Okin, S. M., Cohen, J., Howard, M., & Nussbaum, M. C. (1999). Is multiculturalism bad for women? Princeton University Press Princeton, NJ.
Is Multiculturalism Bad for Women? Susan M. Okin. 7-24
Liberalism's Sacred Cow. Homi K. Bhabha. 79-84.
A Plea for Difficulty. Martha C. Nussbaum. 105-114.
By questioning, “Is multiculturalism bad for women?” in Boston Review in 1997, Okin (1999) contests that multiculturalism in the name of group rights tends to provide rationales for perpetuating gender inequality in minority cultures. Examining the French accommodation of polygamy in minority groups while prohibiting Magrbin girls from wearing headscarves at school in the 1980s, Okin suggests intrinsic tensions between feminism and multiculturalism that commits to group rights for minority cultures.
She claims that most cultures are patriarchal and many of the cultural minorities calling for group rights are more patriarchal than the ‘surrounding culture’. This assumption of the nature of minority cultures stems partially from a view that regards a culture as a self-defined and well-bounded static entity. As Song rightly points out, Okin overlooks that cultures are interconnected and shaped by interactions between majority and minority cultures. What’s more, her approach to the issue of gender inequality in minority cultures is based on a biased view that Western societies are more liberal with respect to gender equality. This premise is observed in her clause us versus them:
Surely it is not enough, for one to be able to "question one's inherited social roles" and to have the capacity to make choices about the life one wants to lead, that one's culture be protected. At least as important to the development of self-respect and self-esteem is our place within our culture [sic]. And at least as important to our capacity to question our social roles is whether our culture instills in and enforces particular social roles on us [sic]. To the extent that their culture is patriarchal, in both these respects the healthy development of girls is endangered. (p. 22)
Okin supports her idea of the likely contention between multiculturalism and feminism on the two basis: (1) almost legal cases related to women’s rights are grounded in their individual rights were violated by the practices of their cultural groups and (2) As Amy Gutmann pointed out, the majority of challenges of multiculturalism has to do with gender inequality. Okin maintains that this multicultural commitment to cultural diversity/defense can violate individual rights to the equal protection of the laws. On the grounds that gender discrimination in minority cultures tends to remain private, she calls for special care in looking at the inequality issue within the cultures.
Okin’s forceful argument aroused debate among scholars. Bhabha responds to Okin’s argument by stating that Okin falls into monolithic, though gender-differentiated, characterization of minority cultures by focusing on patriarchal cultural defense for certain crimes, thus missing the liberal grounds where multiculturalism and feminism might negotiate. Bhabha insinuates that Okin’s pitfall stems partially from her view to evaluate minority cultures from a perspective of liberal Western culture. Instead, he insists on placing cultural defense or group rights in the context of the current lives of minorities in the Western cultures. In this regards, he states, “[w]hat is considerably more problematic than the inappropriate application of "external" norms is the way in which the norms of Western liberalism become at once the measure and mentor of minority cultures” (p. 83).
In contrast to Okin’s perspective, Bhabha maintains that a Western liberalism interacts with and is inscribed in the exclusionary division of post-colonial practices. Thus he writes, “[a]n awareness of the ambivalent and "unsatisfied" histories of the liberal persuasion allows "us"--postcolonial critics, multiculturalists, or feminists--to join in the unfinished work of creating a more viable, intra-cultural community of rights” (p. 84).
In responding to Okin's argument of sex discrimination in religion, Nussbaum states that it is a difficult task to define the complexity of the relationship between religion and feminism but Okin makes it sound too easy. In this regard, Nussbaum is attentive to civil movements, in particular feminist movement, grounded in religion. She writes:
By treating the original core of the religion as equivalent to certain patriarchal stories, Okin simply bypasses centuries of debate within each of the religions, debate highly pertinent to religion's role in the search for women's equality.(p. 107)
Nussbaum argues further that by ignoring religious struggle for justice, Okin alienates potential allies and makes her own feminist struggle difficult. With regard to state's political intervention to religious practices, Nussbaum hesitates to present a clear view, writing:
It is indeed difficult to say how far the state should accommodate comprehensive religious views that seem at odd with secular liberal political values. But this is my point: it is [sic] difficult, rather than easy. (p. 108)
She agrees with a special protection for minority religions because of their vulnerability in all societies. Questionable to her is how state should intervene. She proposes that we should ask whether a proposed law, banning child marriage or polygamy, for example, really does impose a 'substantial burden' on people's free exercise of their religion. If the answer is no, the law may go forward, she argues. On the basis of her argument, she calls for respect for different lives one choose to lead before delving into the complexity of this issue.
Monday, January 11, 2010
Saturday, January 9, 2010
Critical multiculturalism
Chicago Cultural Studies Group. (1992). Critical Inquiry, 18(3), 530-555.
This article examines multiculturalism critically along with cultural studies. This group critiques that multiculturalism as a social movement has rushed for Utopian thinking than cultural studies as an academic discipline. One of the reasons is, the Group explains, that multiculturalism, which intrinsically challenges established norms and link together identity struggles with a common rhetoric and resistance, failed to provide critical content but only described different styles of cultural relationship--the Group calls this the Benetton effect. The Group argues that multiculturalism failed to perceive tensions and relations with identity politics. They insinuate that it is a false assumption that marginalized voices and disciplines will create an alliance simple because of their minoritized identities.
This article examines multiculturalism critically along with cultural studies. This group critiques that multiculturalism as a social movement has rushed for Utopian thinking than cultural studies as an academic discipline. One of the reasons is, the Group explains, that multiculturalism, which intrinsically challenges established norms and link together identity struggles with a common rhetoric and resistance, failed to provide critical content but only described different styles of cultural relationship--the Group calls this the Benetton effect. The Group argues that multiculturalism failed to perceive tensions and relations with identity politics. They insinuate that it is a false assumption that marginalized voices and disciplines will create an alliance simple because of their minoritized identities.
Friday, January 8, 2010
Post-Colonial Ruptures and Democratic Possibilities: Multiculturalism as Anti-Racist Pedagogy
Giroux, Henry. (1992). Cultural Critique, 21 (Spring), 5-39.
From the debate about education and democracy in the 1980s, Giroux deduces that culture is a terrain of political and ideological struggle. In particular, conservative attack on multiculturalism drew impact on social movement as well as education in general. Giroux states:
“What is being valorized in the dominant language of the conservative offensive is an undemocratic approach to social authority and a politically regressive moce to reconstruct American life within the script of Eurocentrism, racism, and patriarchy. Similarly, within these discourses, the call to define civilization as synonymous with selected aspects of Western tradition is being matched by a fervent attempt to reduce pedagogy to the old transmission model of teaching and learning.” (p. 5-6)
Giroux analyzes further the implications of conservative cultural offensive: in a larger social context, the conservative backlash was an attempt to dismantle/reverse the gains made by subordinate groups, such as gays and lesbians, women, racial minorities, etc. around a politics of identity. In higher education and public schooling, the attack was manifested against political correctness and multiculturalism. In the conservative view, multiculturalism provokes separatism, threatens western civilization and politicizes universities. D’Souza writes:
“Liberal arts students…are very likely to be exposed to an attempted brainwashing that deprecates Western learning and exalts a neo Marxist ideology promoted in the name of multiculturalism” (Illiberal Education, p. 35)
Conservative diatribes against multiculturalism were side by side with the attack on political correctness, which undermined multiculturalism. Giroux writes:
“The political correctness movement seizes upon the issue of free expression in order to undermine social criticism that opposes cultural chauvinism, racism, and gender discrimination. Political correctness is euphemism used by liberals and neoconservatives to disparage radical professors, cultural workers, and students from displaying ongoing pedagogical interests in fashioning a democratic culture within and outside of higher education. Accordingly, the rallying cry against political correctness is an act of bad faith designed to legitimate and enforce the pedagogical imperative to learn a selected cultural tradition and common culture invented in a monolithic and totalizing discourse.” (p. 10)
Giroux observes that common culture is a counter concept used by conservatives in attacking multiculturalism. Central to this concept is that the common culture of the United States is made up of diverse racial and ethnic groups. Giroux criticizes that this concept depoliticizes and dehistoricizes the idea of culture. In other words, common culture does not acknowledge inequality of power among social groups, the systematic maintenance of power domination, Eurocentric curriculum, social movement and struggle, etc. About this liberal notion of multiculturalism, Giroux critiques:
“Liberal notions of multiculturalism affirm difference within a politics of consensus that erases culture as a terrain of struggle constituted within asymmetrical relations of power, knowledge, and experience.” (p. 14)
Giroux states that, although liberal multiculturalism challenges totalizing and racist views of conservatives, it fails to question ways in which political and cultural authority is maintained in the academic canon and does not call attention to critical issues in forms of ‘domestic colonialism’ expressed in racial violence, unemployment among black and other minorities, etc.
Thus, Giroux observes that both liberal and conservative approaches to multiculturalism refuse to identify culture in the context of white supremacy and unequal power relations. He writes:
[C]onservative and liberal discourses that conflate multiculturalism with the imperatives of a ‘common culture’ generally suppress any attempts to call into question the norm of whiteness as a ethnic category that secures its dominance by appearing to be invisible. In this case, emancipatory interests in liberal approaches to multicultural education are generally limited to the call for either assimilation or the demand to reverse negative images of blacks and other ethnic groups as they appear in various forms of texts and images. (p. 15)
In sum, liberal multiculturalism fails to address post-colonial critiques. Calling urgent attention to constructing difference, Giroux seconds post-colonial approaches to democratic society. He explains post-colonial criticism as follows:
“Post-colonial discourses have pushed against the boundaries of the liberal and conservative debate on multiculturalism by asserting that politics and struggle are central to the discourse of difference.” (p. 18)
Post-colonialism emphasizes a politics of difference in contrast to a legacy of colonialism that veils specific forms of privilege. [Find a quote or two-Gayatri Spivak, Tiffin, Ngugi, Issac Julien, Kobena Mercer] About the central argument of post-colonialism, Giroux writes:
“At stake here is deconstructing forms of privilege that benefit males, whiteness, and property as well as those conditions that have disabled others to speak in places where those who are privileged by virtue of the legacy of colonial power assume authority and the conditions for human agency.” (p. 19)
“[Post-colonial discourses] provide a theoretical foundation for deconstructing the master narratives of white supremacist logic and redrawing the boundaries between the construction of experience and power…post-colonial criticism has illuminated how Eurocentric-American discourses of identity suppresses difference, heterogeneity, and multiplicity in their efforts to maintain racist hegemonic relations of power.”(p. 21)
Thus, Giroux sums that “Post-Colonial discourses represents a space in which to retheorize, locate, and address the possibilities for a new politics based on the construction of new identities, zones of cultural difference, and forms of ethical address.”(p. 22)
Within this context, Giroux calls for a border pedagogy to address power inscription in body, culture, space, history, land and psyche as a means of achieving anti-racist teaching.
From the debate about education and democracy in the 1980s, Giroux deduces that culture is a terrain of political and ideological struggle. In particular, conservative attack on multiculturalism drew impact on social movement as well as education in general. Giroux states:
“What is being valorized in the dominant language of the conservative offensive is an undemocratic approach to social authority and a politically regressive moce to reconstruct American life within the script of Eurocentrism, racism, and patriarchy. Similarly, within these discourses, the call to define civilization as synonymous with selected aspects of Western tradition is being matched by a fervent attempt to reduce pedagogy to the old transmission model of teaching and learning.” (p. 5-6)
Giroux analyzes further the implications of conservative cultural offensive: in a larger social context, the conservative backlash was an attempt to dismantle/reverse the gains made by subordinate groups, such as gays and lesbians, women, racial minorities, etc. around a politics of identity. In higher education and public schooling, the attack was manifested against political correctness and multiculturalism. In the conservative view, multiculturalism provokes separatism, threatens western civilization and politicizes universities. D’Souza writes:
“Liberal arts students…are very likely to be exposed to an attempted brainwashing that deprecates Western learning and exalts a neo Marxist ideology promoted in the name of multiculturalism” (Illiberal Education, p. 35)
Conservative diatribes against multiculturalism were side by side with the attack on political correctness, which undermined multiculturalism. Giroux writes:
“The political correctness movement seizes upon the issue of free expression in order to undermine social criticism that opposes cultural chauvinism, racism, and gender discrimination. Political correctness is euphemism used by liberals and neoconservatives to disparage radical professors, cultural workers, and students from displaying ongoing pedagogical interests in fashioning a democratic culture within and outside of higher education. Accordingly, the rallying cry against political correctness is an act of bad faith designed to legitimate and enforce the pedagogical imperative to learn a selected cultural tradition and common culture invented in a monolithic and totalizing discourse.” (p. 10)
Giroux observes that common culture is a counter concept used by conservatives in attacking multiculturalism. Central to this concept is that the common culture of the United States is made up of diverse racial and ethnic groups. Giroux criticizes that this concept depoliticizes and dehistoricizes the idea of culture. In other words, common culture does not acknowledge inequality of power among social groups, the systematic maintenance of power domination, Eurocentric curriculum, social movement and struggle, etc. About this liberal notion of multiculturalism, Giroux critiques:
“Liberal notions of multiculturalism affirm difference within a politics of consensus that erases culture as a terrain of struggle constituted within asymmetrical relations of power, knowledge, and experience.” (p. 14)
Giroux states that, although liberal multiculturalism challenges totalizing and racist views of conservatives, it fails to question ways in which political and cultural authority is maintained in the academic canon and does not call attention to critical issues in forms of ‘domestic colonialism’ expressed in racial violence, unemployment among black and other minorities, etc.
Thus, Giroux observes that both liberal and conservative approaches to multiculturalism refuse to identify culture in the context of white supremacy and unequal power relations. He writes:
[C]onservative and liberal discourses that conflate multiculturalism with the imperatives of a ‘common culture’ generally suppress any attempts to call into question the norm of whiteness as a ethnic category that secures its dominance by appearing to be invisible. In this case, emancipatory interests in liberal approaches to multicultural education are generally limited to the call for either assimilation or the demand to reverse negative images of blacks and other ethnic groups as they appear in various forms of texts and images. (p. 15)
In sum, liberal multiculturalism fails to address post-colonial critiques. Calling urgent attention to constructing difference, Giroux seconds post-colonial approaches to democratic society. He explains post-colonial criticism as follows:
“Post-colonial discourses have pushed against the boundaries of the liberal and conservative debate on multiculturalism by asserting that politics and struggle are central to the discourse of difference.” (p. 18)
Post-colonialism emphasizes a politics of difference in contrast to a legacy of colonialism that veils specific forms of privilege. [Find a quote or two-Gayatri Spivak, Tiffin, Ngugi, Issac Julien, Kobena Mercer] About the central argument of post-colonialism, Giroux writes:
“At stake here is deconstructing forms of privilege that benefit males, whiteness, and property as well as those conditions that have disabled others to speak in places where those who are privileged by virtue of the legacy of colonial power assume authority and the conditions for human agency.” (p. 19)
“[Post-colonial discourses] provide a theoretical foundation for deconstructing the master narratives of white supremacist logic and redrawing the boundaries between the construction of experience and power…post-colonial criticism has illuminated how Eurocentric-American discourses of identity suppresses difference, heterogeneity, and multiplicity in their efforts to maintain racist hegemonic relations of power.”(p. 21)
Thus, Giroux sums that “Post-Colonial discourses represents a space in which to retheorize, locate, and address the possibilities for a new politics based on the construction of new identities, zones of cultural difference, and forms of ethical address.”(p. 22)
Within this context, Giroux calls for a border pedagogy to address power inscription in body, culture, space, history, land and psyche as a means of achieving anti-racist teaching.
New 'Politically Correct Metaphors Insult History and Our Campuses
Stimpson, Catharine. (May 29, 1991). The Chronicle of Higher Education. p. A40.
This article shows a heated debate over PC and its impact on academia. Criticized as intolerant, left, trendy, dominant, or even "Multiculturalism is a fad", Stimpson states:
"For the misuse of the term 'politically correct'--or P.C.--is a rhetorical virus that has been spereading through higher education and the meia so rapidly that it is nearing comic self-parody. The virus is also obscuring our vision of the real center of gravity in higher education." (Para. 3)
Stimpson criticizes that PC that was applied to a set of beliefs in the late 1980s became a conservatives' convenient label for their opposition to, for instance, affirmative action, women's studies, black studies, ethnic studies, gay and lesbian studies, and cultural studies....
This article shows a heated debate over PC and its impact on academia. Criticized as intolerant, left, trendy, dominant, or even "Multiculturalism is a fad", Stimpson states:
"For the misuse of the term 'politically correct'--or P.C.--is a rhetorical virus that has been spereading through higher education and the meia so rapidly that it is nearing comic self-parody. The virus is also obscuring our vision of the real center of gravity in higher education." (Para. 3)
Stimpson criticizes that PC that was applied to a set of beliefs in the late 1980s became a conservatives' convenient label for their opposition to, for instance, affirmative action, women's studies, black studies, ethnic studies, gay and lesbian studies, and cultural studies....
The Attack on 'Political Correctness'
: Islamophobia and the Erosion of Multiculturalism in Australia Under the Howard Regime. Poynting, Scott. (2008). Social Alternative, 27 (1), 5-9.
Poynting examines the erosion of multiculturalism since 1996 with the rise of State-sponsored Islamophobia in Australia. He notes that multiculturalism was a policy that has been developed since the early 1970s in response to the failure of the existing assimilation policy then and increasing inequality among immigrants. It was a fruition of 'New Social Movements' that called attention to recognition, access and equity.
The debate of PC in the United State undermined the multiculturalism in Australia, Poynting asserts. What's more, he sharply points out liberal leader John Howard seamlessly melded in his 2001 election campaign the 'othering' of Middle-Eastern asylum seekers and the Muslim 'enemy within'.
Poynting examines the erosion of multiculturalism since 1996 with the rise of State-sponsored Islamophobia in Australia. He notes that multiculturalism was a policy that has been developed since the early 1970s in response to the failure of the existing assimilation policy then and increasing inequality among immigrants. It was a fruition of 'New Social Movements' that called attention to recognition, access and equity.
The debate of PC in the United State undermined the multiculturalism in Australia, Poynting asserts. What's more, he sharply points out liberal leader John Howard seamlessly melded in his 2001 election campaign the 'othering' of Middle-Eastern asylum seekers and the Muslim 'enemy within'.
Roger Kimball
Ian Buruma and multiculturalism (April 29, 2007)
Arma Virumque, web blog of New Criterion.
Roger Kimball writes, "multiculturalism [is] university-nurtured version of cultural relativism that has now firmly ensconced itself wherever politically correct college-educated elites congregate, which is to say just about everywhere." He detests multiculturalism. Connecting to multiculturalism, he maintains a pejorative perspective on PC.
Introduction: What was a liberal education?
New Criterion; May2008, Vol. 26 Issue 9, p4-8, 5p
He moans the demise of liberal education, writing:
"Indeed, until at least the early 1960s there was robust agreement about the intellectual and moral goals of a liberal arts education even if those goals seemed difficult to achieve. There was, for example, a shared commitment to the ideal of disinterested scholarship devoted to the preservation and transmission of knowledge—which meant the preservation and transmission of
a civilization—pursued in a community free from ideological intimidation." (p. 4)
"[In the 1970s and 1980s] despite the rise of alternative voices here and there, those dominating the discussion at most institutions are committed to discrediting the traditional humanistic ideals of liberal education by injecting politics into the heart of the educational enterprise."(p. 5)
He finds the root of the demise in multiculturalism and PC. He criticizes:
"what generally travels under the name of "multiculturalism" is really a form of monocultural animus directed against the dominant culture...[Multiculturalists] encourage an orgy of self-flagellating liberal guilt as impotent as it is insatiable. Hence the sensitivity of the multiculturalist is an index not of moral refinement but of moral vacuousness. Multiculturalism is a paralyzing intoxicant; its thrill centers around the emotion of superior virtue; its hangover
subsists on a diet of ignorance and blighted good intentions...The most ironic aspect of this whole spectacle is that what appears to its adherents as bravely anti-Western is in fact part of tlie West's long tradition of self-scrutiny...No civilization in history has been as consistently self-critical as the West." (p. 5)
To Kimball, multiculturalists are enemies of Western civilization and values of American identity grounded in individual liberty and public virtue and these traditional values are "deeply at odds with the radical, de-civilizing tenets of the "multiculturalist" enterprise of political correctness." (p. 5)
He denounces PC resulted in students' poor acquisition of American history while promoting intellectual conformity and sentimentality. He criticizes academics' "self-infatuating embrace of political correctness" for the quintessential Western ideas under attack. He calls attention to:
"Respect for rationality and the rights of the individual; a commitment to the ideals of disinterested criticism and color-blind justice; advancement according to merit, not
according to sex, race, or ethnic origin."
Individual rights, blind justice and meritocracy are highlighted here. Politicization of campus is his ever concern, saying, "it is this failure—the colonization of intellectual life by politics—that stands behind and fuels the degradation of liberal education. (p. 8)
Institutionalizing our demise: America vs. Multiculturalism
New Criterion; Jun2004, Vol. 22 Issue 10, p5-16, 12p
He denounces, "Multiculturalism is a moral intoxicant" (p. 7) in that it threatens Western civilization and national identity; what's more, it fosters social and intellectual consequences beyond an academic phenomenon. He writes:
"One consequence has been a sharp rise in the phenomenon of immigration without--or with only partial--assimilation: a dangerous demographic trend that threatens American identity in the most basic way. These various agents of dissolution are also elements in a wider culture war: the contest to define who we live and what counts as the good in the good life." (p. 8)
Affirmative action is an irony and reverse discrimination from his perspective. He writes, "Multiculturalism and 'affirmative action' are allies in the assault on the institutions of America identity" (p. 10)
He refuses the notion that America is a nation of immigrants, insisting on a country of setters [sic]. He maintains that predominantly Anglo-Protestant settlers defines American culture, founding a state and making possible immigration later on. [In his view, there is no native American before the settlers.] In his view, immigrants became American "by embracing the Anglophone culture of the original settlers" (p. 10)
He asserts that immigration, characterized with Americanization or assimilation to the original culture, became a dangerous matter since the 1960s with the massive immigration from Asia, Latin America and Muslim countries. He criticizes that a great number of immigrants do not make concerted efforts, thus leading to disastrous and potentially irreversible impact on American identity. He rebukes multiculturalism for abetting such phenomenon at school. Thus, he continues to denounce multiculturalism, saying, "The combined effect of the multicultural enterprise has been to undermine the foundation of American national identity" (p. 12)
Arma Virumque, web blog of New Criterion.
Roger Kimball writes, "multiculturalism [is] university-nurtured version of cultural relativism that has now firmly ensconced itself wherever politically correct college-educated elites congregate, which is to say just about everywhere." He detests multiculturalism. Connecting to multiculturalism, he maintains a pejorative perspective on PC.
Introduction: What was a liberal education?
New Criterion; May2008, Vol. 26 Issue 9, p4-8, 5p
He moans the demise of liberal education, writing:
"Indeed, until at least the early 1960s there was robust agreement about the intellectual and moral goals of a liberal arts education even if those goals seemed difficult to achieve. There was, for example, a shared commitment to the ideal of disinterested scholarship devoted to the preservation and transmission of knowledge—which meant the preservation and transmission of
a civilization—pursued in a community free from ideological intimidation." (p. 4)
"[In the 1970s and 1980s] despite the rise of alternative voices here and there, those dominating the discussion at most institutions are committed to discrediting the traditional humanistic ideals of liberal education by injecting politics into the heart of the educational enterprise."(p. 5)
He finds the root of the demise in multiculturalism and PC. He criticizes:
"what generally travels under the name of "multiculturalism" is really a form of monocultural animus directed against the dominant culture...[Multiculturalists] encourage an orgy of self-flagellating liberal guilt as impotent as it is insatiable. Hence the sensitivity of the multiculturalist is an index not of moral refinement but of moral vacuousness. Multiculturalism is a paralyzing intoxicant; its thrill centers around the emotion of superior virtue; its hangover
subsists on a diet of ignorance and blighted good intentions...The most ironic aspect of this whole spectacle is that what appears to its adherents as bravely anti-Western is in fact part of tlie West's long tradition of self-scrutiny...No civilization in history has been as consistently self-critical as the West." (p. 5)
To Kimball, multiculturalists are enemies of Western civilization and values of American identity grounded in individual liberty and public virtue and these traditional values are "deeply at odds with the radical, de-civilizing tenets of the "multiculturalist" enterprise of political correctness." (p. 5)
He denounces PC resulted in students' poor acquisition of American history while promoting intellectual conformity and sentimentality. He criticizes academics' "self-infatuating embrace of political correctness" for the quintessential Western ideas under attack. He calls attention to:
"Respect for rationality and the rights of the individual; a commitment to the ideals of disinterested criticism and color-blind justice; advancement according to merit, not
according to sex, race, or ethnic origin."
Individual rights, blind justice and meritocracy are highlighted here. Politicization of campus is his ever concern, saying, "it is this failure—the colonization of intellectual life by politics—that stands behind and fuels the degradation of liberal education. (p. 8)
Institutionalizing our demise: America vs. Multiculturalism
New Criterion; Jun2004, Vol. 22 Issue 10, p5-16, 12p
He denounces, "Multiculturalism is a moral intoxicant" (p. 7) in that it threatens Western civilization and national identity; what's more, it fosters social and intellectual consequences beyond an academic phenomenon. He writes:
"One consequence has been a sharp rise in the phenomenon of immigration without--or with only partial--assimilation: a dangerous demographic trend that threatens American identity in the most basic way. These various agents of dissolution are also elements in a wider culture war: the contest to define who we live and what counts as the good in the good life." (p. 8)
Affirmative action is an irony and reverse discrimination from his perspective. He writes, "Multiculturalism and 'affirmative action' are allies in the assault on the institutions of America identity" (p. 10)
He refuses the notion that America is a nation of immigrants, insisting on a country of setters [sic]. He maintains that predominantly Anglo-Protestant settlers defines American culture, founding a state and making possible immigration later on. [In his view, there is no native American before the settlers.] In his view, immigrants became American "by embracing the Anglophone culture of the original settlers" (p. 10)
He asserts that immigration, characterized with Americanization or assimilation to the original culture, became a dangerous matter since the 1960s with the massive immigration from Asia, Latin America and Muslim countries. He criticizes that a great number of immigrants do not make concerted efforts, thus leading to disastrous and potentially irreversible impact on American identity. He rebukes multiculturalism for abetting such phenomenon at school. Thus, he continues to denounce multiculturalism, saying, "The combined effect of the multicultural enterprise has been to undermine the foundation of American national identity" (p. 12)
‘Political correctness’: the politics of culture and language
Fairclough, Norman. (2003). Discourse Society, 14 (1), 17-28.
Fairclough locates the controversy of political correctness (PC) around cultural politics, in particular, within the context of a controversy over language. From this perspective, his main question revolves around how to achieve political or social change through cultural/lingual politics.
He explains the grounds of emergence of PC: the increasing impact of culture industries on social life and growing competitive global economy have turned education as a primary concern of right politics in order to form and transformation identities and values through 'cultural governance'. Left politics, however, was behind. He writes:
"Meanwhile, left politics, unable to respond to these social transformations and the ideological assault of the New Right and neo-liberalism with an effective counter-hegemonic strategy (Hall,
1994), has become fragmented. They are no longer centred upon the political parties and social classes but oriented to ‘single issues’ and to a politics of recognition, identity and difference as much as to a politics of re-distributive social justice." (p. 21)
Fairclough sharply points out that PC is cultural interventions (changing representations, identities, and values as a way of social change) orchestrated by Reagan and Thatcher at different levels of socio-economic-political practices as part of projects for changing culture and discourse--neo-liberal discourse.
In responding to his main question, Fairclough criticizes the fragmentation of the left that remains only at a rhetoric level of PC. Instead, he calls for a hegemonic politics that brings together interventions of various levels of the social.
In particular, he calls attention to the critique of PC in the context of the controversy over political asylum as it is crucial to the analysis of contemporary global migration. [I should look for a debate over this issue.]
Fairclough locates the controversy of political correctness (PC) around cultural politics, in particular, within the context of a controversy over language. From this perspective, his main question revolves around how to achieve political or social change through cultural/lingual politics.
He explains the grounds of emergence of PC: the increasing impact of culture industries on social life and growing competitive global economy have turned education as a primary concern of right politics in order to form and transformation identities and values through 'cultural governance'. Left politics, however, was behind. He writes:
"Meanwhile, left politics, unable to respond to these social transformations and the ideological assault of the New Right and neo-liberalism with an effective counter-hegemonic strategy (Hall,
1994), has become fragmented. They are no longer centred upon the political parties and social classes but oriented to ‘single issues’ and to a politics of recognition, identity and difference as much as to a politics of re-distributive social justice." (p. 21)
Fairclough sharply points out that PC is cultural interventions (changing representations, identities, and values as a way of social change) orchestrated by Reagan and Thatcher at different levels of socio-economic-political practices as part of projects for changing culture and discourse--neo-liberal discourse.
In responding to his main question, Fairclough criticizes the fragmentation of the left that remains only at a rhetoric level of PC. Instead, he calls for a hegemonic politics that brings together interventions of various levels of the social.
In particular, he calls attention to the critique of PC in the context of the controversy over political asylum as it is crucial to the analysis of contemporary global migration. [I should look for a debate over this issue.]
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)