Orlando Fals-Borda. (2002). In P. Valero & O. Skovsmose (Eds.), Proceedings of the 3rd International conference on mathematics education and society (pp. 1-10).
Copenhagen: Centre for Research in Learning Mathematics.
For him, PAR attempts to challenge power through a radical change in knowledge production. He stated:
We appeared to be involved in a risky mixture of power/ knowledge, for we dared to challenge established ways and rules with heterodox research-and-study techniques in the field, in the classroom and even in the comfort of our armchairs in order to promote changes that are felt necessary both for academia and for society at large. (p. 2)
PAR is a remedy for ineffective analytical procedure in academia and at the same time a tool to pursue social justice for ordinary people in society. From this perspective, he drew attention to three types of tensions that arose in building PAR : (1) theory/practice in determining appropriate safeguards for the application of praxis, (2) in the meaning of the subject/ object and knowledge triad; and 3) in the search for a more satisfactory vision of science, within the context of mathematics education.
Concerning validity, Fals-Borda argued that it has to do with the notions of QUAL and QUAN research. He continued that quantitative measures may be combined with qualitative descriptions. More importantly, he stated:
Validity criteria could be derived from sources other than numerical regressions and correlations. Such alternative guidelines could be drawn by common sense, from inductive/deductive analysis of results obtained in practice through personal involvement in processes, and approved by the considered judgement of local reference groups. (p. 7)
Validity can be sought through self-reflexivity, participants, and other reference groups, as suggested in constructivist approaches as shown in fourth generation evaluation.
Fals-Borda asserted that PAR can bring together diverse knowledge systems--suggesting both QUAL and QUAN--and wrote that is a challenge for intellectual and moral reconstruction. He stated:
Convergence of this type should only be limited by how useful it is in the sociocultural and environmental context that inspired it, and in producing the positive practical results expected of it in the real world. (p. 8)
He noted, "PAR approach is open, plural, practical and interdisciplinary" (p. 9). He continued to stress that:
This open, holistic paradigm of PAR brings together praxis and ethics, academic knowledge and popular wisdom, the professor and the student, the rational and the existential, the regular and the fractal, the qualitative and the quantitative. It breaks down the subject/object dichotomy. It is founded on the democratic pluralist concepts of otherness, service and justice, upholding toleration of diversity and introducing neglected perspectives of culture, gender, popular classes and pluriethnicity into research and teaching activities. (p. 9)
Friday, December 3, 2010
Participatory Action Research
: Psychology and social change. (1997). Mary Brydon-Miller. Journal of social issues, 53 (4), 657-666.
PAR can be defined as a process of research, education, and action (Hall, 1981, Participatory research, popular knowledge and power: A personal reflection. Convergence, 14(3), 6-1 7).
Hall explained: The term participatory research was first used in the early 1970s in the research in Tanzania that drew on local knowledge and expertise in developing a project. Fals-Borda preferred the term PAR to emphasize the social change component of the work. In India, Tandon developed similar approaches to conducting community-based research.
Brydon-Miller finds its major philosophical influence in the work of Freire, who emphasized experience-based learning and developing critical consciousness from this knowledge through repeated cycles of action-and-reflection. The author stated that this cycle lies at the heart of PAR's knowledge generation.
One of the distinctions between PAR and more traditional research is in the acknowledgment of the political nature of research. PAR rejects value-free knowledge production. Brydon-Miller noted that this acknowledgment allows researcher to act in a more direct manner upon social issues.
Brydon-Miller described a basic set of tenets of PAR by following Hall (1981):
PAR originates in communities and populations that have traditionally been exploited; PAR addresses specific concerns of the community and the fundamental causes of oppression in order to bring about change; and PAR is a process of research, education, and action.
Brydon-Miller asserted the difficulty in typifying the methodology of PAR. In this light, she stated:
PAR can and does use what might seem to be fairly traditional methods of social scientific inquiry such as community questionnaires and interviews, the fundamental difference being that in PAR, members of the community determine which methods to use. (p. 661) [This indicates PAR is not a kind of methods, which is often divided into QUAL and QUAN. Both can be used in PAR but under a different set of rules, i.e., who determines what methods to use.]
She continued to state:
They then develop or adapt the research instruments and learn to carry out the research and to take part in analyzing the results. Finally, and most important, they own the results of the research and can determine how the information is to be used in addressing the concerns they have articulated. In addition to more standard methods, PAR also utilizes a variety of other approaches, including popular theater, political action, group discussions, community seminars, educational camps, intercultural exchange programs, video productions, and storytelling, to name just a few. (p. 661).
PAR can be defined as a process of research, education, and action (Hall, 1981, Participatory research, popular knowledge and power: A personal reflection. Convergence, 14(3), 6-1 7).
Hall explained: The term participatory research was first used in the early 1970s in the research in Tanzania that drew on local knowledge and expertise in developing a project. Fals-Borda preferred the term PAR to emphasize the social change component of the work. In India, Tandon developed similar approaches to conducting community-based research.
Brydon-Miller finds its major philosophical influence in the work of Freire, who emphasized experience-based learning and developing critical consciousness from this knowledge through repeated cycles of action-and-reflection. The author stated that this cycle lies at the heart of PAR's knowledge generation.
One of the distinctions between PAR and more traditional research is in the acknowledgment of the political nature of research. PAR rejects value-free knowledge production. Brydon-Miller noted that this acknowledgment allows researcher to act in a more direct manner upon social issues.
Brydon-Miller described a basic set of tenets of PAR by following Hall (1981):
PAR originates in communities and populations that have traditionally been exploited; PAR addresses specific concerns of the community and the fundamental causes of oppression in order to bring about change; and PAR is a process of research, education, and action.
Brydon-Miller asserted the difficulty in typifying the methodology of PAR. In this light, she stated:
PAR can and does use what might seem to be fairly traditional methods of social scientific inquiry such as community questionnaires and interviews, the fundamental difference being that in PAR, members of the community determine which methods to use. (p. 661) [This indicates PAR is not a kind of methods, which is often divided into QUAL and QUAN. Both can be used in PAR but under a different set of rules, i.e., who determines what methods to use.]
She continued to state:
They then develop or adapt the research instruments and learn to carry out the research and to take part in analyzing the results. Finally, and most important, they own the results of the research and can determine how the information is to be used in addressing the concerns they have articulated. In addition to more standard methods, PAR also utilizes a variety of other approaches, including popular theater, political action, group discussions, community seminars, educational camps, intercultural exchange programs, video productions, and storytelling, to name just a few. (p. 661).
Ideology and Political Economy in Inquiry
: Action research and participatory research. (1983). L. David Brown & Rajesh Tandon. Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 19 (3), 277-294. DOI: 10.1177/002188638301900306
The authors examine two traditions of applied behavioral science inquiry--action research and participatory research. They argued that both espouse similar values and employ common methods in different settings.
They pointed out that action research, formulated by Lewin, which consists of cycles of analysis, fact finding, conceptualization, planning, implementation, and evaluation to simultaneously solve problems and generate new knowledge. They observed that action research took place in the Global North in business firms and educational organizations. Yet, academia social scientists had not accepted it as fully as applied researchers in organizations.
On the other hand, participatory research emerged from the work with the oppressed in the Third World, where problems of adult education and social oppression are particularly acute, in various forms, such as Freire's conscientization and other work in Africa and Asia. The international network of participatory researchers was formed in 1978 sponsored by the International Council for Adult Education. Here the characteristics of participatory research were summarized:
Hall (1981, Convergence, p.7) defined participatory research as "an integrated activity that combines social investigation, educational work and action."
The authors examine two traditions of applied behavioral science inquiry--action research and participatory research. They argued that both espouse similar values and employ common methods in different settings.
They pointed out that action research, formulated by Lewin, which consists of cycles of analysis, fact finding, conceptualization, planning, implementation, and evaluation to simultaneously solve problems and generate new knowledge. They observed that action research took place in the Global North in business firms and educational organizations. Yet, academia social scientists had not accepted it as fully as applied researchers in organizations.
On the other hand, participatory research emerged from the work with the oppressed in the Third World, where problems of adult education and social oppression are particularly acute, in various forms, such as Freire's conscientization and other work in Africa and Asia. The international network of participatory researchers was formed in 1978 sponsored by the International Council for Adult Education. Here the characteristics of participatory research were summarized:
Hall (1981, Convergence, p.7) defined participatory research as "an integrated activity that combines social investigation, educational work and action."
Thursday, December 2, 2010
Paragidmatic controversies, contradictions, and emerging confluences
Egon G. Guba & Yvonna S. Lincoln. (2008). In Norman K. Denzin & Yvonna S. Lincoln (Eds.), The landscape of qualitative research (3rd ed.) (pp. 255-286). Thousand Oaks, London, New Delhi, and Singapore: Sage.
The authors developed their definition of the nature of paradigms proposed in 1994 by incorporating John Heron and Peter Reason's (1997) participatory/cooperative paradigm. In this chapter, they focused on issues of axiology, commensurability, action, control, foundations of truth and knowledge, validity, voice, reflexivity, and postmodern textual representation.
It is interesting to note that they changed their perspective on commensurability: in the past, they had argued commensurability between paradigms is not possible, although within each paradigm, mixed methodologies may make good sense. Yet, in this chapter is argued that it would not be impossible to blend some elements from each paradigm. For instance, positivism and postpositivism are clearly commensurable.
Concerning the call to action, the authors noted:
"The mandate for social action, especially action designed and created by and for rearch participants with the aid and cooperation of researchers, can be most sharply delineated between positivist/postpositivist and new paradigm inquirers. (p. 267)
Another controversy around paradigms is centered on control of the study: who initiates? who determines research processes? who determines what to be represented? The authors noted that the issue of control is deeply embedded in the questions of voice, reflexivity, and postmodern textual representation, which are relevant only to new paradigm inquirers. Interestingly, however, the term control is used to foster empowerment, noted the authors:
"[F]or new-paradigm researchers control is a means of fostering emancipation, democracy, and community empowerment, and of redressing power imbalances such that those who were previously marginalized now achieve voice (Mertens, 1998) or "human flourishing" (Heron & Reason, 1997). (p. 268)
Validity is the most controversial term among paradigms. Questions relevant to validity include: are the findings sufficient enough to act upon them?
Voice: In the past, the only appropriate voice was "voice from nowhere" (p. 277). While the voice of informants becomes important, the authors observed that it is critical to participatory research, having a researcher's voice in the text and simultaneously letting participants speak for themselves through various media, such as plays, forums, performance-oriented media... The authors remarked: "Performance texts, in particular, give an emotional immediacy to the voices of researchers and research participants far beyond their own sites and locale" (p. 278). For Rosanna Herz (1997, Introduction: Reflexivity and voice. In (Ed.), Reflexivity and voice), voice is a struggle for representation of the author's self as well as the respondents' selves. She wrote:
Voice has multiple dimensions: First there is the voice of the author. Second, there is the presentation of the voices of ones' respondents within the text. A third dimension appears when the self is the subject of the inquiry. (p. 278).
[Participatory video, these dimensions come into play. How do participants represent their voice when they present their respondents' interviewed voice? Is this argument really relevant ti PV in any case? I explored a bit of this issue in writing reflexivity.]
Reflexivity: The authors defined as reflexivity here reflecting critically on the self as researcher, instrumental to research.
Postmodern textual representations: postmodern and poststructural perspectives brought forth criticism around conventional texts: their reductionist representation of human reality and contribution to historical oppression. As a counter-text, new forms of texts flourish to break boundaries and moving the center to the margin. One of the examples is "messy texts" (Marcus & Fischer, 1986), which breaks the binary between science and literature. The authors noted that "Representation may be arguably the most open-ended for the controversies surrounding phenomenological research today" (p. 280).
In concluding, the authors remain as constructivists. They think it is highly unlikely and even less than useful that positivist and new paradigm forms of inquiry resolve their differences because of the assumption that there is no single truth. Thus, they wrote:
"We stand at the threshold of a history marked by multivocality, contested meanings, paradigmatic controversies, and new texual forms" (p. 281).
The authors developed their definition of the nature of paradigms proposed in 1994 by incorporating John Heron and Peter Reason's (1997) participatory/cooperative paradigm. In this chapter, they focused on issues of axiology, commensurability, action, control, foundations of truth and knowledge, validity, voice, reflexivity, and postmodern textual representation.
It is interesting to note that they changed their perspective on commensurability: in the past, they had argued commensurability between paradigms is not possible, although within each paradigm, mixed methodologies may make good sense. Yet, in this chapter is argued that it would not be impossible to blend some elements from each paradigm. For instance, positivism and postpositivism are clearly commensurable.
Concerning the call to action, the authors noted:
"The mandate for social action, especially action designed and created by and for rearch participants with the aid and cooperation of researchers, can be most sharply delineated between positivist/postpositivist and new paradigm inquirers. (p. 267)
Another controversy around paradigms is centered on control of the study: who initiates? who determines research processes? who determines what to be represented? The authors noted that the issue of control is deeply embedded in the questions of voice, reflexivity, and postmodern textual representation, which are relevant only to new paradigm inquirers. Interestingly, however, the term control is used to foster empowerment, noted the authors:
"[F]or new-paradigm researchers control is a means of fostering emancipation, democracy, and community empowerment, and of redressing power imbalances such that those who were previously marginalized now achieve voice (Mertens, 1998) or "human flourishing" (Heron & Reason, 1997). (p. 268)
Validity is the most controversial term among paradigms. Questions relevant to validity include: are the findings sufficient enough to act upon them?
Voice: In the past, the only appropriate voice was "voice from nowhere" (p. 277). While the voice of informants becomes important, the authors observed that it is critical to participatory research, having a researcher's voice in the text and simultaneously letting participants speak for themselves through various media, such as plays, forums, performance-oriented media... The authors remarked: "Performance texts, in particular, give an emotional immediacy to the voices of researchers and research participants far beyond their own sites and locale" (p. 278). For Rosanna Herz (1997, Introduction: Reflexivity and voice. In (Ed.), Reflexivity and voice), voice is a struggle for representation of the author's self as well as the respondents' selves. She wrote:
Voice has multiple dimensions: First there is the voice of the author. Second, there is the presentation of the voices of ones' respondents within the text. A third dimension appears when the self is the subject of the inquiry. (p. 278).
[Participatory video, these dimensions come into play. How do participants represent their voice when they present their respondents' interviewed voice? Is this argument really relevant ti PV in any case? I explored a bit of this issue in writing reflexivity.]
Reflexivity: The authors defined as reflexivity here reflecting critically on the self as researcher, instrumental to research.
Postmodern textual representations: postmodern and poststructural perspectives brought forth criticism around conventional texts: their reductionist representation of human reality and contribution to historical oppression. As a counter-text, new forms of texts flourish to break boundaries and moving the center to the margin. One of the examples is "messy texts" (Marcus & Fischer, 1986), which breaks the binary between science and literature. The authors noted that "Representation may be arguably the most open-ended for the controversies surrounding phenomenological research today" (p. 280).
In concluding, the authors remain as constructivists. They think it is highly unlikely and even less than useful that positivist and new paradigm forms of inquiry resolve their differences because of the assumption that there is no single truth. Thus, they wrote:
"We stand at the threshold of a history marked by multivocality, contested meanings, paradigmatic controversies, and new texual forms" (p. 281).
Competing paradigms in qualitative research
Egon G. Guba & Yvonna S. Lincoln (Eds.). (1994). Handbook of qualitative research (pp. 105-117).
An alternative paradigm dialog
Egon C. Guba (1990). In E.G. Guba (Ed.), The paradigm dialog (pp. 17-30). Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
In this chapter, Guba proposed as the generic definition of paradigm "a basic set of belief that guides action" (p. 17), in particular, disciplined inquiry as the action in our concern. Such paradigms respond to three questions: ontological, epistemological, and methodological questions.
1) Ontological: What is the nature of reality?
2) Epistemological: What is the nature of the relationship between the knower (researcher) and the known (researched)?
3) Methodological: what is the process of finding out knowledge or research?
Positivism
The positivist paradigm is rooted in a realist ontology, the belief that "there exists a reality out there driven by immutable natural laws" (p. 19). The purpose of science is to discover the true nature of reality and how it truly works.
From this ground, positivists practice an objectivist epistemology, in which they put questions directly to nature and wait for its answer without altering it. Since the inquirer can be positioned far away from nature, research outcomes are value free. Within this paradigm, experimental/manipulative methodology is the most appropriate in such a way that questions and hypotheses are stated in advance and subjected to empirical tests under carefully controlled conditions.
Postpositivism
It is a modified/less naïve version of positivism. It is based on critical realism: postpositivists believe that reality exists out there, yet because of human sensory/intellectual limitations, it is impossible for humans truly to perceive it. Thus, they emphasize the need for being critical about what researchers find.
Epistemologically, postpositivists recognize the absurdity of the separation of inquirers from the inquired; thus they take on a modified objectivist epistemology in the sense that objectivity is a regulatory ideal to adhere, yet in reality, can be achieved reasonably closely (approximated) only by cleaning up one's preposition, relying on the tradition of the field to report the inquiry, and seeking judgment from peers in the disciplinary community. Guba criticized that the latter two requirements virtually make is impossible for new paradigm to assert themselves.
Methodologically, it put forth critical multiplism (modified experimentalism/manipulatism), which was also articulated as triangulation by Denzin (1978). Because of limited human sensory, it seeks as many sources as possible to draw findings. They often calls for more qualitative methods, depending more on grounded theory, and reintroducing discovery into the inquiry process.
Critical Theory
Guba proposed the label of "ideologically oriented inquiry" instead of critical theory, which encompasses feminism, neo-Marxism, Frerieism, participatory inquiry, and critical theory. The shared quality in this family is rejecting the claim of "value freedom" made by positivism (and postpositivism to an extent). They believe that values do enter into every inquiry; inquiry thereby becomes a political act.
Guba criticizes an ontological juncture that critical theorists (ideologists) adhere to:
But, for whatever reason, critical theorists (ideologists) have elected to believe in an objective reality--as the phrase commonly used by them, "false consciousness," readily demonstrates (because it implies that there is a "true consciousness" somewhere "out there," or, more likely, possessed by the inquirer or some better informed elite). The task of inquiry is, by definition, to raise people (the oppressed) to a level of "true consciousness." Once they appreciate how oppressed they are, they can act to transform the world. The close parallel between transforming the world and predicting and controlling it should not be lost. (p. 24)
Critical theorists undertake subjectivist epistemology, regarding inquiry acts as a process intimately related to the inquirer's values. Yet, Guba points out a logical disjunction a "realist ontology coupled with a subjectivist epistemology" (p. 24).
Guba asserted that critical theorists' methodology is more consistent and framed it as transformative and dialogic one. It seeks to eliminate false consciousness and to facilitate transformation.
Constructivism
Constructivist calls for a completely different paradigm. It acknowledge value-laden facts and furthermore, the interaction of inquirer and inquired into that shapes outcomes of an inquiry. Therefore, constructivists state that:
It [constructivism] renders the distinction between ontology and epistemology obsolete; what can be known and the individual who comes to know it are fused into a coherent whole. Further, it makes the findings of an inquiry not a report of what is "out there" but the residue of a process that literally creates them. Finally, it depicts knowledge as the outcome or consequence of human activity; knowledge is a human construction, never certifiable as ultimately true but problematic and ever changing. (p. 26)
From this perspective, ontologically, it takes a position of relativism in that "realities are multiple, and they exist in people's minds" (p. 26). Guba argued that relativism is "the key to openness and the continuing search for ever more informed and sophisticated constructions" (p. 26).
Epistemologically, the constructivist takes a subjectivist position, not because of the limited human conditions but because of its ontological assumptions: if realities exist only in people's minds, subjectivist interaction is the only way to accessing them.
Methodologically, the constructivist takes hermeneutics and dialectics: it attempts to depict individual constructions as accurately as possible, and simultaneously, contrast and compare dialectically to generate informed constructions on which there is substantial consensus.
In this chapter, Guba proposed as the generic definition of paradigm "a basic set of belief that guides action" (p. 17), in particular, disciplined inquiry as the action in our concern. Such paradigms respond to three questions: ontological, epistemological, and methodological questions.
1) Ontological: What is the nature of reality?
2) Epistemological: What is the nature of the relationship between the knower (researcher) and the known (researched)?
3) Methodological: what is the process of finding out knowledge or research?
Positivism
The positivist paradigm is rooted in a realist ontology, the belief that "there exists a reality out there driven by immutable natural laws" (p. 19). The purpose of science is to discover the true nature of reality and how it truly works.
From this ground, positivists practice an objectivist epistemology, in which they put questions directly to nature and wait for its answer without altering it. Since the inquirer can be positioned far away from nature, research outcomes are value free. Within this paradigm, experimental/manipulative methodology is the most appropriate in such a way that questions and hypotheses are stated in advance and subjected to empirical tests under carefully controlled conditions.
Postpositivism
It is a modified/less naïve version of positivism. It is based on critical realism: postpositivists believe that reality exists out there, yet because of human sensory/intellectual limitations, it is impossible for humans truly to perceive it. Thus, they emphasize the need for being critical about what researchers find.
Epistemologically, postpositivists recognize the absurdity of the separation of inquirers from the inquired; thus they take on a modified objectivist epistemology in the sense that objectivity is a regulatory ideal to adhere, yet in reality, can be achieved reasonably closely (approximated) only by cleaning up one's preposition, relying on the tradition of the field to report the inquiry, and seeking judgment from peers in the disciplinary community. Guba criticized that the latter two requirements virtually make is impossible for new paradigm to assert themselves.
Methodologically, it put forth critical multiplism (modified experimentalism/manipulatism), which was also articulated as triangulation by Denzin (1978). Because of limited human sensory, it seeks as many sources as possible to draw findings. They often calls for more qualitative methods, depending more on grounded theory, and reintroducing discovery into the inquiry process.
Critical Theory
Guba proposed the label of "ideologically oriented inquiry" instead of critical theory, which encompasses feminism, neo-Marxism, Frerieism, participatory inquiry, and critical theory. The shared quality in this family is rejecting the claim of "value freedom" made by positivism (and postpositivism to an extent). They believe that values do enter into every inquiry; inquiry thereby becomes a political act.
Guba criticizes an ontological juncture that critical theorists (ideologists) adhere to:
But, for whatever reason, critical theorists (ideologists) have elected to believe in an objective reality--as the phrase commonly used by them, "false consciousness," readily demonstrates (because it implies that there is a "true consciousness" somewhere "out there," or, more likely, possessed by the inquirer or some better informed elite). The task of inquiry is, by definition, to raise people (the oppressed) to a level of "true consciousness." Once they appreciate how oppressed they are, they can act to transform the world. The close parallel between transforming the world and predicting and controlling it should not be lost. (p. 24)
Critical theorists undertake subjectivist epistemology, regarding inquiry acts as a process intimately related to the inquirer's values. Yet, Guba points out a logical disjunction a "realist ontology coupled with a subjectivist epistemology" (p. 24).
Guba asserted that critical theorists' methodology is more consistent and framed it as transformative and dialogic one. It seeks to eliminate false consciousness and to facilitate transformation.
Constructivism
Constructivist calls for a completely different paradigm. It acknowledge value-laden facts and furthermore, the interaction of inquirer and inquired into that shapes outcomes of an inquiry. Therefore, constructivists state that:
It [constructivism] renders the distinction between ontology and epistemology obsolete; what can be known and the individual who comes to know it are fused into a coherent whole. Further, it makes the findings of an inquiry not a report of what is "out there" but the residue of a process that literally creates them. Finally, it depicts knowledge as the outcome or consequence of human activity; knowledge is a human construction, never certifiable as ultimately true but problematic and ever changing. (p. 26)
From this perspective, ontologically, it takes a position of relativism in that "realities are multiple, and they exist in people's minds" (p. 26). Guba argued that relativism is "the key to openness and the continuing search for ever more informed and sophisticated constructions" (p. 26).
Epistemologically, the constructivist takes a subjectivist position, not because of the limited human conditions but because of its ontological assumptions: if realities exist only in people's minds, subjectivist interaction is the only way to accessing them.
Methodologically, the constructivist takes hermeneutics and dialectics: it attempts to depict individual constructions as accurately as possible, and simultaneously, contrast and compare dialectically to generate informed constructions on which there is substantial consensus.
A Participatory Inquiry Paradigm
John Heron and Peter Reason (1997). Qualitative inquiry, 3 (3), 274-294. doi: 10.1177/107780049700300302
Deveoloping Guba and Lincoln (1994, Competing paradigms in qualitative research. In N.
K. Denzin & Y S. Lincoln (Eds.), Handbook of qualitative research), the authors articulate a participatory paradigm by supporting Guba and Lincoln's argument that the constructivist paradigm is unclear about the relation between constructed realities and the original cosmos. In this light, the authors argued that "participative realities" are more useful.
The authors begin a paradigm building from the constructivist worldview. Further, it emphasizes human beings in relation to the living world and experiential knowledge, inquiry and reality. They argued:
"Constructivist views tend to be deficient in any acknowledgment of experiential knowing; that is, knowing by acquaintance, by meeting, and by felt participation in the presence of what is there. (p. 277)
For them, reality is a form of experience and experiential reality is both subjective and objective. For instance, holding someone's hand means that it shapes the person and simultaneously I meet the person. Thus, they stated, "To experience anything is to participate in it, and to participate is to both to mold and to encounter; hence, experiential reality is always subjective-objective" (p. 278). This participatory, subjective-objective, experiential reality constitutes the ontology of participatory worldview. Heron (1996 p, 11 ...) wrote:
It is subjective because it is only known through the form the mind gives it; and it is objective because the mind interpenetrates the given cosmos which it shapes. (p. 11)
Thus, in this paradigm, they argue that there is a primordial reality, in which the mind actively penetrates and cocreates reality through interaction with the cosmos.
Epistemology: the authors emphasize critical subjectivity as the epistemological ground. They acknowledge that knowing is from a perspective and that perspective has authentic values as well as restricting bias. Thus, what involves is critical subjectivity, such that a self-reflexive attention is given to the knower's ground. Developing the community consensus (which determines relative truth) of constructivism, the authors add shared experiential meaning to judge the relative truth. [THIS ARGUMENT IS VERY VAGUE.] In this light, they argued that critical subjectivity extends to critical intersubjectivity, for personal knowing is always set within cultural and experiential shared meaning.
Methodology: Collaborative/Cooperative forms of action inquiry.
The authors argued that cooperative inquiry rests on two participatory principles: epistemic participation and political participation:
The first means that any propositional knowledge that is the outcomes of the research is grounded by the researchers in their own experiential knowledge. The second means that research subjects have a basic human right to participate fully in designing the research that intends to gather knowledge about them. (p. 284)
The more participatory systematically the more cooperative. Thus, they distinguish this methodology from the mainstream qualitative paradigm:
Qualitative research about people is a halfway house between exclusive, controlling, quantitative, positivist research on people and fully participatory, cooperative research with people. (p. 285)
Cooperative inquiry is "a wide-ranging science about any aspect of the human condition that a group of coresearchers choose to explore through the instrumentality of their own experience" (p. 286).
Axiology: the authors contended that the omission of axiology in Guba and Lincoln's paradigm table is a critical deficit because axiology ultimately asks why we try to create reality and what it worthwhile and valuable. In this question, the authors respond that the participatory paradigm answers it is for human flourishing. It is practical knowing of "how to choose and act" (p. 287).
Deveoloping Guba and Lincoln (1994, Competing paradigms in qualitative research. In N.
K. Denzin & Y S. Lincoln (Eds.), Handbook of qualitative research), the authors articulate a participatory paradigm by supporting Guba and Lincoln's argument that the constructivist paradigm is unclear about the relation between constructed realities and the original cosmos. In this light, the authors argued that "participative realities" are more useful.
The authors begin a paradigm building from the constructivist worldview. Further, it emphasizes human beings in relation to the living world and experiential knowledge, inquiry and reality. They argued:
"Constructivist views tend to be deficient in any acknowledgment of experiential knowing; that is, knowing by acquaintance, by meeting, and by felt participation in the presence of what is there. (p. 277)
For them, reality is a form of experience and experiential reality is both subjective and objective. For instance, holding someone's hand means that it shapes the person and simultaneously I meet the person. Thus, they stated, "To experience anything is to participate in it, and to participate is to both to mold and to encounter; hence, experiential reality is always subjective-objective" (p. 278). This participatory, subjective-objective, experiential reality constitutes the ontology of participatory worldview. Heron (1996 p, 11 ...) wrote:
It is subjective because it is only known through the form the mind gives it; and it is objective because the mind interpenetrates the given cosmos which it shapes. (p. 11)
Thus, in this paradigm, they argue that there is a primordial reality, in which the mind actively penetrates and cocreates reality through interaction with the cosmos.
Epistemology: the authors emphasize critical subjectivity as the epistemological ground. They acknowledge that knowing is from a perspective and that perspective has authentic values as well as restricting bias. Thus, what involves is critical subjectivity, such that a self-reflexive attention is given to the knower's ground. Developing the community consensus (which determines relative truth) of constructivism, the authors add shared experiential meaning to judge the relative truth. [THIS ARGUMENT IS VERY VAGUE.] In this light, they argued that critical subjectivity extends to critical intersubjectivity, for personal knowing is always set within cultural and experiential shared meaning.
Methodology: Collaborative/Cooperative forms of action inquiry.
The authors argued that cooperative inquiry rests on two participatory principles: epistemic participation and political participation:
The first means that any propositional knowledge that is the outcomes of the research is grounded by the researchers in their own experiential knowledge. The second means that research subjects have a basic human right to participate fully in designing the research that intends to gather knowledge about them. (p. 284)
The more participatory systematically the more cooperative. Thus, they distinguish this methodology from the mainstream qualitative paradigm:
Qualitative research about people is a halfway house between exclusive, controlling, quantitative, positivist research on people and fully participatory, cooperative research with people. (p. 285)
Cooperative inquiry is "a wide-ranging science about any aspect of the human condition that a group of coresearchers choose to explore through the instrumentality of their own experience" (p. 286).
Axiology: the authors contended that the omission of axiology in Guba and Lincoln's paradigm table is a critical deficit because axiology ultimately asks why we try to create reality and what it worthwhile and valuable. In this question, the authors respond that the participatory paradigm answers it is for human flourishing. It is practical knowing of "how to choose and act" (p. 287).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)