Walzer, Michael. 99-104
From Talyor's argument, Walzer derives two kinds of liberalism: (1) Liberalism 1 is committed to absolute individual rights and guaranteed by a state's neutrality and (2) Liberalism 2 allows state intervention to preserve a particular culture or nation within the boundaries where the basic rights of citizens are protected. Walzer delineates the first kind of liberalism as the official doctrine of immigrant societies like the United States (and federal Canada), as Rawls formulated as social unions. Under this rule, the plural unions are free to do what they need to do but without help from the state.
In reality, however, there is inequality among nationalities, social unions or cultural communities and some are more at risk than others; and the state is called upon to take responsibility for everyone's cultural survival. From this perspective, Walzer carefully proposes "Liberalism 1 chosen from within Liberalism 2" to respond to multiculturalism, that is liberalism governed by "the social condition and the actual life choices of these[sic] men and women" (p. 103). Not rejecting the idea of Liberalism 2, Walzer holds tight to the concept of Liberalism 1 in particular with respect to immigrants who made an individual choice and were prepared to take cultural risks. Thus their lives are significantly shaped by the liberal idea of individual rights. Walzer argues that this choice and their rights should not be curtailed. In addition, he contests that Liberalism 1 does not exclude support for studying otherness.
Showing posts with label communitarian. Show all posts
Showing posts with label communitarian. Show all posts
Saturday, January 16, 2010
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)