Saturday, February 12, 2011

The Symbolism of video

: Exploring migrant mothers' experiences. Yolanda Hernandez-Albujar. (2007). in Gregory Stanczak (2007), Visual research methods: Image, society, and representation (pp, 281-306). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

The author discussed some ethical issues involved in visual ethnographic video approach in her study of the migratory experience among Latin American mothers in Italy. She argued that the conventional ethnographic videotaping was not feasible because it could disclose identities of the participants. Thus she reconfigured the video (the title is "Voices") by incorporating related images in an experimental way to convey emotions and situations that the participants described through in-depth interviews. She wrote the final video was a practical solution to the participants' refusal to be video-recorded, and writing, "I substituted the participants' faces and their gestures and actions in front of the camera by symbols that engages metaphors of the verbal and visual narratives" (p. 291)

Finally, she discussed some limitations of her work: Although the video should represent the finding, but screening the video itself potentially limit a generation of sociological knowledge. She admitted that the video should be presented alongside with the conventional text analysis of the project for the best understanding of the project. However, she pointed out, access to visual data in publication limits video methodology in the social sciences. Video is not streamlined in the publication unlike still images, she argued.

She quoted Ken Plummer (2001, Documents of life 2, An invitation to a critical humanism) in the delayed use of video for sociology:

"[I]ndeed a whole new generation of "video" experts seems to have emerged outside of sociology to do sociology's work! There are now several generations of "video workers" who have used video as radical means of transforming the orthodox visual image and of providing a whole library of "alternative video forms." (p. 71, cited p. 303)

Photo-elicitation

Collier, Malcolm. (2007). The applied visual anthropology of John Collier: A photo essay. In Sarah Pink (Ed.), Visual intervention: Applied visual anthropology. New York, NY: Berghahn Books.

In this chapter, the author introduces some works of John Collier Jr, to whom we are indebted for the use of photography in anthropology and sociology research, in particular, photo-elicitation, a method he developed. Looking at the Vicos Project (in the mid-1950s), in which close to nine-thousand still images and hours of 16 mm films were taken in Vicos, Peru, the author wrote:

The visual ethnography was intended to provide both information for immediate use and also a baseline record for later comparative evaluation of the impact of the project. (p. 35)

The author noted that in the late 60s, John Collier turned his attention to cross-cultural schooling and at the same time, started using super 8 film equipment in response to the limitations of still photography. With this respect, the author wrote, "The shift to film placed more emphasis on observation and analysis of social interactions and process through time and space" (p. 44)

[This essay indicates that J. Collier, perhaps many others in that period, regarded visual images as a mirroring representation of the reality like a documentation]

In concluding the use of visual images by J. Collier, the author wrote:

"While in earlier years John Collier Jr's photographs were more classically documentary in character, intended to make statements to viewers for applied purposes (what I understand this term as an exploration of the potential of photos to reveal something that painting cannot do), by the 1960s they became explicitly tools for obtaining information and understanding about the circumstances in which they were made. The camera became a more systematically directed tool for data gathering and less of an expressive device. The resulting images were often less individually compelling but the collective informational content became a far more extensive and complete source of information on the circumstances in front of the lens" (p. 49)

[This indicate that the use of photos was predominantly objectivistic and positivistic. The photos were to provide vivid reality themselves. They were a tool for data gathering.]

Visusal Methods in Social Research

Banks, Marcus. (2001). London, UK: Sage.

Banks introduces ways to incorporate visual images into social science research. According to him, anthropology has been a pioneer of using visual images as a form of visual anthropology. But he noted a growing body of literature on visual research in other disciplines in social science research in 1990s, and yet, methodological insights was confined to specific areas, such as the production of ethnographic films. Thus he presents some alternative methods and some advantages of using visual images. However, this book is heavily focused on photography. Acknowledging this, Banks found an advantage of using still photos for research in its ubiquity in modern society:

Still photography is a medium available to almost everyone in the world as either producer or consumer. and examples form the use of still photography can often serve to points arising from the use of all or most visual media . . . (p. x)

About photo-elicitation:
Banks introduced photo-elicitation. "It involves using photography to invoke comments, memory and discussion in the course of a semi-structure interview" (p. 87). Photos become the basis of discussion and provoking vague memories. Collier and Collier (1986, Visual anthropology: Photography as a research method), who pioneered photo elicitation (using archival photos), pointed out that photos can contribute to lessen awkwardness that interviewees might feel: eliminating direct eye contact and awkward silence. Banks pointed out that photo-elicitation is not straightforward in practice because of issues of photographic multivocality and the complexity of relationship between photo objects and human social relations. In this light, he discussed the use of other types of photos. Further, he argued for the potential of collaborative research through photo-elicitation. He wrote:

"Rather, the introduction of photographs to interviews and conversations sets off a kind of chain reaction: the photographs effectively exercise agency, causing people to do and think things they had forgotten, or to see things they had always known in a new way, . . . (p. 98)

For Banks, the term "method" is inseparable from theory and analysis , and yet, no less important than the others, because it makes social research an "an engagement, not an exercise in data collection" (p. 179) by letting research subjects co-operate with researchers, if not participate, in the research process based on their knowledge of their lives. He implies using visual images can be one of such methods.

The last paragraph well summarizes his view of images in research:

"Images exist materially in the world, are involved in particular and specific huamn social relations. Their meanings are historically and socially embedded, told through their internal and external narratives. They have authors and consumers, they are attributed with agency and affect the agency of others. All these features are discernible, documentable, and can be isolated for analysis and comparison. The practitioners of visual social research who bemoan the lack of attention paid to their labours are, in some ways, missing the point. Visual images are ubiquitous in the lives of work of those who study and those who are studied. There is no lack of attention paid to the visual, merely a failure of perspective." (p. 179)

[Despite his beginning tone that research projects can be done without visual images, but with them research becomes different, his final tone is very strong and positive on what researchers can do with visual images.]

Sunday, January 30, 2011

Through Navajo Eyes

: An exploration in film communication and anthropology. Sol Worth & John Adair (1997). (with a new forward, afterword, and illustrations by Richard Chalfen). Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press. (Originally published 1972)

Forward to the revised edition (ix-xxi)
Chalfen describes the late 1960s and early 1970s as active times in the development of visual anthropology when the Navajo Project was carried out in 1966 (both CFC and the Fogo Island Project embarked in 1967). He noted that the change in the field of visual anthropology was accelerating in 1990s (as of writing this forward) and described one significant change: Visual products are seen as part of a process of communication and demands critical attention. Thus, more correct is anthropology of visual communication rather than visual anthropology. Chalfen ascribes the Navajo Project as a cornerstone of this reformulation. This is clear in the purpose of this project described in Chapter 15:

As we have said, one of the aims of our research was to develop a method for collecting, analyzing, and comparing how various groups and cultures structured their world when making a film about it. (p. 228)

This research was focused on a methodological development to interpret ways in which people in different cultures structure their world in particular by using film production techniques. This context constituted the particular condition of collaborative filmmaking in this project. Chalfen stated:

At this time paradigms of collaborative ethnographic film research were simply not well developed. In this sense the communication scholar Worth and the cultural anthropologist Adair were breaking new ground by suggesting an "action research" collaboration along two dimensions--first, across discipline, and second across the politically loaded divide of scholar/outsider and "native"/insider. (p. xiii)

(In this regard, Chalfen noted some philosophical and ethical issues around the idea of "handing the camera over to others": first, it is not familiar practice (at least back then--me) and it is still Western-oriented thing to force people to do.)

Chalfen categorizes several patterns of participation. The Navajo Project is in the 6th: researchers ask local people to make a movie on anything they choose. This practice, and yet, preserves objectivist attitudes: little emphasis on researchers involvement, and lack of attention to problematizing issues under investigation. On the other hand, a project that immediately followed the Navajo Project draw my attention. In 1971, Adair, approached by a psychiatrist, developed a project on Navajo alcoholism. Two films were produced and one of them was immediately lost. This approach was an advance and actual application of the method to address real problems.

Chapter 16. Some concluding thoughts (252-262)

Afterword to the revised edition (276-341)

Sunday, January 16, 2011

Familial Pursuits, Editorial Acts

: Documentaries after the Age of Home Video. Orgeron, Marsha,& Orgeron, Devin. (2007). The Velvet Light Trap, 60, 47-62.

The authors observed that a significant number of documentaries created since the 1990s took a form of autobiography, relying upon primary footage taken from home videos. Home movies in the post World War II were promoted primarily by equipment makers for documenting family life and children targeting the baby boom generation (Zimmerman). Reading Zimmerman and Chalfen, the authors summarized that those movies were focused on family togetherness and unity. Yet, with the advent of video, its affordability and simplicity, now home movies become home videography and its influence on a documentary production stream, observed the authors. They stated:

"By the 1980s and 1990s the skills—indeed, even the resources—needed to film and edit no longer appeared the exclusive province of adults, the former gatekeepers of the family iconography. Even kids could use a video camera, and a new generation of videographers was able to move outside of the parentally controlled patterns that dominated the home movie age" (p. 48).

This technology change changed ways in which a new generation of videographers describe their family portraits, the authors argued. They stated:

"homevvvideography lends itself to capturing the family in ways that are not consonant with earlier conventions of home filmmaking, earlier conventions, in fact, that occasionally appear, often by way of contrast, in these recent documentary films." (pp. 48-49)

the allure of these films partly hinges on their promise of a glimpse (p. 50) beyond the surface, an invitation to see the unlovely elements typically concealed by the curtain drawn on private lives, and that these elements are made visible especially through the documentary director’s use of primary home video footage.(p. 51)

Thursday, January 13, 2011

Video in development: FILMING FOR RURAL CHANGE

Rico Lie and Andreas Mandler (2009). CTA and FAO

NGO group who used video for development projects throughout the world. Worthwhile noting.

Wednesday, January 12, 2011

‘The Life That We Don’t Want’: Using Participatory Video in Researching Violence

Wheeler, Joanna. (2009). IDS Bulletin, 40(3), 10-18

Abstract -------
This article reports on the use of participatory video as a research tool for working in violent contexts. The research asked how people living in poor areas of Rio de Janeiro, Brazil can build a bridge between violence and citizenship through participatory social action. Working in violent favelas and housing estates, the process involved creating participatory discussion groups drawn from different segments of the community. Participatory video was one of several tools used in the research process. The main contribution of participatory video was not in generating empirical findings, but in challenging patterns of power and control--------

Wheeler more precisely repeated the last sentence: "It concludes that, while the methodological challenges are certainly more numerous and complex, participatory video was important in terms of the research process and the social action surrounding it, rather than in terms of the research findings it generated" (p. 10).

Wheeler found the root of participatory video in participatory approaches to development work in the 1970s, pioneered by Snowden in 1967. She also noted a recent trend of PV as a participatory action research tool.

Wheeler stated the advantage of using PV as strengthening the research and communication process, more specifically:

-"give participants a greater degree of control over the research process and communication of
findings, and helped build their confidence and their trust in the research process." (p. 12)
-"It also helped create an opportunity for interaction between a diverse group of people who might not otherwise have listened to each other’s perspectives on the violence which affects them all" (pp. 12-13)--catalyzing interaction.
-"A significant dimension to the role of video was the validation of people’s perspectives and views through public screenings" (p. 13)
-"It also served as a feedback mechanism for research participants. Because of their easy replicability and visual nature, the videos facilitated communication of the research beyond the group immediately involved, including dialogues with policymakers." (p. 13)
-"people were more willing to listen to what others were saying when they watched it on video than they would have in face to face encounters." (p. 13)
-"the films caught the attention of policymakers. . . . The films framed the debate in a way which would have been difficult to achieve through more conventional presentations or dialogue. As a result of the debate, the city councillor launched a programme using participatory video in over 40 communities across the city" (p. 13).

As limitation of using PV, Wheeler noted, "In a context of fear and mistrust caused by violence, the public nature of video limits what people are able to say." [THIS IS ALSO APPLICABLE TO OP RESEARCH CONTEXT] By the public nature of video, she meant ethics. Besides, Wheeler pointed out the "interviewer effect" that distorts what an interviewee say--they often say what interviewers might want to hear. More critically, video brings up another level of ethics issues. Wheeler noted:

Once the videos are made and copies distributed within the community, the video can be seen by anyone anywhere. This is very different from an interview or a questionnaire, where anonymity is more plausible. This heightens some of the risks arising from using video as a research tool on violence. (p. 14)

Wheeler called interviewee's selective topic/content a "deliberate silence" (p. 14)