Tuesday, September 6, 2011
Gentrification before gentrification: the plight of Pilsen in Chicago
Pilsen, which has home to various immigrants, became the first majority Latino community in Chicago by 1970s. According to the US census, in 2000 Pilsen was 88.9% Hispanic with 49.1% of the population foreign-born (chicagareahousing.org, 2004 cite in page 7.). Since 1980s, there have been various plans from both public and private sectors to redevelop Pilsen to transform Pilsen into the Mexican Mecca of the Midwest (p. 8). More recently, as the real estate industry entered, "the area has moved into center stage as a high stakes development gentrification prospect." (p. 8)
"For many, however, this environment is only a new chapter in the struggle against displacing redevelopment. The following chapters try to capture these tensions and the accompanying unfolding conflicts and events." (p. 9)
"The area is caught in the contradiction between developments that provide improvements intended to benefit residents, and redevelopment schemes with serious displacement impacts" (p. 12). Thus, while home owners and business owners may encourage gentrification, residents, especially renters, are particularly vulnerable to displacement.
In Pilsen, there are three types of institutions: (1) opposing (\pilsen Alliance) (2) upwardly mobile individuals seeking immediate benefits (the Hispanic Democratic Organization and United Neighborhood Organization) (3) neutral.
The author ask, "Is there room for a consensus to achieve viable development within communities that do not result in displacement?"
The author points out, "Since gentrification is a gradual process, it is almost impossible to completely reinvent the perception of place without considering the cultural context of existing residents." (p. 20). In order to transform the concept from ghetto (Pilsen was classified as slum and blight by the Chicago government in the 1970s) to some thing special, worthwhile experiencing.
Thue, "Thus, local governments and private investors often redefine place by emphasizing the existing cultural experience and local excitement. Strong ethnic identities and cultural heritages can give place a uniqueness that cannot be met by others. In this context, cultural distinction becomes a marketing tool in the quest to make areas more appealing to outside residents, developers, and businesses." \further "packaging" culture to sell outsiders, including safetyl, comfort, etc.
However, cultural heritage can be a powerful factor as a means of residents taking ownership of
their neighborhood. But the author argued that the cultural pride should be fostered through community-driven process.
The Mexican Fine Arts Museum, built in 1982 as the largest Mexican cultural center and museum in the country (City of Chicago website, 2003), many local residents feel that it was not actually created for the benefit of residents, the author pointed out. "it only serves an elitist crowd"
Fiesta del sol, annual street festival, created by Pilsen Neighbors Community Council, is decribed as a touristic place by the city.
While discontinuing transportation services to local residents, the city create free trolley services for tourists.
Contending the city's packaging culture, the author quotes:
Jeff Edwards, a professor at Roosevelt University, describes the “theme-parking” of Chicago neighborhoods as distasteful and states, “You’re taking superficial symbols from particular cultures, putting them in a cityscape and calling it ‘recognizing cultural diversity.’ It’s a fake multiculturalism. It’s about displacing citizens with shoppers and tourists” (Edwards as cited in Savage, 1999, cited in 27-28).
Betancur argued:
"Tourist initiatives can be damaging to communities, such as Pilsen, where low-income residents are struggling for resources; these resources are instead being funneled to support people who enter the community for a brief period of time, consume and absorb certain aspects of it, and then leave it to its own selfpreservation and the often polluting effects of this tourism. (p. 28)
Betacur noted the process of gentrification through artists, saying, "Observers believe that the presence of an artist community in East Pilsen makes Pilsen extremely palatable to “gentrifiers” (Puente, 1998). Gentrification has entered Pilsen through this area." small-size Redeveopment suits the need of artists who have modest income. he notes the increase household income in East Pilsen. In this light, Betancur wrote, "As in the case of marketing Pilsen’s Mexican heritage, the “artist” element has been used in the same rhetoric for several new developments throughout the area." (p. 33)
He argued, "Each of them has the ability to market various representations of culture to spark outsider intrigue." (p.34) and wrote, "for a long time Pilsen has been subjected to steady
pressures of upward development coming mostly from the “outside. ... Several other initiatives mentioned earlier also constitute attempts to develop Pilsen without any local input. Importantly, however, these initiatives have met (p. 35) with unprecedented deliberate community action to thwart development and maintain the community’s ethnic heritage and self-determination." (p. 36), although there were some community-based resistance to fail some of the city plans, inspiring to organize community activists
He pointed out community murals as a form of resistance. But ironically, it becomes touristic attractions.
Most Pilsen organizations favor “Development without Displacement". The concept advanced in a Voorhees study for the Chicago Rehab Network (Betancur et al. 1995) offers policy solutions to thwart displacement in Chicago’s gentrifying areas. It suggests that there is a need for a strong community voice to bring the issue of displacement to the forefront of development policy. (p. 45)
Betancur sharply pointed out the discourse surrounding development:
"Agents and supporters of gentrification came up with their own version that appropriated the discourse of ethnicity and reorganized it around neo-liberal ideas of entrepreneurship and commodification of culture and ethnicity. This is a clear case of identity as a source of community and resistance vying against identity as a marketable commodity and penetration tool.' (p. 66)
He concludes, "Gentrification has advanced subtly in this side of Pilsen: eastern census tracts are undergoing a change with a decreasing Latino and foreign-born presence and decreasing household densities, increasing incomes, home ownership rates, home values and rents, and new residential construction" (p. 67)
Gentrification-Caused Displacement
1. This study indicates a great deal of gentrification-caused displacement.
2.Displacement imposes hardships especially on lower income households and elderly.
notes, "rent always increases, modestly for some households, but substantially for others." (p. 54)
They note that the outmovers are indeed diverse in terms of race, age, family structure, occupation, income, much wider range than inmovers. The first generation of gentrification affect lower class white, but recent gentrification-caused displacement document substantical rancial, class and lifestyle conflicts in gentrifying neighborhoods, indicating an increasing number of other minorities affected by gentrification. They also note increasing violence in gentrifying neighborhoods.
Outmovers tend to cluster close to their prior residences, with almost always experiencing rent increase.
Friday, July 29, 2011
Institutional review boards and methodological conservatism
: The challenge to and from phenomenological paradigms. Yvonna S. Lincoln (2008). In N. Denzin & Y. Lincoln (Eds.), The landscape of qualitative research (pp. 221-244). Thousand Oaks, London, New Dehli and Singapore: Sage.
Lincoln argued that the current wind toward methodological conservatism proliferated in the name of evidence-based research or scientifically based educational research not only has brought about overall increased scrutiny over research involved human subjects, in particular, researchers and doctoral students who are involved in ethnography or participatory action research, but also, more critically, has contributed to shaping legitimate forms of scientific inquiry.
She pointed out the backlash of the conservatism, reflected in the NCR report Scientific Research in Education (2002):
1. It contributes to "narrowing the range of what is to be considered 'scientific,' effectively shutting out of the scientific community a wide rage of critical and alternate epistemology researcher" (p. 171)
2. The NCR report "lends support to IRBs in their attempts to limit the range of activities that researchers can undertake with human subjects" (p. 171-172). She noted, "IRBs are rarely favorably disposed toward emergent research methods, paradigms, and methodologies (e.g., action research, participatory action research, constructivist inquiries, qualitative studies), especially when these boards are constituted primarily of hard scientists and experimentalist, as they have traditionally been" (p. 172)
3. By defining "scientific," it supports criticism of critical inquiry and limits academic diversity and openness.
4. It directly and indirectly limits "discussions on individual campuses concerning what constitutes disciplined scientific inquiry and, therefore, what studies are approved by IRBs and which researchers find that their academic freedom to engage in significant research on social problems may be curtailed or abrogated altogether" (p. 173). In this sense, Lincoln stated that the NRC report act as a type of "political barometer" (p. 173).
Lincoln defined methodological conservatism as a mechanism that governs research practices "by prescribing a set of practices that are to be considered normative and standard, and relegating all others to subsidiary statue, frequently with the threat of disapproval" and regulates research "by ensuring conformity to certain sets of practices and discouraging nonconformity by dismissing some forms of inquiry as 'dangerous,' 'unscientific.' or harmful to the institution" (p. 174). Lincoln pointed out that in the name of protecting the institution's reputation and integrity, institutional ethics review processes shy away from the purposes of the IRB, that is, "to ensure freedom from harm for human subjects, to establish the likelihood of beneficence for a large group (of similar research participants), and to ensure that subjects' consent to participate in the research is fully and authentically informed" (p. 174).
Lincoln pointed out that IRBs sometimes improperly review students' proposals using more participatory methodologies by reviewing them with inappropriate criteria in mind, and also, such criteria threaten academic freedom by limiting the models and methodologies that academic believe to be the most efficacious for answering certain questions.
Tuesday, July 12, 2011
Alternative Media as Critical Media
Fuchs critically examines Habermas's public sphere in that it addresses only bourgeois communication sphere and proposes alternative media as critical media. His approach is described as:
Herbert Marcuse (1978) argues that art can only be a societal factor as autonomous art. Art would be a part of society, but one that transcends capitalist society by constituting an autonomous sphere of aesthetical forms that transcend capitalism. The beauty of art is not a portrayal of society as it is, but a metaphor for society as it could be. The notion of the autonomy and functionless character of art that Adorno and Marcuse described can be generalized not just for art, but for all alternative media products (including also expression in the area of popular culture, not just the high arts). Alternative media at the form level of the products have a radical potential if they transcend their societal context and have the potential to subvert experience. In the case of critical forms, the subversion of the experience of capitalism is an indirect one, in the case of critical content it is a more direct one. (p. 188)
Marcuse, Herbert. (1978) The Aesthetic Dimension. Boston: Beacon Press.
Wednesday, June 29, 2011
The story they want to tell, and the visual story as evidence
the education and health domains. LYN YATES. (2010). Visual Studies, Vol. 25, No. 3, December 2010. 280-291. DOI: 10.1080/1472586X.2010.523281
She talks about the contention around voice. In particular, stressing the emphasis on voice as a window to the world of the young people, compared with voice as a window to ‘who I am’. (--> Read more)
Wednesday, June 22, 2011
VIA's visual voices: the awareness of a dedicated audience for voices in patient video narratives
First the authors examine the concept of ‘voice’ in one
model of participant media research (PMR) giving special
attention to parallel variables of hearing, begging questions
about the ‘listening’ component of any communication
process. Second, they describe the use of a research
programme entitled Video Intervention/Prevention
Assessment (VIA) and a series of ongoing video narrative
projects with chronically ill young people at Children’s
Hospital Boston. Young people were asked to show how
they see their own illness-centred lives by using videocam
technology. Third, ‘visual voices’ as found on the videotape
results are examined through Thompson’s five kinds of
voice used by participants living with spina bifida, cystic
fibrosis and, in one case, obesity. We conclude that
knowledge and anticipation of what we have termed
‘a dedicated audience’ is one of the primary variables
in the elicitation of voice and the overall value of
participant media research.
Describing their approach to research as participant media research, in which participants (patients with chronic illness) record themselves in front of a video camera for several weeks once a day, the authors concluded that the patient narratives reveal the complexity of voice. Further they argued that a "dedicated audience" makes such voice more recognizable through the PMR. Stressing the importance of listeners and viewer in PMR, they argued:
"We conclude that knowledge and anticipation of
what we have termed ‘a dedicated audience’ is one of the
primary variables in the success of participant media
research. We found that patients are especially enthusiastic
about engaging in participatory media research when they
sense a concerned audience awaits their tele-presence.
Participants develop an altruistic spirit and tone based on
knowing that ‘my’ knowledge, often grounded in ‘my’
personal life experience, is important and valuable to others
and to the potential improvement of personal care, medical
treatment and even survival." (p. 209).
** Mitchell (2008) South African Journal of Education Vol 28:365-383
"Getting the picture and changing the picture: visual
methodologies and educational research in South Africa"
She also similarly argued that "Visual images are particularly appropriate to drawing in the participants themselves as central to the interpretive process." (p. 374) because of its enhanced accessibility.
Monday, June 20, 2011
Ethical and methodological issues in engaging young people living in poverty with participatory research methods
The author discussed the dilemmas that she encountered when conducting research with children and young people in deprived areas. Argued for the importance of establishing rapport, Sime stressed, "In relation to conducting research in young people’s homes, researchers need to be prepared to be flexible in terms of collecting data and ready to make ethical decisions during as well as before entering the field." (p. 76). She stressed the idea against considering research ethics as a pre-stage field work, it has to be considered throughout and also after research in representing the participants' views in integrity.