Thursday, November 3, 2011

Feminist Research

: exploring the interconnections of epistemology, methodology, and method. Hesse-Biber, Sharlene Nagy (2007). Handbook of feminist research: Theory and praxis (pp. 1-17). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

Hesse-Biber examines feminist research historically and across disciplines and addresses critical points of feminist research in the frameworks of critical theory grounded in the experience of the oppressed, postmodern theories, which commonly draw on difference.

Drawing on Sandra Harding (1993) and Lorrain Code (1991), Hesse-Biber defined reflexivity as a defining feature of feminist research:

"Through disclosing their values, attitudes, and biases in their approach to particular research questions and in engaging in strong reflexivity throughout the research process, feminist researchers can actually improve objectivity of the research." (p. 10)

More clearly, Hesse-Biber defined reflexivity as a "process, whereby researchers recognize, examine, and understand how their social background, location, and assumptions affect their research practice. Practicing reflexivity also includes paying attention to the specific ways in which our own agendas affect the research at all points in the process--from the selection of the research problem to the selection of method and ways in which we analyze and interpret our findings." (pp. 16-17).

REFLEXIVITY is defined as a process that researchers should take on. How is it related to participatory video? Participant researchers should be conscious of the methods they take, their subjective involvement at all? In PV, it aims to bring about participants' subjective involvement. It makes this explicit, while the predominant discourse of reflexivity calls for recognizing and consciously examining it within researchers. Reflexivity means different things in two different contexts. How should it be addressed and be more explicit? How researchers should think of this issue when they take on participatory research?

Wednesday, October 19, 2011

Recording social life: Reflexivity and video methodology

Lomax, H., Casey, N. (1998). Sociological Research Online, 3(2), xiii-xiv.

The authors rejects two streams of using video data: one as a replica of unrecorded event and the other as a distorting effect on the researched phenomenon. They argue that a reflexive analysis of video data is essential because the activity of data collection itself is interactive (i am not sure what this means). In this light, they argue, video generated data should be analyzed by providing a faithful record of the process in which interaction occurs.

Thursday, September 22, 2011

Volunteer sampling

Based on Rosenthal and Rosnow (1975):

Cates, W. (1985). A practical guide to educational research. Prentice-Hall, inc. (55-64)

Something to consider when doing volunteer sampling:

1. better educated than nonvolunteers
2. higher social class
3. more intelligent
4. more unconventional
5. females than male
6. less authoritarian
7. more interested in the topic under investigation than nonvolunteers

Wednesday, September 7, 2011

Successful protect-community discourse

:spatiality and politics in Chicago's Pilsen neighborhood.
David Wilson, Jared Wouters, & Dennis Grammenos. (2004). Environment and Planning A, 36, 1173-1190. DOI:10.1068/a36121

The authors note Pilsen as one nationally notable case where gentrification continues to be successfully resisted by residents. They pointed out positive resident identities, and clear enemies of the current neighborhood as the main reasons.

Also, they pointed out the discourse that PPC (Protect Pilsen Coalition) promoted as one of the causes: promoting the current idealized Pilsen, a unique sense of community, and arguing for protecting the timeless and ideal ethnic space from outsiders, to the contrary to the comment by developers, describing Pilsen as a crime-riddern slum.
[DOES THIS DISCOURSE by PPC hide crime? Or crime was overrated?]

Meanwhile, local governments see Pilsen as a potential for making the city a diverse ethnic city.

"preserving this ethnicity is the key. It is our job to identify [this], capture [this], and sell [this]''
(discussion with the Office of Tourism representative Patricia Sullivan, 8 July 2002, cited on page 1186).

THE PILSEN BUILDING INVENTORY PROJECT

Winifred Curran and Euan Hague
DePaul University, Department of Geography

Introduction to the project

An extensive and systematic community mapping project was undertaken to produce a database of current building conditions and publicly available information on building permits, property taxes, assessed values, property sales, and ownership. This report provides the results of that project, with data collected by DePaul students over two years, from Fall 2004 to Spring 2006. 5002 lots are in the database.

Gentrification

The authors noted that " Its proximity to the Loop, old buildings and historic designation, and
relatively low rents have resulted in Pilsen becoming ripe for gentrification at the start of the 21st century." (p. 4)

Urban planner Peter Marcuse (1999: 790-1) defines gentrification as, “the movement into a previously working-class area by upperincome households, generally professionals, managers, technicians, the new gentry, resulting in the displacement of the former lower-income residents.” (p. 4)

On the eastern side of Pilsen, around one hundred buildings are owned by the Podmajersky family who have been attempting to transform the area into an artists district since the 1950s (Isaacs, 2003). These plans have met with repeated opposition from local residents whose articulation of an anti-gentrification position Wilson et al. (2004: 1173) identify as a “protect-community discourse.” (p. 5)

*

Marcuse, Peter. 1999. Comment of Elvin K. Wyly and Daniel J. Hammel’s “Islands of decay in seas of renewal: Housing policy and the resurgence of gentrification” Housing Policy Debate 10 (4): 789-797.

Isaacs, Deanna. 2003. East Pilsen’s makeover. Chicago Reader, 12 December.

Wilson, David; Wouters, Jared and Grammenos, Dennis. 2004. Successful ‘protect-community’ discourse: spatiality and politics in Chicago’s Pilsen neighborhood. Environment and Planning A, 36, 1173-1190.

THE DIFFERENTIAL IMPACT OF GENTRIFICATION ON COMMUNITIES IN CHICAGO

Philip Nyden, Emily Edlynn, and Julie Davis. (2006). Center for Urban Research and Learning.
Loyola University Chicago, For the City of Chicago Commission on Human Relations

Today’s Pilsen is synonymous with Mexican and Mexican-American culture,


Describing the resistance of Pilsen residents against gentrification attempts

"while Latino community leaders in some heavily-immigrant communities may not be feeling “left behind,” they fear that they will be “pushed out” as gentrification and displacement threatens their own residential stability . Some leaders in Pilsen are fighting the development being subsidized by TIF funds because it is “not necessarily geared toward” the Mexican and Mexican American residents currently living in Pilsen and Little Village. Residents there have protested development plans, which include condos and other luxury housing in the community that have the potential to increase housing costs and property taxes. Expansion of the University of Illinois Chicago campus into the northern edge of this Latino community has met with similar protests." (p. 29)

This paper points out some of the most vulnerable populations: women with children, the disabled, the homeless, the elderly,


"Many of our respondents identified women as a population that is most negatively affected by the cycle of gentrification and displacement, particularly single women with children... Because women and single-parents do not necessarily visibly cluster into particular neighborhoods, their needs are not always front and center." (p. 35)

They pointed out that the homeless population has been even more dramatically affected. Further, social service agencies themselves become the target of complaint from new comers:

"Churches and social service agencies that had been providing housing and social services to the homeless for years find themselves the targets of newcomers to the community who equate low-income with “criminal” and “undesirable.” One focus group participant claimed these “gentrifiers” are targeting social services to force the displacement of the poor and that she has
received petitions they have signed with pleas to the City to “stop funding social services in Uptown, there’s too many poor people here.”" (p. 36)

This paper again recommends that the city or developers should better communicate with residents, adopt adult community service curriculum to facilitate more inter-racial, interethnic,
and inter-group understanding and interaction; creating new or imporiving existing mechanisms for community voice.

IN THE FACE OF GENTRIFICATION:

Case Studies of Local Efforts to Mitigate Displacement.
Diane K. Levy, Jennifer Comey, Sandra Padilla (2006). [White paper]. Washington, DC:
Metropolitan Housing and Communities Policy Center, the Urban Institute.

This paper defined getrification as “the process whereby higher-income households move into low-income neighborhoods, escalating the area’s property values to the point that displacement occurs." (p. 1). It points out revitalization as the first stage of one of the earliest sign of gentrification, writing:

Neighborhoods showing signs of revitalization with the possibility of future gentrification—evidence of housing improvements and increased housing prices in an area proximate to other gentrifying neighborhoods—are characterized as the early stage. (p. 2)

The gentrification of Uptown

A highlighted program is "Chicago Partnership for Affordable Neighborhoods (CPAN), which was implemented citywide in 2001. CPAN is a voluntary program where developers and aldermen from each ward determine the number of affordable units, if any, developers will set aside in their market-rate developments. ...
While CPAN is a citywide program, it is at the discretion of each alderman whether developers must participate.
...
Another problem inherent in a voluntary program is whether developers will choose to participate or take their business elsewhere. Aldermen have leverage only if the developer needs zoning approval. (p. 71)

With this respect, the authors noted that "some developers believe that only elected official’s support is necessary to approve housing development" (p. 72), emphasizing that residents can organize around issues. (But how? Did the gentrification occur because of lack of residents resistance or grassroots organization?)

Tuesday, September 6, 2011

Gentrification before gentrification: the plight of Pilsen in Chicago

Betancur, John. (2005). research white paper. Urban planning and Policy Program, UIC.

Pilsen, which has home to various immigrants, became the first majority Latino community in Chicago by 1970s. According to the US census, in 2000 Pilsen was 88.9% Hispanic with 49.1% of the population foreign-born (chicagareahousing.org, 2004 cite in page 7.). Since 1980s, there have been various plans from both public and private sectors to redevelop Pilsen to transform Pilsen into the Mexican Mecca of the Midwest (p. 8). More recently, as the real estate industry entered, "the area has moved into center stage as a high stakes development gentrification prospect." (p. 8)

"For many, however, this environment is only a new chapter in the struggle against displacing redevelopment. The following chapters try to capture these tensions and the accompanying unfolding conflicts and events." (p. 9)

"The area is caught in the contradiction between developments that provide improvements intended to benefit residents, and redevelopment schemes with serious displacement impacts" (p. 12). Thus, while home owners and business owners may encourage gentrification, residents, especially renters, are particularly vulnerable to displacement.

In Pilsen, there are three types of institutions: (1) opposing (\pilsen Alliance) (2) upwardly mobile individuals seeking immediate benefits (the Hispanic Democratic Organization and United Neighborhood Organization) (3) neutral.

The author ask, "Is there room for a consensus to achieve viable development within communities that do not result in displacement?"

The author points out, "Since gentrification is a gradual process, it is almost impossible to completely reinvent the perception of place without considering the cultural context of existing residents." (p. 20). In order to transform the concept from ghetto (Pilsen was classified as slum and blight by the Chicago government in the 1970s) to some thing special, worthwhile experiencing.

Thue, "Thus, local governments and private investors often redefine place by emphasizing the existing cultural experience and local excitement. Strong ethnic identities and cultural heritages can give place a uniqueness that cannot be met by others. In this context, cultural distinction becomes a marketing tool in the quest to make areas more appealing to outside residents, developers, and businesses." \further "packaging" culture to sell outsiders, including safetyl, comfort, etc.

However, cultural heritage can be a powerful factor as a means of residents taking ownership of
their neighborhood. But the author argued that the cultural pride should be fostered through community-driven process.

The Mexican Fine Arts Museum, built in 1982 as the largest Mexican cultural center and museum in the country (City of Chicago website, 2003), many local residents feel that it was not actually created for the benefit of residents, the author pointed out. "it only serves an elitist crowd"

Fiesta del sol, annual street festival, created by Pilsen Neighbors Community Council, is decribed as a touristic place by the city.

While discontinuing transportation services to local residents, the city create free trolley services for tourists.

Contending the city's packaging culture, the author quotes:

Jeff Edwards, a professor at Roosevelt University, describes the “theme-parking” of Chicago neighborhoods as distasteful and states, “You’re taking superficial symbols from particular cultures, putting them in a cityscape and calling it ‘recognizing cultural diversity.’ It’s a fake multiculturalism. It’s about displacing citizens with shoppers and tourists” (Edwards as cited in Savage, 1999, cited in 27-28).

Betancur argued:

"Tourist initiatives can be damaging to communities, such as Pilsen, where low-income residents are struggling for resources; these resources are instead being funneled to support people who enter the community for a brief period of time, consume and absorb certain aspects of it, and then leave it to its own selfpreservation and the often polluting effects of this tourism. (p. 28)

Betacur noted the process of gentrification through artists, saying, "Observers believe that the presence of an artist community in East Pilsen makes Pilsen extremely palatable to “gentrifiers” (Puente, 1998). Gentrification has entered Pilsen through this area." small-size Redeveopment suits the need of artists who have modest income. he notes the increase household income in East Pilsen. In this light, Betancur wrote, "As in the case of marketing Pilsen’s Mexican heritage, the “artist” element has been used in the same rhetoric for several new developments throughout the area." (p. 33)

He argued, "Each of them has the ability to market various representations of culture to spark outsider intrigue." (p.34) and wrote, "for a long time Pilsen has been subjected to steady
pressures of upward development coming mostly from the “outside. ... Several other initiatives mentioned earlier also constitute attempts to develop Pilsen without any local input. Importantly, however, these initiatives have met (p. 35) with unprecedented deliberate community action to thwart development and maintain the community’s ethnic heritage and self-determination." (p. 36), although there were some community-based resistance to fail some of the city plans, inspiring to organize community activists

He pointed out community murals as a form of resistance. But ironically, it becomes touristic attractions.

Most Pilsen organizations favor “Development without Displacement". The concept advanced in a Voorhees study for the Chicago Rehab Network (Betancur et al. 1995) offers policy solutions to thwart displacement in Chicago’s gentrifying areas. It suggests that there is a need for a strong community voice to bring the issue of displacement to the forefront of development policy. (p. 45)

Betancur sharply pointed out the discourse surrounding development:

"Agents and supporters of gentrification came up with their own version that appropriated the discourse of ethnicity and reorganized it around neo-liberal ideas of entrepreneurship and commodification of culture and ethnicity. This is a clear case of identity as a source of community and resistance vying against identity as a marketable commodity and penetration tool.' (p. 66)


He concludes, "Gentrification has advanced subtly in this side of Pilsen: eastern census tracts are undergoing a change with a decreasing Latino and foreign-born presence and decreasing household densities, increasing incomes, home ownership rates, home values and rents, and new residential construction" (p. 67)

Gentrification-Caused Displacement

LeGates, Richard, T. & Hartman, Chester. (1982). The Urban Lawyer, 14, 31-55.

1. This study indicates a great deal of gentrification-caused displacement.
2.Displacement imposes hardships especially on lower income households and elderly.
notes, "rent always increases, modestly for some households, but substantially for others." (p. 54)

They note that the outmovers are indeed diverse in terms of race, age, family structure, occupation, income, much wider range than inmovers. The first generation of gentrification affect lower class white, but recent gentrification-caused displacement document substantical rancial, class and lifestyle conflicts in gentrifying neighborhoods, indicating an increasing number of other minorities affected by gentrification. They also note increasing violence in gentrifying neighborhoods.

Outmovers tend to cluster close to their prior residences, with almost always experiencing rent increase.

Friday, July 29, 2011

Institutional review boards and methodological conservatism

: The challenge to and from phenomenological paradigms. Yvonna S. Lincoln (2008). In N. Denzin & Y. Lincoln (Eds.), The landscape of qualitative research (pp. 221-244). Thousand Oaks, London, New Dehli and Singapore: Sage.


Lincoln argued that the current wind toward methodological conservatism proliferated in the name of evidence-based research or scientifically based educational research not only has brought about overall increased scrutiny over research involved human subjects, in particular, researchers and doctoral students who are involved in ethnography or participatory action research, but also, more critically, has contributed to shaping legitimate forms of scientific inquiry.



She pointed out the backlash of the conservatism, reflected in the NCR report Scientific Research in Education (2002):


1. It contributes to "narrowing the range of what is to be considered 'scientific,' effectively shutting out of the scientific community a wide rage of critical and alternate epistemology researcher" (p. 171)

2. The NCR report "lends support to IRBs in their attempts to limit the range of activities that researchers can undertake with human subjects" (p. 171-172). She noted, "IRBs are rarely favorably disposed toward emergent research methods, paradigms, and methodologies (e.g., action research, participatory action research, constructivist inquiries, qualitative studies), especially when these boards are constituted primarily of hard scientists and experimentalist, as they have traditionally been" (p. 172)

3. By defining "scientific," it supports criticism of critical inquiry and limits academic diversity and openness.

4. It directly and indirectly limits "discussions on individual campuses concerning what constitutes disciplined scientific inquiry and, therefore, what studies are approved by IRBs and which researchers find that their academic freedom to engage in significant research on social problems may be curtailed or abrogated altogether" (p. 173). In this sense, Lincoln stated that the NRC report act as a type of "political barometer" (p. 173).


Lincoln defined methodological conservatism as a mechanism that governs research practices "by prescribing a set of practices that are to be considered normative and standard, and relegating all others to subsidiary statue, frequently with the threat of disapproval" and regulates research "by ensuring conformity to certain sets of practices and discouraging nonconformity by dismissing some forms of inquiry as 'dangerous,' 'unscientific.' or harmful to the institution" (p. 174). Lincoln pointed out that in the name of protecting the institution's reputation and integrity, institutional ethics review processes shy away from the purposes of the IRB, that is, "to ensure freedom from harm for human subjects, to establish the likelihood of beneficence for a large group (of similar research participants), and to ensure that subjects' consent to participate in the research is fully and authentically informed" (p. 174).


Lincoln pointed out that IRBs sometimes improperly review students' proposals using more participatory methodologies by reviewing them with inappropriate criteria in mind, and also, such criteria threaten academic freedom by limiting the models and methodologies that academic believe to be the most efficacious for answering certain questions.



Tuesday, July 12, 2011

Alternative Media as Critical Media

Christian Fuchs (2010). European Journal of Social Theory, 13, 173-192 .DOI: 10.1177/1368431010362294

Fuchs critically examines Habermas's public sphere in that it addresses only bourgeois communication sphere and proposes alternative media as critical media. His approach is described as:

Herbert Marcuse (1978) argues that art can only be a societal factor as autonomous art. Art would be a part of society, but one that transcends capitalist society by constituting an autonomous sphere of aesthetical forms that transcend capitalism. The beauty of art is not a portrayal of society as it is, but a metaphor for society as it could be. The notion of the autonomy and functionless character of art that Adorno and Marcuse described can be generalized not just for art, but for all alternative media products (including also expression in the area of popular culture, not just the high arts). Alternative media at the form level of the products have a radical potential if they transcend their societal context and have the potential to subvert experience. In the case of critical forms, the subversion of the experience of capitalism is an indirect one, in the case of critical content it is a more direct one. (p. 188)

Marcuse, Herbert. (1978) The Aesthetic Dimension. Boston: Beacon Press.

Wednesday, June 29, 2011

The story they want to tell, and the visual story as evidence

: Young people, research authority and research purposes in
the education and health domains. LYN YATES. (2010). Visual Studies, Vol. 25, No. 3, December 2010. 280-291. DOI: 10.1080/1472586X.2010.523281

She talks about the contention around voice. In particular, stressing the emphasis on voice as a window to the world of the young people, compared with voice as a window to ‘who I am’. (--> Read more)

Wednesday, June 22, 2011

VIA's visual voices: the awareness of a dedicated audience for voices in patient video narratives

Richard Chalfen; Laura Sherman; Michael Rich (2010). Visual Studies, 25: 3, 201 — 209. doi: 10.1080/1472586X.2010.523271

First the authors examine the concept of ‘voice’ in one
model of participant media research (PMR) giving special
attention to parallel variables of hearing, begging questions
about the ‘listening’ component of any communication
process. Second, they describe the use of a research
programme entitled Video Intervention/Prevention
Assessment (VIA) and a series of ongoing video narrative
projects with chronically ill young people at Children’s
Hospital Boston. Young people were asked to show how
they see their own illness-centred lives by using videocam
technology. Third, ‘visual voices’ as found on the videotape
results are examined through Thompson’s five kinds of
voice used by participants living with spina bifida, cystic
fibrosis and, in one case, obesity. We conclude that
knowledge and anticipation of what we have termed
‘a dedicated audience’ is one of the primary variables
in the elicitation of voice and the overall value of
participant media research.


Describing their approach to research as participant media research, in which participants (patients with chronic illness) record themselves in front of a video camera for several weeks once a day, the authors concluded that the patient narratives reveal the complexity of voice. Further they argued that a "dedicated audience" makes such voice more recognizable through the PMR. Stressing the importance of listeners and viewer in PMR, they argued:

"We conclude that knowledge and anticipation of
what we have termed ‘a dedicated audience’ is one of the
primary variables in the success of participant media
research. We found that patients are especially enthusiastic
about engaging in participatory media research when they
sense a concerned audience awaits their tele-presence.
Participants develop an altruistic spirit and tone based on
knowing that ‘my’ knowledge, often grounded in ‘my’
personal life experience, is important and valuable to others
and to the potential improvement of personal care, medical
treatment and even survival." (p. 209).

** Mitchell (2008) South African Journal of Education Vol 28:365-383
"Getting the picture and changing the picture: visual
methodologies and educational research in South Africa"

She also similarly argued that "Visual images are particularly appropriate to drawing in the participants themselves as central to the interpretive process." (p. 374) because of its enhanced accessibility.

Monday, June 20, 2011

Ethical and methodological issues in engaging young people living in poverty with participatory research methods

Daniela Sime. (2008). Children’s Geographies, 6(1), 63–78.

The author discussed the dilemmas that she encountered when conducting research with children and young people in deprived areas. Argued for the importance of establishing rapport, Sime stressed, "In relation to conducting research in young people’s homes, researchers need to be prepared to be flexible in terms of collecting data and ready to make ethical decisions during as well as before entering the field." (p. 76). She stressed the idea against considering research ethics as a pre-stage field work, it has to be considered throughout and also after research in representing the participants' views in integrity.

''Dreaming of . . . '': Reflections on Participatory Action Research as a Feminist Praxis of Critical Hope

Caitlin Cahill, David Alberto Quijada Cerecer and Matt Bradley. (2010). Affilia, 25(4), 406-416. DOI: 10.1177/0886109910384576

This article is about university faculty members' critical engagement in community-based PAR and activism with the youth in Utah. The authors develop their position in undertaking this research project from the basis of a feminist praxis of "an ethic of care, in which primacy is placed on relationships and the responsibilities involved in working with rather than for communities" (p. 407).

Sunday, May 8, 2011

On not talking to strangers

: Researching micro worlds of girls through visual auto-ethnographic practices. Gerry Bloustien and Sarah Baker. (2003). Social Analysis, 47(3), 64-79.

Bloustien: ten 15 years old girls for three years. video cameras.
Baker: pre-teen aged girls (8-11), mainly still cameras.

In these research project, the cameras offered the girls a "space to play" (p. 69). [They named auto-visual ethnography]

The authors wrote about the role of the cameras:

"For the girls, the cameras became ways of interpreting and redefining their worlds, ways which frequently expressed far more than the girls were capable of saying, for often it was what was not said that was important." (p. 69).

"Clearly, then, the use of the camera as a methodological tool, and more importantly, placed in the hands and under the control of the young participants, deepened and precipitated a number of previously unforeseen dimensions to the research project." (p. 69)

Authors discussed about camera power arguing that "the camera was so successfully and so efficaciously an entry point into the field across different social domains and locales" (p. 70).

1. It allowed the girls to become active participants as they can control over the final product.
2. It provides researchers with positive dimensions of the research: it fosters reciprocity as the participants are exciting about learning new skills. This aspect is considered "ethical" by the researchers because it balances power relationship involved between researchers and participants [Give and take]

Rethinking of power imbalance, the authors wrote:

3. "What was clear, though, was that the cameras did give the young people license to explore these places of play through the 'objectifying' lens, a license which, in turn, helped to blur the more traditional lines between researcher and researched, and offered new insights about the nature of research." (p. 72).

4. The authors argued that "the use of the camera was able to provide the means of giving the participants an authoritative voice" (p. 72). This implies that the use of the camera was not for reflect reality but for "making the process of mutual discovery and creativity of both the researcher and subjects more transparent" (p. 72). The authors rephrased, "the camera offered insights into the 'layering' of ethnography, the different ways understanding and knowledge are negotiated and realized as part of everyday transactions in the world" (p. 72) . [CREATION OF REALITY]

This layering aspect was the focus of their research projects; they also purposefully examined what is not taken. Thus what mattered to these authors is:

"The point, then, is not what is produced with the visual tool, but how the production relates to the position occupied by the producer in the particular field of that production" (p. 76).

GIRL MAKING: A CROSSCULTURAL ETHNOGRAPHY ON THE PROCESSES OF GROWING UP FEMALE

Gerry Bloustein (2003). Oxford: Berghahn Books

This book describes her ethnographic research on girlhood. The research methods include in-depth interviews with her subjects and reviewing videos created by teen-aged girls.

Introduction: Envisioning ethnography

-Exploring the meaning of the visual in research. Gerry Bloustein (2003). Social Analysis, 47(3), 1-7.

Visual images in the forms of photographs, video, film, and new media have become important to ethnographic endeavors and all of the social sciences (She cited from Banks, 2001).

In the use of the camera for recording oneself, Bloustein wrote:

For it the camera seems to objectify, it can also subjectify. The taking and revisiting of a photo or video of oneself become analogous to the way Lacan has described the dream state of "seeing ourselves seeing ourselves" (Lacan 1979: 74, quote in Sanders 1980:1). No wonder the camera and related visual images increasingly find themselves at the heart of ethnographic research. (p. 2)

Introducing Bloustein's and Baker's work with video projects to which girls were invited to record their daily lives to investigate young girls' developing sense of self from their own perspectives and their relations and negotiations with various institutions, Bloustein described:

"Initially, the cameras were conceived of as an innovative solution to the extreme difficulties of entering, or at least having regular and comfortable access to groups that, almost by definition, would be closed to an adult researcher, but quickly, it was realized that the cameras in both projects took on a far more complex role in the research process." (p. 6)

Thursday, April 28, 2011

Transformative research and evaluation

Mertens, Donna M. (2009). New York, NY: Guilford.

Introduction (1-7)
Mertens earlier noted four dominant paradigms in educational and psychological research: positivism, constructivism, pragmatism and emancipatory. In this text, he renamed emancipatory to transformative to emphasize working together with people for personal and social transformation. In this context, he discussed the transformative paradigm as "an overarching metaphysical framework" (3) to cover various approaches labeled critical theory, feminist theory, participatory, inclusive, culturally responsive, etc. that aim to furthering social justice through research and evaluation. [Here Mertens mentions research and evaluation together. I wonder what is difference. Perhaps it is the use of terms. Research is often referred to activities of seeking knowledge for the sake of knowledge while evaluation as more practical, but knowledge-for the sake of knowledge is not practical in particular in the domain of the transformative paradigm. In a sense, research is part of evaluation.]

1. Resilience, resistance, and complexities that challenge (9-42)

Mertens wrote for the foci of the transformative paradigm:

"Rather, the paradigm focuses on culturally appropriate strategies to facilitate understandings that will create sustainable social change. Understanding the dynamics of power and privilege and how they can be challenged in the status quo is also a priory" (10)

In this light, she emphasized participatory approaches to research and evaluation and stressed the potential role of the researcher or evaluator as an "instrument of social change" (11).

Mertens wrote, "Participatory action research is one example of an approach that is compatible with the transformative paradigm when it is applied to the goal of social justice" (21).

Mertens discussed ethical impetus. Looking at the Belmont report from the U.S. national commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research (1979), she wrote that the landscape of ethics is useful, and yet, issues outside of the norms and principles also arise in the conduct of research: "some ethical issues will surface differently or not at all, depending on the researchers' or evaluators' paradigmatic stance" (35)

Chilisa (2005, Educational research within postcolonial Africa. International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education, 18, 659-684) suggests that ethics narrowly defined as protection fails to protect the researched as it fails to recognize ethics in light of respect for the integrity of the researched community.

Mertens also looked into AEA's Guiding Principles over a period of time and other codes, and suggested that revisions of professional association code recently made indicate a "greater awareness of the need to consciously incorporate principles of cultural competence as a salient dimension of their ethical codes" (36): APA, AERA, America Evaluation Association, American Sociological Association, American Anthropological Association, and the United Nations.

[Find out the examples, and look for some examples in Canadian contexts]

Mertens read through Kirkhart (1995, 2005) and Lincoln (1995) for the discussion of research validity. In particular, Kirkhart (2005) proposed "multicultural validity" to indicate "correctness or authenticity of understanding across multiple, intersecting cultural contexts" (p.22) and suggested five justifications for multicultural validity: theoretical, experiential, consequential, interpersonal, methodological.

Lincoln (1995, Standards for qualitative research. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the AERA, San Francisco) suggested the followings for the criteria for quality in research and evaluation: positionality or standpoint epitemology (researchers should acknowledge all texts are incomplete and limited by the position of the researchers), community (know well enough of the community), attention to voice (researchers should seek out those who are silent), critical reflexivity (high level of awareness to acknowledge the psychologocal state of others and themselves), reciprocity (should demonstrate that a method was used to develop a sense of trust and mutuality with the participants), sharing the perquisites of privilege. (as cited 39-40)

[Checking the quality of the embedded research (PV), it demonstrates sustained quality]

2. Basic beliefs and commensurate theories (43-69)

Some philosophical statements of the transformative paradigm:

Axiology (assumptions about ethics): "Ethical considerations include respect for cultural norms of interaction; beneficence is defined in terms of the promotion of human rights and increase in social justice)

Ontology (assumptions about what exists; what is reality): "Rejects cultural relativism and recognizes the influence of privilege in determining what is real ad the consequence of accepting one version of reality over another; multiple realities are shaped by social, political, cultural, economic, ethnic, gender, disability, and other values" (p. 49)

Epistemology (assumptions about the nature of knowledge and the relationship between the researcher/evaluator and the stakeholders needed to achieve accurate knowledge): Recongnizes an interactive link between researcher/evaluator and participants/co-researchers/evaluator; knowledge is seen as socially and historically situated; issues of power and privilege are explicitly addressed; development of a trusting relationship is seen as critical

Methodology (assumptions about appropriate methods of systematic inquiry): "Inclusion of qualitative methods (dialogical) is seen as critical; quantitative and mixed methods can be used; interactive link recognized between the researcher/evaluator and participants in the definition of the focus and questions; methods are adjusted to accommodate cultural complexity; and contextual and historical factors are acknowledged. especially as they relate to discrimination and oppression. (p. 49)

About Validity
Gaventa and Cornwall (2006, Power and knoweldge. In Reason and Bradbury (Eds.) Handbook of action research (71-82)) argued for the need to evolve new concepts of validity in participatory research and the quality of knowledge. [So, WHAT IS THEIR CONCEPT?]

Mertens stressed that researchers should be sensitive to cultural diversity because "The embedded biases of researchers and evaluators toward culturally diverse people threaten validity. In contrast, validity is enhanced by cultural responsiveness" (62). [Mertens stressed cultural responsiveness as criteria of validity]

In this regard, Mertens disregarded triangulation and called for crystallization: she wrote that triangulation was used to validate findings in traditional qualitative research through different methods. But she implied that triangulation does not convey the multifaceted nature of knowledge, subject to cultural refraction (oh, nice word that I coined), and supported crystallization indicating multidimentionalities, angles of approaches, transmutations, borrowing from Richardson and St. Pierre (2005, Writing: A method of inquiry, in Denzin & Lincoln (eds.) The sage handbook of qualitative research (3rd, 959-978)).


6. Quantitative, qualitative, and mixed methods (164-198)

Mertens suggests that specific quantitative and qualitative approaches have the potential to be used as a mixed-methods approach as long as they are used in culturally appropriate context.

In particular in the context of participatory action research, Mertens quotes Greenwood and Levine (2007, Introduction to action research, Sage), who argued that AP is not limited to group meetings and qualitative methods. They regarded action research as a research strategy that "generates knowledge claims for the express purpose of taking action to promote social analysis and democratic social change" (p. 5, cited in 183). They summarized, "Surveys, statistical analyses, interviews, focus groups, ethnographies, and life histories are all acceptable, if the reason for deploying them has been agreed upon by the AP collaborators and if they are used in a way that does not oppress the participants" (p. 6).

[GREENWOOD and LEVINE is good to quote to support the mixed method used in my study.]

Tuesday, April 26, 2011

Qualitative research & evaluation methods

(3rd ed.). Patton, Michael Quinn. (2002). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

1. The nature of qualitative inquiry (3-29)
*Three kinds of qualitative data: interview, observation, and document

The purposes of research and evaluation are different, but research can be evaluative: "When one examines and judges accomplishments and effectiveness, one is engaged in evaluation. When this examination of effectiveness is conducted systematically and empirically through careful data collection and thoughtful analysis, one is engaged in evaluation research" (p. 10)

*Criteria to judge the quality of the findings:
evaluation standards: utility, feasibility, propriety, accuracy
nontraditional criteria: trustworthiness, diversity of perspectives, clarity of voice, credibility of the inquirer to primary users of the findings.

Patton noted, "In qualitative inquiry, the researcher is the instrument. The credibility of qualitative methods, therefore, hinges to a great extent on the skills, competence, and rigor of the person doing fieldwork--as well as things going on in a person's life that might prove a distraction" (p. 14)

Patton discussed the purposes of open-ended responses and participant observation for evaluative research: "the open-ended responses permit one to understand the world as seen by the respondents. The purpose of gathering responses to open-ended questions is to enable the researcher to understand and capture the points of view of other people without predetermining those points of view through prior selection of questionnaire categories. . . . The task for the qualitative researcher is to provide a framework within which people can respond in a way that represents accurately and thoroughly their points of view about the world..." (p. 21)

In order to overcome the limitations pertaining to what people say, Patton called for participant observation for evaluation research. "The purpose of observational analysis is to take the reader into the setting that was observed" (p. 23).

[In my evaluation research, I utilized participant observation, written out in depth in chapter 3, and made available direct quotes from the observed to provide readers with their points of view.]

2. Strategic themes in qualitative inquiry (37-73)
* Patton presented some analysis strategies: unique case orientation (capturing the details of the individual case being studied), inductive analysis and creative synthesis, holistic perspective (focusing on complex interdependence and providing it as a complex system), context sensitivity (attentive to a social, historical, and temporal context), voice/reflexivity (reflective on my own voice)

With regard to reflexivity, Patton wrote: "Reflexivity has entered the qualitative lexicon as a way of emphasizing the importance of self-awareness, political/cultural consciousness, and ownership of one's perspective" (p. 64) He suggested using the first-person, active voice in this light.

Patton seems to be skeptical about paradigmatic division. He argued that a paradigmatic strategy indeed can be a hindrance for evaluation research. He argued:

"Such prejudices and paradigmatic blinders limit methodological choices, flexibility, and creativity. Adherence to a methodological paradigm can lock researchers into unconscious patterns of perception and behavior that disguise the biased, predetermined nature of their methods "decision." " (p. 71)

Further, he argued that "the qualitative-quantitative debate oversimplified and often confused methodological and philosophical issues" (p. 71), as in reality, there are the cases that notably consistent methods and philosophy in a certain paradigm have proven problematic.

3. Variety in qualitative inquiry: Theoretical orientations (75-142)
Patton introduces 16 qualitative inquiries, including phenomenology and grounded theory, which I think are the most relevant to my dissertation research. So I will take a close look at them.

Phenomenology
Foundational question: what is the meaning, structure, and essence of the lived experience of this phenomenon for this person or group of people?

Phenomenon can be emotion, a relationship, a program, or a culture. The focus is on describing the essence of people's experience in a certain phenomenon and developing a worldview. It usually involves participant observation and in-depth interviews. For example, the essence of being a participant in a particular program can be a kind of phenomenological study. [My chapter 4 is a definitely phenomenological study in that sense.]

Grounded theory
Foundational question: What theory emerges from systematic comparative analysis and is grounded in fieldwork so as to explain what has been and is observed?

Popular in social sciences and methodology with emphasis on generating, instead of testing, theory. Patton asserts that all the approaches are grounded in the empirical world, but the conceptualizations of what to ask vary from one inquiry to another. "While the phrase "ground theory" is often used as a general reference to inductive, qualitative analysis, as an identifiable approach to qualitative inquiry, it consists of quite specific methods and systematic procedure" (p. 126). Thus, he argued:

"As a matter of philosophical distinctness, then, grounded theory is best understood as fundamentally realist and objectivist in orientation, emphasizing disciplined and procedural ways of getting the researcher's biases out of the way but adding healthy doses of creativity to the analytic process." (p. 128-129).

[To the extent that I compared the experience of the research participants with that of others in other programs in Chapter 4, it has a systematic comparison emphasized in grounded theory, and yet, this analysis is not so much grounded theory as phenomenology. On the other hand, Chapter 5 is more linked to grounded theory as I intend to provide some methodological tools to researchers. But I also doubt that it can be called grounded theory as I do not develop theory out of the fieldwork. ]

4. Particularly appropriate qualitative applications (143-205)
Patton holds pragmatism in his approach to methodology: "Pragmatic and utilitarian frameworks can guide qualitative inquiry on their practical and applied underpinnings without having to be attached to or derived from a theoretical tradition." (p. 145)

Patton suggests various evaluation models:

Goal-free evaluation
"doing fieldwork and gathering data on a broad array of actual effects or outcomes, then comparing the observed outcomes with the actual needs of program participants" (p. 169). In general, it purposefully suspends the researcher's judgment.

[Then, I can take up goal-free evaluation for the embedded study. The participants want to find out ways to help increase retention rate, in the end, they suggested a way. There is no way to check the actual effects, but from the participants' perspective, the research brought about some solutions they looked for. ]

Transaction models: responsive and illuminative evaluation

The transaction model of evaluation that Ernie House (1978) called concentrates on case studies and "places prime emphasis on perception and knowing as a transactional process between researcher and research participant" (p. 172). Its variations include illuminative evaluation, developed in educational evaluation, and Stake's (1975) responsive approach to evaluation, which requires to have "face-to-face contact with people in the program and learn about diverse stakeholder's perspectives, experiences and concerns. This responsive evaluation has been integrated into Guba and Lincoln's (1989) "responsive constructivist evaluation" known as the fourth generation evaluation, which is based on naturalistic inquiry.
Connoisseurship studies
It places the evaluator's perceptions and expertise at the center of the evaluation process, "drawing heavily on his or her own judgments about what constitutes excellence" (172).

Interactive and participatory applications:

Placing a greater emphasis on human interaction in designing evaluation strategies, Patton wrote:

Qualitative methods may also be perceived as more personal because of their inductive nature. This means that, again, rather than imposing on people or a program some predetermined model or hypotheses, the results unfold in a way that takes into account idiosyncrasies, uniqueness, and complex dynamics. Finally, qualitative methods may be perceived as more humanistic and personal simply by avoiding numbers. (p. 176)

Action research, action learning, reflective practice
i.e. adult educators interviewing students as case studies, then through cross-case analysis they deepened their sensitivity to new immigrant students and developed their professional skills.
Participatory research and evaluation
Film: Awakening (1990)--a real story of participatory research in a mental hospital

Patton provided an overview of a growing popularity of participatory research:
"Interest in participatory research has exploded in recent years, especially as an element of larger community change efforts (Stoecker 1999). The principal researcher trains the coresearchers to observe, interview, reflect, and/or keep careful records or diaries. Those involved come together periodically to share in the data analysis process. The purpose of such shared inquiry is typically to elucidate and improve the nature of practice in some arena of action" (183).

In particular, participatory evaluation emphasizes "working with people" (183), thus, Patton wrote: "The process is facilitated by the researcher, but is controlled by the people in the program or community. They undertake a formal, reflective process for their own development and empowerment" (183).

Patton noted that participatory evaluation has been used with great success by a number of NGOs and private voluntary organization in the Third World.

Patton also drew attention to various connotations of participatory inquiry, saying that there is no definitive definition for participatory evaluation. Patton, in particular, emphasized teaching inquiry logic and skills as the purpose of participatory evaluation, as "the process of participatory self-evaluation, in and of itself, provided useful learning experience for participants" (184).

[Here Patton suggests participatory evaluation/inquiry as a pedagogical form.]

Finally, he noted, "these participatory approaches often employ qualitative methods because those methods are understandable, teachable, and usable by people without extensive research training." (185)

[Patton regards participatory paradigm from the perspective of pragmatism and links qualitative methods as strong candidates for that paradigmatic inquiry.]

8. Qualitative analysis and interpretation (431-534)

Patton discussed about summative vs. formative evaluation: Summative evaluations are usually accompanied by a full report with data, analysis, and recommendations, whereas formative evaluation is conducted for program improvement and may not generate a written report. Findings are often presented orally to the staff or funders. Patton wrote:
"The methods are qualitative, the purpose is practical, and the analysis is done throughout fieldwork; no written report is expected beyond a final outline of observations and implications. Academic theory takes second place to understanding the program's theory of action as actually practices and implemented" (435)

[The VT research can be viewed as formative evaluation to give insights into the OP program, which is not academic theory oriented and rather concentrates on providing critical insights from the insiders' perspective.]

Theory-based analysis approaches: Patton discusses phenomenological analysis and ground theory analysis in great detail, along with qualitative comparative analysis and analytic induction.

Analytic induction seems to be the most relevant to my approach. It originally emphasized discovering universal causal generalizations, but gradually moved away to qualitative inquiry and comparative case analysis including examination of preconceived hypotheses. In this approach, "researchers actively seek to disconfirm emerging hypotheses through negative case analysis, that is, analysis of cases that hold promise for disconfirming emerging hypotheses and that add variability to the sample. In this way, the originators of the method sought to examine enough cases to assure the development of universal hypothesis." (Jane Gilgun 1995:268-269, We shared something special: the moral discourse of incest perpetrators, Journal of marriage and the family, 57, 265-81). Analytic induction consists of re-examinations.

9. Enhancing the quality and credibility of qualitative analysis (541-597)

In traditional scientific research, among the criteria for judging the credibility are objectivity, validity, systematic rigor of fieldwork procedures, triangulation, etc. The common aim is "to use qualitative methods to describe and explain phenomena as accurately and completely as possible so that their descriptions and explanations correspond as closely as possible to the way the world is and actually operates" (p. 546)

Social construction and constructivist criteria: Lincoln and Guba (1986) proposed credibility (for internal validity), transferability, dependability and confirmability. In combination, they viewed these criteria as addressing trustworthiness (in lieu of rigor). Fundamentally, they are "suspicious of causal explanations and empirical generalizations applied to complex human interactions and cultural system" (546)

Critical change criteria: another stream of qualitative inquiry aims at social and political change. Thus consequential validity matters in addressing the credibility of the inquiry.

[For the analysis of my dissertation study, what criteria should be applied? The set of criteria should stem from the hypotheses of participatory (video) research. What does participatory research claim to be able to do? Does my study prove or disprove it? How do I make judgment? --My judgment should be grounded in constructivist perspective, the fourth generation evaluation. Then, what I need to verify is the claims of participatory research. ]