Friday, April 16, 2010

Critical Reflection: More Than Nuts and Bolts

Chiu, Lai Fong. (2006). Action Research, 4(2), 183-203.

"Emancipation and transformation are the twin goals of Participatory Action Research" (p. 184). Chiu writes that the notion of critical reflection has been taken for granted in PAR and lacks a genuine review on what constitutes critical reflection.

Chiu draws the contemporary concept of reflection from Shön (1983, 1996), who conceptualized conscious and unconscious practices of reflection. According to him, reflection-in-action is ‘tacit and spontaneous and often delivered without taking thought’ (Schön, 1987, p. 3) and reflection-on-action is a retrospective intellectual activity that 'requires verbalisation and symbolisation’ (p. 5). He asserted that one gains knowledge through the two kinds of reflection.

Specifically, concerning giving voices to the oppressed through narrating life experience, Chiu rightly argues that hearing the voices is intellectually unsatisfactory unless it addresses the process of generating such voices and revealing identities to unsettle exiting power relations. In particular, in pointing out a dilemma of presenting participants' experience in the researcher's own term, which makes the researcher suppress her own experience, Chiu contends that it is the very interactions between researchers and participants that may explain the process of changes that occur during the research. Hereby she calls for a researcher's self-reflexivity.

Chiu contends that reflection is underdeveloped in PAR and critical reflection, in particular, has been taken for granted. She argues that reflection in PAR is multi-perspectival--first, second and third person--as the forms of knowing are diverse--experiential, presentational, propositional and practical. Among these forms, experiential knowing is the foundation of all the other forms, she notes. Interweaving the two sets of conceptual framework, Chiu develops experiential reflection, presentational reflection, critical reflection, and practical reflection and discuss each reflection from first, second and third person perspective.

According to Chiu, reflection is crucial to different forms of knowledge creation. In particular, critical reflection enables people to generate propositional knowledge, such as analysis, conceptualization, inference, and synthesis, mediated by intellectual processes. In the first person, critical reflection is concerned with the reflexivity of the researcher, that is, "turning the researcher’s gaze back onto themselves and examining the hidden assumptions that structure their research" (p. 195; Bourdieu & Wacquant, 1992). In the second person, critical reflection deals with power relations between participants and between participants and researchers and examines ways in which the relations are structured and supported in society. In the third person, critical reflection refers to the facilitation of collective critical reflection among participants.

Practical reflection, on the other hand, is important to create transformative knowledge.

Through her quest for different forms of reflection by attending to different ways of knowing, Chiu proposes a conceptual framework of critical reflexivity: self-reflexivity, relational-reflexivity, and collective reflexivity, which all are concerted to generate propositional knowing.

In her conclusion, she argues that her approach to reflection, first-, second-, and third-person perspective is useful to improve practices of PAR as these multi-perspectival reflection is in tune with the multi-dimensional knowing that PAR practitioners assert. First-person reflection [self-reflexivity] improves PAR practices. Reflexivity from the second-person perspective [relational-reflexivity] attends to conversations and interconnectedness with others, whereas reflexivity from the third person calls for social and political analysis that contributes to social change.

Thursday, April 15, 2010

Research and Indigenous participation: critical reflexive methods

Nicholls, Ruth. (2009). International Journal of Social Research Methodology, 12(2), 117–126.

Building upon Chiu's (2006) model of reflexivity, Nicholls further discusses three layers of reflexivity: self-reflexivity, inter-personal reflexivity, and collective reflexivity. In this discussion, she emphasizes recognition of difference within a collective.

Self-reflexivity (1st person) indicates a researcher's awareness of hidden assumptions that underpin the research; inter-personal reflexivity (2nd person) is referred to as relational-reflexivity, which has to do with researchers' ability of collaboration with others; collective reflexivity "demands the question of asking about the process of how the collaboration determined the frames of inquiry. It also asks what were the terms of participation, who participated or did not…[sic] and what effects did this have on the outcome of social change and practical knowing for the community participants." (p. 123).

Lived Experience, Reflexivity, and Research on Perpetrators of Interpersonal Violence

Gilgun, Jane. (2008). Qualitative Social Work, 7 (2), 181-197.

Emphasizing that researchers are part of research similar to the researched, Gilgun delineates her position of reflexivity:

My working definition of reflexivity involves the idea of awareness – that researchers are reflexive when they examine and take into account the multiple influences they have on research processes and how research processes affect them and the persons and situations they research (Gilgun, 2006). Examples of reflexive processes include informants and researchers’ experience of research
processes, relationships between researchers and informants, and changes informants and researchers undergo in the course of participating in research. (p. 184).

Wednesday, April 14, 2010

Interdisciplinary agendas in visual research: re-situating visual anthropology

Pink, Sarah. (2003). Visual Studies, 18 (2), 179-192.

In her review of recent literature around visual research methods, which owe much to visual anthropology, Pink notes as common interests among visual researcher reflexivity, collaboration, ethics, and the relationship between the content, social context and materiality of images.
(p. 9)

Looking through the history of visual anthropology and contemporary visual culture studies, Pink concludes that across disciplines, critical approaches to the interpretation of images has departed from positivist truth-seeking.

Pink refers to reflexivity as a key concern among visual researchers, yet calls for clarification of distinct claims to and uses of reflexivity. Calling reflexivity "a kind of autobiography" (p. 130), Rose (2001, Visual Methodologies) writes certain discourses refuse to be reflexive. Foucauldian discourse analysis is one of them, for it analyzes power subconsciously embedded in texts. Pink agrees with Rose to the extent that these methodologies cannot be critical visual ones because they lack reflexivity.

For Pink, reflexivity in ethnography means a researcher's awareness of "how they look and understand when doing ethnography as well as when they look at images" (p. 188).

Pink further traces approaches to reflexivity in research: Whereas visual anthropologists such as Ruby regards reflexivity as an ethical issue, Emmison and Smith (2000, Researching the Visual) interpret reflexivity as a question of validity. For MacDougall, another visual anthropologist, a 'deep' reflexivity requires revealing "the position of the author in the very construction of the work" (1998:89, Transcultural Cinema; cited on the page 188). Critiquing Holliday (2000), who refered to reflexivity as "a mere buzz word" (p. 505), Pink writes Holliday's argument lack historical understanding of issues and debates around visual anthropology in the past couple of decades.

In sum up, Pink writes:

"Across the different approaches, reflexivity has commonly been coined as a need for understanding ‘‘where the researcher is coming from’’ and how this impacts on the knowledge
produced. Some leave this at a question of validity and research quality control. However, most visual anthropologists take a quite different tack. They argue that reflexivity should be integrated fully into processes of fieldwork and visual or written representation in ways that do not simply explain the researcher’s approach but reveal the very processes by which the positionality of researcher and informant were constituted and through which knowledge was produced during the fieldwork" (p. 189)

Monday, April 12, 2010

We've been framed: visualising methodology

Holliday, Ruth. (2000). The Sociological Review, 48 (4), 503-521.

Holliday asserts that reflexivity, alongside with multivocality, has arisen as an outcome of the post-colonial critique of the ethnocentrism of anthropology. She contends that multivocality, however, loses some of its criticality. She quotes Trinh (Visualizing theory : selected essays from V.A.R., 1990-1994, Author:Lucien Castaing-Taylor (Ed.). Trinh's interview with Nancy Chang.(1994). p.440):

"Multivocality...is not necessarily a solution to the problems of centralized and hierarchical knowledge when it is practised accumulatively--by juxtaposing voices that continue to speak within identified boundaries. Like the much abused concept of multiculturalism, multivocality here could also lead to the bland 'melting-pot' type of attitude, in which 'multi' means 'no'--no voice--or is used only to better mask the Voice--that very place from where meaning is put together.

As to reflexivity, Holliday argues, "Reflexivity is the latest in a long line of ... techniques aimed at ensuring the production of greater degrees of 'truth'," thus it can be viewed as a pseudo-positivist approach concerning greater truth.
Holliday stresses video as a confessional medium quoting from Michael Renov (1996, “Video Confessions” in Resolutions: Contemporary video Practices, Univ. of Minnesota Press):
In the case of video confessions, the virtual presences of a partner—the imagined other effectuated by the technology—turns out to be a more powerful facilitator of emotion than flesh-and-blood interlocutors. Camera operators, sound booms, cables, and clapperboards are hardly a boon to soul confession. (pp. 88-89; as cited on page 511)

Holliday’s argument about the power of video diaries in exploring one’s subjectivity is tied with this insight into video as a confessional medium. She wrote:

In terms of the video diaries, then, the power to present one’s subjectivity may override the risk of having that speech appropriated by others (for example, academics). Thus, the fullest confession opens up the greatest space to talk and affords the greatest power at that moment. (p. 512)

[In a participatory video, an interviewing situation may be similar to this confessional setting, for interviewers are much closer to interviewees compared with academics. Thus interviewees’ subjectivity can be more freely expressed and thus the medium of video can be more reflexive in bring out the lived/embodied experience of the interviewees.]

Holliday proposes video diaries as a “Queer Methodology” that “disrespects and disrupts disciplinary boundaries and discriplines”(p. 516) and an unconventional format of academic text.

‘I’m gonna show you what it’s really like out here’: the power and limitation of participatory visual methods

Packard, Josh. (2008). Visual Studies, 23 (1), 63-77.

Packard explores the boundaries of participatory visual methods based on his empirical research with the homeless. He finds the most dedicated effort of power-leveling research methods in handing over cameras to the research participants. In his argument, he contends that the ubiquity of low-cost cameras is important to participatory methods as participants are equally equipped with technology aptitude. For Packard, it is problematic that researchers have to "teach" participants how to operate a piece of equipment, for it tends to coalesce power to the researcher.

[This view is problematic primarily because of his deterministic perspective. The price of visual equipment tends to drop down, however, it does not guarantee that research participants may have equal access to the equipment.]

The research design Packard used was to giving a disposable camera to a homeless with the minimum instruction and the promise of remuneration of $5 upon their return with the camera the next day. He conducted interviews driven from the content of the photos they took. He wrote that there was little skepticism from participants when he explained his goal of this research--helping the homeless, etc.

Interpreting the styles of photos taken by the participants, Packard remarked its tendency of less affected convention and dominant photography rules. However, he rightly contends, "In order for knowledge to be truly powerful, it must be mobilized. Knowledge is power only to the extent to which it can be communicated" (p. 73).

[This sharp observation critiques overemphasis on non-dominant knowledge and practices outside of the mainstream. There may be a potential in a sense, but non-conventional practices and performances are not themselves a form of resistance.]

Packard combined in this research photo-elicitation with participant-driven data generation. However, in my opinion, this participatory visual method does not constitute participatory action research, for the data analysis is done solely by the researcher himself.

Friday, April 9, 2010

Walking with video

Pink, Sarah. (2007). Visual Studies, 22 (3), 240 — 252

In her methodological proposal of "walking with someone" to learn his or her experiences, Pink further inquires into "how the integration of video into this method can serve as a catalyst for creating ethnographic understandings of other people’s experiences and communicating about these to a wider audience" (p. 243).

Her ethnographic study stems from the emphasis of the sensory nature of sociality and empathetic learning by sharing the same sensory experiences. In particular with respect to walking or moving body, she quotes Ingold, "Locomotion, not cognition, must be the starting point for the study of perceptual activity’ (Ingold 2004, 331; 2000, 166; as cited on page 245).

As to benefits of using video in the method, she wrote:

First, video provides us with a tool that can enable embodied communication about, empathetic understandings of and representations of other people’s perceptions of their environments. Second, ... the film/videomaking context serves as a process through which people, things and sensory experiences are drawn together. (p. 245)

Pink attributed David and Judith MacDougall to a key development of a participatory and reflexive form of observational anthropological filmmaking. Building on this approach, Pink defines the method of walking with camera as a place-making practice, for film explores and gathers experiences, things, people, relationships, and so forth, while "meandering" the routes taken by the film subject (p. 247). With respect to empathetic experience of watching such ethnographic films, Pink wrote:

Some types of ‘indeterminate’ experience generated through viewing the embodied experience of another represented in ethnographic film would not necessarily transcend culture, but would allow us to make culturally framed reflections based on our empathetic responses to filmic representations of others’ experiences. (p. 248)

Here, concerning about application of ethnographic knowledge outside of academia, Pink argues for the empathetic engagement that film or video can invite to viewers.

As to walking with camera with a subject, Pink describes a representation of people's experience, thus producing historical text.