: a comprehensive international survey. (1978). Budd L. Hall & J. R. Kidd. Oxford ; New York : Pergamon Press.
LC5209 I524 1976 (EDU)
Sunday, December 5, 2010
Intimate details : Participatory action research in prison
Michelle Fine and MarĂa Elena Torre. (2006). 4 (3), 253–269. doi: 10.1177/1476750306066801
For the authors, "participatory action researchers have an obligation to reveal, when possible, the intimate details of PAR undertaken in difficult social institutions" (p. 255)
"In communities, schools or prisons, PAR projects document the subterranean pools of collective dissent by aggregating and making public ‘private’ troubles among very different youth, women and men. Revealing the common, public roots of these ‘private’ troubles (Mills, 1959), PAR demonstrates the differentiated consequences of social oppression, distributed unevenly (but not only) by race, ethnicity and class. PAR shatters the false consensus of neo-liberal institutional life by challenging the everyday banality and seeming inevitability of injustice. More specifically, participatory action research lifts the multiple stories and counter stories dwelling within any complex institution or social arrangement, privileging in particular those perspectives that age on the bottom of social arrangements, where the lies, the ghosts, the buried memories, the disposables, the traitors and the silences gather." (p. 255)
Fine continues to use and stresses the word PAR.
[Fancy descriptions and cautious uses of words in this article]
For the authors, "participatory action researchers have an obligation to reveal, when possible, the intimate details of PAR undertaken in difficult social institutions" (p. 255)
"In communities, schools or prisons, PAR projects document the subterranean pools of collective dissent by aggregating and making public ‘private’ troubles among very different youth, women and men. Revealing the common, public roots of these ‘private’ troubles (Mills, 1959), PAR demonstrates the differentiated consequences of social oppression, distributed unevenly (but not only) by race, ethnicity and class. PAR shatters the false consensus of neo-liberal institutional life by challenging the everyday banality and seeming inevitability of injustice. More specifically, participatory action research lifts the multiple stories and counter stories dwelling within any complex institution or social arrangement, privileging in particular those perspectives that age on the bottom of social arrangements, where the lies, the ghosts, the buried memories, the disposables, the traitors and the silences gather." (p. 255)
Fine continues to use and stresses the word PAR.
[Fancy descriptions and cautious uses of words in this article]
Saturday, December 4, 2010
Visual Methods in Social Research
Reviewed by Mark Turin
BANKS, MARCUS. Visual methods in social research. xvi, 201 pp., tables, illus., bibliogr. London, Delhi: Sage Publications, 2001.
In this helpful introductory text, Banks offers advice to social scientists interested in using visual imagery in their work, and discusses the benefits of doing so. The author's approach is neither dogmatic nor evangelical, combining instead quiet confidence with cautionary good sense. The result is a very solid book which will be particularly useful for students in sociology and anthropology hoping to engage with issues of visual representation.
Visual methods in social research covers empirical approaches to image creation as well as image analysis. Drawing on wide-ranging examples, from holiday postcards to vintage film, Banks illustrates how methodology relating to visual form in the social sciences is '[either] scattered or confined to quite specific areas' (p. 2). The author makes effective use of rhetorical questions and discrete subsections (such as 'unnatural vision' and 'reading narratives'), thereby encouraging the reader to reconsider often-unquestioned assumptions about visual culture. Banks is well versed both topically and technologically, and jumps nimbly from caste in India to the Kayapo of Brazil, and from Polaroid to webcams. Moreover, by choosing explicitly contemporary reference points, such as Jorg Haider or Quentin Tarantino's now-cult film, Pulp fiction, he succeeds in engaging younger readers on their own visual territory.
A number of sections are particularly strong and worthy of special attention. Discussing the presence of foreign objects and non-indigenous bodies in ethnographic films, Banks points out that in future generations, the 'sight of "imported" artefacts would not be taken as mournful tokens of lost innocence, but celebrated as cultural appropriations' (p. 144). About the aptly named HADDON web-based meta-catalogue of archival ethnographic film and footage, the author's own creation, he is characteristically modest. The existence of this online catalogue and of a supporting website for the book under discussion, , embodies the hands-on approach which Banks advocates. While largely photo-centric, Visual methods also offers useful pointers for working with computer-based digital media, one advantage of which is the potential for 'research parity between sound, text and image' (p. 162). Increasingly, as academic publishing becomes a not-for-profit enterprise and publishers attempt to curtail their production costs, a well-conceived website of video clips and images can provide access to a supporting corpus of rich visual data which can help to illustrate a written text. Focusing on the Yanomamo interactive CD-ROM. Banks demonstrates how the use of multimedia 'opens up a non-linear space within which the detail can be absorbed at the user's own pace, and the arguments which rest upon that detail can be fully explored' (p. 165). This is the power of bits and bytes: the social researcher can 'usefully employ multimedia to state her own case but also to outline the alternative interpretations and provide access to the raw materials to allow the user to test them all' (p. 164). Banks concludes his otherwise cautious narrative with an unexpected, albeit entirely justified, sting in the tail. Having offered the disclaimer that his book contains little explicit theory, he takes a well-aimed swipe at scholars who advocate nothing other than 'swooping god-like into other people's lives and gathering "data" ... according to a predetermined theoretical agenda [which] strikes me not simply as morally dubious but intellectually flawed' (p. 179).
Students would be well served to read this book alongside James Monaco's now-classic How to read a film (currently in its third edition). In tandem, these background handbooks are amply sufficient to prepare researchers in social science with enough practical know-how, together with a healthy dose of reflexive understanding, to ensure the responsible use of visual imagery in their work. Banks is at his best when he stresses the material nature of visual media and the cultural nature of vision (bringing to mind John Berger's work), and in demonstrating how visual objects are entangled in social relations. In his introduction, Banks suggests that 'good visual research rests upon a judicious reading of both internal and external narratives' (p. 12). His own approach--critical yet mindful--does just this.
BANKS, MARCUS. Visual methods in social research. xvi, 201 pp., tables, illus., bibliogr. London, Delhi: Sage Publications, 2001.
In this helpful introductory text, Banks offers advice to social scientists interested in using visual imagery in their work, and discusses the benefits of doing so. The author's approach is neither dogmatic nor evangelical, combining instead quiet confidence with cautionary good sense. The result is a very solid book which will be particularly useful for students in sociology and anthropology hoping to engage with issues of visual representation.
Visual methods in social research covers empirical approaches to image creation as well as image analysis. Drawing on wide-ranging examples, from holiday postcards to vintage film, Banks illustrates how methodology relating to visual form in the social sciences is '[either] scattered or confined to quite specific areas' (p. 2). The author makes effective use of rhetorical questions and discrete subsections (such as 'unnatural vision' and 'reading narratives'), thereby encouraging the reader to reconsider often-unquestioned assumptions about visual culture. Banks is well versed both topically and technologically, and jumps nimbly from caste in India to the Kayapo of Brazil, and from Polaroid to webcams. Moreover, by choosing explicitly contemporary reference points, such as Jorg Haider or Quentin Tarantino's now-cult film, Pulp fiction, he succeeds in engaging younger readers on their own visual territory.
A number of sections are particularly strong and worthy of special attention. Discussing the presence of foreign objects and non-indigenous bodies in ethnographic films, Banks points out that in future generations, the 'sight of "imported" artefacts would not be taken as mournful tokens of lost innocence, but celebrated as cultural appropriations' (p. 144). About the aptly named HADDON web-based meta-catalogue of archival ethnographic film and footage, the author's own creation, he is characteristically modest. The existence of this online catalogue and of a supporting website for the book under discussion, , embodies the hands-on approach which Banks advocates. While largely photo-centric, Visual methods also offers useful pointers for working with computer-based digital media, one advantage of which is the potential for 'research parity between sound, text and image' (p. 162). Increasingly, as academic publishing becomes a not-for-profit enterprise and publishers attempt to curtail their production costs, a well-conceived website of video clips and images can provide access to a supporting corpus of rich visual data which can help to illustrate a written text. Focusing on the Yanomamo interactive CD-ROM. Banks demonstrates how the use of multimedia 'opens up a non-linear space within which the detail can be absorbed at the user's own pace, and the arguments which rest upon that detail can be fully explored' (p. 165). This is the power of bits and bytes: the social researcher can 'usefully employ multimedia to state her own case but also to outline the alternative interpretations and provide access to the raw materials to allow the user to test them all' (p. 164). Banks concludes his otherwise cautious narrative with an unexpected, albeit entirely justified, sting in the tail. Having offered the disclaimer that his book contains little explicit theory, he takes a well-aimed swipe at scholars who advocate nothing other than 'swooping god-like into other people's lives and gathering "data" ... according to a predetermined theoretical agenda [which] strikes me not simply as morally dubious but intellectually flawed' (p. 179).
Students would be well served to read this book alongside James Monaco's now-classic How to read a film (currently in its third edition). In tandem, these background handbooks are amply sufficient to prepare researchers in social science with enough practical know-how, together with a healthy dose of reflexive understanding, to ensure the responsible use of visual imagery in their work. Banks is at his best when he stresses the material nature of visual media and the cultural nature of vision (bringing to mind John Berger's work), and in demonstrating how visual objects are entangled in social relations. In his introduction, Banks suggests that 'good visual research rests upon a judicious reading of both internal and external narratives' (p. 12). His own approach--critical yet mindful--does just this.
Friday, December 3, 2010
The North-South convergence : A 30-year first-person assessment of PAR
Orlando Fals Borda. (2006). Action Research 4(3), 351–358. DOI: 10.1177/1476750306066806
Fals-Borda warns the attempts of asserting a set of rules or guides applicable to all. He argued that there are so many autonomous groups. So, he argued:
[I]t is preferable for us to seek our own explanations for building an alternative paradigm, by studying our indigenous or founding regional groups and emphasizing their values of human solidarity. Some of these groups extend from one country to another without respecting present frontiers . . . . The fundamental values of the founding groups provide a strong ethos identifiable with a deep-rooted non-violent socialism that is worth salvaging to repair our deteriorating social fabric.(p. 356-357)
Within this perspective, he called for an alternative methodological paradigm pertinent to regional context:
Our methodology is now faced with the creative challenge of constructing an alternative paradigm in regional contexts, for understanding and valuing the complexities of societies,
as regards their oral links, particular characteristics, present situation and spontaneous nature. (p. 357)
Fals-Borda warns the attempts of asserting a set of rules or guides applicable to all. He argued that there are so many autonomous groups. So, he argued:
[I]t is preferable for us to seek our own explanations for building an alternative paradigm, by studying our indigenous or founding regional groups and emphasizing their values of human solidarity. Some of these groups extend from one country to another without respecting present frontiers . . . . The fundamental values of the founding groups provide a strong ethos identifiable with a deep-rooted non-violent socialism that is worth salvaging to repair our deteriorating social fabric.(p. 356-357)
Within this perspective, he called for an alternative methodological paradigm pertinent to regional context:
Our methodology is now faced with the creative challenge of constructing an alternative paradigm in regional contexts, for understanding and valuing the complexities of societies,
as regards their oral links, particular characteristics, present situation and spontaneous nature. (p. 357)
Research tensions and paradigm shifts in action sciences
Orlando Fals-Borda. (2002). In P. Valero & O. Skovsmose (Eds.), Proceedings of the 3rd International conference on mathematics education and society (pp. 1-10).
Copenhagen: Centre for Research in Learning Mathematics.
For him, PAR attempts to challenge power through a radical change in knowledge production. He stated:
We appeared to be involved in a risky mixture of power/ knowledge, for we dared to challenge established ways and rules with heterodox research-and-study techniques in the field, in the classroom and even in the comfort of our armchairs in order to promote changes that are felt necessary both for academia and for society at large. (p. 2)
PAR is a remedy for ineffective analytical procedure in academia and at the same time a tool to pursue social justice for ordinary people in society. From this perspective, he drew attention to three types of tensions that arose in building PAR : (1) theory/practice in determining appropriate safeguards for the application of praxis, (2) in the meaning of the subject/ object and knowledge triad; and 3) in the search for a more satisfactory vision of science, within the context of mathematics education.
Concerning validity, Fals-Borda argued that it has to do with the notions of QUAL and QUAN research. He continued that quantitative measures may be combined with qualitative descriptions. More importantly, he stated:
Validity criteria could be derived from sources other than numerical regressions and correlations. Such alternative guidelines could be drawn by common sense, from inductive/deductive analysis of results obtained in practice through personal involvement in processes, and approved by the considered judgement of local reference groups. (p. 7)
Validity can be sought through self-reflexivity, participants, and other reference groups, as suggested in constructivist approaches as shown in fourth generation evaluation.
Fals-Borda asserted that PAR can bring together diverse knowledge systems--suggesting both QUAL and QUAN--and wrote that is a challenge for intellectual and moral reconstruction. He stated:
Convergence of this type should only be limited by how useful it is in the sociocultural and environmental context that inspired it, and in producing the positive practical results expected of it in the real world. (p. 8)
He noted, "PAR approach is open, plural, practical and interdisciplinary" (p. 9). He continued to stress that:
This open, holistic paradigm of PAR brings together praxis and ethics, academic knowledge and popular wisdom, the professor and the student, the rational and the existential, the regular and the fractal, the qualitative and the quantitative. It breaks down the subject/object dichotomy. It is founded on the democratic pluralist concepts of otherness, service and justice, upholding toleration of diversity and introducing neglected perspectives of culture, gender, popular classes and pluriethnicity into research and teaching activities. (p. 9)
Copenhagen: Centre for Research in Learning Mathematics.
For him, PAR attempts to challenge power through a radical change in knowledge production. He stated:
We appeared to be involved in a risky mixture of power/ knowledge, for we dared to challenge established ways and rules with heterodox research-and-study techniques in the field, in the classroom and even in the comfort of our armchairs in order to promote changes that are felt necessary both for academia and for society at large. (p. 2)
PAR is a remedy for ineffective analytical procedure in academia and at the same time a tool to pursue social justice for ordinary people in society. From this perspective, he drew attention to three types of tensions that arose in building PAR : (1) theory/practice in determining appropriate safeguards for the application of praxis, (2) in the meaning of the subject/ object and knowledge triad; and 3) in the search for a more satisfactory vision of science, within the context of mathematics education.
Concerning validity, Fals-Borda argued that it has to do with the notions of QUAL and QUAN research. He continued that quantitative measures may be combined with qualitative descriptions. More importantly, he stated:
Validity criteria could be derived from sources other than numerical regressions and correlations. Such alternative guidelines could be drawn by common sense, from inductive/deductive analysis of results obtained in practice through personal involvement in processes, and approved by the considered judgement of local reference groups. (p. 7)
Validity can be sought through self-reflexivity, participants, and other reference groups, as suggested in constructivist approaches as shown in fourth generation evaluation.
Fals-Borda asserted that PAR can bring together diverse knowledge systems--suggesting both QUAL and QUAN--and wrote that is a challenge for intellectual and moral reconstruction. He stated:
Convergence of this type should only be limited by how useful it is in the sociocultural and environmental context that inspired it, and in producing the positive practical results expected of it in the real world. (p. 8)
He noted, "PAR approach is open, plural, practical and interdisciplinary" (p. 9). He continued to stress that:
This open, holistic paradigm of PAR brings together praxis and ethics, academic knowledge and popular wisdom, the professor and the student, the rational and the existential, the regular and the fractal, the qualitative and the quantitative. It breaks down the subject/object dichotomy. It is founded on the democratic pluralist concepts of otherness, service and justice, upholding toleration of diversity and introducing neglected perspectives of culture, gender, popular classes and pluriethnicity into research and teaching activities. (p. 9)
Participatory Action Research
: Psychology and social change. (1997). Mary Brydon-Miller. Journal of social issues, 53 (4), 657-666.
PAR can be defined as a process of research, education, and action (Hall, 1981, Participatory research, popular knowledge and power: A personal reflection. Convergence, 14(3), 6-1 7).
Hall explained: The term participatory research was first used in the early 1970s in the research in Tanzania that drew on local knowledge and expertise in developing a project. Fals-Borda preferred the term PAR to emphasize the social change component of the work. In India, Tandon developed similar approaches to conducting community-based research.
Brydon-Miller finds its major philosophical influence in the work of Freire, who emphasized experience-based learning and developing critical consciousness from this knowledge through repeated cycles of action-and-reflection. The author stated that this cycle lies at the heart of PAR's knowledge generation.
One of the distinctions between PAR and more traditional research is in the acknowledgment of the political nature of research. PAR rejects value-free knowledge production. Brydon-Miller noted that this acknowledgment allows researcher to act in a more direct manner upon social issues.
Brydon-Miller described a basic set of tenets of PAR by following Hall (1981):
PAR originates in communities and populations that have traditionally been exploited; PAR addresses specific concerns of the community and the fundamental causes of oppression in order to bring about change; and PAR is a process of research, education, and action.
Brydon-Miller asserted the difficulty in typifying the methodology of PAR. In this light, she stated:
PAR can and does use what might seem to be fairly traditional methods of social scientific inquiry such as community questionnaires and interviews, the fundamental difference being that in PAR, members of the community determine which methods to use. (p. 661) [This indicates PAR is not a kind of methods, which is often divided into QUAL and QUAN. Both can be used in PAR but under a different set of rules, i.e., who determines what methods to use.]
She continued to state:
They then develop or adapt the research instruments and learn to carry out the research and to take part in analyzing the results. Finally, and most important, they own the results of the research and can determine how the information is to be used in addressing the concerns they have articulated. In addition to more standard methods, PAR also utilizes a variety of other approaches, including popular theater, political action, group discussions, community seminars, educational camps, intercultural exchange programs, video productions, and storytelling, to name just a few. (p. 661).
PAR can be defined as a process of research, education, and action (Hall, 1981, Participatory research, popular knowledge and power: A personal reflection. Convergence, 14(3), 6-1 7).
Hall explained: The term participatory research was first used in the early 1970s in the research in Tanzania that drew on local knowledge and expertise in developing a project. Fals-Borda preferred the term PAR to emphasize the social change component of the work. In India, Tandon developed similar approaches to conducting community-based research.
Brydon-Miller finds its major philosophical influence in the work of Freire, who emphasized experience-based learning and developing critical consciousness from this knowledge through repeated cycles of action-and-reflection. The author stated that this cycle lies at the heart of PAR's knowledge generation.
One of the distinctions between PAR and more traditional research is in the acknowledgment of the political nature of research. PAR rejects value-free knowledge production. Brydon-Miller noted that this acknowledgment allows researcher to act in a more direct manner upon social issues.
Brydon-Miller described a basic set of tenets of PAR by following Hall (1981):
PAR originates in communities and populations that have traditionally been exploited; PAR addresses specific concerns of the community and the fundamental causes of oppression in order to bring about change; and PAR is a process of research, education, and action.
Brydon-Miller asserted the difficulty in typifying the methodology of PAR. In this light, she stated:
PAR can and does use what might seem to be fairly traditional methods of social scientific inquiry such as community questionnaires and interviews, the fundamental difference being that in PAR, members of the community determine which methods to use. (p. 661) [This indicates PAR is not a kind of methods, which is often divided into QUAL and QUAN. Both can be used in PAR but under a different set of rules, i.e., who determines what methods to use.]
She continued to state:
They then develop or adapt the research instruments and learn to carry out the research and to take part in analyzing the results. Finally, and most important, they own the results of the research and can determine how the information is to be used in addressing the concerns they have articulated. In addition to more standard methods, PAR also utilizes a variety of other approaches, including popular theater, political action, group discussions, community seminars, educational camps, intercultural exchange programs, video productions, and storytelling, to name just a few. (p. 661).
Ideology and Political Economy in Inquiry
: Action research and participatory research. (1983). L. David Brown & Rajesh Tandon. Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 19 (3), 277-294. DOI: 10.1177/002188638301900306
The authors examine two traditions of applied behavioral science inquiry--action research and participatory research. They argued that both espouse similar values and employ common methods in different settings.
They pointed out that action research, formulated by Lewin, which consists of cycles of analysis, fact finding, conceptualization, planning, implementation, and evaluation to simultaneously solve problems and generate new knowledge. They observed that action research took place in the Global North in business firms and educational organizations. Yet, academia social scientists had not accepted it as fully as applied researchers in organizations.
On the other hand, participatory research emerged from the work with the oppressed in the Third World, where problems of adult education and social oppression are particularly acute, in various forms, such as Freire's conscientization and other work in Africa and Asia. The international network of participatory researchers was formed in 1978 sponsored by the International Council for Adult Education. Here the characteristics of participatory research were summarized:
Hall (1981, Convergence, p.7) defined participatory research as "an integrated activity that combines social investigation, educational work and action."
The authors examine two traditions of applied behavioral science inquiry--action research and participatory research. They argued that both espouse similar values and employ common methods in different settings.
They pointed out that action research, formulated by Lewin, which consists of cycles of analysis, fact finding, conceptualization, planning, implementation, and evaluation to simultaneously solve problems and generate new knowledge. They observed that action research took place in the Global North in business firms and educational organizations. Yet, academia social scientists had not accepted it as fully as applied researchers in organizations.
On the other hand, participatory research emerged from the work with the oppressed in the Third World, where problems of adult education and social oppression are particularly acute, in various forms, such as Freire's conscientization and other work in Africa and Asia. The international network of participatory researchers was formed in 1978 sponsored by the International Council for Adult Education. Here the characteristics of participatory research were summarized:
Hall (1981, Convergence, p.7) defined participatory research as "an integrated activity that combines social investigation, educational work and action."
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)