Wednesday, September 7, 2011

THE DIFFERENTIAL IMPACT OF GENTRIFICATION ON COMMUNITIES IN CHICAGO

Philip Nyden, Emily Edlynn, and Julie Davis. (2006). Center for Urban Research and Learning.
Loyola University Chicago, For the City of Chicago Commission on Human Relations

Today’s Pilsen is synonymous with Mexican and Mexican-American culture,


Describing the resistance of Pilsen residents against gentrification attempts

"while Latino community leaders in some heavily-immigrant communities may not be feeling “left behind,” they fear that they will be “pushed out” as gentrification and displacement threatens their own residential stability . Some leaders in Pilsen are fighting the development being subsidized by TIF funds because it is “not necessarily geared toward” the Mexican and Mexican American residents currently living in Pilsen and Little Village. Residents there have protested development plans, which include condos and other luxury housing in the community that have the potential to increase housing costs and property taxes. Expansion of the University of Illinois Chicago campus into the northern edge of this Latino community has met with similar protests." (p. 29)

This paper points out some of the most vulnerable populations: women with children, the disabled, the homeless, the elderly,


"Many of our respondents identified women as a population that is most negatively affected by the cycle of gentrification and displacement, particularly single women with children... Because women and single-parents do not necessarily visibly cluster into particular neighborhoods, their needs are not always front and center." (p. 35)

They pointed out that the homeless population has been even more dramatically affected. Further, social service agencies themselves become the target of complaint from new comers:

"Churches and social service agencies that had been providing housing and social services to the homeless for years find themselves the targets of newcomers to the community who equate low-income with “criminal” and “undesirable.” One focus group participant claimed these “gentrifiers” are targeting social services to force the displacement of the poor and that she has
received petitions they have signed with pleas to the City to “stop funding social services in Uptown, there’s too many poor people here.”" (p. 36)

This paper again recommends that the city or developers should better communicate with residents, adopt adult community service curriculum to facilitate more inter-racial, interethnic,
and inter-group understanding and interaction; creating new or imporiving existing mechanisms for community voice.