowerment, and of redressing power imbalances such that those who were previously marginalized now achieve voice (Mertens, 1998) or "human flourishing" (Heron & Reason, 1997). (p. 268)
Validity is the most controversial term among paradigms. Questions relevant to validity include: are the findings sufficient enough to act upon them?
Voice: In the past, the only appropriate voice was "voice from nowhere" (p. 277). While the voice of informants becomes important, the authors observed that it is critical to participatory research, having a researcher's voice in the text and simultaneously letting participants speak for themselves through various media, such as plays, forums, performance-oriented media... The authors remarked: "Performance texts, in particular, give an emotional immediacy to the voices of researchers and research participants far beyond their own sites and locale" (p. 278). For Rosanna Herz (1997, Introduction: Reflexivity and voice. In (Ed.), Reflexivity and voice), voice is a struggle for representation of the author's self as well as the respondents' selves. She wrote:
Voice has multiple dimensions: First there is the voice of the author. Second, there is the presentation of the voices of ones' respondents within the text. A third dimension appears when the self is the subject of the inquiry. (p. 278).
[Participatory video, these dimensions come into play. How do participants represent their voice when they present their respondents' interviewed voice? Is this argument really relevant ti PV in any case? I explored a bit of this issue in writing reflexivity.]
Reflexivity: The authors defined as reflexivity here reflecting critically on the self as researcher, instrumental to research.
Postmodern textual representations: postmodern and poststructural perspectives brought forth criticism around conventional texts: their reductionist representation of human reality and contribution to historical oppression. As a counter-text, new forms of texts flourish to break boundaries and moving the center to the margin. One of the examples is "messy texts" (Marcus & Fischer, 1986), which breaks the binary between science and literature. The authors noted that "Representation may be arguably the most open-ended for the controversies surrounding phenomenological research today" (p. 280).
In concluding, the authors remain as constructivists. They think it is highly unlikely and even less than useful that positivist and new paradigm forms of inquiry resolve their differences because of the assumption that there is no single truth. Thus, they wrote:
"We stand at the threshold of a history marked by multivocality, contested meanings, paradigmatic controversies, and new texual forms" (p. 281).
An alternative paradigm dialog
Egon C. Guba (1990). In E.G. Guba (Ed.), The paradigm dialog (pp. 17-30). Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
In this chapter, Guba proposed as the generic definition of paradigm "a basic set of belief that guides action" (p. 17), in particular, disciplined inquiry as the action in our concern. Such paradigms respond to three questions: ontological, epistemological, and methodological questions.
1) Ontological: What is the nature of reality?
2) Epistemological: What is the nature of the relationship between the knower (researcher) and the known (researched)?
3) Methodological: what is the process of finding out knowledge or research?
Positivism
The positivist paradigm is rooted in a realist ontology, the belief that "there exists a reality out there driven by immutable natural laws" (p. 19). The purpose of science is to discover the true nature of reality and how it truly works.
From this ground, positivists practice an objectivist epistemology, in which they put questions directly to nature and wait for its answer without altering it. Since the inquirer can be positioned far away from nature, research outcomes are value free. Within this paradigm, experimental/manipulative methodology is the most appropriate in such a way that questions and hypotheses are stated in advance and subjected to empirical tests under carefully controlled conditions.
Postpositivism
It is a modified/less naïve version of positivism. It is based on critical realism: postpositivists believe that reality exists out there, yet because of human sensory/intellectual limitations, it is impossible for humans truly to perceive it. Thus, they emphasize the need for being critical about what researchers find.
Epistemologically, postpositivists recognize the absurdity of the separation of inquirers from the inquired; thus they take on a modified objectivist epistemology in the sense that objectivity is a regulatory ideal to adhere, yet in reality, can be achieved reasonably closely (approximated) only by cleaning up one's preposition, relying on the tradition of the field to report the inquiry, and seeking judgment from peers in the disciplinary community. Guba criticized that the latter two requirements virtually make is impossible for new paradigm to assert themselves.
Methodologically, it put forth critical multiplism (modified experimentalism/manipulatism), which was also articulated as triangulation by Denzin (1978). Because of limited human sensory, it seeks as many sources as possible to draw findings. They often calls for more qualitative methods, depending more on grounded theory, and reintroducing discovery into the inquiry process.
Critical Theory
Guba proposed the label of "ideologically oriented inquiry" instead of critical theory, which encompasses feminism, neo-Marxism, Frerieism, participatory inquiry, and critical theory. The shared quality in this family is rejecting the claim of "value freedom" made by positivism (and postpositivism to an extent). They believe that values do enter into every inquiry; inquiry thereby becomes a political act.
Guba criticizes an ontological juncture that critical theorists (ideologists) adhere to:
But, for whatever reason, critical theorists (ideologists) have elected to believe in an objective reality--as the phrase commonly used by them, "false consciousness," readily demonstrates (because it implies that there is a "true consciousness" somewhere "out there," or, more likely, possessed by the inquirer or some better informed elite). The task of inquiry is, by definition, to raise people (the oppressed) to a level of "true consciousness." Once they appreciate how oppressed they are, they can act to transform the world. The close parallel between transforming the world and predicting and controlling it should not be lost. (p. 24)
Critical theorists undertake subjectivist epistemology, regarding inquiry acts as a process intimately related to the inquirer's values. Yet, Guba points out a logical disjunction a "realist ontology coupled with a subjectivist epistemology" (p. 24).
Guba asserted that critical theorists' methodology is more consistent and framed it as transformative and dialogic one. It seeks to eliminate false consciousness and to facilitate transformation.
Constructivism
Constructivist calls for a completely different paradigm. It acknowledge value-laden facts and furthermore, the interaction of inquirer and inquired into that shapes outcomes of an inquiry. Therefore, constructivists state that:
It [constructivism] renders the distinction between ontology and epistemology obsolete; what can be known and the individual who comes to know it are fused into a coherent whole. Further, it makes the findings of an inquiry not a report of what is "out there" but the residue of a process that literally creates them. Finally, it depicts knowledge as the outcome or consequence of human activity; knowledge is a human construction, never certifiable as ultimately true but problematic and ever changing. (p. 26)
From this perspective, ontologically, it takes a position of relativism in that "realities are multiple, and they exist in people's minds" (p. 26). Guba argued that relativism is "the key to openness and the continuing search for ever more informed and sophisticated constructions" (p. 26).
Epistemologically, the constructivist takes a subjectivist position, not because of the limited human conditions but because of its ontological assumptions: if realities exist only in people's minds, subjectivist interaction is the only way to accessing them.
Methodologically, the constructivist takes hermeneutics and dialectics: it attempts to depict individual constructions as accurately as possible, and simultaneously, contrast and compare dialectically to generate informed constructions on which there is substantial consensus.
In this chapter, Guba proposed as the generic definition of paradigm "a basic set of belief that guides action" (p. 17), in particular, disciplined inquiry as the action in our concern. Such paradigms respond to three questions: ontological, epistemological, and methodological questions.
1) Ontological: What is the nature of reality?
2) Epistemological: What is the nature of the relationship between the knower (researcher) and the known (researched)?
3) Methodological: what is the process of finding out knowledge or research?
Positivism
The positivist paradigm is rooted in a realist ontology, the belief that "there exists a reality out there driven by immutable natural laws" (p. 19). The purpose of science is to discover the true nature of reality and how it truly works.
From this ground, positivists practice an objectivist epistemology, in which they put questions directly to nature and wait for its answer without altering it. Since the inquirer can be positioned far away from nature, research outcomes are value free. Within this paradigm, experimental/manipulative methodology is the most appropriate in such a way that questions and hypotheses are stated in advance and subjected to empirical tests under carefully controlled conditions.
Postpositivism
It is a modified/less naïve version of positivism. It is based on critical realism: postpositivists believe that reality exists out there, yet because of human sensory/intellectual limitations, it is impossible for humans truly to perceive it. Thus, they emphasize the need for being critical about what researchers find.
Epistemologically, postpositivists recognize the absurdity of the separation of inquirers from the inquired; thus they take on a modified objectivist epistemology in the sense that objectivity is a regulatory ideal to adhere, yet in reality, can be achieved reasonably closely (approximated) only by cleaning up one's preposition, relying on the tradition of the field to report the inquiry, and seeking judgment from peers in the disciplinary community. Guba criticized that the latter two requirements virtually make is impossible for new paradigm to assert themselves.
Methodologically, it put forth critical multiplism (modified experimentalism/manipulatism), which was also articulated as triangulation by Denzin (1978). Because of limited human sensory, it seeks as many sources as possible to draw findings. They often calls for more qualitative methods, depending more on grounded theory, and reintroducing discovery into the inquiry process.
Critical Theory
Guba proposed the label of "ideologically oriented inquiry" instead of critical theory, which encompasses feminism, neo-Marxism, Frerieism, participatory inquiry, and critical theory. The shared quality in this family is rejecting the claim of "value freedom" made by positivism (and postpositivism to an extent). They believe that values do enter into every inquiry; inquiry thereby becomes a political act.
Guba criticizes an ontological juncture that critical theorists (ideologists) adhere to:
But, for whatever reason, critical theorists (ideologists) have elected to believe in an objective reality--as the phrase commonly used by them, "false consciousness," readily demonstrates (because it implies that there is a "true consciousness" somewhere "out there," or, more likely, possessed by the inquirer or some better informed elite). The task of inquiry is, by definition, to raise people (the oppressed) to a level of "true consciousness." Once they appreciate how oppressed they are, they can act to transform the world. The close parallel between transforming the world and predicting and controlling it should not be lost. (p. 24)
Critical theorists undertake subjectivist epistemology, regarding inquiry acts as a process intimately related to the inquirer's values. Yet, Guba points out a logical disjunction a "realist ontology coupled with a subjectivist epistemology" (p. 24).
Guba asserted that critical theorists' methodology is more consistent and framed it as transformative and dialogic one. It seeks to eliminate false consciousness and to facilitate transformation.
Constructivism
Constructivist calls for a completely different paradigm. It acknowledge value-laden facts and furthermore, the interaction of inquirer and inquired into that shapes outcomes of an inquiry. Therefore, constructivists state that:
It [constructivism] renders the distinction between ontology and epistemology obsolete; what can be known and the individual who comes to know it are fused into a coherent whole. Further, it makes the findings of an inquiry not a report of what is "out there" but the residue of a process that literally creates them. Finally, it depicts knowledge as the outcome or consequence of human activity; knowledge is a human construction, never certifiable as ultimately true but problematic and ever changing. (p. 26)
From this perspective, ontologically, it takes a position of relativism in that "realities are multiple, and they exist in people's minds" (p. 26). Guba argued that relativism is "the key to openness and the continuing search for ever more informed and sophisticated constructions" (p. 26).
Epistemologically, the constructivist takes a subjectivist position, not because of the limited human conditions but because of its ontological assumptions: if realities exist only in people's minds, subjectivist interaction is the only way to accessing them.
Methodologically, the constructivist takes hermeneutics and dialectics: it attempts to depict individual constructions as accurately as possible, and simultaneously, contrast and compare dialectically to generate informed constructions on which there is substantial consensus.
A Participatory Inquiry Paradigm
John Heron and Peter Reason (1997). Qualitative inquiry, 3 (3), 274-294. doi: 10.1177/107780049700300302
Deveoloping Guba and Lincoln (1994, Competing paradigms in qualitative research. In N.
K. Denzin & Y S. Lincoln (Eds.), Handbook of qualitative research), the authors articulate a participatory paradigm by supporting Guba and Lincoln's argument that the constructivist paradigm is unclear about the relation between constructed realities and the original cosmos. In this light, the authors argued that "participative realities" are more useful.
The authors begin a paradigm building from the constructivist worldview. Further, it emphasizes human beings in relation to the living world and experiential knowledge, inquiry and reality. They argued:
"Constructivist views tend to be deficient in any acknowledgment of experiential knowing; that is, knowing by acquaintance, by meeting, and by felt participation in the presence of what is there. (p. 277)
For them, reality is a form of experience and experiential reality is both subjective and objective. For instance, holding someone's hand means that it shapes the person and simultaneously I meet the person. Thus, they stated, "To experience anything is to participate in it, and to participate is to both to mold and to encounter; hence, experiential reality is always subjective-objective" (p. 278). This participatory, subjective-objective, experiential reality constitutes the ontology of participatory worldview. Heron (1996 p, 11 ...) wrote:
It is subjective because it is only known through the form the mind gives it; and it is objective because the mind interpenetrates the given cosmos which it shapes. (p. 11)
Thus, in this paradigm, they argue that there is a primordial reality, in which the mind actively penetrates and cocreates reality through interaction with the cosmos.
Epistemology: the authors emphasize critical subjectivity as the epistemological ground. They acknowledge that knowing is from a perspective and that perspective has authentic values as well as restricting bias. Thus, what involves is critical subjectivity, such that a self-reflexive attention is given to the knower's ground. Developing the community consensus (which determines relative truth) of constructivism, the authors add shared experiential meaning to judge the relative truth. [THIS ARGUMENT IS VERY VAGUE.] In this light, they argued that critical subjectivity extends to critical intersubjectivity, for personal knowing is always set within cultural and experiential shared meaning.
Methodology: Collaborative/Cooperative forms of action inquiry.
The authors argued that cooperative inquiry rests on two participatory principles: epistemic participation and political participation:
The first means that any propositional knowledge that is the outcomes of the research is grounded by the researchers in their own experiential knowledge. The second means that research subjects have a basic human right to participate fully in designing the research that intends to gather knowledge about them. (p. 284)
The more participatory systematically the more cooperative. Thus, they distinguish this methodology from the mainstream qualitative paradigm:
Qualitative research about people is a halfway house between exclusive, controlling, quantitative, positivist research on people and fully participatory, cooperative research with people. (p. 285)
Cooperative inquiry is "a wide-ranging science about any aspect of the human condition that a group of coresearchers choose to explore through the instrumentality of their own experience" (p. 286).
Axiology: the authors contended that the omission of axiology in Guba and Lincoln's paradigm table is a critical deficit because axiology ultimately asks why we try to create reality and what it worthwhile and valuable. In this question, the authors respond that the participatory paradigm answers it is for human flourishing. It is practical knowing of "how to choose and act" (p. 287).
Deveoloping Guba and Lincoln (1994, Competing paradigms in qualitative research. In N.
K. Denzin & Y S. Lincoln (Eds.), Handbook of qualitative research), the authors articulate a participatory paradigm by supporting Guba and Lincoln's argument that the constructivist paradigm is unclear about the relation between constructed realities and the original cosmos. In this light, the authors argued that "participative realities" are more useful.
The authors begin a paradigm building from the constructivist worldview. Further, it emphasizes human beings in relation to the living world and experiential knowledge, inquiry and reality. They argued:
"Constructivist views tend to be deficient in any acknowledgment of experiential knowing; that is, knowing by acquaintance, by meeting, and by felt participation in the presence of what is there. (p. 277)
For them, reality is a form of experience and experiential reality is both subjective and objective. For instance, holding someone's hand means that it shapes the person and simultaneously I meet the person. Thus, they stated, "To experience anything is to participate in it, and to participate is to both to mold and to encounter; hence, experiential reality is always subjective-objective" (p. 278). This participatory, subjective-objective, experiential reality constitutes the ontology of participatory worldview. Heron (1996 p, 11 ...) wrote:
It is subjective because it is only known through the form the mind gives it; and it is objective because the mind interpenetrates the given cosmos which it shapes. (p. 11)
Thus, in this paradigm, they argue that there is a primordial reality, in which the mind actively penetrates and cocreates reality through interaction with the cosmos.
Epistemology: the authors emphasize critical subjectivity as the epistemological ground. They acknowledge that knowing is from a perspective and that perspective has authentic values as well as restricting bias. Thus, what involves is critical subjectivity, such that a self-reflexive attention is given to the knower's ground. Developing the community consensus (which determines relative truth) of constructivism, the authors add shared experiential meaning to judge the relative truth. [THIS ARGUMENT IS VERY VAGUE.] In this light, they argued that critical subjectivity extends to critical intersubjectivity, for personal knowing is always set within cultural and experiential shared meaning.
Methodology: Collaborative/Cooperative forms of action inquiry.
The authors argued that cooperative inquiry rests on two participatory principles: epistemic participation and political participation:
The first means that any propositional knowledge that is the outcomes of the research is grounded by the researchers in their own experiential knowledge. The second means that research subjects have a basic human right to participate fully in designing the research that intends to gather knowledge about them. (p. 284)
The more participatory systematically the more cooperative. Thus, they distinguish this methodology from the mainstream qualitative paradigm:
Qualitative research about people is a halfway house between exclusive, controlling, quantitative, positivist research on people and fully participatory, cooperative research with people. (p. 285)
Cooperative inquiry is "a wide-ranging science about any aspect of the human condition that a group of coresearchers choose to explore through the instrumentality of their own experience" (p. 286).
Axiology: the authors contended that the omission of axiology in Guba and Lincoln's paradigm table is a critical deficit because axiology ultimately asks why we try to create reality and what it worthwhile and valuable. In this question, the authors respond that the participatory paradigm answers it is for human flourishing. It is practical knowing of "how to choose and act" (p. 287).
Tuesday, November 30, 2010
The Sage handbook of action research
: Participative inquiry and practice. Reason, Peter & Bradbury, Hilary (Eds.). (2008). London, Thousand Oaks, New Delhi, and Singapore: Sage.
Introduction (P. Reason & H. Bradbury, 1-13)
Reason and Bradbury traced back to the origin of action research to Lewin, liberationist perspective, exemplified by Freire, scholar-practitioners' work in education, health, and community development, and philosophical roots in critical theory, constructivism, phenomenology, etc. Epistemologically, they argue that action research has been shied away from the mainstream social sciences, which focus on objectivity and emphasize representation rather than action. Within this context, they define action research as:
a family of practices of living inquiry that aims, in a great variety of ways, to link practice and ideas in the service of human flourishing. It is not so much a methodology as an orientation to inquiry that seeks to create participative communities of inquiry in which qualities of engagement, curiosity and question posing are brought o bear on significant practical issues. (p. 1)
In their definition, action research is characterized with a participatory process. They wrote: "[A]ction research is participatory research, and all participatory research must be action research" (p. 4). Here "action" means that research responds to "people's desire to act creatively in the face of practical and often pressing issues in their lives in organization and communities" (p. 3) and it is action because the research looks into the participants' own action in their daily lives. They distinguish action research from traditional research in that action research aims at producing practical knowledge to act upon practical issues and bring about transformative experience of our daily lives. Thereby, it is contentious to some of the academic community, which aims at producing academic theories unencumbered by practical questions. In so doing, action research challenges a monopoly of knowledge production inveterate in academic practices. The authors emphasize the emancipatory dimension of action research: Without it, action research would be co-opted by the status quo instead of flourishing individual or community lives.
The authors' terms first, second, and third-person research practices as an organizing framework are useful to analyze the process of action research. First-person action research practices involve with the individual ability to inquire into his or her own life. Second-person action research practices addresses the ability to inquire into mutual issues and problem through face-to-face interpersonal dialogue and develop organizations. Third-person action research practices aims to create a wider impact. They assert that research reports can be an important form of third-person inquiry.
The authors do not bind action research with a specific set of methodologies. Instead, they draw attention to action research as a form of bringing scholarship and praxis together and a new way of knowing, and the development of new thinking about validity and quality in research. It is a paradigm. In their definition, participation is the backbone of action research. They also note that participation is political in that it allows people to have a say in decision making and producing knowledge about them. It empowers them because it allows them to see that they can construct and use their own knowledge to address pressing issue.
Living inquiry: Personal, political and philosophical groundings for action research practice (15-30, Wicks, P. G., Reason, P., & Bradbury, H. ).
The authors analyze the survey responses from action research practitioners. One of the patterns noted by the respondents is Thomas Kuhn's influence on paradigmatic shift for their epistemological understanding and research practices. Some also attributed their practices to pragmatist position that "knowledge is acquired through responding to a real need in life" (p. 19). Most respondents also seek critical social theories as their philosophical backdrop: the political dimension of theories and knowledge led them to the perspective that knowledge is value-laden and can be emancipatory. Also many come from the objection to traditional education research and embraces critical perspectives on pedagogy influenced by Freire and Hall. McTaggart and Kemmis in particular look for the transformative potential of action research. The authors conclude as the status of action researchers:
[A]ction researchers themselves could be understood to have been action as 'bricoleurs' over time, and in a very real sense, 'making the road while walking'. Indeed, the active process of integrating and making sense of various influences and perspectives and of developing one's own understanding seems to be central to many action researchers' accounts. (p. 26)
Participatory action research as practice (31-48, Swantz, Marja Liisa)
Swantz argued that the conventional scientific criteria could not validate PAR; practical success verifies the usefulness, asserted the author. Specifically, she noted Heinz Moser's (1975, as cited on page 43) three criteria: (1) transparency: are all the participants aware of the whole process of research, such as functions, aims, and methods, (2) compatibility of the aims and methods. For instance, outside researchers cannot be an independent observer, and (3) participant researcher's claim: does she claim that she knows better than does any outside observer and can she set forth all the aspects that she knows? [Criteria to evaluate PR]
Analyzing her own work, Swantz argued for the potential of participatory action research: She argued that by breaking the monopoly of privileged knowledge, people can break the monopoly of bureaucratic and technocratic power. She also asserts that knowledge should be grained in people's lives and PAR should promote such knowledge production.
Some trends in the praxis of participatory action research (Rahman, Anisur. 49-62)
Rahman finds the philosophical background of PAR in Marxist's call for the working class to create their own history, yet pointed out that Marxists have shown little interest in PAR movement. Instead, Freirians or others who focused micro-level grassroots movement and "conscientization" have promoted active PAR. Looking through regional trends throughout the world, Rahman defined PAR as a 'micro ideology' (p. 60), through which the downtrodden people can create their own history by building their own science.
[As Swantz, knowledge is tied to power in the discourse of PAR. Yet, on what basis?]
Continuing the journey: articulating dimensions of feminist participatory action research (FPAR) (Collen Reid and Wendy Frisby, 93-105)
Based on their experience, the authors articulate six dimensions of FPAR:
(1) Centering gender and women's diverse experiences in addressing power;
(2) Accounting for intersectionality across the differences in gender, class, race, culture, etc.
(3) Honoring voice and difference: by articulating personal experiences based on real life, FPAR aims at revealing hidden structural and social institutions. Cooke and Kothari (2001) warned that participatory approaches could contribute to perpetuating entrenched power relations if the heterogeneity of communities is neglected or there is lack of institutional change.
The authors noted as the current limitation of FPAR: "Yet, the feminist ideals of using participatory research techniques to give voice to people's experience and create change by focusing on action aimed at social transformation have not been fully realized" (p. 99).
(4) Exploring new forms of representation by continuing to pushing boundaries of prescribed ways of conducting research;
(5) Reflexivity: The authors define reflexivity in research as making explicit the power relations and the exercise of power in the research process. They note that feminist action researchers are attentive to self criticism and consciously write about themselves into the text. Yet, they argue that writing themselves into the text is not enough; researchers should write themselves into action and activism, meaning provoking self-discovery by using researchers' own self reflection.
(6) Honoring many forms of action: FPAR sees that actions are dependent on one's social, economic and political situation and can occur at both individual and collective levels. Yet, they argue that in some FPAR, it is not always clear what actions were taken and by whom, its effect, etc. More critically, they stated:
"Another critical consideration is whether individual and local actions eventually link up to a larger social change agenda. What this should look like and what steps could be taken to accomplish this are seldom clear." (p. 102)
* Cooke, B., & Kothari, U. (2001). The case of participation as tyranny. In B. Cooke & U. Kothari (Eds.), Participation: The new tyranny? (pp. 1-15). London: Zed.
Towards transformational liberation: Participatory and action research and praxis (M. Brington Lykes & Amelia Mallona, 106-120)
The authors discussed the liberatory and transformational potential of participatory "and" action research. They argued for a preferential option for the poor and a politically contextualized psychology to realize its radical potential. In particular, looking at PAR conceived in the majority society in the 70s and 80s, they asserted:
Participatory and action research and the broad-based social movements of the time were 'walking a long road together' and, in the best of circumstances, contributed to self- and social consciousness among social actors who constructed participatory and transformative grassroots movements towards social transformation. Participatory and action research were thus situated as a resource at the interface of radical humanism and structural transformation. (p. 109)
The authors also found the same idea in participatory and action research in the late 1960s and 70s in India and Latin America, in which personal transformation was emphasized (i.e Rahman, 1990). The authors described it as radical humanism. Reflecting on their own work around participatory and action research, they wrote:
[W]e are still 'making the road as we go', ever aware of the contradictions described above and that transformational liberation is a process to be engaged in, not an endpoint or outcome that we have achieved. (p. 117)
[Action doesn't have to me immediate, as social change is less likely to occur immediately. It is a progress. Thus I would call participatory research, instead of action research or participatory action research.]
Critical theory and participatory action research (Stephen Kemmis, 121-138)
Drawing upon critical theory--in particular the work of Habermas, Kemmis theorizes a new definition of critical participatory action research (CPAR) [WHY so many words?]
He attended to the increasing emphasis on the "social" in PAR. In particular, he drew attention to Habermas's analysis of social life in late modernity and stressed "communicative spaces" that transforms subjectivity to intersubjectivity, through which people "thematize and explore issues and crises, not from the perspective of whole system (either people or states or other social totalities as 'systems') but in terms of public discussions aimed at greater understanding and transformations of social life at the moments and places where specific crises occur" (p. 122).
But in fact, Kemmis's definition of critical PAR is not new. Rather, it insinuates a change within his perspective. His emphasis on PAR was closer to Lewin's action research. In this chapter, he came to see macro-dynamics and adjoin critical theory to his own definition of PAR.
Social construction ad research as action (159-171. Kenneth J. Gergen and Mary M. Gergen)
Gergen and Gergen explores the nexus between action research and constructionist theory. (To begin with, they clarify constructionism and constructivism: Social construction refers to a tradition of scholarship that traces the origin of knowledge, meaning or understanding to human relationships, whereas constructivist scholars views processes inherent in the individual mind and their interpretation of the world.)
As the convergence between "action oriented research" and constructionist theory, the authors explore four aspects:
(1) research as political action: As opposed to posivitists who are committed to a view of scientific neutrality and value-free facts, constructionists believe that "all research is essentially a contribution to domains of meaning" regardless of the researcher's intention. Likewise, action researchers also bring forth values in their research and do not advocate universality, treating action research as like storytelling than sermonizing.
(2) collaboration beyond individualism: As another characteristic of action research that cut away from traditional positive research practices, the authors refer to collaborative methods as opposed to individualist orientation of research. (Heron and Reason (2001) emphasizeds action research as a 'practice of co-operative inquiry,' a domain of practice that researches 'with people rather than on people'). This shift from an individualist to a collectivist orientation to research methods is in tune with constructionism. The authors noted, " constructionist theory lends itself to an ontology in which relationship precedes the individual" (p. 166) and it accounts constructionists' approach to knowledge formation.
(3) From mapping to world making: as opposed to positivist program, in which researchers attempt to bring about accurate accounts of the world, constructionists believe that language cannot map the world of human behaviors and social sciences can only bring about the meaning of the world. Likewise, action researchers reject the concept of describing "the world as it is". Rather, their focus is laid on social change and to realize versions of "what the world can become" (p. 167).
(4) From theoretical and practical priority: In the positivist tradition, the ultimate goal of research is the development of general theory and research itself is important as a case to vindicate or challenge theoretical assumptions. On the other hand, constructionists believe that experimental methods are typically remote from everyday life, thus being stripped of cultural significance; abstract theory has not of use. Within this context, the authors state that action research provides a refreshing and productive alternative by attempting to change existing conditions of life, for its ultimate goal is to generate change.
*Heron, J. & Reason, P. (2001). The practice of co-operative inquiry: research "with" rather than "on" people. In P. Reason and H. Bradbury (Eds.), Handbook of action research: participative inquiry and practice (pp. 179-99). London: Sage.
Power and knowledge (172-189, John Gaventa and Andrea Cornwall)
The authors observed that participatory action researchers have focused on their critique on structural relationships between power and monopolies of knowledge. In particular, Fals-Borda and Rahman (1991) asserted that the control of knowledge and its production was as important as material and other social relations. In this light, they saw the role of PAR is to empower themselves by participating in knowledge production through action and reflection.
The authors asserted that despite slightly different understandings of the location of power (i.e. power within, power between, power embedded in social relations, etc.), PAR practitioners share an epistemological critique about ways in which knowledge is embedded and reinforced in the dominant (or positivist) knowledge production system.
(1) positivist methods distort reality by distancing those who study reality from those who experience it;
(2) traditional research methods (surveys, i.e.) further alienate powerless groups by making them the objects of another's inquiry. And, empirical, quantitative form of knowledge may reduce the complexity of human experience;
(3) it perpetuates the legitimacy of knowledge produced by a small number of privileged experts by obscuring other forms of knowledge and the voices of other knowers.
From this perspective, PAR (1) attempts to bring forth a different forms of knowledge, the authors argued, thereby letting those who directed affected by the research participate in the research process ; PAR also recognizes the social constructedness of knowledge, thus delving into collective analysis of life experiences of power and knowledge; Lastly PAR recognizes different ways of knowing and viewing reality: research often starts with popular knowledge, yet it is deepened through a dialectical process of acting and understanding. It also stresses the importance of listening to diverse voices within the group.
The authors draw a diagram of dimensions of participatory research: participation is constituted by knowledge (as a source to affect decision-making), action (involvement in such knowledge production), and consciousness (production of knowledge as consciousness builder). They observe that one or more aspects are emphasized among PAR practitioners.
[It is interesting to note that "action" is far from the concept of Lewin's action research. Action-reflection is an important cycle of the authors' PAR, yet here action is the process of participation in knowledge production itself, not the part of verification of Lewin's concept of action research.]
Ethics and action research: Deepening our commitment to principles of social justice and redefining systems of democratic practice (199-209, Mary Brydon-Miller)
Brydon-Miller analyzes key ethical principles of research within the notion of power in research setting. For her, the shared values of action research, such as "participation in democratic processes, the improvement of human life, and engagement in morally committed action" (p. 209), are the very ethical challenge among action researchers. Yet, there is a discrepancy between the morality and institutional structural for ethics review. In this light, she rejects the tradition of ethical review centered on university-based experts. She wrote:
[S]hifts in power within the research setting away from the oversight and control of university-based experts and paternalistic oversight committees and toward ownership by members of communities themselves would better reflect the ethical principles of respect for person, beneficence, and justice. This is a critical move if the full promise of these principles is to be realized in our practice as action researchers, but at the same time such redistributions of power and control carry unique challenges and genuine risks if we do not remain vigilant to the ethical implications of our practice. (p. 208)
Introduction (P. Reason & H. Bradbury, 1-13)
Reason and Bradbury traced back to the origin of action research to Lewin, liberationist perspective, exemplified by Freire, scholar-practitioners' work in education, health, and community development, and philosophical roots in critical theory, constructivism, phenomenology, etc. Epistemologically, they argue that action research has been shied away from the mainstream social sciences, which focus on objectivity and emphasize representation rather than action. Within this context, they define action research as:
a family of practices of living inquiry that aims, in a great variety of ways, to link practice and ideas in the service of human flourishing. It is not so much a methodology as an orientation to inquiry that seeks to create participative communities of inquiry in which qualities of engagement, curiosity and question posing are brought o bear on significant practical issues. (p. 1)
In their definition, action research is characterized with a participatory process. They wrote: "[A]ction research is participatory research, and all participatory research must be action research" (p. 4). Here "action" means that research responds to "people's desire to act creatively in the face of practical and often pressing issues in their lives in organization and communities" (p. 3) and it is action because the research looks into the participants' own action in their daily lives. They distinguish action research from traditional research in that action research aims at producing practical knowledge to act upon practical issues and bring about transformative experience of our daily lives. Thereby, it is contentious to some of the academic community, which aims at producing academic theories unencumbered by practical questions. In so doing, action research challenges a monopoly of knowledge production inveterate in academic practices. The authors emphasize the emancipatory dimension of action research: Without it, action research would be co-opted by the status quo instead of flourishing individual or community lives.
The authors' terms first, second, and third-person research practices as an organizing framework are useful to analyze the process of action research. First-person action research practices involve with the individual ability to inquire into his or her own life. Second-person action research practices addresses the ability to inquire into mutual issues and problem through face-to-face interpersonal dialogue and develop organizations. Third-person action research practices aims to create a wider impact. They assert that research reports can be an important form of third-person inquiry.
The authors do not bind action research with a specific set of methodologies. Instead, they draw attention to action research as a form of bringing scholarship and praxis together and a new way of knowing, and the development of new thinking about validity and quality in research. It is a paradigm. In their definition, participation is the backbone of action research. They also note that participation is political in that it allows people to have a say in decision making and producing knowledge about them. It empowers them because it allows them to see that they can construct and use their own knowledge to address pressing issue.
Living inquiry: Personal, political and philosophical groundings for action research practice (15-30, Wicks, P. G., Reason, P., & Bradbury, H. ).
The authors analyze the survey responses from action research practitioners. One of the patterns noted by the respondents is Thomas Kuhn's influence on paradigmatic shift for their epistemological understanding and research practices. Some also attributed their practices to pragmatist position that "knowledge is acquired through responding to a real need in life" (p. 19). Most respondents also seek critical social theories as their philosophical backdrop: the political dimension of theories and knowledge led them to the perspective that knowledge is value-laden and can be emancipatory. Also many come from the objection to traditional education research and embraces critical perspectives on pedagogy influenced by Freire and Hall. McTaggart and Kemmis in particular look for the transformative potential of action research. The authors conclude as the status of action researchers:
[A]ction researchers themselves could be understood to have been action as 'bricoleurs' over time, and in a very real sense, 'making the road while walking'. Indeed, the active process of integrating and making sense of various influences and perspectives and of developing one's own understanding seems to be central to many action researchers' accounts. (p. 26)
Participatory action research as practice (31-48, Swantz, Marja Liisa)
Swantz argued that the conventional scientific criteria could not validate PAR; practical success verifies the usefulness, asserted the author. Specifically, she noted Heinz Moser's (1975, as cited on page 43) three criteria: (1) transparency: are all the participants aware of the whole process of research, such as functions, aims, and methods, (2) compatibility of the aims and methods. For instance, outside researchers cannot be an independent observer, and (3) participant researcher's claim: does she claim that she knows better than does any outside observer and can she set forth all the aspects that she knows? [Criteria to evaluate PR]
Analyzing her own work, Swantz argued for the potential of participatory action research: She argued that by breaking the monopoly of privileged knowledge, people can break the monopoly of bureaucratic and technocratic power. She also asserts that knowledge should be grained in people's lives and PAR should promote such knowledge production.
Some trends in the praxis of participatory action research (Rahman, Anisur. 49-62)
Rahman finds the philosophical background of PAR in Marxist's call for the working class to create their own history, yet pointed out that Marxists have shown little interest in PAR movement. Instead, Freirians or others who focused micro-level grassroots movement and "conscientization" have promoted active PAR. Looking through regional trends throughout the world, Rahman defined PAR as a 'micro ideology' (p. 60), through which the downtrodden people can create their own history by building their own science.
[As Swantz, knowledge is tied to power in the discourse of PAR. Yet, on what basis?]
Continuing the journey: articulating dimensions of feminist participatory action research (FPAR) (Collen Reid and Wendy Frisby, 93-105)
Based on their experience, the authors articulate six dimensions of FPAR:
(1) Centering gender and women's diverse experiences in addressing power;
(2) Accounting for intersectionality across the differences in gender, class, race, culture, etc.
(3) Honoring voice and difference: by articulating personal experiences based on real life, FPAR aims at revealing hidden structural and social institutions. Cooke and Kothari (2001) warned that participatory approaches could contribute to perpetuating entrenched power relations if the heterogeneity of communities is neglected or there is lack of institutional change.
The authors noted as the current limitation of FPAR: "Yet, the feminist ideals of using participatory research techniques to give voice to people's experience and create change by focusing on action aimed at social transformation have not been fully realized" (p. 99).
(4) Exploring new forms of representation by continuing to pushing boundaries of prescribed ways of conducting research;
(5) Reflexivity: The authors define reflexivity in research as making explicit the power relations and the exercise of power in the research process. They note that feminist action researchers are attentive to self criticism and consciously write about themselves into the text. Yet, they argue that writing themselves into the text is not enough; researchers should write themselves into action and activism, meaning provoking self-discovery by using researchers' own self reflection.
(6) Honoring many forms of action: FPAR sees that actions are dependent on one's social, economic and political situation and can occur at both individual and collective levels. Yet, they argue that in some FPAR, it is not always clear what actions were taken and by whom, its effect, etc. More critically, they stated:
"Another critical consideration is whether individual and local actions eventually link up to a larger social change agenda. What this should look like and what steps could be taken to accomplish this are seldom clear." (p. 102)
* Cooke, B., & Kothari, U. (2001). The case of participation as tyranny. In B. Cooke & U. Kothari (Eds.), Participation: The new tyranny? (pp. 1-15). London: Zed.
Towards transformational liberation: Participatory and action research and praxis (M. Brington Lykes & Amelia Mallona, 106-120)
The authors discussed the liberatory and transformational potential of participatory "and" action research. They argued for a preferential option for the poor and a politically contextualized psychology to realize its radical potential. In particular, looking at PAR conceived in the majority society in the 70s and 80s, they asserted:
Participatory and action research and the broad-based social movements of the time were 'walking a long road together' and, in the best of circumstances, contributed to self- and social consciousness among social actors who constructed participatory and transformative grassroots movements towards social transformation. Participatory and action research were thus situated as a resource at the interface of radical humanism and structural transformation. (p. 109)
The authors also found the same idea in participatory and action research in the late 1960s and 70s in India and Latin America, in which personal transformation was emphasized (i.e Rahman, 1990). The authors described it as radical humanism. Reflecting on their own work around participatory and action research, they wrote:
[W]e are still 'making the road as we go', ever aware of the contradictions described above and that transformational liberation is a process to be engaged in, not an endpoint or outcome that we have achieved. (p. 117)
[Action doesn't have to me immediate, as social change is less likely to occur immediately. It is a progress. Thus I would call participatory research, instead of action research or participatory action research.]
Critical theory and participatory action research (Stephen Kemmis, 121-138)
Drawing upon critical theory--in particular the work of Habermas, Kemmis theorizes a new definition of critical participatory action research (CPAR) [WHY so many words?]
He attended to the increasing emphasis on the "social" in PAR. In particular, he drew attention to Habermas's analysis of social life in late modernity and stressed "communicative spaces" that transforms subjectivity to intersubjectivity, through which people "thematize and explore issues and crises, not from the perspective of whole system (either people or states or other social totalities as 'systems') but in terms of public discussions aimed at greater understanding and transformations of social life at the moments and places where specific crises occur" (p. 122).
But in fact, Kemmis's definition of critical PAR is not new. Rather, it insinuates a change within his perspective. His emphasis on PAR was closer to Lewin's action research. In this chapter, he came to see macro-dynamics and adjoin critical theory to his own definition of PAR.
Social construction ad research as action (159-171. Kenneth J. Gergen and Mary M. Gergen)
Gergen and Gergen explores the nexus between action research and constructionist theory. (To begin with, they clarify constructionism and constructivism: Social construction refers to a tradition of scholarship that traces the origin of knowledge, meaning or understanding to human relationships, whereas constructivist scholars views processes inherent in the individual mind and their interpretation of the world.)
As the convergence between "action oriented research" and constructionist theory, the authors explore four aspects:
(1) research as political action: As opposed to posivitists who are committed to a view of scientific neutrality and value-free facts, constructionists believe that "all research is essentially a contribution to domains of meaning" regardless of the researcher's intention. Likewise, action researchers also bring forth values in their research and do not advocate universality, treating action research as like storytelling than sermonizing.
(2) collaboration beyond individualism: As another characteristic of action research that cut away from traditional positive research practices, the authors refer to collaborative methods as opposed to individualist orientation of research. (Heron and Reason (2001) emphasizeds action research as a 'practice of co-operative inquiry,' a domain of practice that researches 'with people rather than on people'). This shift from an individualist to a collectivist orientation to research methods is in tune with constructionism. The authors noted, " constructionist theory lends itself to an ontology in which relationship precedes the individual" (p. 166) and it accounts constructionists' approach to knowledge formation.
(3) From mapping to world making: as opposed to positivist program, in which researchers attempt to bring about accurate accounts of the world, constructionists believe that language cannot map the world of human behaviors and social sciences can only bring about the meaning of the world. Likewise, action researchers reject the concept of describing "the world as it is". Rather, their focus is laid on social change and to realize versions of "what the world can become" (p. 167).
(4) From theoretical and practical priority: In the positivist tradition, the ultimate goal of research is the development of general theory and research itself is important as a case to vindicate or challenge theoretical assumptions. On the other hand, constructionists believe that experimental methods are typically remote from everyday life, thus being stripped of cultural significance; abstract theory has not of use. Within this context, the authors state that action research provides a refreshing and productive alternative by attempting to change existing conditions of life, for its ultimate goal is to generate change.
*Heron, J. & Reason, P. (2001). The practice of co-operative inquiry: research "with" rather than "on" people. In P. Reason and H. Bradbury (Eds.), Handbook of action research: participative inquiry and practice (pp. 179-99). London: Sage.
Power and knowledge (172-189, John Gaventa and Andrea Cornwall)
The authors observed that participatory action researchers have focused on their critique on structural relationships between power and monopolies of knowledge. In particular, Fals-Borda and Rahman (1991) asserted that the control of knowledge and its production was as important as material and other social relations. In this light, they saw the role of PAR is to empower themselves by participating in knowledge production through action and reflection.
The authors asserted that despite slightly different understandings of the location of power (i.e. power within, power between, power embedded in social relations, etc.), PAR practitioners share an epistemological critique about ways in which knowledge is embedded and reinforced in the dominant (or positivist) knowledge production system.
(1) positivist methods distort reality by distancing those who study reality from those who experience it;
(2) traditional research methods (surveys, i.e.) further alienate powerless groups by making them the objects of another's inquiry. And, empirical, quantitative form of knowledge may reduce the complexity of human experience;
(3) it perpetuates the legitimacy of knowledge produced by a small number of privileged experts by obscuring other forms of knowledge and the voices of other knowers.
From this perspective, PAR (1) attempts to bring forth a different forms of knowledge, the authors argued, thereby letting those who directed affected by the research participate in the research process ; PAR also recognizes the social constructedness of knowledge, thus delving into collective analysis of life experiences of power and knowledge; Lastly PAR recognizes different ways of knowing and viewing reality: research often starts with popular knowledge, yet it is deepened through a dialectical process of acting and understanding. It also stresses the importance of listening to diverse voices within the group.
The authors draw a diagram of dimensions of participatory research: participation is constituted by knowledge (as a source to affect decision-making), action (involvement in such knowledge production), and consciousness (production of knowledge as consciousness builder). They observe that one or more aspects are emphasized among PAR practitioners.
[It is interesting to note that "action" is far from the concept of Lewin's action research. Action-reflection is an important cycle of the authors' PAR, yet here action is the process of participation in knowledge production itself, not the part of verification of Lewin's concept of action research.]
Ethics and action research: Deepening our commitment to principles of social justice and redefining systems of democratic practice (199-209, Mary Brydon-Miller)
Brydon-Miller analyzes key ethical principles of research within the notion of power in research setting. For her, the shared values of action research, such as "participation in democratic processes, the improvement of human life, and engagement in morally committed action" (p. 209), are the very ethical challenge among action researchers. Yet, there is a discrepancy between the morality and institutional structural for ethics review. In this light, she rejects the tradition of ethical review centered on university-based experts. She wrote:
[S]hifts in power within the research setting away from the oversight and control of university-based experts and paternalistic oversight committees and toward ownership by members of communities themselves would better reflect the ethical principles of respect for person, beneficence, and justice. This is a critical move if the full promise of these principles is to be realized in our practice as action researchers, but at the same time such redistributions of power and control carry unique challenges and genuine risks if we do not remain vigilant to the ethical implications of our practice. (p. 208)
Monday, April 19, 2010
Theorizing Audience, Products and Provocation
Michelle Fine & María Elena Torre. (2008). In Peter Reason & Hilary Bradbury (Eds.), The Sage Handbook of Action Research Participative Inquiry and Practice (pp. 407-419). LA, London, New Delhi, and Singapore: Sage Publications.
Describe PAR products as "counter-hegemonic 'weapons of mass instruction'" (p. 407), Fine and Torre write, "PAR is explicitly political" (p. 417), thus call for critical deliberation about the ethics of provocation in relation to vulnerability of participants and social justice.
Describe PAR products as "counter-hegemonic 'weapons of mass instruction'" (p. 407), Fine and Torre write, "PAR is explicitly political" (p. 417), thus call for critical deliberation about the ethics of provocation in relation to vulnerability of participants and social justice.
Action Research
Ernest T. Stringer. (1999). (2nd Ed.). Thousand Oaks, London, and New Delhi: Sage.
Chapter 1. Research in Professional and Public Life.
Similar to Kurt Lewin's model of action research, Ernest Stringer calls attention to action research as a decentralized small-scale format of research that would benefit practitioners' daily work in working with community groups. His model consists of a look-think-act routine. There are three basic assumptions in his model: a researcher's involvement, research subjects' participation in the research processes, and direct benefit to all participants. Thus, community-based research takes on action research. Built on Denzin and Lincoln's (1994) argument, Stringer defines as community-based research "enacting local, action-oriented approaches to inquiry, applying small-scale theorizing to specific problems in specific situations" (p. 10). Characterizing such research as stakeholders' participation, he specifies stages for the participation: data collection, analysis, theorizing, action, and evaluation. Here Stringer describes researchers as research facilitators with less directive power.
Chapter 5. Think: Interpreting and Analyzing.
Built on Denzin's (1997, Interpretive Ethnography) call for performance--"texts waiting to be staged" (as cited on the page 109)--Stringer contends that predominant formalist texts for presentation of research findings may not only silence the voices of people but also limit evocative responses from audiences. He calls particular attention to the movement to performance, such as drama, role play, dance, song, poem, etc., in action research so that people can express their feelings without intrusion of the formality.
Chapter 8. Formal Reports, Theses, and Dissertations (pp. 165-186)
This chapter has useful information about how to write up research findings in formal/informal ways. [GOOD]
In particular, the section of methodology is excellent. Stringer divides it into four subsections.
(1) Methodological Assumptions or a Philosophical Rationale: he suggests a more extended treatment than usual as PAR is not widely accepted yet. Identify research paradigm, detailed purposes, processes, outcomes of research. Cite sources. In principle, answer these questions, "why have we used this approach to research? Is it a valid and rigorous research process? Clarify the nature of the research process by comparing it with survey research, or more conventional styles.
(2) Research Processes: details, who was involved, what information collected, how analyzed. Include position of the researcher and participants. Data collection technique may include INTERVIEWS, OBSERVATIONS, DOCUMENTS (MEDIA, ARTIFACTS), RECORDING INFORMATION (VIDEOTAPES, PHOTOS...). The part of analysis should provide how research participants analyzed information. Stringer introduces the term BRAKETING to refer to the process of analyzing information in interpretive research to reduce it to its most significant or key, elements.
(3) Rigor: Unlike traditional criteria for evaluating rigor, such as objectivity, reliability, validity and generalizability, Stringer proposes CREDIBILITY, TRANSFERABILITY, AND DEPENDABILITY AND CONFIRMABILITY in order to establish the trustworthiness of PAR.
He asserts that credibility is established by prolonged engagement with participants, triangulation of information from multiple sources, member checking to verify the accuracy, and peer debriefing for reflection on the process.
By Transferability Stringer means applying research findings to other contexts. He argues that research methods should provide thick description so that audiences can identify similarities of the research setting with other contexts.
Dependability and confirmability are obtained through detailed description of collecting and analyzing processes and references to the raw data.
[I think that my research project can have certain credibility to begin with. I should work in transferability and the other. Should I keep the raw data? Final video should be sufficient as raw data if we publish a report in a formal way?]
Stringer also suggests having a section of limitations, not for an apology, but for an explanation about why traditional criteria such as objectivity, reliability, etc. are not appropriate.
(4) Ethical issues
guard against unwarranted intrusion into private life, maintaining privacy, establishing ownership, describe how research processed were enacted in ways sensitive to the cultural values and protocols of research participants.
Chapter 9. Understanding Action Research: The Theory Behind the Practice (187-215)
Chapter 1. Research in Professional and Public Life.
Similar to Kurt Lewin's model of action research, Ernest Stringer calls attention to action research as a decentralized small-scale format of research that would benefit practitioners' daily work in working with community groups. His model consists of a look-think-act routine. There are three basic assumptions in his model: a researcher's involvement, research subjects' participation in the research processes, and direct benefit to all participants. Thus, community-based research takes on action research. Built on Denzin and Lincoln's (1994) argument, Stringer defines as community-based research "enacting local, action-oriented approaches to inquiry, applying small-scale theorizing to specific problems in specific situations" (p. 10). Characterizing such research as stakeholders' participation, he specifies stages for the participation: data collection, analysis, theorizing, action, and evaluation. Here Stringer describes researchers as research facilitators with less directive power.
Chapter 5. Think: Interpreting and Analyzing.
Built on Denzin's (1997, Interpretive Ethnography) call for performance--"texts waiting to be staged" (as cited on the page 109)--Stringer contends that predominant formalist texts for presentation of research findings may not only silence the voices of people but also limit evocative responses from audiences. He calls particular attention to the movement to performance, such as drama, role play, dance, song, poem, etc., in action research so that people can express their feelings without intrusion of the formality.
Chapter 8. Formal Reports, Theses, and Dissertations (pp. 165-186)
This chapter has useful information about how to write up research findings in formal/informal ways. [GOOD]
In particular, the section of methodology is excellent. Stringer divides it into four subsections.
(1) Methodological Assumptions or a Philosophical Rationale: he suggests a more extended treatment than usual as PAR is not widely accepted yet. Identify research paradigm, detailed purposes, processes, outcomes of research. Cite sources. In principle, answer these questions, "why have we used this approach to research? Is it a valid and rigorous research process? Clarify the nature of the research process by comparing it with survey research, or more conventional styles.
(2) Research Processes: details, who was involved, what information collected, how analyzed. Include position of the researcher and participants. Data collection technique may include INTERVIEWS, OBSERVATIONS, DOCUMENTS (MEDIA, ARTIFACTS), RECORDING INFORMATION (VIDEOTAPES, PHOTOS...). The part of analysis should provide how research participants analyzed information. Stringer introduces the term BRAKETING to refer to the process of analyzing information in interpretive research to reduce it to its most significant or key, elements.
(3) Rigor: Unlike traditional criteria for evaluating rigor, such as objectivity, reliability, validity and generalizability, Stringer proposes CREDIBILITY, TRANSFERABILITY, AND DEPENDABILITY AND CONFIRMABILITY in order to establish the trustworthiness of PAR.
He asserts that credibility is established by prolonged engagement with participants, triangulation of information from multiple sources, member checking to verify the accuracy, and peer debriefing for reflection on the process.
By Transferability Stringer means applying research findings to other contexts. He argues that research methods should provide thick description so that audiences can identify similarities of the research setting with other contexts.
Dependability and confirmability are obtained through detailed description of collecting and analyzing processes and references to the raw data.
[I think that my research project can have certain credibility to begin with. I should work in transferability and the other. Should I keep the raw data? Final video should be sufficient as raw data if we publish a report in a formal way?]
Stringer also suggests having a section of limitations, not for an apology, but for an explanation about why traditional criteria such as objectivity, reliability, etc. are not appropriate.
(4) Ethical issues
guard against unwarranted intrusion into private life, maintaining privacy, establishing ownership, describe how research processed were enacted in ways sensitive to the cultural values and protocols of research participants.
Chapter 9. Understanding Action Research: The Theory Behind the Practice (187-215)
Friday, April 16, 2010
Critical Reflection: More Than Nuts and Bolts
Chiu, Lai Fong. (2006). Action Research, 4(2), 183-203.
"Emancipation and transformation are the twin goals of Participatory Action Research" (p. 184). Chiu writes that the notion of critical reflection has been taken for granted in PAR and lacks a genuine review on what constitutes critical reflection.
Chiu draws the contemporary concept of reflection from Shön (1983, 1996), who conceptualized conscious and unconscious practices of reflection. According to him, reflection-in-action is ‘tacit and spontaneous and often delivered without taking thought’ (Schön, 1987, p. 3) and reflection-on-action is a retrospective intellectual activity that 'requires verbalisation and symbolisation’ (p. 5). He asserted that one gains knowledge through the two kinds of reflection.
Specifically, concerning giving voices to the oppressed through narrating life experience, Chiu rightly argues that hearing the voices is intellectually unsatisfactory unless it addresses the process of generating such voices and revealing identities to unsettle exiting power relations. In particular, in pointing out a dilemma of presenting participants' experience in the researcher's own term, which makes the researcher suppress her own experience, Chiu contends that it is the very interactions between researchers and participants that may explain the process of changes that occur during the research. Hereby she calls for a researcher's self-reflexivity.
Chiu contends that reflection is underdeveloped in PAR and critical reflection, in particular, has been taken for granted. She argues that reflection in PAR is multi-perspectival--first, second and third person--as the forms of knowing are diverse--experiential, presentational, propositional and practical. Among these forms, experiential knowing is the foundation of all the other forms, she notes. Interweaving the two sets of conceptual framework, Chiu develops experiential reflection, presentational reflection, critical reflection, and practical reflection and discuss each reflection from first, second and third person perspective.
According to Chiu, reflection is crucial to different forms of knowledge creation. In particular, critical reflection enables people to generate propositional knowledge, such as analysis, conceptualization, inference, and synthesis, mediated by intellectual processes. In the first person, critical reflection is concerned with the reflexivity of the researcher, that is, "turning the researcher’s gaze back onto themselves and examining the hidden assumptions that structure their research" (p. 195; Bourdieu & Wacquant, 1992). In the second person, critical reflection deals with power relations between participants and between participants and researchers and examines ways in which the relations are structured and supported in society. In the third person, critical reflection refers to the facilitation of collective critical reflection among participants.
Practical reflection, on the other hand, is important to create transformative knowledge.
Through her quest for different forms of reflection by attending to different ways of knowing, Chiu proposes a conceptual framework of critical reflexivity: self-reflexivity, relational-reflexivity, and collective reflexivity, which all are concerted to generate propositional knowing.
In her conclusion, she argues that her approach to reflection, first-, second-, and third-person perspective is useful to improve practices of PAR as these multi-perspectival reflection is in tune with the multi-dimensional knowing that PAR practitioners assert. First-person reflection [self-reflexivity] improves PAR practices. Reflexivity from the second-person perspective [relational-reflexivity] attends to conversations and interconnectedness with others, whereas reflexivity from the third person calls for social and political analysis that contributes to social change.
"Emancipation and transformation are the twin goals of Participatory Action Research" (p. 184). Chiu writes that the notion of critical reflection has been taken for granted in PAR and lacks a genuine review on what constitutes critical reflection.
Chiu draws the contemporary concept of reflection from Shön (1983, 1996), who conceptualized conscious and unconscious practices of reflection. According to him, reflection-in-action is ‘tacit and spontaneous and often delivered without taking thought’ (Schön, 1987, p. 3) and reflection-on-action is a retrospective intellectual activity that 'requires verbalisation and symbolisation’ (p. 5). He asserted that one gains knowledge through the two kinds of reflection.
Specifically, concerning giving voices to the oppressed through narrating life experience, Chiu rightly argues that hearing the voices is intellectually unsatisfactory unless it addresses the process of generating such voices and revealing identities to unsettle exiting power relations. In particular, in pointing out a dilemma of presenting participants' experience in the researcher's own term, which makes the researcher suppress her own experience, Chiu contends that it is the very interactions between researchers and participants that may explain the process of changes that occur during the research. Hereby she calls for a researcher's self-reflexivity.
Chiu contends that reflection is underdeveloped in PAR and critical reflection, in particular, has been taken for granted. She argues that reflection in PAR is multi-perspectival--first, second and third person--as the forms of knowing are diverse--experiential, presentational, propositional and practical. Among these forms, experiential knowing is the foundation of all the other forms, she notes. Interweaving the two sets of conceptual framework, Chiu develops experiential reflection, presentational reflection, critical reflection, and practical reflection and discuss each reflection from first, second and third person perspective.
According to Chiu, reflection is crucial to different forms of knowledge creation. In particular, critical reflection enables people to generate propositional knowledge, such as analysis, conceptualization, inference, and synthesis, mediated by intellectual processes. In the first person, critical reflection is concerned with the reflexivity of the researcher, that is, "turning the researcher’s gaze back onto themselves and examining the hidden assumptions that structure their research" (p. 195; Bourdieu & Wacquant, 1992). In the second person, critical reflection deals with power relations between participants and between participants and researchers and examines ways in which the relations are structured and supported in society. In the third person, critical reflection refers to the facilitation of collective critical reflection among participants.
Practical reflection, on the other hand, is important to create transformative knowledge.
Through her quest for different forms of reflection by attending to different ways of knowing, Chiu proposes a conceptual framework of critical reflexivity: self-reflexivity, relational-reflexivity, and collective reflexivity, which all are concerted to generate propositional knowing.
In her conclusion, she argues that her approach to reflection, first-, second-, and third-person perspective is useful to improve practices of PAR as these multi-perspectival reflection is in tune with the multi-dimensional knowing that PAR practitioners assert. First-person reflection [self-reflexivity] improves PAR practices. Reflexivity from the second-person perspective [relational-reflexivity] attends to conversations and interconnectedness with others, whereas reflexivity from the third person calls for social and political analysis that contributes to social change.
Monday, April 12, 2010
‘I’m gonna show you what it’s really like out here’: the power and limitation of participatory visual methods
Packard, Josh. (2008). Visual Studies, 23 (1), 63-77.
Packard explores the boundaries of participatory visual methods based on his empirical research with the homeless. He finds the most dedicated effort of power-leveling research methods in handing over cameras to the research participants. In his argument, he contends that the ubiquity of low-cost cameras is important to participatory methods as participants are equally equipped with technology aptitude. For Packard, it is problematic that researchers have to "teach" participants how to operate a piece of equipment, for it tends to coalesce power to the researcher.
[This view is problematic primarily because of his deterministic perspective. The price of visual equipment tends to drop down, however, it does not guarantee that research participants may have equal access to the equipment.]
The research design Packard used was to giving a disposable camera to a homeless with the minimum instruction and the promise of remuneration of $5 upon their return with the camera the next day. He conducted interviews driven from the content of the photos they took. He wrote that there was little skepticism from participants when he explained his goal of this research--helping the homeless, etc.
Interpreting the styles of photos taken by the participants, Packard remarked its tendency of less affected convention and dominant photography rules. However, he rightly contends, "In order for knowledge to be truly powerful, it must be mobilized. Knowledge is power only to the extent to which it can be communicated" (p. 73).
[This sharp observation critiques overemphasis on non-dominant knowledge and practices outside of the mainstream. There may be a potential in a sense, but non-conventional practices and performances are not themselves a form of resistance.]
Packard combined in this research photo-elicitation with participant-driven data generation. However, in my opinion, this participatory visual method does not constitute participatory action research, for the data analysis is done solely by the researcher himself.
Packard explores the boundaries of participatory visual methods based on his empirical research with the homeless. He finds the most dedicated effort of power-leveling research methods in handing over cameras to the research participants. In his argument, he contends that the ubiquity of low-cost cameras is important to participatory methods as participants are equally equipped with technology aptitude. For Packard, it is problematic that researchers have to "teach" participants how to operate a piece of equipment, for it tends to coalesce power to the researcher.
[This view is problematic primarily because of his deterministic perspective. The price of visual equipment tends to drop down, however, it does not guarantee that research participants may have equal access to the equipment.]
The research design Packard used was to giving a disposable camera to a homeless with the minimum instruction and the promise of remuneration of $5 upon their return with the camera the next day. He conducted interviews driven from the content of the photos they took. He wrote that there was little skepticism from participants when he explained his goal of this research--helping the homeless, etc.
Interpreting the styles of photos taken by the participants, Packard remarked its tendency of less affected convention and dominant photography rules. However, he rightly contends, "In order for knowledge to be truly powerful, it must be mobilized. Knowledge is power only to the extent to which it can be communicated" (p. 73).
[This sharp observation critiques overemphasis on non-dominant knowledge and practices outside of the mainstream. There may be a potential in a sense, but non-conventional practices and performances are not themselves a form of resistance.]
Packard combined in this research photo-elicitation with participant-driven data generation. However, in my opinion, this participatory visual method does not constitute participatory action research, for the data analysis is done solely by the researcher himself.
Monday, December 7, 2009
Principles for Participatory Action Research
McTaggart, Robin. (1991). Adult Education Quarterly, 41(3), 168-187.
McTaggart ascribes that the modern concept of PAR is a convergence and coalescence of theoretical and practical traditions in many fields such as agriculture, social work, education, heath, community development, etc., and it is often characterized with communitarian politics.
Analyzing the cyclic nature of Lewinian action research, McTaggart asserts that group decision and commitment to improvement are central to the approach. He sharply points out, however, that Lewin’s approach did not consider the commitment of all the participants to research, which is fundamental to PAR, thus this lack of insight to participation and its power dynamics became a confusing factor in identifying the nature of PAR.
Within this context, McTaggart distinguishes participation from involvement, writing “People are often involved in research, but rarely are they participants with real ownership of research theory and practice” (p.51).
Criticizing often reoccurring imperialistic relationships of researchers with participant in PAR, McTaggart attributes them to academic command of particular specialized discourses and deference and uncertainty of participants (workers in his term) who have been forced hegemonically to accommodate what they were told to do. To counter this, he emphasizes the practice of ideology critique to maintain its reciprocity and symmetry of relations….
McTaggart ascribes that the modern concept of PAR is a convergence and coalescence of theoretical and practical traditions in many fields such as agriculture, social work, education, heath, community development, etc., and it is often characterized with communitarian politics.
Analyzing the cyclic nature of Lewinian action research, McTaggart asserts that group decision and commitment to improvement are central to the approach. He sharply points out, however, that Lewin’s approach did not consider the commitment of all the participants to research, which is fundamental to PAR, thus this lack of insight to participation and its power dynamics became a confusing factor in identifying the nature of PAR.
Within this context, McTaggart distinguishes participation from involvement, writing “People are often involved in research, but rarely are they participants with real ownership of research theory and practice” (p.51).
Criticizing often reoccurring imperialistic relationships of researchers with participant in PAR, McTaggart attributes them to academic command of particular specialized discourses and deference and uncertainty of participants (workers in his term) who have been forced hegemonically to accommodate what they were told to do. To counter this, he emphasizes the practice of ideology critique to maintain its reciprocity and symmetry of relations….
Participatory video in geographic research
: A feminist Practice of Looking? Kindon, Sara. (2003). Area, 35 (2), 142-153.
Criticizing the predominant masculinist gaze, Kindon explores possibilities of using participatory video as a means of achieving a feminist practice of looking in geographic research for more equitable outcomes and transformation for research participants.
Citing Sarah Pink's note, "the use of video as a method of qualitative research and representation has become 'revived' as a topic in discussions of qualitative methodologies" (p.586), Kindon maintains:
"[U]sing video makes the gaze explicit within a research process. It highlights the relationship between researcher/researched, observer/observed, drawing attention to who is in control of the viewing technology, what is being framed and how the images are being produced or represented. In particular, participatory video demands critical attention to the exercise of power within research relationships, it challenges us to explore reflexive ways that enable us to, 'join with another, to see together without claiming to be another' (Haraway 1991, 193)." (p.145-146)
In her criticism of the use of video for empowerment, Kindon sharply points out that, while such video enables researchers to discuss participants' self-reflexivity, it does not acknowledge reseachers' influence on the research or encourage their own reflexivity, which makes researchers effectively remain invisible in the video they make. [This is a paradox that Kindon draws from the practice of participatory video.] She continues that by rigorously participating alongside participants, the research method may destabilize conventional power relations between researcher and researched, observer and observed, and documentarians and documented.
Kindon compares cons and pros of using video for research. She writes about the potential benefit of using video, "[G]reater attention can be paid to the corporeal aspects of knowledge production by focusing on everyone's body language, use of and movements through space" (p.148). She cites other negative practices, such as confidentiality (negative impact on researcher-subject relationship) and access (the limitation of context-dependency). Kindon denotes that the same problems arose even in the participatory video project she involved with when those who were not directly involved with the research project were requested for an interview. However, she evaluates that participatory video transformed the relationships and the nature of research as shown in the discussion of the use of created video, which implies ownership, individual experience of empowerment, and a process of disruption of researchers' assumption.
Lastly she sheds light on the (time) commitment necessary to render the potential of transformation and empowerment that PV may bring to participants as well as researchers.
[Pink, S. (2001). More visualizing, more methodologies: on video, reflexivity and qualitative research. The Sociological Review, 49, 586-99.
Haraway, D. (1991). Simians, cyborgs and women: the reinvention of nature. Free Association Books, London.]
-----------
I do this through a consideration of how participatory video may offer a feminist practice of looking, which actively works to engage with and challenge conventional relationships of power associated with the gaze in geographic research, and results in more equitable outcomes and/or transformation for research participants. (p. 143)
I then discuss how a form of participatory video was employed in a bi-cultural research project with a group of Maaori people in Aotearoa New Zealand. This project was developed to explore
the relationships between place, identity and 'social cohesion' in communities in the district.
videos produced were not designed to travel outside of the iwi or be used for advocacy purposes, but were part of a process of internal capacity building and knowledge sharing. (p. 144)
Yet, using video makes the gaze explicit within a research process. It highlights the relationship between researcher/researched, observer/observed, drawing attention to who is in control of the viewing technology, what is being (p. 145) framed and how the images are being produced or represented. In particular, participatory video demands critical attention to the exercise of power within research relationships, it challenges us to explore reflexive ways that enable us to, 'join with another, to see together without claiming to be another' (Haraway 1991, 193). (p. 146)
Criticizing Ruth Holliday's video diary, Kindon argued:
They enable researchers to discuss participants' self-representations and reflexivity, but do not always acknowledge the influence of the researcher, or encourage their self-reflexivity. The researcher effectively remains invisible and reinforces conventions associated with documentary film and scientific observation. If the recordings generated are then treated as 'untainted realities', rather than as representations and/or performances produced in the context of social relationships and strategies of self representation (Pink 2001 b, 87), they may perpetuate unequal power relations and assumptions about objectivity within the research process.
Criticizing the predominant masculinist gaze, Kindon explores possibilities of using participatory video as a means of achieving a feminist practice of looking in geographic research for more equitable outcomes and transformation for research participants.
Citing Sarah Pink's note, "the use of video as a method of qualitative research and representation has become 'revived' as a topic in discussions of qualitative methodologies" (p.586), Kindon maintains:
"[U]sing video makes the gaze explicit within a research process. It highlights the relationship between researcher/researched, observer/observed, drawing attention to who is in control of the viewing technology, what is being framed and how the images are being produced or represented. In particular, participatory video demands critical attention to the exercise of power within research relationships, it challenges us to explore reflexive ways that enable us to, 'join with another, to see together without claiming to be another' (Haraway 1991, 193)." (p.145-146)
In her criticism of the use of video for empowerment, Kindon sharply points out that, while such video enables researchers to discuss participants' self-reflexivity, it does not acknowledge reseachers' influence on the research or encourage their own reflexivity, which makes researchers effectively remain invisible in the video they make. [This is a paradox that Kindon draws from the practice of participatory video.] She continues that by rigorously participating alongside participants, the research method may destabilize conventional power relations between researcher and researched, observer and observed, and documentarians and documented.
Kindon compares cons and pros of using video for research. She writes about the potential benefit of using video, "[G]reater attention can be paid to the corporeal aspects of knowledge production by focusing on everyone's body language, use of and movements through space" (p.148). She cites other negative practices, such as confidentiality (negative impact on researcher-subject relationship) and access (the limitation of context-dependency). Kindon denotes that the same problems arose even in the participatory video project she involved with when those who were not directly involved with the research project were requested for an interview. However, she evaluates that participatory video transformed the relationships and the nature of research as shown in the discussion of the use of created video, which implies ownership, individual experience of empowerment, and a process of disruption of researchers' assumption.
Lastly she sheds light on the (time) commitment necessary to render the potential of transformation and empowerment that PV may bring to participants as well as researchers.
[Pink, S. (2001). More visualizing, more methodologies: on video, reflexivity and qualitative research. The Sociological Review, 49, 586-99.
Haraway, D. (1991). Simians, cyborgs and women: the reinvention of nature. Free Association Books, London.]
-----------
I do this through a consideration of how participatory video may offer a feminist practice of looking, which actively works to engage with and challenge conventional relationships of power associated with the gaze in geographic research, and results in more equitable outcomes and/or transformation for research participants. (p. 143)
I then discuss how a form of participatory video was employed in a bi-cultural research project with a group of Maaori people in Aotearoa New Zealand. This project was developed to explore
the relationships between place, identity and 'social cohesion' in communities in the district.
videos produced were not designed to travel outside of the iwi or be used for advocacy purposes, but were part of a process of internal capacity building and knowledge sharing. (p. 144)
Yet, using video makes the gaze explicit within a research process. It highlights the relationship between researcher/researched, observer/observed, drawing attention to who is in control of the viewing technology, what is being (p. 145) framed and how the images are being produced or represented. In particular, participatory video demands critical attention to the exercise of power within research relationships, it challenges us to explore reflexive ways that enable us to, 'join with another, to see together without claiming to be another' (Haraway 1991, 193). (p. 146)
Criticizing Ruth Holliday's video diary, Kindon argued:
They enable researchers to discuss participants' self-representations and reflexivity, but do not always acknowledge the influence of the researcher, or encourage their self-reflexivity. The researcher effectively remains invisible and reinforces conventions associated with documentary film and scientific observation. If the recordings generated are then treated as 'untainted realities', rather than as representations and/or performances produced in the context of social relationships and strategies of self representation (Pink 2001 b, 87), they may perpetuate unequal power relations and assumptions about objectivity within the research process.
Friday, December 4, 2009
Doing Participatory Research: a feminist approach
Maguire, P. (1987). Doing participatory research: A feminist approach. Center for International Education, School of Education, University of Massachusetts.
Maguire describes three core activities of PR--investigation, education and action--and emphasizes that these activities are collective processes, denoting that it is collective inquiry that builds group ownership of information while carrying out research. With regard to action, Maguire stresses the fluid time frame of action, writing "While direct community action is an intended outcome of participatory research, people may also decide not to act at a particular point in time. The important point is that those involved in the production of knowledge are involved in the decision making regarding its use and application to their everyday life" (p.37). Hence, she defines PR as "a systematic approach to radical social transformation grounded in an alternative paradigm world view" (p.37).
She finds the origins of PR in three domains: international economic development in the 60s and 70s, alternative adult education and social science communities: (1) radical and reformist reconceptualizations of internatinal economic development assistance by including the poor into full participation in development decisions, processes, and benefits, (2) the reframing of adult education as an empowering alternative to traditional educational approaches: Freire, for instance, emphasized the importance of critical consciousness, conscientization, for social change, and this consciousness is developed by taking actions. Bud Hall brought PR practices to adult education on the ground that adult learners participate actively in the world while adult education regards them as passive entities. (3) an ongoing debate within the social sciences, challenging the dominant social science paradigm.
Maguire delineates the underlying assumptions of PR as follows: (1) PR begins with the premise that knowledge the single most important basis of power and control and only one particular knowledge, scientific knowledge, became validated in society, excluding other types of knoweldge, in particular, knowledge developed by the ordinary. (2) PR emphasizes the partnership between researcher and participant, insisting on their further learning through collaboration. (3) PR assumes that ordinary people, provided with tools and opportunities, are capable of critical reflection and analysis. (4) The principle of shared power is central to PR to the extent that it attempts to shift the power and control of decision making to participants. (5) PR conceives social change by returning the power of knowledge production to the ordinary.
Maguire sharply points out the androcentricity of PR: PR, breaking the positivist monopoly of knowledge creation, appears to collude with the predominant male bias of the social sciences by rendering gender indistinguishably through generic terms such as "people", "oppressed", "the community", etc.
(p.61)
[CONTINUE]
She finds the origins of PR in three domains: international economic development in the 60s and 70s, alternative adult education and social science communities: (1) radical and reformist reconceptualizations of internatinal economic development assistance by including the poor into full participation in development decisions, processes, and benefits, (2) the reframing of adult education as an empowering alternative to traditional educational approaches: Freire, for instance, emphasized the importance of critical consciousness, conscientization, for social change, and this consciousness is developed by taking actions. Bud Hall brought PR practices to adult education on the ground that adult learners participate actively in the world while adult education regards them as passive entities. (3) an ongoing debate within the social sciences, challenging the dominant social science paradigm.
Maguire delineates the underlying assumptions of PR as follows: (1) PR begins with the premise that knowledge the single most important basis of power and control and only one particular knowledge, scientific knowledge, became validated in society, excluding other types of knoweldge, in particular, knowledge developed by the ordinary. (2) PR emphasizes the partnership between researcher and participant, insisting on their further learning through collaboration. (3) PR assumes that ordinary people, provided with tools and opportunities, are capable of critical reflection and analysis. (4) The principle of shared power is central to PR to the extent that it attempts to shift the power and control of decision making to participants. (5) PR conceives social change by returning the power of knowledge production to the ordinary.
Maguire sharply points out the androcentricity of PR: PR, breaking the positivist monopoly of knowledge creation, appears to collude with the predominant male bias of the social sciences by rendering gender indistinguishably through generic terms such as "people", "oppressed", "the community", etc.
(p.61)
[CONTINUE]
Thursday, December 3, 2009
Traveling Companions
:Feminism, Teaching, and Action Research. Brydon-Miller, M., Mcguire, P., & McIntyre, A. (Eds.). (2004). Westport, CT: Praeger Publishers.
Introduction (Mcguire, Brydon-Miller, & McIntyre, pp. ix-xix)
Despite the initial enthusiasm of feminists for PAR as a counter-hegemonic approach to knowledge creation through the collaborative process of inquiry, education and action, the authors denote, the androcentrism of PAR marginalized feminist issues as manifested in 1997 Cartagena World Congress. In response to the marginalization, the authors initiated a movement that connects feminist scholarship and PAR since then, including the publication of this book.
The authors explain that PAR and feminism shares its common ground that knowledge is produced in the context of human relationships where hierarchical power is embedded, thus, both feminist researchers and PAR practitioners attend to the dynamics and mechanics of researcher/participant relationships and attempt to reconstruct them. In this regard, the authors sharply point out that feminist-informed PAR embraces the notion of multiple positionalities/identities and multiple ways of being oppressed and oppressing. Within this context, they state that third-world feminist, Women of Color, contributed to challenging a monolithic or universal feminist perspective. The authors also argue that PAR will contribute to providing a framework to translate feminist insights into tangible action for social change.
Understranding Muslim Women's Self-Identity and Resistance to Feminism and Participatory Action Research (Barazangi, Nimat Hafez, 21-39)
She criticizes mainstream Western approach that have marginalized the world-view of Muslim women "by both dismissing their views as 'religious' and taking, unknowingly. the prevailing Muslim male elites' views at their face value" (p.23). Thus she calls for a genuine dialogue between western feminists and Muslim feminists.
Testimonio: Bridging feminist and Participatory Action Research Principles to Create New Spaces of Collectivity (Brabeck, Kalina. 41-54)
Looking into Testimonio, an indigenous literary genre that emerged in Latin America in the 1960s, Brabeck associates principles of feminism and PAR that converge in the genre. First, she asserts that feminism, despite variations, addresses issues of power and gender, calls attention the ways in which patriarchal oppression shapes women's experiences and perceptions of reality, intend to create a feminist consciousness and to be self-reflexive (in her explanation, it is, e.g.
"to reflect upon, examine critically, and explore analytically both the research process and one's own self" (p.43).
Within this context Barbeck outlines the common ground between feminism and PAR as follows:
1) Both regard subjective experience as a basis of knowledge production. PAR, aiming real-life change through the collective research-participant knowledge creation, calls attention to the researcher's subjective experience, self-reflexivity, to interrogate her assumptions, biases, privileges and power positionalities.
2)Both reappropriate silenced voice and agency of the oppressed. In order to do so, PAR explicitly move people from objects to subjects in their own research process. Feminist researchers seeks feminist perspectives and representation by challenging traditional, male-oriented research biases and distortions.
3)Both seek commitment to political action: While PAR attempts to change oppressive social structure as well as the positions of both researcher and participant, feminist researchers engage in action to achieve social justice for all.
4)Both encompass a commitment to collaborative work and solidarity among peoples: Like PAR, feminist research methods focuses on inclusive, accessible and creative dialogue between participants as well as shared process of discovery, expression, interpretation. Thus, self-reflexivity, that explores the power relationships between researcher and participant, is an important aspect for both. In particular, Lyke exclusively delves into this discourse--a (powerful) us and a (powerless) them (Lykes, 1997, "Activist Participatory Research Among the Maya of Guatemala: Constructing Meanings from Situated Knowledge").
Weaving Words and Pictures in/through Feminist Participatory Action Research (McIntyre, A., & Lykes, M.B. 57-77)
Reckoning the Photovoice projects both in Northern Ireland and Guatemala, McIntyre and Lykes describe the emergence of a third voice through their collaboration with research participants. Regarding the projects as a process of re-storying their realities towards a better and more just future, they conclude that it is building the relationships with each other that contributed to the research projects, and defines their roles as facilitators to the process of insiders' description of their realities whereby previously marginalized voices have generated stories within and beyond their communities.
Reflecting on her own experience in the research project, McIntyre writes recurring discussions about guidance as her own involvement in the research. In this regard, she writes,
"More often than not, we responded to the challenges with sarcasm, friendly banter, and/or by simply ignoring the problem...These behaviors can be distancing at times. Yet they are behaviors that we forged in our relationships as women, friends. and researchers." (p.66)
Lykes defines a third voice as "a dialectic wherein indigenous knowledge and academic research strategies inform knowledge construction within relationships across differences" (66-67). Particularly interesting in her account about the research is the development of a story through multiple reiteration. The example she brings up is a photo of a village girl, who collected wood to sell in the hope of getting a chocobanana. The original photographer incorporated narrations of her group's analysis into her original story when she presented in a conference in the U.S., and the story was transformed again in the final book. Tracing this process, Lykes describes,
"Personal desire and singularity have been deconstructed and resituated in a discourse of childhood characterized by poverty, human pain, and children's rights. The voice represented in the final phototext was coconstructed through negotiated relationality both in Chajul and on tour in the United States--relationships that shifted throughout the nearly three years of this project." (p.73)
Introduction (Mcguire, Brydon-Miller, & McIntyre, pp. ix-xix)
Despite the initial enthusiasm of feminists for PAR as a counter-hegemonic approach to knowledge creation through the collaborative process of inquiry, education and action, the authors denote, the androcentrism of PAR marginalized feminist issues as manifested in 1997 Cartagena World Congress. In response to the marginalization, the authors initiated a movement that connects feminist scholarship and PAR since then, including the publication of this book.
The authors explain that PAR and feminism shares its common ground that knowledge is produced in the context of human relationships where hierarchical power is embedded, thus, both feminist researchers and PAR practitioners attend to the dynamics and mechanics of researcher/participant relationships and attempt to reconstruct them. In this regard, the authors sharply point out that feminist-informed PAR embraces the notion of multiple positionalities/identities and multiple ways of being oppressed and oppressing. Within this context, they state that third-world feminist, Women of Color, contributed to challenging a monolithic or universal feminist perspective. The authors also argue that PAR will contribute to providing a framework to translate feminist insights into tangible action for social change.
Understranding Muslim Women's Self-Identity and Resistance to Feminism and Participatory Action Research (Barazangi, Nimat Hafez, 21-39)
She criticizes mainstream Western approach that have marginalized the world-view of Muslim women "by both dismissing their views as 'religious' and taking, unknowingly. the prevailing Muslim male elites' views at their face value" (p.23). Thus she calls for a genuine dialogue between western feminists and Muslim feminists.
Testimonio: Bridging feminist and Participatory Action Research Principles to Create New Spaces of Collectivity (Brabeck, Kalina. 41-54)
Looking into Testimonio, an indigenous literary genre that emerged in Latin America in the 1960s, Brabeck associates principles of feminism and PAR that converge in the genre. First, she asserts that feminism, despite variations, addresses issues of power and gender, calls attention the ways in which patriarchal oppression shapes women's experiences and perceptions of reality, intend to create a feminist consciousness and to be self-reflexive (in her explanation, it is, e.g.
"to reflect upon, examine critically, and explore analytically both the research process and one's own self" (p.43).
Within this context Barbeck outlines the common ground between feminism and PAR as follows:
1) Both regard subjective experience as a basis of knowledge production. PAR, aiming real-life change through the collective research-participant knowledge creation, calls attention to the researcher's subjective experience, self-reflexivity, to interrogate her assumptions, biases, privileges and power positionalities.
2)Both reappropriate silenced voice and agency of the oppressed. In order to do so, PAR explicitly move people from objects to subjects in their own research process. Feminist researchers seeks feminist perspectives and representation by challenging traditional, male-oriented research biases and distortions.
3)Both seek commitment to political action: While PAR attempts to change oppressive social structure as well as the positions of both researcher and participant, feminist researchers engage in action to achieve social justice for all.
4)Both encompass a commitment to collaborative work and solidarity among peoples: Like PAR, feminist research methods focuses on inclusive, accessible and creative dialogue between participants as well as shared process of discovery, expression, interpretation. Thus, self-reflexivity, that explores the power relationships between researcher and participant, is an important aspect for both. In particular, Lyke exclusively delves into this discourse--a (powerful) us and a (powerless) them (Lykes, 1997, "Activist Participatory Research Among the Maya of Guatemala: Constructing Meanings from Situated Knowledge").
Weaving Words and Pictures in/through Feminist Participatory Action Research (McIntyre, A., & Lykes, M.B. 57-77)
Reckoning the Photovoice projects both in Northern Ireland and Guatemala, McIntyre and Lykes describe the emergence of a third voice through their collaboration with research participants. Regarding the projects as a process of re-storying their realities towards a better and more just future, they conclude that it is building the relationships with each other that contributed to the research projects, and defines their roles as facilitators to the process of insiders' description of their realities whereby previously marginalized voices have generated stories within and beyond their communities.
Reflecting on her own experience in the research project, McIntyre writes recurring discussions about guidance as her own involvement in the research. In this regard, she writes,
"More often than not, we responded to the challenges with sarcasm, friendly banter, and/or by simply ignoring the problem...These behaviors can be distancing at times. Yet they are behaviors that we forged in our relationships as women, friends. and researchers." (p.66)
Lykes defines a third voice as "a dialectic wherein indigenous knowledge and academic research strategies inform knowledge construction within relationships across differences" (66-67). Particularly interesting in her account about the research is the development of a story through multiple reiteration. The example she brings up is a photo of a village girl, who collected wood to sell in the hope of getting a chocobanana. The original photographer incorporated narrations of her group's analysis into her original story when she presented in a conference in the U.S., and the story was transformed again in the final book. Tracing this process, Lykes describes,
"Personal desire and singularity have been deconstructed and resituated in a discourse of childhood characterized by poverty, human pain, and children's rights. The voice represented in the final phototext was coconstructed through negotiated relationality both in Chajul and on tour in the United States--relationships that shifted throughout the nearly three years of this project." (p.73)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)