Tuesday, April 12, 2011

Types of authorship in cinema

Livingston, Paiseley. (2009). In Cinema, philosophy, and Bergman: On film as philosophy (pp. 63-83). Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Livingston three key issues of mainstream large-scale film-making. (1) individual and joint/collective authorship: he emphasizes these two forms of authorship in lieu of the predominant notion of individual authorship. (2)authorship and value: one of the reasons for discussing authorship is the link between certain kinds of values and intentional activity. (3) authorship and unity: Livingston argues, "only the maker of a large, strongly unified life work or oeuvre complet truly qualifies as an author" (p. 68). [This view makes him distinct from Gaut, who argued for multiple authors within a single work of art.]

Livingston argues for two conditions of cinematic authorship: sufficient control over the production of a work plus an intentional act to express the author's own attitude. In this regard, he presented various types of cinematic authorship: individual authorship, individual authorship in the context of a collective film-making process, and joint authorship amongst equals. In particular with joint authorship, Livingston borrowed the term "mashing sub-plans" used by Michael E. Bratman (Faces of intention: Selected essays on intention and agency, 98-103, Cambridge University Press, 1999):

"In many cases where two or more persons jointly author an utterance or work, they intentionally generate or select the text, artefact [sic], performance, or structure that is the work's publicly observable component; in so doing, they act on meshing sub-plans and exercise shared control and decision-making authority over the results; furthermore, in making the work or utterance, they together take credit for it as a whole." (p. 74)

Livingston contended that individual authorship is indeed rare in large-scale commercial film-making, for film-making is a collective process in which people depend on each other's skills. And yet, he stressed that there should be one who control over the overall process. In this respect, Livingston distinguishes himself from Gaut (1997, 2010), who argued for multiple authorship in mainstream authorship, in part, because actors also contribute to creating artistic properties that deserves recognition as one of the work's multiple authors.

Despite his agreement with Gaut that most films are not individually authored and various artistic contributions merit appreciation, Livingston limited the word author to " a person who has played the role of the dominant coordinating collaborator in the creation of the work, provided, that is, that the work has been made by this person with the aim of expressing his or her attitude (or, in the absence of any expressive content, with the aim of endowing the work with artistic quality)" (p. 77). One of the reasons why Livingston disqualify actors' performances as authorship is that they do not play controlling and expressive roles in the making of the work, although their performances are successfully "mashed" with the director's intention and expression.

In short, Livingston emphasized, in the notion of cinematic authorship, overall control and expressive or artistic intentional design in the making of a work. Nonetheless, he does not exclude other types of cinematic authorship, namely, in non-hierarchical forms of artistic collaboration. He leaves the door open to this field. [I think that PV can fall into this category.]

Thursday, April 7, 2011

Vertov's World

Power, Nina. (2010). Film Quarterly, Vol. 63, No. 4 (Summer 2010), pp. 65-69

In this article, Power reviews Dziga Vertov's film world, in particular, by taking a critical gaze on his films, A Sixth Part of the World (1926) and The Eleventh Year (1928), both of which were followed by Man with a Movie Camera (1929). Contrary to the suggestion that the title, A Six Part of the World, made, Power argued that the film is not. She focused on the use of the word "you" in this film, implying various ethnic groups of the USSR, audiences, and members of the USSR as a political totality. Throughout the film, Power noted Vertov's genuine egalitarian humanity. She put it as:

"Vertov’s presentation of the cultural diversity of the USSR in A Sixth Part of the World strives to unite the audience, who are both its subject and its intended recipient: cinema as social inclusion. This land is your land: your oil, your cotton, your flax, your machines." (p. 68)

On the five obstructions

Hjort, Mette. (Ed.). (2008). London, UK: Wallflower Press.

Preface (M. Hjort, xiii-xxviii)
It overviews The Five Obstructions (2003), Lars von Trier and Jørgen Leth's collaborative experimental film. In 2000, von Trier invited Leth, his former teacher and filmmaker, to his game-like project. In his statement, von Trier wrote:

Fiction is limited by our imagination and facts by our insights, and the part of the world that we are seeking cannot be encompassed by a 'story' or embraced from an 'angle'. The subject matter we seek is found in the same reality that inspires fiction-makers; the reality that journalists believe they are describing. But they cannot find this unusual subject matter because their techniques blind them. Nor do they want to find it, because the techniques have become the goal itself. (xvi). . . In a world life where the media kneel before the altar of sharpness, draining life out of life in the process, the DEFOCUSISTS will be the communicators of our era--nothing more, nothing less! (xvii--original. Danish Film Institute 2002)

[For von Trier, the most pressing task in filmmaking is to break the techniques that try to sharpen the representation of reality: Counter-intuitively, these techniques blind us to see the facts and block our imagination. Within this context, he embarked on an experiment with Leth. The Five Obstructions is the result of this experiment to challenge the existing techniques and bring about a new definition of cinematic reality.]

Responding to von Trier's statement, Leth wrote in his statement:

We follow the flow, we see where it wants to to and what it want to do with us. We watch it take form and come together but we must ground it while it is still flowing and not too defined. We are in love. A feeling has bit us, we try to perceive it during its superficial passage yet are afraid of losing it again by understanding it too well. (cited on page xvii)

Leth also tried to break the conventions to "follow the flow", however, he did not think that von Trier's intention of defocus influenced the actual filmmaking of The Five Obstructions (p. xvi).

Style and creativity in The Five Obstructions (Mette Hjort, 15-37)
Hjort discusses styles by looking at the Five Obstructions. Effectively summarizing the film:

"The Five Obstructions, a philosophically-minded experiment involving Danish filmmakers Lars von Trier and Jørge Leth, contributes a number of key insights to the discussion of film and style. Analysis of this work shows, more specifically, that (i) salient regularities can be the mark of creativity at one moment in time and an obstacle to creativity at a later moment in time; (ii) style, narrowly understood as discernible regularities, can be the cause of a loss of style in a broader sense; and (iii) a loss of style that arises n this manner is a problem that can be resolves through strategies involving the obstruction of preferred practices and the imposition of new rules for creative production" (p. 16)

Within this context, she expands the notion of individual style in the context of cinematic authorship. In particular, Berys Gaut (1997, Film authorship and collaboration) is on the focus of her debate. Gaut pointed out some problems that a defense of cinematic authorship as a single author entailed, stressing the collaborative nature of filmmaking, thus suggesting that films should be "multiply categorized: by actors, cameramen, editors, composers, and so on" (p. 165), breaking the rigid categorization by directors. With this respect, Hjort spectulated the validity of the multiple authorship thesis, arguing that, as Gaut conceded, creativity tends to be centralized in filmmaking.

Artistic nesting in the Five Obstructions (Laisley Livingston, 57-75)

Livingston asserted that authorship requires "uncoerced expressive action" that "serves to indicate someone's attitude" (p. 71). He wrote: "Someone who neither makes nore displys anything indicative of any attitudes cannot be an author; anyone who does engage in such expressive actions is in a broad sense an author." (p. 71)

In the case of The Five Obstruction, although its credits include "von Trier as a performer plyaing the role of 'Obstructor' and Leth that of 'Director'" (p. 73), he credit von Trier as joint authors because "the nesting of works by Leth and his collaborators has the function of constituting a favourable context for both the making and reception of Leth's cinematic art" (p. 74), which is done by von Trier. Livinston concluded:

"Obviously, the challenges themselves provide Leth with help in the form of motivation and orientation, but my point here has also been that the film's skillfully crafted story of the Leth/von Trier interaction constitutes a favourable context for the reception and appreciation of the nested works, which acquire certain positively valenced stylistic and thematic qualities only in this context. And this is partly what makes Lars von Trier's help Jørgen Leth' project a success." (p. 74)

[Then, can I think of me as von Trier and PV participants as Leth, who are challenged by missions that I impose to them? This idea at least gives me something to think about. Interesting allegory.]

Work and play: The 5-0 game
(Trevor Ponech, 76-94)

Ponech describes The Five Obstructions's production as a game with a particular strain of cinéma-vérité and formost a commitment to participation. Then, Ponech looks into Chronicle of a summer and singled out a commitment to "provocation" in the way the film was produced. For the filmmakers, discovering or recording psychological dramas is not as important as provoking events, "especially otherwise unattainable self-revelations". In short, Ponech states the role of the camera for Rouch and Morin in their approach to cinéma-vérité:

"Participation in the vérité film extends to viewing the cinematic representations of one's self, with an eye to critiquing both mirror and window insofar as its use facilitates self-awareness and communication among participants." (p. 87)

Ponech argued that the film The Five Obstructions moves a step further, as such:

"Von Trier not only pins his subject beneath the camera's lens so that he might reveal something hidden for all, including the subject, to see; he also makes an expert practitioner struggle with practical and creative problems of filmmaking under barbed constraints customised to chafe, like a bespoke hair shirt. (p. 87).

Tuesday, March 22, 2011

Participatory Video

Images that transform and empower. Shirley A. White. (Ed.). (2003). New Delhi, India: Sage.

In the Forward, White astutely stated that despite participatory communication experiences over the last three decades, scholarly theories and definitions are yet to be developed and more so in information on practical and innovative programs at the grass root level.

Introduction: Video Power (17-30)
White approaches participatory video as a practical program of participatory communication. In the introduction to the book, she asserted that the major objective of participatory communication is to "empower people to shape their own destiny" (p. 20), arguing, "Participatory communication has the capacity to connect human beings as they experience social change" (p. 20).

White summarizes the current development of participatory video:

"Not only are there few definitive concepts but there is remarkable absence of any well-formulated theories to undergird the participatory video practices. While projects have been routinely evaluated, the lessons learned and understandings that have resulted have not led to significant theoretic work on the part of academics or other development professionals."(p.24)

Chapter 2. Involving people in a participatory process (33-62)
According to White, participation surfaced in the 1970s and dominated the development scene since then; in particular, communication technologies have played an important role in giving "voice" to the grass roots people. White emphasizes participatory communication as a process:

It [participatory communication] also must be conceived as process methodology that involves people in an interactive way, making communication resources accessible to them directly, in turn, helping the grass roots people acquire the knowledge and skill that enables a partnership in generating messages. (p. 37)

White describes the outcomes of the process of participatory communication:

"Through the process, a person experiences self-awareness and becomes conscious of social issues that affect their lives. The transformative dynamic of communication exchanges acts as a catalyst for identifying one's own problems, recognizes possible routes to empowerment and self-reliance, and builds a sense of independence through interdependence." (p. 37)

While describing the dimensions of involvement in participatory communication for development, White wrote:
"Initially, people may become involved out of curiosity, but when given the opportunity to be recognized and have a "voice", the enthusiasm builds. Video has proven to be a powerful tool for motivating participation, when used in the initial stages of involvement." (p. 47-48).

Besides, White also discussed confidence and self-development as a dimension of involvement. Here she implies the role of learning to build confidence and let them continue to be involved. She wrote:
"As individuals experience success in expressing views, learning new things, using indigenous knowledge and skills, they will develop the confidence to continue to be involved. They will recognize their own self-development and the fact that they are becoming different people. Feelings of satisfaction and usefulness result from being able to play a part in community effort and be recognized and valued for that part (CONNECT TO STAR'S REFLECTION)." (p. 49)

Discussing the role of the facilitator as a communication catalyst, Nair and White (1999) wrote that they "unlock the human potentials of individuals, increasing their capacity to think, to relate, to act, and to reflect from a foundation of communication competencies" (p. 40) (cited on p. 51).

*Nair, K. S., & White, S. A. (1999). The catalyst communicator: Facilitation without fear. In S. White, K. Nair & J. Ascroft (Eds.), Participatory communication: Working for change and development. New Delhi: Sage.

With regard to conflict, White writes "no change is possible without conflict--the greater the change, the greater the conflict" (p. 58). Thus, she writes as the role of facilitator:

"The development facilitator, as a catalyst communicator, can enter a conflicted community and readily recognize conflicts. Bringing the people together and giving them tools to address their differences is the first order of the day. Creating the opportunity for them to talk about and share their differences will quickly lead to the identification of common interests and aspirations. Participatory Video (PV) has played a vital role in this process throughout communities on all continents" (p. 58)

Finally, White discusses some challenges of participatory communication: One of them is a long time span to build human capacity. In this light, she proposes "mini" projects (p. 60):

In the future there needs to be recognition of the fact that projects need to be small and localized in order to allow participants a safer, more comfortable relationship with fellow community members. These "mini" projects can offer greater feelings of satisfaction and in reality, be more effectively managed and controlled. Small successes produce capacity, confidence, and courage to tackle larger, more complex development plans of action. Communication media--video, audio, and the Internet--will provide the mechanisms for linking and sharing the outcomes of these projects" (p. 60).

For White, PV is useful for conducting mini projects.

Chapter 3. Participatory video: A process that transforms the self and the other (63-101)

White succinctly defined PV as follows:

"Participatory video as a process is a tool for individual, group, and community development. It can serve as a powerful force for people to see themselves in relation to the community and become conscientized about personal and community needs. It brings about a critical awareness that forms the founcation for creativity and communication. Thus, it has the potential to bring about personal, social, political, and cultural change. That's what video power is all about." (p. 64)

White distinguished PV as a process and as a product: PV as a process is described as a tool to facilitate interaction and enable self-expression. PV as a product, on the other hand, emphasizes the video itself, which becomes a historical fact. Unlike non-participatory video, White argued, PV as a product is highly interactive to make a message come across via video.

Among others, White stressed PV as a tool for education and self-training that emerged in the use of PV in particular FAO projects. For video has "immediacy" (p. 67) that video can be replayed in the field. In particular, she mentioned video feedback as one of the most powerful yet simple uses of PV, such as videotaping a simple process of pesticides or other similar skills, conducting an interview for participatory research, conducting a training session, etc.

White highly regarded participatory message-making with video, which enables bottom-up grass roots involvement in the development of knowledge construction. Calling this process as PMD (Participatory Message Development), she emphasized the researcher as an important variable in the PMD process and listed the following as other critical variables.

1. Flexibility of the process (i.e., willingness to adapt and change directions)
2. Ability of the development communicator to play the facilitator role
3. The necessity of effective interpersonal communication
4. The joint analysis/teamwork or spirit among the researchers, development communicators and intended receivers
5. Recognizing that the participatory process is an educational process.

As outcomes of her research with Patel (1994), she write the following in relation to video:
"The characteristic and potential of small format video, as a development tool, is an ideal medium of communication when using a participatory research approach"
"Video as a development tool allows people to become involved in the process of decision-making and change in their community, which is an empowering experience."
"The presence of video in the community takes on a new meaning in that its evolution will move from a form of entertainment to a means of serious communication, dealing with and trying to find solutions to day-to-day issues." (p. 70)

In discussing Transformation, White argued that initially transformation must take place within individuals and it is intertwined with knowledge acquisition. She argued that knowledge acquisition is in itself empowering. She further stated:
"It [knowledge] builds the capacity for gaining control over one's own life and life space. It is at the heart of transforming situations and moving toward better quality life" (p. 76). More, she stressed that transformation accompanies conflict, saying, "There is no change without conflict whether it be interpersonal conflict or conflict within one's self" (p. 81). Further, "[C]onflicts can be negotiated in positive and constructive ways through mediation and management...Conflict is actually healthy because it helps move relationships out of a rut and can result in new visions and renewed confidence between conflicting individuals." (p. 81). In this light, she called for the process of reaching a consensus: "Consensus doesn't necessarily mean that everyone agrees on an issue, but it does mean they can be committed to a decision that is reached through dialog in which each person has been able to freely express an opinion on that issue" (p. 79).

Her personal reflection on those days in which small format video emerged is interesting. She recalled that even in the late 1960s when portable cameras became available, the concepts and norms that had governed television technologies dominated the guidelines for the use of small format video. She recalled that alternative video was born out of experiment, in her case, via an enthusiastic audiovisual librarian, who did not set boundaries for the use of the new technology. Then they teamed up to explore the power of video based on do-it-yourself spirit for students and faculty. Then, interestingly, they traveled to Canada to learn about the Challenge for Change programs for the purpose of learning an approach to participatory media.

Chapter 4. Participatory video that empowers (102-121, Renuka Bery)
Bery gives a succinct definition of empowerment: "Empowerment is closely linked with identity and context. Gaining control of one's life, making one's own decisions and being able to influence the context in which one lives are essential elements of empowerment." (p. 104)

Bery discussed the flexibility of participatory video throughout the world: "Participatory video producers can adapt the medium to meet their needs, whether it is used to expose current reality or to weave a narrative that brings the changing world closer to the viewers. Different styles of participatory video have emerged around the world that address the specific context and needs of the communities it served." Then she concluded, "[P]articipatory video is truly empowering. It opens up new aveunes for telling stories in ways that will build strong individuals and communities. These stories are strong enough to identify problems and to make necessary changes in order to improve lives and to transform societies in ways that value the individual and recognize the unique contribution and dynamic of every interaction" (p. 119).

Chapter 8. Trapped: Women Take Control of Video Storytelling (195-214, K. Sadanandan Nair and Shirley A. White)

The authors introduced participatory video research project that began in 1985 in rural areas of India. This research was experimentation with portable video cameras, responding to questions with respect to video as a communication tool for knowledge production, policy change, and empowerment, in particular, in the context of women's need. They stated that the problems described in this research were different from those identified in the World Bank's recent report on poverty, arguing that women are doubly rejected in a poverty-stricken family environment.

The authors noted that this experimental approach to video gave rise to the concept of participatory video. Based on the data gathered in 23 different villages, the research team produced the documentary called The Trapped. It was reviewed with several women and they confirmed the authenticity of the video and their comments were incorporated in further editing. Then, the research team moved toward the participatory model of message production. First, researchers visited some villages and selected two villages for "experimental" work (p. 204). Next, the researchers used a "Trigger Tape" (p. 205), which consisted of video images of rural women shot throughout earlier days of the research, to catalyze the involvement of village women in the investigation of community problems on their own. Here the authors emphasized the role of researchers as a catalyst as well as the Trigger Tape:

"The primary role of the researcher was that of a catalyst to get the women to discuss their own problems. The Trigger Tape led not only to discussions of problems, but also to the decision to produce a participatory tape jointly with the researchers. The researchers (p. 206) concurred that the reason the women agreed to do their own tapes was that they thought that the researchers depicted their way of life incorrectly. As such, they realized that the researchers made a lot of mistakes just like they do, and therefore were not superior to them. The women felt they could do it because our tape wasn't all that good. All of them were excited about doing video to have some fun. They wanted to show it to their friends and relatives in other village." (p. 206-207)

Finally, five women made a commitment to produce the video, Rural Women's Problems. They were individually or in groups. Then, a camera was left in the village, while the women were asked to document whatever they felt important about the issues they had been discussing. In the following, the village women and the researchers reviewed an hour long video footage. They continued to define problems faced by rural women through group discussions while providing video training simultaneously for a six week period. The authors concluded that "these meetings helped not only to raise issues, but also to find solutions to problems through collective action" (p. 208). The completed video (15 min) were presented in several villages.

The authors compared the two documentaries, The Trapped and Rural Women's Problems:

"Beneath the outward appearances of their 'hard life and abusive life space' they have a bond of dignity. They do not want to be perceived as downtrodden and they value the daily aspects of their lives, even though difficult at times. This pride shows through in the participatory tape they produced.
The Trapped was a 'poor me' story, while Rural Women's Problems was am 'I am Me' story. When women could tell their own story, they carefully portrayed the reality of their daily life, without pity or apology. They declared themselves as people who clearly recognized their problems and had ideas as to how to solve them." (p. 211)

Through the documentation of the participation process, the authors concluded that the process of participation contributed to the participants' transformation in that they formed alliances and gained confidence that their perspectives are valuable; further, the video they created empowered the women for a short duration.

Saturday, February 12, 2011

Using visual data in qualitative research

Banks, Marcus. (2007). London, UK: Sage

The Symbolism of video

: Exploring migrant mothers' experiences. Yolanda Hernandez-Albujar. (2007). in Gregory Stanczak (2007), Visual research methods: Image, society, and representation (pp, 281-306). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

The author discussed some ethical issues involved in visual ethnographic video approach in her study of the migratory experience among Latin American mothers in Italy. She argued that the conventional ethnographic videotaping was not feasible because it could disclose identities of the participants. Thus she reconfigured the video (the title is "Voices") by incorporating related images in an experimental way to convey emotions and situations that the participants described through in-depth interviews. She wrote the final video was a practical solution to the participants' refusal to be video-recorded, and writing, "I substituted the participants' faces and their gestures and actions in front of the camera by symbols that engages metaphors of the verbal and visual narratives" (p. 291)

Finally, she discussed some limitations of her work: Although the video should represent the finding, but screening the video itself potentially limit a generation of sociological knowledge. She admitted that the video should be presented alongside with the conventional text analysis of the project for the best understanding of the project. However, she pointed out, access to visual data in publication limits video methodology in the social sciences. Video is not streamlined in the publication unlike still images, she argued.

She quoted Ken Plummer (2001, Documents of life 2, An invitation to a critical humanism) in the delayed use of video for sociology:

"[I]ndeed a whole new generation of "video" experts seems to have emerged outside of sociology to do sociology's work! There are now several generations of "video workers" who have used video as radical means of transforming the orthodox visual image and of providing a whole library of "alternative video forms." (p. 71, cited p. 303)

Photo-elicitation

Collier, Malcolm. (2007). The applied visual anthropology of John Collier: A photo essay. In Sarah Pink (Ed.), Visual intervention: Applied visual anthropology. New York, NY: Berghahn Books.

In this chapter, the author introduces some works of John Collier Jr, to whom we are indebted for the use of photography in anthropology and sociology research, in particular, photo-elicitation, a method he developed. Looking at the Vicos Project (in the mid-1950s), in which close to nine-thousand still images and hours of 16 mm films were taken in Vicos, Peru, the author wrote:

The visual ethnography was intended to provide both information for immediate use and also a baseline record for later comparative evaluation of the impact of the project. (p. 35)

The author noted that in the late 60s, John Collier turned his attention to cross-cultural schooling and at the same time, started using super 8 film equipment in response to the limitations of still photography. With this respect, the author wrote, "The shift to film placed more emphasis on observation and analysis of social interactions and process through time and space" (p. 44)

[This essay indicates that J. Collier, perhaps many others in that period, regarded visual images as a mirroring representation of the reality like a documentation]

In concluding the use of visual images by J. Collier, the author wrote:

"While in earlier years John Collier Jr's photographs were more classically documentary in character, intended to make statements to viewers for applied purposes (what I understand this term as an exploration of the potential of photos to reveal something that painting cannot do), by the 1960s they became explicitly tools for obtaining information and understanding about the circumstances in which they were made. The camera became a more systematically directed tool for data gathering and less of an expressive device. The resulting images were often less individually compelling but the collective informational content became a far more extensive and complete source of information on the circumstances in front of the lens" (p. 49)

[This indicate that the use of photos was predominantly objectivistic and positivistic. The photos were to provide vivid reality themselves. They were a tool for data gathering.]