Nico Carpentier (2009) European Journal of Communication 2009 24: 407-420, doi: 10.1177/0267323109345682
Participation became (at least partially) an object of celebration, trapped in a reductionist discourse of novelty, detached from the reception of its audiences and decontextualized from its political-ideological, communicativecultural and communicative-structural contexts. (p. 408)
[P]articipatory practices are not unconditionally appreciated by audience members, but are subject to specific conditions of possibility that are still embedded within the mass communication paradigm. Albeit in different degrees, these case studies show the importance of two ‘old’ key concepts – professional quality and social relevance – for these audiences’ evaluation of participatory practices. (p. 408)
The authors sharply criticized the contentions brought by the advent of new media and the participatory media theory: (1) privileging new media over old media in terms of the potential for participation and (2) interactivity is considered participation. Their argument is supported by Colin Sparks (2007, Globalization, Development and the Mass Media. London: Sage): In his analysis of participatory development theory, he wrote, "the dominant paradigm passed in theory, but retained a very extensive appeal in practice; the participatory paradigm, on the other hand, triumphed in development theory, but has failed to command any substantial
support in practice" (p. 59)
The authors also argued that participatory media theory emphasizes active use of media, leaving out those who are not involved in the participatory process. They also pointed out the underlying assumption that participation is beneficial and all involved would appreciate it decontextualizes the participatory practices, obscuring such important topics as democracy, empowerment, and so forth.
The authors show their research result of viewers' responses to participatory media products aired on Belgium. In their summary, the viewers seemed to understand the theoretical perspectives of participatory media theory in that ordinary people create their own media, but they criticized either poor quality or social relevance of such products. [The content is very much personal video letter style]. The authors wrote:
"The participatory nature of the production process (and its outcomes) may be theoretically applauded in the focus groups, but the actual materializations are met with fierce critiques or with indifference." (p. 418)
Thus, after long writing, the authors concluded that participation is not enough, stating:
"Both case studies show that the respondents perceive a strong need for media to use (aesthetic, narrative and technical) languages that are exceptional, and to narrate stories which are socially relevant. Just showing everyday life, or just organizing participation, is simply not enough. The images they want to see, still have to be magical as well." (p. 418)
[Participation as a form does not convey social relevance. It can be only self-indulgence. Therefore, sought connection to democracy and social power is important. Hereby participatory video should be distinct from traditional people's access to media.]
Tuesday, January 11, 2011
Monday, January 10, 2011
Participatory Theatre and Video: Acting Against Violence in Northern Nigeria
Oga Steve Abah, Jenkeri Zakari Okwori and Ogoh Alubo. (2009). Institute of Development Studies [IDS] Bulletin, 40(3), 19-26.
The authors discussed the use of theatre for development [TFD] and participatory video [PV] in the research on violence in northern Nigeria. First, they carried out a survey throughout several communities, then developed a drama performed in each community and followed by a debate. PV was used throughout. The research finding is interesting: they argued that people do not see contemporary violence as a result of religion; rather, people perceive it as the organizing platform.
Interesting to note the reasons for choosing TFD and PV for this participatory action research (p. 21):
1. high level of illiteracy
2. "Wonderment about video makes people eager to speak to the camera" (p. 21)
3. can "afford participant ownership of the research tools and process.
4. "participatory process. . . is a spur to reflection and self-critical analysis".
5. alternative ways of looking at violence and manipulating the end of violence.-->seed for change.
The way they used PV techniques was to record the process from the community survey through drama-making to the discussions after the performances. It also recorded message from people on opposite sides of the religious and ethnic divides. It was done by trained community researchers.
The authors defined the roles of theatre and PV played:
"Theatre thus played multiple roles of information-gathering, feedback, analysis and triangulation or validation of facts, while PV played a role in building up a broadly accepted and pluralistically-constructed version of events, and in data-recording on both content and process" (p. 22).
Reflecting on the methods, the authors wrote:
"In broad terms, the TFD and PV, the quantitative research and qualitative interviews complemented each other very nicely throughout. The quantitative component provided useful information on the areas most affected by the violent incidents in Kaduna, Plateau and Kano States" (p. 23).
[Seamless use of quantitative, qualitative, arts-based methods for community-based research]
Arguing the suitability of TFD and PV for participatory research, the authors wrote about its connection with oral culture, reinforced reflection, and catharsis:
"The appeal and relevance of such reinterpretation and reflexivity are underscored by the fact that the work we do is mostly situated in oral cultures where the ability to read and write are limited or non-existent. Instead of being constrained by specific questions, people were enabled to connect with the incidents of violence in a reflective manner, through testimony or narration of their experiences during the drama and during the PV discussion. This outpouring appeared to allow them purgation and relief" (p. 24)
They also pointed out the importance of non-verbal expression that constitutes real life reflected in the methods of TFD and PV:
"In real life, most meanings are constructed not just by words, but by signs and body language. Eliciting these through TFD and then capturing them for posterity using PV generates a permanent and rich source of complex data including body language, facial expressions, postures, movements, bodily adornment and material culture" (p. 24)
As an advantage of PV over TFD, the authors argued for its transferability:
"While TFD can only be experienced at the place and the moment when it is happening, the videos enabled community members to see what happened in other communities, hear the views
of others and see the multiple ways these were articulated, including their emotions and bodily
expressions. No dramatic action can be repeated exactly twice, but PV can record the action and
repeat it several times over, which allows for deeper reflection" (pp. 24-25)
The authors asserted that this research contributed to consciousness raising achievement by telling some emblematic stories of individual participants. They attributed two factors --the participatory method and the experiential lives of the community --to the outcome. They argued that these two factors created ownership, participants' ownership not only of the research process but also of the discussions, arguments, etc. [Ownership is discussed in the context of the content]
The authors discussed the use of theatre for development [TFD] and participatory video [PV] in the research on violence in northern Nigeria. First, they carried out a survey throughout several communities, then developed a drama performed in each community and followed by a debate. PV was used throughout. The research finding is interesting: they argued that people do not see contemporary violence as a result of religion; rather, people perceive it as the organizing platform.
Interesting to note the reasons for choosing TFD and PV for this participatory action research (p. 21):
1. high level of illiteracy
2. "Wonderment about video makes people eager to speak to the camera" (p. 21)
3. can "afford participant ownership of the research tools and process.
4. "participatory process. . . is a spur to reflection and self-critical analysis".
5. alternative ways of looking at violence and manipulating the end of violence.-->seed for change.
The way they used PV techniques was to record the process from the community survey through drama-making to the discussions after the performances. It also recorded message from people on opposite sides of the religious and ethnic divides. It was done by trained community researchers.
The authors defined the roles of theatre and PV played:
"Theatre thus played multiple roles of information-gathering, feedback, analysis and triangulation or validation of facts, while PV played a role in building up a broadly accepted and pluralistically-constructed version of events, and in data-recording on both content and process" (p. 22).
Reflecting on the methods, the authors wrote:
"In broad terms, the TFD and PV, the quantitative research and qualitative interviews complemented each other very nicely throughout. The quantitative component provided useful information on the areas most affected by the violent incidents in Kaduna, Plateau and Kano States" (p. 23).
[Seamless use of quantitative, qualitative, arts-based methods for community-based research]
Arguing the suitability of TFD and PV for participatory research, the authors wrote about its connection with oral culture, reinforced reflection, and catharsis:
"The appeal and relevance of such reinterpretation and reflexivity are underscored by the fact that the work we do is mostly situated in oral cultures where the ability to read and write are limited or non-existent. Instead of being constrained by specific questions, people were enabled to connect with the incidents of violence in a reflective manner, through testimony or narration of their experiences during the drama and during the PV discussion. This outpouring appeared to allow them purgation and relief" (p. 24)
They also pointed out the importance of non-verbal expression that constitutes real life reflected in the methods of TFD and PV:
"In real life, most meanings are constructed not just by words, but by signs and body language. Eliciting these through TFD and then capturing them for posterity using PV generates a permanent and rich source of complex data including body language, facial expressions, postures, movements, bodily adornment and material culture" (p. 24)
As an advantage of PV over TFD, the authors argued for its transferability:
"While TFD can only be experienced at the place and the moment when it is happening, the videos enabled community members to see what happened in other communities, hear the views
of others and see the multiple ways these were articulated, including their emotions and bodily
expressions. No dramatic action can be repeated exactly twice, but PV can record the action and
repeat it several times over, which allows for deeper reflection" (pp. 24-25)
The authors asserted that this research contributed to consciousness raising achievement by telling some emblematic stories of individual participants. They attributed two factors --the participatory method and the experiential lives of the community --to the outcome. They argued that these two factors created ownership, participants' ownership not only of the research process but also of the discussions, arguments, etc. [Ownership is discussed in the context of the content]
Diary of a participatory advocacy film project: transforming communication initiatives into living campaigns
Flower, Emilie, & McConville, Brigid. (2009). Development in Practice, 19 7), 933 — 937. doi: 10.1080/09614520903122428
Flower discussed her involvement in a PV project with the White Ribbon Alliance for Safer Motherhood in Tanzania in 2006. Many, including trained health workers and skilled film producers, were involved in this project. Yet, the author noted, "The PV methodology had been incorporated into the process because it reflected the WRA ethos of respect for and participation of all members. . . . In our work in Tanzania, however, the PV method was being brought in at a later stage; the WRA had already decided what was needed, so the film would be used to demonstrate that these were ‘real’ messages and to raise the profile of an existing advocacy campaign. The challenge was to use the PV method as an opportunity for communities to express their views and needs, without imposing a set of agendas" (p. 934-935).
[ This is a special case: PV was instrumental to proving the WRA's agenda]
The authors noted the successful delivery of the final product, showing it through a conference and TV, showing to the Minister of Health, interviewing him again. Yet they emphasized the participatory aspect began later:
"The project had successfully delivered the product, and the team returned to their posts with equipment and assignments. It would have been easy to leave the project there, but the participatory aspect of the video project really began to flourish almost from the moment we left the country. . ." (p. 936)
The local coordinator continued to produce films from participatory perspectives, bringing local voices and responses.
Flower discussed her involvement in a PV project with the White Ribbon Alliance for Safer Motherhood in Tanzania in 2006. Many, including trained health workers and skilled film producers, were involved in this project. Yet, the author noted, "The PV methodology had been incorporated into the process because it reflected the WRA ethos of respect for and participation of all members. . . . In our work in Tanzania, however, the PV method was being brought in at a later stage; the WRA had already decided what was needed, so the film would be used to demonstrate that these were ‘real’ messages and to raise the profile of an existing advocacy campaign. The challenge was to use the PV method as an opportunity for communities to express their views and needs, without imposing a set of agendas" (p. 934-935).
[ This is a special case: PV was instrumental to proving the WRA's agenda]
The authors noted the successful delivery of the final product, showing it through a conference and TV, showing to the Minister of Health, interviewing him again. Yet they emphasized the participatory aspect began later:
"The project had successfully delivered the product, and the team returned to their posts with equipment and assignments. It would have been easy to leave the project there, but the participatory aspect of the video project really began to flourish almost from the moment we left the country. . ." (p. 936)
The local coordinator continued to produce films from participatory perspectives, bringing local voices and responses.
Video for recording and training in participatory development
Frost, Nicola, & Jones, Carolyn. (1998). Development in Practice: Stimulating thought for action, 8(1), 90-94. doi: 10.1080/09614529854043
Frost used video recording as ways of keeping fieldnotes and reports for donors for a multi-disciplinary research of the effects of tourism in eastern Indonesia; Jones used video recording for field and classroom training, and participatory rural appraisal (PRA) community-level workshops. Based upon their experiences, the authors discussed the use of video in participatory development.
1. Creating a record of fieldwork for research--> on-site playback stimulates instant comments on the process [Transparency of research process]
2. Recording participants' discussion on local issues-->useful for supporting funding proposal
3. Used as a training resources instead of paper hand-outs.
Pro's and con's of using video
Pro's: quick and accurate establishment of contexts. flexibility to move around. presentation of a kinetic process. preserving the spatial dynamics of a PRA meeting. can be less intrusive than still cameras with flash.
The authors note the transferability of the advantages of using video for discussion: whereas some may distrust video, preferring to speak anonymity, others become more focused on discussion. Thus, they argue, "Clearly, the appropriateness of video will vary according to context, the individuals involved, and the subject matter being discussed" (p. 92).
The authors discuss the inevitable possibility of trade-off between quality and other purposes such as local involvement, daily feedback, etc.
Discussing editing, the authors argue the potential loss of transparency of video in particular if the editor lacks the original context, yet they play an important role in shaping the final product.
The authors argue that the potential for video relies on its overall objective: who it is intended for and for what purpose.
Frost used video recording as ways of keeping fieldnotes and reports for donors for a multi-disciplinary research of the effects of tourism in eastern Indonesia; Jones used video recording for field and classroom training, and participatory rural appraisal (PRA) community-level workshops. Based upon their experiences, the authors discussed the use of video in participatory development.
1. Creating a record of fieldwork for research--> on-site playback stimulates instant comments on the process [Transparency of research process]
2. Recording participants' discussion on local issues-->useful for supporting funding proposal
3. Used as a training resources instead of paper hand-outs.
Pro's and con's of using video
Pro's: quick and accurate establishment of contexts. flexibility to move around. presentation of a kinetic process. preserving the spatial dynamics of a PRA meeting. can be less intrusive than still cameras with flash.
The authors note the transferability of the advantages of using video for discussion: whereas some may distrust video, preferring to speak anonymity, others become more focused on discussion. Thus, they argue, "Clearly, the appropriateness of video will vary according to context, the individuals involved, and the subject matter being discussed" (p. 92).
The authors discuss the inevitable possibility of trade-off between quality and other purposes such as local involvement, daily feedback, etc.
Discussing editing, the authors argue the potential loss of transparency of video in particular if the editor lacks the original context, yet they play an important role in shaping the final product.
The authors argue that the potential for video relies on its overall objective: who it is intended for and for what purpose.
Thursday, December 16, 2010
Criteria for assessing interpretive validity in qualitative research
Altheide, D. L.,&Johnson, J. M. (1994). . In N. K. Denzin&Y. S. Lincoln (Eds.), Handbook of qualitative research (pp. 485-499). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Validity in Qualitative Research
Robin Whittemore, Susan K. Chase and Carol Lynn Mandle (2001). Qualitative Health Research. 11 (4), 522-537.
Abstract:
Much contemporary dialogue has centered on the difficulty of establishing validity criteria in qualitative research. Developing validity standards in qualitative research is challenging because of the necessity to incorporate rigor and subjectivity as well as creativity into the scientific process. This article explores the extant issues related to the science and art of qualitative research and proposes a synthesis of contemporary viewpoints. A distinction between primary and secondary validity criteria in qualitative research is made with credibility, authenticity, criticality, and integrity identified as primary validity criteria and explicitness, vividness, creativity, thoroughness, congruence, and sensitivity identified as secondary validity criteria.
Reading the historical development of validity issues, the authors discussed three types of tensions.
1. Tension Between Qualitative and Quantitative Research
"Despite the incongruency between quantitative epistemology and qualitative methodology, translated standards of validity have proven to be useful criteria for demonstrating rigor and legitimacy of qualitative research. Guba and Lincoln (1989) advanced this work by proposing standards that were more reflective of specific threats to qualitative research." (pp. 523-524)
2. Tension Between Epistemological Purism and Pluralism
3. Tension Between Rigor and Creativity
"Creativity must be preserved within qualitative research, but not at the expense of the quality of the science. Creative work supports the discovery of the not yet known, going beyond previously established knowledge and challenging accepted thinking (Marshall, 1990). However, it is essential that qualitative work should be highly creative at the same time that it is analytically rigorous and explicit (Patton //--page break--// 1990). Creativity in and of itself will not contribute to sound science. Elegant and innovative thinking can be balanced with reasonable claims, presentation of evidence, and the critical application of methods." (pp. 526-527)
The authors pointed out there is no championing terms to articulate validity criteria in qual. Yet, they call Lincoln and Guba (1985, Naturalistic Inquiry: "credibility" for validity ) "the staying power." Yet, they argued, "validity is an accurate term and does provide the opportunity for criteria to be developed that are reflective of the tenets of the interpretive perspective" (pp. 527).
The authors wrote:
"Validity cannot be assumed, and presentation of research findings must invite the opportunity for critical reflection by consumers. The importance of explicating “how we claim to know what we know” (Altheide & Johnson, 1994, p. 496) is as essential as the claim to what we know." (p 535)
[It implies validity is self-reflection on the research process: authentic, rigor, moral]
Abstract:
Much contemporary dialogue has centered on the difficulty of establishing validity criteria in qualitative research. Developing validity standards in qualitative research is challenging because of the necessity to incorporate rigor and subjectivity as well as creativity into the scientific process. This article explores the extant issues related to the science and art of qualitative research and proposes a synthesis of contemporary viewpoints. A distinction between primary and secondary validity criteria in qualitative research is made with credibility, authenticity, criticality, and integrity identified as primary validity criteria and explicitness, vividness, creativity, thoroughness, congruence, and sensitivity identified as secondary validity criteria.
Reading the historical development of validity issues, the authors discussed three types of tensions.
1. Tension Between Qualitative and Quantitative Research
"Despite the incongruency between quantitative epistemology and qualitative methodology, translated standards of validity have proven to be useful criteria for demonstrating rigor and legitimacy of qualitative research. Guba and Lincoln (1989) advanced this work by proposing standards that were more reflective of specific threats to qualitative research." (pp. 523-524)
2. Tension Between Epistemological Purism and Pluralism
3. Tension Between Rigor and Creativity
"Creativity must be preserved within qualitative research, but not at the expense of the quality of the science. Creative work supports the discovery of the not yet known, going beyond previously established knowledge and challenging accepted thinking (Marshall, 1990). However, it is essential that qualitative work should be highly creative at the same time that it is analytically rigorous and explicit (Patton //--page break--// 1990). Creativity in and of itself will not contribute to sound science. Elegant and innovative thinking can be balanced with reasonable claims, presentation of evidence, and the critical application of methods." (pp. 526-527)
The authors pointed out there is no championing terms to articulate validity criteria in qual. Yet, they call Lincoln and Guba (1985, Naturalistic Inquiry: "credibility" for validity ) "the staying power." Yet, they argued, "validity is an accurate term and does provide the opportunity for criteria to be developed that are reflective of the tenets of the interpretive perspective" (pp. 527).
The authors wrote:
"Validity cannot be assumed, and presentation of research findings must invite the opportunity for critical reflection by consumers. The importance of explicating “how we claim to know what we know” (Altheide & Johnson, 1994, p. 496) is as essential as the claim to what we know." (p 535)
[It implies validity is self-reflection on the research process: authentic, rigor, moral]
Monday, December 13, 2010
Institutional review boards and methodological conservatism
: The challenge to and from phenomenological paradigms. Yvonna S. Lincoln (2008). In N. Denzin & Y. Lincoln (Eds.), The landscape of qualitative research (pp. 221-244). Thousand Oaks, London, New Dehli and Singapore: Sage.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)